25 ms·
To solve affordability crisis, Bay Area housing stock must grow 50% in 20 years
- joeblow9999 9y agoGood luck with that
- epistasis 9y agoI think it's becoming increasingly apparent that the Bay Area needs a regional government that can supercede tiny municipalities. Wise governance is impossible with lots of small outposts preventing sensible planning for the region, because they are only interested in advancing short-term interests of a small number of people. Democracy does not function well in that environment. If the Bay Area doesn't step up to do that, it's likely that the State of California will have to start implementing policies, and that's not going to be as good as a regional government and planning.
- conanbatt 9y agoThe housing situation is a California wide problem. The bigger government is the first one messing up housing.
- epistasis 9y agoI agree that it's a California wide problem, though I think the cause is slightly different in different parts of the state. What do you mean by: > The bigger government is the first one messing up housing. Do you mean that State policies are the ones messing up housing? I think that Prop 13 and CEQA get named sometimes for stopping housing development, but a far bigger hurdle are the local zoning policies, and the veto power of local communities. Are you suggesting something like a state-wide policy of by-right development for plans that meet local code and zoning regulations? That would definitely help reduce building costs, but it won't be enough to allow the amount of housing that is suggested in the original article.
- conanbatt 9y agoAll the cities in california are failing to build for the demand. SF and LA are obvious because they are the biggest, but its a state level problem. The core problem to me is taxation: California should have a Land value tax, but instead of that, it rewards owners with things like prop 13, and punishes workers by using sales taxes and income taxes. Just changing that taxation would change everything: owners would not block development anymore because their land has negative worth unless it houses multiple people. Right now a big building that houses 1000 people pays more property taxes than a few houses that house 10. A Land value tax would shift the burden and make the few houses super expensive, while rent remains the same, and workes see increases in income and also in cheaper goods. Of this there is no economic doubt in my mind. But politically, neither rent control nor prop 13 are revokable,so my assessment is that SF will hit a ceiling of growth. Maybe the last property owners will be left holding the bag as their expectations of growth will never come about. And then another city will pick up the slack, one without this issue.
- epistasis 9y agoTotally agree that Prop 13 is a huge problem, it's a hugely regressive tax that seems completely out of place in a state that's supposed to be liberal or even leftist. California's liberalism is only skin deep, particularly among the wealthy, who pull their kids of out public school increasingly too. This report from 2015: http://lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/finance/housing-costs/housing-costs.aspx http://lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/finance/housing-costs/housing... has a section titled "Why DO Coastal Areas Not Build Enough Housing?" * Community Resistance to New Housing. * Environmental Reviews Can Be Used to Stop or Limit Housing Development. * Local Finance Structure Favors Nonresidential Development. * Limited Vacant Developable Land. And Prop 13 feeds into the third in a huge way, and a bit into the first.
- briandear 9y agoModern liberalism is contrary to the free market. If the market were allowed to work, you wouldn’t have a housing shortage. The housing shortage is because of liberalism, not despite it. You don’t have housing shortages in Houston. High density projects are typically opposed (in Houston) by the NPR-listening liberals inside the loop. For example, the Houston Heights, Upper Kirby District and other enclaves of very liberal, higher income people. In Katy, Texas (a Houston suburb,) if you want to build a 25 story condo development — you build it. Try the same thing inside of liberal areas of Houston, no way, they’ll fight it with all they’ve got while proudly displaying campaign signs from Democrat politicians. Democrats, in my experience, are very anti-development, using hot-button words like “environment” or “historic preservation” as tools to support their NIMBYism. I was at a restaurant in Cupertino last week and overheard some gents talking about a proposed new housing project in San Francisco and they said that the meeting consisted of people making arguments like, “but this project would anger Mother Earth.” Apparently, there is a Druid constituency with whom the Bay Area has to contend. This isn’t an indictment of “liberalism” — merely an observation that rich liberals can be the worst sort. The vast majority of Silicon Valley are self-styled liberals, without a conservative within 100 miles, yet despite the name, the folks in charge are about as regressive as they come.
- coding123 9y agoAnd the freeways can support this how?
- oftenwrong 9y agoCongestion pricing
- ecshafer 9y agoYou can build more trains and use more buses, and use congestion pricing to keep down the number of cars instead of subsidizing their use. This is a solved problem.
- wklauss 9y agoSeveral ways, including congestion taxes and more public transportation options, like it's been pointed out. But, also, a 50% increase in housing supply means higher density of population, with higher buildings instead of single family homes and therefore more comercial space in large populated areas, meaning more jobs will be at walking/biking/short-bus-ride distance.
- DataWorker 9y agoSorry but you are totally naive if you think a 50% increase is possible in that time frame. You just can’t, or don’t want to do the math. What you are suggesting amounts to jail cells with no infrastructure.
- epistasis 9y agoJail cells? It's not polite to put rude words in others' mouths. There are limitations on current build rates though; we'll have to massively increase the construction work force to do anything like this, as it's already not quite able to meet demand here.
- DataWorker 9y agoYou’re suggesting these people won’t drive anywhere. There’s no way to support that growth given the limitations in our roadways. Traffic is already terrible, imagine 4 or 5 hours to get from oakland to San Francisco.
- ssalka 9y agoinb4 The Seasteading Institute builds "New San Francisco" off the coast
- rb808 9y agoBecause big dense cities like NY are affordable?
- umanwizard 9y agoNo, but a lot more affordable than SF.
- nwah1 9y agoYour point is valid and you shouldn't be downvoted. Empirically, we know that high density of residential units is correlated with high rent. Why is this? It ultimately comes back to the Law of Rent. The amount that landlords are able to charge directly corresponds to the produce obtainable at that location over their next best alternative... and that alternative is likewise set that way up until you reach the "margin" which is the best available rent-free location. Since all land has been homesteaded, there's not much of a ceiling on rents... they tend towards the entire nominal productivity of the site. And the more desirable that site is, the more astronomical the rent. We want locations to be desirable, so in effect we actually do want rent to be high. It's just important that everyone share in that rising wealth. In other words, we need to create a high demand for labor, by shifting taxes from labor onto idle landlords. Land speculators are like patent trolls atop the surface of the planet.
- conanbatt 9y agoHenry George would shed a tear. I do believe that the thing that would change the housing stock situation for SF is to remove sales taxes and add land value taxes. Just that change alone will make workers and renters richer overnight, and would change the anti-development mindset of owners quite a bit, considering that low-dense units will pay the highest amount.
- jartelt 9y agoWouldn't a decent portion of the land value tax just be passed on to renters in the form of higher rent charged by their landlord?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoIf this is true then I think the Bay will need to let go of it's ideas towards rezoning. Deregulatory zoning adjustments just won't be able to stimulate this level of building. Why not just build out and do greenfield development but put some mandatory density requirements in place for new building?
- DataWorker 9y agoIf you think this is doable you haven’t thought hard enough. What of all the home owners? Imminent domain and reclaim the peninsula?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI think it's doable, you just have to keep going a bit. Is Tyler Cowen right, then? “Basically SF is ed?” No. San Francisco could be just fine. The thing about San Francisco is that while greenfields have been exhausted in the city, the San Francisco Bay Area is largely undeveloped. We are always arguing over San Francisco, or Palo Alto (ick). Outside of the 47 square miles of San Francisco proper are almost 3200 square miles in San Mateo, Santa Clara, Alameda, and Contra Costa counties. (I’ll leave out the hoity-toity North Bay counties — Marin, Sonoma, Napa — but if it’s Latin-America-style land reform you want, the vines there are ripe for revolution!) Nobody wants new suburban sprawl, thank goodness. But dense development is not sprawl, even when it is greenfield development. http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/6487.html http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/6487.html
- conanbatt 9y agoI personally believe SF is just f'ed. Its not a problem of choosing a solution, its a political problem. It would require politically unfeasble solutions. Removing rent control, changing sales taxes to land value taxes, reducing superfluous city government spending, etc. San francisco will not change without a back-breaking situation: tech companies moving away, homelessness getting to untenable levels, median workers leaving the city, etc. Its already happening, but not hard enough to curb the expected profits of the last generation of landowners.
- 9y ago
- sampo 9y agoJust quoting the last paragraph. This is the kind of honesty people need. > Intellectual honesty requires taking numbers seriously. Either we prioritize making the Bay Area affordable for all of us or we don’t. The less housing we build, the more wealth will be trapped in high housing prices. Unless we decide to grow our housing stock to accommodate our economy, we are continuing to choose the interests of those who are rich or who already own their homes over the interests of the struggling middle and working classes.
- rb808 9y agoIf density increases the people who will benefit the most are current landowners. If you have single family home on a big lot, its value will go up many times if you can suddenly build an apartment building on it.
- mistermann 9y agoThat is: a) Correct. b) Beneficial to most participants in the market, well off (mainly due to luck in timing) NIMBY's being the exception.
- epistasis 9y agoYes, in the short term, there are two things that happen: 1) land values go up, 2) housing costs go down. The first may benefit current land owners a lot, but the second is absolutely essential for lower incomes to succeed at all. This is not a zero-sum move, and is fact hugely beneficial to everyone. When there's fixed housing supply, that's when things are closer to a zero-sum economic game.
- davidw 9y ago"Density is how those with less money compete with the rich for expensive land" http://marketurbanism.com/2018/02/05/density-working-poor-outbid-rich-urban-land/ http://marketurbanism.com/2018/02/05/density-working-poor-ou...
- swimfar 9y ago
- weeksie 9y agoJust a reminder that the growth rates for SF, SV, Seattle, Portland are all pretty puny compared to the growth rates of, e.g. Detroit at its peak. Hell they're not even that crazy compared to growth rates those cities have handled before. People just aren't interested in any perceived threat to their property values so they're strangling growth based on an entitlement mindset. No, sirs and ma'ams, your home's price appreciation isn't a right.
- redthrowaway 9y ago>No, sirs and ma'ams, your home's price appreciation isn't a right. No, but they do have a right to vote for policies and politicians that defend their interests.
- weeksie 9y agoThey can vote. However, any system that allows people to rent seek by creating building restrictions that protect their property values is not an optimal solution. So sure, they can vote but they should not be able to vote on zoning. What about nuisances or factories or what have you? Well, that's easy enough to take care of through noise ordinances. Land use zoning is mostly a well intentioned but terrible in practice policy idea.
- marcell 9y ago> No, sirs and ma'ams, your home's price appreciation isn't a right Doesn't increased density help property values? If I can build a high rise on your 1 acre plot of land, its value should go up.
- weeksie 9y agoDepends! Increased density should drive up the price of land. However, if you are in a neighborhood of single family homes and a huge multi family building is constructed on your block, your home price will go down because there will be enough supply to meet demand, taking pressure off the single family homes. If you are in an already dense city and regulations are relaxed so that more high rises can be built in more neighborhoods, the price of your condo all else being equal will be lower because there will be more supply. The land price may well go up but your individual apartment would likely be worth less.
- redthrowaway 9y agoWhat is far more likely is that people will simply leave the Bay Area, and demand will fall. It's far easier to create tech clusters in other cities than it is to convince a bunch of NIMBY boomers that other people need places to live, too.
- TuringNYC 9y ago>> people will simply leave the Bay Area, and demand will fall Short of a bubble popping, it usually doesnt work like a cusp, but rather, things remain on the edge of extremity (i.e.: dual income couple plowing 70% of income into insane mortgage.)
- Reedx 9y agoPeople are leaving actually, to the point that U-Haul is having a hard time keeping up with demand. The trucks aren't coming back here. "Rent a moving truck from Las Vegas to San Jose and you'll pay about $100. In the opposite direction, the same truck will cost you 16 times that, or nearly $2,000." https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/U-Haul-San-Francisco-Bay-Area-prices-shortage-12617855.php https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/U-Hau...
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"It's far easier to create tech clusters in other cities" Wouldn't it have been done by now if that were the case? Yet SF is still the Mecca for the tech and startup scenes.
- redthrowaway 9y agoNetwork effects are powerful. But beyond the original secondary tech centres of Seattle, Boston, and NYC, there are now thriving tech scenes in all sorts of smaller markets--Portland, Denver, Austin, etc. It's easy to see every major tech company having a base in SFBA for the foreseeable future, but it's also easy to see being a working programmer living in one of those smaller markets and actually being a homeowner being a much bigger thing going forward.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoSomeone who recognizes the opportunity to develop tech centers between the coasts is going to cash in big. Zappos and Tesla seem to have had their fingers on that pulse by settling in the Reno/Sparks area.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoFor the past 20 years or so, every state has tried doing just that. Very few have been anywhere near successful, and those that have end up with housing problems similar to (maybe not as severe as) SV.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoDifference being, Silicon Valley was not entirely booked up until recently.
- stevenwoo 9y agoMaybe Amazon HQ2 will revitalize somewhere new, but it seems like some of the areas still on the list have pretty horrendous traffic problems now.
- austincheney 9y agoIf 60,000 people continue to move from there to Texas every year then 20 years from now when the area has lost over a million residents the housing prices might well flatten organically. This madness is causing housing prices to climb in Texas though.
- tabtab 9y agoTell you what, we'll send all the jerks to TX and keep the non-jerks ;-)
- downrightmike 9y agoThen there wouldn't be anyone left.
- justherefortart 9y agoBut I was told Austin is the SF of Texas?!!?! I used to laugh my ass off at ignorant Californians that would say that. It's still fucking Texas.
- seabrookmx 9y agoIt's not a _terrible_ analogy though. I haven't been to all the major US cities but I got a bit of a Portland vibe from Austin. It's definitely not what I expected from my first time in Texas (I'm a West Coast Canadian).
- tabtab 9y agoLet's not get into the usual culture wars here. My comment was meant as a joke. My apologies if it offended anyone. Live and let live.
- rconti 9y ago"Everyone" has been fleeing California for as long as I can remember (and long before myself, my family, and most of my friends all moved here).
- m0llusk 9y agoWhat is often missing from this discussion is financialization of housing markets. As long as housing units are chips for a game among banks and wealthy patrons it is not clear we will be able to build enough homes to satiate artificially inflated demand.
- rubicon33 9y agoThis. This. This. This. This. Absent from the vast majority of these threads is the critical component in this "crisis": Property can be purchased and held onto for purely speculative purposes, thereby draining the inventory pool, and raising the cost of housing for residents of the city. This has been happening in the bay area for a very long time. Wealthy Chinese investors who do not LIVE in the bay area, have purchased an incredible amount of inventory over the last decade and it has remained vacant / unused. Of course we need more building, that's obvious. But what we also need is to immediately disallow the purchase of land by foreign entities that is not used for habitation. I have yet to hear a constructive argument for why that shouldn't be banned at a constitutional level. Housing may not be a "right" per se, but it's certainly in the communities best interest to use available housing for that communities interest, not the interest of wealthy foreign investors.
- boreas 9y agoYou need to provide statistics for extraordinary claims about housing being purchased by foreign investors and not used. Common sense says it should be a very marginal phenomenon. After all, renting out property should almost always be worth it with the high housing prices in the area.
- coccinelle 9y agoI’ve been wondering about that when it comes to rent-controlled places like SF. It seems « tenant occupied » properties sell for less than equivalent empty places. Then is it worth it to let a tenant in who might just drive down the price of the place if you decide to sell a couple of years later?
- 9y ago
- pascalxus 9y agoI know we'd all love to fix the bay area housing problem here. The most obvious answer is to increase the supply. But, fixing the zoning laws and allowing developers to build isn't the only thing that's standing in the way. The problems are too numerous to fix: NIMBYs sueing developers, CEQA, Proposition 13, AND don't forget about the underlying labor cost (all our middle class people's aren't going to come back, after having been forced out). The bay area has forever lost it's ability to produce cost effective housing. One article I read, said that San Jose rents would have to increase another 25% to 4.75$ per sq foot, just to allow developers to break even on high rise construction! This points to some serious fundamental problem with our economy here in the bay area and it's not going to fixed with just one or two adjustments to the above reasons. We've kindof Venezuela'd our bay area economy here. Edit: here is the link (4.25 - 4.75$/sq foot to build in San jose!): https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/04/27/construction-costs-could-hamper-bay-area-residential-towers/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/04/27/construction-costs-co... By all means, let's work to fix the problem. But, for anyone who wants to get cost effective housing in the next 30 years: I'm sorry to say it, its time to bail out. We need to start lobbying software companies to get the heck out of the bay area and CA in general. Let's get Elon musk to build one of those hyperTubes to some city like Austin, Denver, Albuquerkee, or madison, WI. maybe some of us could commute in for 4 days a week or something.
- Moseman23 9y ago"The bay area has forever lost it's ability to produce cost effective housing." Strong statement, if slightly ungrammatical. I think this is a challenge to visionary thinkers and leaders to change the game. Engineering is one part, as is regulatory capture and regressive real estate laws and norms, weak state government in the state, and highly atrophied political participation. What could change that? I can think of one thing, and one thing only, that would "shake up" the status quo.
- alonmower 9y agoYa, as a current renter I've wondered what a giant earthquake would do to housing prices. On the one hand, lots of people lose their investments and are forced to sell their land or take out loans to rebuild. You might be able to buy land or a damaged property for a good deal. Contractors would all be completely overbooked and the price to rebuild would likely be quite high for some time. Some who have never experienced earthquakes might get scared out of the region altogether. On the other hand the houses that survive are now part of a much smaller pool of available, livable houses and there's still a lot of money in the region so I could see prices for these houses shoot through the roof.
- eecsninja 9y agoLet's not forget this article from a month ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501 The great irony is that there are plenty of people in the SF bay area who think Tokyo is more expensive than SF just like it was decades ago, even though it's not true anymore.
- irq11 9y agoTokyo is still very expensive relative to Japanese incomes. Is it more expensive than SF on an adjusted basis? Hard to say, but it’s not as clear as you’re asserting. If anything, magacities like Tokyo and London show us that you can build like crazy, and still end up a very expensive place to live.
- nerfhammer 9y agohere's a thorough cost comparison breakdown: https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/in/Tokyo https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/in/Tokyo rent in particular is drastically less expensive
- irq11 9y agoAgain: you can’t just compare rent values without adjusting for income. Japanese people aren’t earning San Francisco salaries. The number you want there is the the one that says Tokyo is 10% cheaper than NYC. That’s the adjusted number. Say what you will about rent, but “10% cheaper than New York” is nobody’s definition of cheap.
- nerfhammer 9y agothe tool has all that in it according to it, salaries in SF are ~66% higher than Tokyo and rents are ~300% higher.
- khazhoux 9y agoOr Google, Apple, Facebook could grow the next 200,000 jobs somewhere else? Everyone talks about housing affordability and NIMBYs and we get into class warfare and home-appreciation snobbery, but the simple thing I can't understand is how will the area's transportation infrastructure scale up? There's no credible solution.
- asdsa5325 9y agoThis. If Silicon Valley is full, then don't move there! Live somewhere else, your wallet and your sanity will thank you!
- s73v3r_ 9y agoUnfortunately, until the big guys and the startup scene decide to move elsewhere, or at least spread out beyond the Bay Area, that's not very practical advice. I recently had a couple interviews with Google, and basically, for the positions they wanted me for, I would be required to move to Mountain View. So your advice in my situation would boil down to "Don't work for Google."
- asdsa5325 9y agoGoogle has many offices in other states
- ng12 9y agoOk, but what about your kids? Are they going to live with you forever? Are they going to be able to afford $2m homes? I've never met so many 30 year olds who live with their parents as I did when I lived in South Bay. You can't wave the problem away with "eh, transplants".
- acover 9y agoAre there studies that explain the cause of high house prices and what can be done?
- s73v3r_ 9y agoLots of people want to be there, and not enough housing is being built for them all. It doesn't help that a lot of the people moving there, are doing so because of high tech job salaries, meaning they're more able to absorb the high rent costs.
- gojomo 9y agoNews from 2029: Skylynr, the 'Uber of nanoassembled highrises', last night replaced 44 San Francisco Victorians with apartment buildings. Reached for comment, SF's Planning Department said the overnight construction violates a city moratorium, to study displacement issues, now in its 14th year. The Board of Supervisors plans to address the issue in an emergency session next Tuesday. A Skylynr spokesperson says over 4,000 new residents, in the nearly 2,000 new apartments, will be registered as voters on the San Francisco Department of Elections blockchain before that meeting. By November, over half the city's voters may be residents of the on-demand skyscrapers popping up across the city, most built by Skylynr or its competitors Instatower and Zipartments.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JeffreyKaine 9y agoI love this. Both for it's tongue and cheek attitude, and for it's not unlikely depiction of the future.
- flanbiscuit 9y agoI believe William Gibson described something similar to the self-building towers in his book Idoru[1]. I think they were called nanotech buildings[2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idoru https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idoru [2] http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=83 http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/content.asp?Bnum=83
- Cerium 9y agoAdditionally Neal Stephenson describes vertically extruded nanotech buildings in "The Diamond Age".
- flanbiscuit 9y agoI haven't read a sci-fi/cyberpunk book in a long time, I think I'm going to pick this up. Been meaning to read more of Stephenson's novels
- lazyjones 9y agoIt's the same all over the world. Politicians seem to have too close ties with developers and real estate investors and they put unhealthy zoning laws in effect to drive prices into absurd regions and boost tax income as well. People should contact their representatives and ask them to change this. It worked in Span (admittedly, they overdid it), it would work anywhere. Unfortunately, there's no easy workaround for the situation. Perhaps an "Uber for commuters" would work, together with some sort of coordinated purchase/rent of affordable housing in areas ~1 hour commute from those chokepoints? (i.e. get 100 people to move to a small village together, then fill 2 busses every day with commuters to SF).
- TomVDB 9y agoAre you sure that the zoning laws are driven by developers and real estate investors? In most Bay Area cities, they are the wishes of the residents who do not want more development. My neighborhood in Sunnyvale was recently rezoned to be single story only and that process is entirely driven by the residents, not the politicians. It was the 25th neighborhood in Sunnyvale to do so, and it cost around $200 per resident to file an application. No a single resident was against it.
- rmk 9y agoPalo Alto has a 50-ft building height limit. The height of greed, that is!
- TomVDB 9y ago50 ft is plenty, 3 stories, and has little to do with greed. The new zoning rules in our neighborhood limit height to 17 ft. And greed wasn't the driving factor either. People are much more concerned about the new neighbor tearing down the single story house next door and building an ugly two story McMansion from which you can look straight down in their garden/pool.
- nerfhammer 9y agoIt seems to be a Western phenomenon and much less of problem in Asia where NIMBYism is seen as being not socially responsible
- chroem- 9y agoThe housing crisis is fundamentally a transportation problem. The bay area has intentionally made it impractical to own a car, so everyone is forced seek housing within walking distance of a limited number of public transit lines. The "war on sprawl" and lack of affordable housing are two sides of the same coin.
- rconti 9y agoOwning cars is quite practical in the bay area. You might argue that COMMUTING in a car is impractical, but then again, I just commuted 20 miles down 101 in the heart of silicon valley in under 20 minutes this morning, so, I don't know. I'd say relatively few people commute on the limited number of public transit lines you say everyone has to live near.
- chrischen 9y agoForcing people to live near transit is a good thing. The problem is thebat are doesn’t allow building dense hosuing near transit lines (common sense!) and so very few people can actually let people live near transit.
- chrischen 9y ago*the Bay Area not "thebat"
- conanbatt 9y agoMore investment into transportation will accelerate the demise of san francisco. It can only be funded by higher sales taxes that workers pay, that end up rising the value of land and thus rent. It falls doubly on workers and renters.
- cozzyd 9y agoThe vast majority of the Bay Area is designed for cars.
- alexhutcheson 9y agoThe headline could also be re-stated as "To solve affordability crisis, Bay Area housing stock must grow 2% per year". Using a long time period will give you large headline numbers.
- notadoc 9y agoBuild up, it's the only solution.
- partycoder 9y ago- World population goes up - Global amount of wealthy people goes up - Demand for a spot in a city goes up So if you extrapolate this 100 years, you will end up in a situation where even the worst cities of 2018 will be unaffordable for the regular person.
- cwkoss 9y agoThis reminds me of the joke, "If our daughter keeps growing at this rate, she'll be 12 feet tall by age 18"
- partycoder 9y agoSounds dumb but consider the evolution of world population over time: - 1950: 2.5 billion - 2000: 6 billion - 2018: 7.6 billion
- cwkoss 9y agoI don't mean to be dismissive of your general sentiment, I think we agree - I just think your example is a bit superlative. I think when viewing exponential trends we need to consider the maximum 'carrying capacity' - typically when something is growing exponentially there is some latent 'available energy' that is being consumed to fuel the growth. Once consumption reaches parity with that energy production - growth may continue for a bit longer as 'excess reserves' are drained, but a trend reversal becomes inevitable. > even the worst cities of 2018 will be unaffordable for the regular person. In your city example, I'd argue that once a city is too expensive for any 'regular' person it will create a negative feedback loop: if unable to source enough labor to satisfy the service demands of the wealthy residents, those residents will begin leaving, reducing housing prices until the problem is at least somewhat mitigated.
- partycoder 9y agoExcept that in 2118 those wealthy residents may not need less wealthy residents because of automation.
- floatingatoll 9y agoHow much of San Francisco’s billion dollars of debt would be mitigated by tax revenue associated with a 50% increase in taxable population? Would the tax revenue over 20 years make up for the infrastructure buildout costs and the legal costs of fighting NIMBY folks to increase density?
- saosebastiao 9y agoThe entire current population of the bay area (~9M) would fit within 165 of the 10,000 square miles of the CSA, if built at Parisian densities. That is less than 2% of the land. This is what boggles my mind: despite such a minimal land requirement, nobody in the entire fucking region will budge. Put it somewhere else, they say. It has become a game of musical chairs where nobody gets up for the next round. State intervention is the only thing that will solve this problem.
- shifter 9y agoOr, as the calculus on living in the Bay Area shifts [0], top tier talent starts to direct itself elsewhere. This stems growth in the Bay Area since founding successful companies in lower cost areas will be possible, housing investment slows as a result of that, and the market naturally cools down a bit [1]. [0] Don't fool yourself into thinking that only people without the income or capital to live well in the Bay Area would leave it. There are intangibles (culture, traffic, distance to skiing, etc.) that, for some people, are non-optimal. For others, it's perfect. That's okay, humans are a varied lot (and it's a good thing). [1] Nothing major, it will remain expensive due to geography and talent/creativity/capital density.
- jdtang13 9y agoIt's not really about tech companies, although the tech companies don't help. Contemporary conversation about Bay Area housing always makes it sound like some impossible dream that is hampered by hordes of techies. It seems to me that most of those concerns are red herrings; it's actually about zoning, local opposition, and government incompetence. The other HN comment ITT summarizes it pretty well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16970532 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16970532
- digianarchist 9y agoCalifornia tried and failed to pass legislation recently. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/04/26/606151956/california-s-housing-conundrum https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/04/26/606151956/cali...
- trumped 9y agoIt sounds like a small problem if all tech companies want to stay in a small geographical area and if they work with each other to resolve it... They should look at what China is doing if they need ideas.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- daveguy 9y agoOr worded another way: If Bay Area Housing grows slightly more than 2% per year the affordability crisis will be solved within 20 years. ( 1.5(1/20) ~ 1.0205 )
- njarboe 9y agoAn amazing amount of land opened up in the Bay Area that could have been used for housing developement with the closing of many military bases (The Presidio, Treasure Island, Alameda Naval station, Concord Naval Base, Hunters Point) and the closing of salt production in the South Bay. While a few of these areas are finally seeing some construction[1] 20 years later, the density is often low and the amount of acres set aside for green space seems excessive to me. Treasure Island, for instance, is 465 acres with 300 of those acres as parks. Cargill handed over 15,000 acres of salt ponds to state and federal agencies for wetland restoration in 2002. No housing planned. For comparison all of San Francisco is 30,000 acres. [1]https://www.bisnow.com/san-francisco/news/construction-development/these-5-decommissioned-military-bases-are-the-bay-areas-biggest-development-opportunities-74375 https://www.bisnow.com/san-francisco/news/construction-devel...
- cjensen 9y agoSalt ponds being turned into natural wetland is a HUGE win for the environment, particularly water quality and fisheries. Being entirely mud, they are literally the worst place to build in an earthquake-prone region. "Affordability" just means a balance between jobs (which produce people needing housing) and the supply of houses. There are TWO ways of fixing supply and demand problems like that. It is insane that the city of Cupertino has allowed the construction of offices for 26K jobs but only has housing for 58K people. It is insane that Mountain View has allowed the construction of offices for 30K jobs but only provided places for 77K people to live. Those two cities and others collect all the sweet revenue and burden the rest of the Bay Area with costs of housing and commuting. Rather than insisting that cities must build housing, we should insist they balance jobs and homes. I'm angry that my home town, Fremont, had a plan to reserve space for both homes and jobs, but is forced by the state to accept home construction and we have no money to build the schools needed to accommodate the new population.
- khuey 9y agoFremont's jobs/housing ratio is 1.44 which is larger than the regional average.
- 089723645897236 9y agoHey maybe some other parts of the world need populating too. This obsession with location location location is quaint to me in the age of telecom. Maybe the Bay Area is just Done. It'll turn into every other Rich Person Town and the people who need to get real s* done will go somewhere else. Legacy industry is no excuse to keep cramming more people onto a tiny peninsula in California. It sucks for people in the middle and lower involved right now but honestly I encourage them to move at all costs. The writing is on the wall.
- Clubber 9y agoI would think this could be solved by allowing remote work when viable, and making sure there is plenty of internet in rural areas. I would love to live on 5-500 acres somewhere and work on the porch. There's plenty of land to go around; we're just stuck in the 20th century way of thinking about work in a digital age. Strange.