12 ms·
The author's particular gripe is that the Watson advertisements showing someone sitting down and talking to "Watson." They bother me as well (and did so when I
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
The author's particular gripe is that the Watson advertisements showing someone sitting down and talking to "Watson." They bother me as well (and did so when I was working at IBM in the Watson group) because they portray a capability that nothing in IBM can provide. Nobody can provide it (again to the author's point) because dialog systems (those which interact with a user through conversational speech) don't exist out side specific, tightly constrained, decision trees (like voice mail or customer support prompts).
If SpaceX were to advertise like that, they would have famous people sitting in their living room, on mars, and talking about what they liked about the Martian way of life. In that case I believe that most people would understand that SpaceX wasn't already hosting people on Mars.
Unfortunately many, many people think that talking to your computer in actually already possible, they just haven't experienced it yet. Not sure how we fix that.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoKinda how Tesla advertises autopilot as a self driving car that's safer than human drivers? > Full Self-Driving Hardware on All Cars > All Tesla vehicles produced in our factory, including Model 3, have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver. https://www.tesla.com/autopilot/ https://www.tesla.com/autopilot/
- Judgmentality 9y agoAm I extreme in feeling someone should go to jail for that? It was bad enough when they were originally advertising it, but now that they're defending it even after people died...ugh. https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/28/17172178/tesla-model-x-crash-autopilot-fire-investigation https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/28/17172178/tesla-model-x-cr...
- GW150914 9y agoI think if anything you’re overly conservative for thinking somone rather than many people need jail time for it. I would look up the line of people who made and supported the decision for that kind of fraudulent marketing and drag them all into court.
- earenndil 9y agoSo...one person died? Do you know how many people die in normal, non-self-driving cars? It's never possible to get 100% accuracy.
- GW150914 9y agoIf those people die because the car fails catastrophically, and predictably, rather than the usual reasons it would be news. This is not about 100% or “the perfect is the enemy of the good” or any bullshit Utopianism. This is about a company marketing a flawed product deceptively for money, while letting useful idiots cover their asses with dreams of level 5 automation that aren’t even close to the horizon.
- Judgmentality 9y agoOne person died from that accident. There are now at least 4 deaths where Tesla's autopilot was involved (most of the deaths in China don't get much publicity, and I wouldn't be surprised if there are more). And the statistics do not back up your claim that Tesla is safer (despite their attempts to spin it that way).
- Aqueous 9y agoThis seems to contradict your assertion: http://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-autopilot-cuts-crash-rates-by-40-government-finds-2017-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-autopilot-cuts-crash-ra...
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoNo, the NHTSA report says nothing about how Tesla's autopilot compares to human driving. Here are two comments I made last week about this: In that study there are two buckets, one which is total Tesla miles in TACC-enabled cars and then after the update total Tesla miles in cars with TACC + Autosteer and they calculated on airbag deployments. Human driven miles are going to dominate both of those buckets and there's a reason the NHTSA report makes zero claims about Tesla's safety relative to human drivers. It's totally outside the scope of the study. Then add in that some researchers who are skeptical of the methodology and have been asking for the raw data from NHTSA/Tesla have yet to receive it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16932350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16932350 Autosteer, however, is relatively unique to Tesla. That’s what makes singling out Autosteer as the source of a 40 percent drop so curious. Forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking were introduced just months before the introduction of Autosteer in October 2015. A previous IIHS study shows that both the collision warning and auto emergency braking can deliver a similar reduction in crashes. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16932406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16932406
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoJail, no? Financial ruin for the company that was willing to put that BS below it's letterhead? Yeah, sure, in proportion with the harm caused. That said, human life isn't sacred. It and everything else gets trades for dollars all the time. A death or three shouldn't cripple a big company like Tesla unless they were playing so fast and loose that there's significant punitive damages. In a large company like Tesla it shouldn't be marketing's job to restrain itself. That's not safe at that scale. There should be someone or a group who's job it is to prevent marketing from getting ahead of reality just like it's security's job to spend all day playing whack-a-mole with the stupid ideas devs (especially the web ones) dream up. Efficiently mediating conflicting interests like that is what the corporate control structure is for. People using your product in accordance with your marketing should be considered almost the same as in accordance with your documentation. While "people dying while using the product in accordance with TFM" is not treated as strict liability it's pushing awfully close. I see it as a simple case of the company owning up to its actions. It failed to manage itself properly, marketing got ahead of reality. You screw up and someone gets hurt then you pay up.
- mrj 9y ago"That said, human life isn't sacred. It and everything else gets trades for dollars all the time." Wow. Uhm, slavery is illegal if you haven't heard. We made it illegal because life is sacred.
- sologoub 9y agoOP is probably referring to the fact that in wrongful death suits, society has put a very tangible financial number on the value of human life. This made it possible for corporations to make trade-off between profit and liability, giving the potential that someone could get enough profit to justify risking others’ lives. Punitive damages go part way to help prevent this, but not far enough to guarantee that it never happens. Had the society truly believed life to be sacred, I suspect we’d have very different business practices and penalties that are not limited to financial ruin.
- 9y ago
- hacker11235 9y agoWhile I don't necessarily agree with how they've advertised it I think they are legally safe. All Model 3's DO have the HARDWARE to support full-self driving, even if the software is not there. And regarding the software, it has been shown to be about 40% safer than humans where it is used, which is what they've claimed.
- stdgy 9y agoHow do we know the hardware will adequately support full self-driving if it doesn't actually exist yet? That seems overly optimistic, if not an outright fabrication.
- tomp 9y agoBecause humans can do driving with comparable (worse, actually) hardware. Superhuman reflexes mean that software with superhuman driving abilities can exist.
- mhermher 9y agoHumans also have human brains, which are much more important to driving than eyes.
- hacker11235 9y agoThis is the part that can be emulated in software. All you have to prove is that what ever platform/language you're using for the programming is Turing Complete, which is the case for almost all of the most popular languages.
- mhermher 9y agoSo can I run Crysis on my TI calculator? I'm sure whatever platform/language is running on it is Turing Complete. I think you missed the point that the brain is also hardware.
- jcranmer 9y agoMusk's statements, and Tesla in general, have gone to cultivating an impression that Tesla almost has self-driving. An impression that, okay, it's not perfect, but it's good enough that you can act like it is for most of the time. This impression is far enough from the truth that it's fundamentally dishonest, particularly when the response from Tesla after incidents amounts to "the driver is completely at fault here, we don't need to change anything" (in other words, their marketing says it's basically self-driving, their legal defense says self-driving is only at your own risk). In the moralistic sense, yes, Tesla needs to be reprimanded for its actions. However, lying in this manner is often well-protected by law, if you manage to include enough legalese disclaimers somewhere, and I suspect Tesla has enough lawyers to make sure that legalese is sufficient to disclaim all liability.
- nojvek 9y agoUS advertising laws are very lax, just like data collection laws. You can getaway with saying a lot of shit in the name of advertising. Deaths caused by Uber and Tesla hold little repercussions for them other than bad PR. The US govt celebrates removing regulations which benefit its corporations at the cost of its citizens
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThat is a much better example. With the twist that believing it can get you killed.
- Rjevski 9y agoHardware. That’s the keyword, and it might very well be true. Tesla doesn’t claim their software is capable of full self-driving yet and in fact the system will scream at you and stop the car if you take your hands off the steering wheel for too long.
- lordnacho 9y agoAnd when the software is self-driving, it's safe to use the car in the way we all want? Who's to know if there isn't a third key component necessary for that, behind yet another technical term?
- ghostly_s 9y agoIt's deliberately deceptive, and I'm real tired of tech people tripping over each other to defend it. Technically correct? Sure. But deliberately phrased to obscure the fact that this is a hypothetical future capability that the product does not possess today. And please spare me your "well actually, the showroom attendants will clarify exactly what it means" -- they are framing this in a misleading way to generate public interest.
- myared 9y agoWho is being deceived? Non-Tesla owners? Or are you suggesting that there are Tesla owners who are (a) sitting in their driveway wondering why their car isn't driving them to work or (b) returning their cars upon finding out many of the features on the Autopilot page require regulatory approval?
- GW150914 9y agohttps://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/tesla-autopilot-driver-motorway-m1-nottingham-a8326911.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/tesla-autopilot-... Tesla driver caught turning on autopilot and leaving driver’s seat on motorway Culprit admits he knew what he had done was ‘silly’ but that the car was capable of something ‘amazing’
- kmonsen 9y ago
- djhworld 9y agoUnfortunately people take that marketing literally https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/tesla-autopilot-driver-motorway-m1-nottingham-a8326911.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/tesla-autopilot-...
- delinka 9y agoBut it’s technically correct: the hardware is present. The software isn’t there yet, that’s true. So is this a “lie by omission”? Reading the whole page, there’s this quote: “It is not possible to know exactly when each element of the functionality described above will be available.” What else needs to be said? At some point, critical thinking is required to navigate the world. The customer should ask “and when will the software catch up?” And I’ll concede that the overwhelming majority of the population doesn’t think like that. Should Tesla update the site with statements to confirm the negative cases? e.g. “Our software can’t yet do X, Y, Z, etc”
- c22 9y agoSince we have yet to build a system that is capable of "full self-driving ... at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver" I'm not even sure they can make the claim that their existing hardware supports this. They might have high hopes, but there's no way to know what combination of hardware and software will be necessary until the problem is actually solved.
- lifeformed 9y agoI don't even think a lot of people would even consider the software side when reading that sentence. To the layperson, "Full self-driving hardware on all cars" sounds exactly like "These cars are self-driving".
- rifung 9y agoI would argue even if something is technically correct but deliberately misleading companies should get in trouble for it. Nobody has time or energy to learn about every single thing they may buy. Also, how can we even know the hardware is sufficient unless said software exists and shows that what we think is possible is indeed possible?
- wang_li 9y agoUntil tesla can provide a real world demonstration of an existing vehicle running at L5 automation after only a software upgrade, it's unproven whether the hardware required is present or not. At some point, they will have to provide said demo or they will be facing a class action lawsuit that will bankrupt the company.
- mpweiher 9y ago"...have the hardware needed for...". Nothing about the full capability. So no actual claim about the capability, just that the hardware is in place. Still a bit deceptive, to me. Reminds me of "...electroplated in 16 carat gold...".
- phkahler 9y agoIt's not just them. A lot of people think that because NNs can do object identification that self driving cars are almost here. It's similar to thinking that word recognition and pattern matching are going to give us conversational AI. Things like that are prerequisites for AI, but they are hardly the whole thing. Companies are spending billions on this stuff and I hope they're just hedging in case it pans out rather than planning their future around it.
- blattimwind 9y agoMany people seem to think the arrival of fully autonomous cars is right around the corner; when I say that it will likely take at least 10 years, but probably more like 20, until there will be significant numbers of those on the road they are very surprised. I admit I recently upped that number from "5-10 years minimum" after seeing the media reaction to recent driver-assist systems related accidents — it became clear to me that the old adage "the autonomous car does not need to be perfect, it only needs to be better than an {average, good, skilled} human driver" is simply wrong, because autonomous car brand X will be regarded - and judged - as if all X cars are one driver. Thus, these cars actually need to be much better than humans in essentially any traffic situation, because it simply won't be acceptable for "autonomous cars of brand X" to kill a few thousand people each year in every country. People would equate this to a single human driver mowing down thousands. This effect is not necessarily bad, I don't have the inside information, but it's likely (or at least probable) that manufacturers invested in this technology observed the same and drew a similar conclusion. The question now is whether the car makers make autonomous cars that good, or invest into massive PR campaigning to change public perception towards "each autonomous car is like an individual driver and it doesn't need to do much better than that". We've seen the latter before. Jaywalking and avenues are just two examples.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoWell Jaywalking is only illegal in 10 countries. So PR campaigns won't be enough for that. The benefits of self driving cars as so massive that it will trump anything like that - but we are still a long way away from practical self driving cars.
- martimarkov 9y agoAre you for real? Statistics prove that Tesla is right on this. I’m not saying human life has no value, and I do empathise with the people who lost someone due to a Tesla crash, but we can see what is the percentage. It IS lower compared to human error, and yes that includes DUI and every other time it was a human error. Tesla is safer for the community based on the statistical data. Also it is safer than a human driving. I’m not saying it will never crash just that it will crash less than a human. Maybe another way to compare it would be to an autopilot in airplanes. Sometimes it fails so we might as well be angry at the airline companies if they advertise it. But a pilot would make more mistakes than the autopilot with the current workload. Side note: if you are going to downvote you can comment on why. Negative feedback is very useful and helps build better argumentative skills.
- rohit2412 9y ago> It IS lower compared to human error, What is lower and compared to what? I am tired of this vague misleading statements by Elon musk, Tesla and their supporters. They claimed Autopilot + driver is 40% safer than a driver alone. And that includes Automatic emergency braking. Is it a surprise that AEB reduces accidents? Why is that used as proof that Tesla's software is FSD. FSD implies that the car is capable of driving without a driver. Is Autopilot alone safer than a driver? There is no proof of that But what you should compare is Autopilot alone compared with a driver assisted by Autopilot. So, is Autopilot better than Driver+Autopilot? I can assure you its not, the driver still adds value.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mkirklions 9y agoIts crazy how reasonable ycombinator is compared to reddit. Reddit is dominated by tesla's marketing team. Upvoting, downvoting, and commenting. Here you get a real discussion regarding Elon's outlandish promises.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>It IS lower compared to human error One of the big issues here is the concept of "human error", as though a statistical average is some sort of monolith that can be applied to all humans. The truth is that many people lack the basic skills and attributes needed to drive safely (concentration, attention to detail, the ability to multitask effectively). This is true even before factoring the millions of elderly people who are unable to tie their own shoes or operate a self-checkout kiosk who are out on the road making things more dangerous for everyone (including themselves). Performing virtually any task better than "the average human" is a very, very low bar to hurdle. The question is, what standard should we be using to determine who (or what, in the case of self-driving cars) should be allowed to pilot a multi-ton vehicle on public streets? The truth is that we favor convenience over safety (and I'm not even arguing that this is a bad thing - just that it is an often ignored fact) in many facets of society, and in order to have an intelligent debate about self-driving cars we ought to recognize and acknowledge this fact.
- reaperducer 9y ago"Self-driving" is not the same as "Never going to crash." People just assume that if a computer does something, it's going to be perfect. It isn't. Most humans can't even "self-walk" without occasionally stumbling and falling. Does that make human locomotion dangerous and false?
- air7 9y agoClaiming that the hardware is ready and we're just waiting on the software is at best a vacuous claim and worse, a fraudulent one. I can hammer two web-cams onto a rotating plank and claim that's "full self-driving capability". Just look at the eyes in my head! Now I just need to iron out some kinks in the software...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 9y agoThis is Marketing 101 though. It's easier to sell someone a dream or some emotional state than it is to sell an actual product/thing that you have. I'd give people a little more credit. Adults know what advertisements are and that they're all phony.
- briffle 9y agoIE, unlimited data plans where unlimited is defined as de-prioritized after X GB per billing month.
- mkirklions 9y agoI hate tmobile for this reason. Totally crap, especially since tmobile runs ads that have pink background and 1 word on the screen: UNLIMITED No. Its not unlimited. I know because I paid 25 extra dollars for a month for their international plan. Truly unlimited.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI don't disagree, although I'd be a bit more nuanced than that. It is like herbal supplements, you can say how great they make you feel but you have to avoid making medical claims that you can't back up. I don't think anyone would have flinched at setting the stage like "At IBM we're working on technology so that some day your interaction with a computer can be as simple as sitting down and having a conversation." Setting expectations you cannot meet is something you try to avoid in Marketing. Because you get angry op eds like the one that kicked off this conversation.
- reaperducer 9y ago>I don't think anyone would have flinched at setting the stage like "At IBM we're working on technology so that some day your interaction with a computer can be as simple as sitting down and having a conversation." Like those old AT&T commercials (available on YouTube) where AT&T made all kinds of predictions about the future that seemed crazy in the 1980's, but are reality 35 years later. Video calls, instant electronic toll booth payment, etc... / R.I.P, AT&T.
- PaulHoule 9y agoWhat's bad about it is that it leads to a "market for lemons" for anyone working in the A.I. field in either engineering or sales. People see so much bullshit that they come to the conclusion that it is all bullshit.
- mkirklions 9y agoI think this is good. In a world that moves too quick to have review/ratings companies for everything, you should come in skeptical and be proven wrong. Its up to the merchant to make a great product, its up to you to compare and make good decisions.
- optimuspaul 9y agoNo, it's bad because it drives down the potential market value for good products that could become available in the market because the market expects that all AI is inferior to expectations.
- CharlesW 9y agoTemporarily. Once past (and possibly during) the "Trough of Disillusionment"[1], products that really do solve problems that people are willing to pay to have solved will do very well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle
- PaulHoule 9y agoIBM can bullshit it's way through a coming "AI Winter"; startups might not be able to.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoHow do you "compare" multimillion dollar custom IT installations, before you buy?
- 9y ago
- pacala 9y agoWe fix that by building conversational AI ;)
- hristov 9y agoOne way to fix it is not to make outright false advertisements.
- _rpd 9y agoOr at least require cigarette style warning labels: Warning, this advertisement is a lie. Believing this advertisement may harm your cognitive health.
- salatschussel 9y agoWarning, this statement is false.
- shmageggy 9y ago> Not sure how we fix that How about prosecuting them for false advertising? Seems like a classic case, albeit in a new domain.
- dullgiulio 9y agoWe could also classify fake ads using machine learning...
- fjsolwmv 9y agoRed Bull doesn't actually give you wings. Ads are metaphors.
- raarts 9y agoNo, the Red Bull ad _uses_ a metaphor. False advertising is claiming to be something you are not, raising false expectations.
- shmageggy 9y agoYou guys couldn't have picked a more perfect example: Red Bull settled a class action lawsuit for false advertising, not because of "gives you wings", but because their advertising falsely suggested scientific support for their product being better than caffiene-only products. https://www.truthinadvertising.org/red-bull/ https://www.truthinadvertising.org/red-bull/
- pnloyd 9y agoTo be fair, you can kinda talk to Google assistant in a "question response" type capacity and it does pretty well.
- arghwhat 9y agoYou can also kinda talk to ELIZA. Google Assistant, Apple Siri and Amazon Echo are all quite fancy natural language parsers. After parsing, it's just a group of "dumb" (wo)man-made widgets.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThere not entirely true. Google Search will answer a question with an automatically extracted excerpt from a website page. Watson did the similar with its Jeopardy system
- arghwhat 9y agoOnly in some cases, supposedly as a fallback.
- vertexFarm 9y agoIs that not parsing and keyword searching? Once again there's no "cognitive computing" going on. Which is a really weird and nebulous thing to define, by the way. I think we aren't going to have super convincing cognitive computing until we have something approaching AGI. Which of course is waaay different from the AI and machine learning that is popular today, despite most laypeople conflating any mention of AI with AGI. Of course, when IBM is making an ad, they are largely aiming at laypeople.
- sgt101 9y agoSearch and command interfaces are doable (within reasonable expectations) dialogs just aren't without eye popping engineering challenges (like 100k branches hand engineered onto trees + lots of deep learning.) Also we (science) know shockingly little about real dialogs and their challenges as far as I can find out - but I am not a linguist and am angling here fore some killer references !
- kbenson 9y ago> Unfortunately many, many people think that talking to your computer in actually already possible, they just haven't experienced it yet. Given how often another person can't correctly infer meaning when people talk, I doubt it will ever be how people imagine it. Initially, I imagine it will be a lot of people trying to talk normally and a lot of AI responses asking how your poorly worded worded request should be carried out, choice A, or choice B. You'll be annoyed because why can't the system just do the thing that's right 90% of the time? The problem is that 10% of the time you're just not explaining yourself well at all and 10% is really quite a lot of the time, and probably ranges from a few requests to dozens of requests a day, and while being asked what you meant is annoying, having the wrong thing done can be catastrophic. As humans, we get around this to some degree by modeling the person we are conversing with as thinking "what would they want to do right now", which is another class of problem for AIs I assume, so I think we may not get human level interaction until AI's can fairly closely model humans themselves. I imagine we'll probably develop some AI pidgin language that provides more formality that as long as we follow it AI voice interactions become less annoying (but you have to spend a bit of time before to formulate it). Then again, maybe I'm way off base. You sound like you would know much better than me. :)
- joshmarlow 9y ago> I imagine we'll probably develop some AI pidgin language that provides more formality that as long as we follow it AI voice interactions become less annoying (but you have to spend a bit of time before to formulate it). There's been some tentative discussion of using Lojban as a basis for just that! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lojban#Lojban_as_a_potential_machine_interlingua https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lojban#Lojban_as_a_potential_m... http://www.goertzel.org/new_research/Loglish.htm http://www.goertzel.org/new_research/Loglish.htm
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI think you have a good point. Something that was fascinating for me was that one of the things the search engine did after being acquired by IBM was looking at search queries for common questions people would ask a search engine. Taking 5 years of search engine query strings (no PII[1]) and turning them into a 'question' that someone might ask. What was interesting is that it was clear that search engines have trained a lot of people to speak 'search engine' rather than stick with English. Instead of "When is Pizza hut open?" you would see a query "Pizza Hut hours". That works for a search engine because you have presented it with a series of non stopword terms in priority order. It reminded me of the constraint based naming papers that came out of MIT in the late 80's / early 90's. It also suggested to me ways to take dictated speech and reformat it into a search engine query. There is probably a couple of good academic papers in that data somewhere. That experience suggests to me that what you are proposing (a pidgin type language for AI) is a very likely possibility. One of the bits that Jimmy Fallon does on the Tonight Show is an interviewer who asks people a question but uses nonsense words that sound "right" in the question. The most recent example was changing the question "Do you think you will see Avengers: Infinity War" With things like "Do you think you will see Avengers something I swear." Similar sounds and people have already jumped to the question with enough context that they always answer as if he had said "Infinity War." How will conversational systems deal with that, I have no idea.
- modeless 9y ago> I believe that most people would understand that SpaceX wasn't already hosting people on Mars. You overestimate people's understanding of space. Many people thought "The Martian" was a true story like "Apollo 13".
- mwfunk 9y agoHow many is “many” though? I’m assuming slightly more than thought Star Wars was real, and slightly fewer than think Iron Man was real. That’s not ignorance, that’s mental illness.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoCreating an impression of a capability without legally promising it is the essence of marketing, especially in the corporate IT consulting world which is 90% garbage and hugely expense.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoThere was a time when I'd introduce people to 'Eliza'-type programs. Those programs stashed phrases typed in by users. When new users typed in a phrase, the programs would parrot back the stashed phrases ... based on really crude algo's, or even random selection. Nonetheless, I watched people get really worked up about what the computer was 'saying'. Partly because of the sarcastic stuff people would say, partly because of their expectations about 'cybernetic brains'. Now the 'Cyc'le is back. And people actually working on this really hard problem are not helped by dumb marketing.
- opportune 9y agoIt all goes back to how the Watson that played jeopardy - what the vast majority think of when they hear the word "Watson" - was a really cool research experiment and amazing advertising. A lot of the people that pay for "Watson" probably think they're paying for something really similar to the Watson that beat Ken Jennings at Jeopardy! and cracked jokes on TV. They're paying for something that might use some of the same algorithms and software, but they're not actually getting something that seems as sentient and "clever" as what was on TV. To me, the whole "Watson" division does seem like false advertising.
- cheeko1234 9y agoYup. And they have sold it as a "potential solution" to everything data processing related. Hell, they even got NASA to pay for it: https://www.space.com/35042-ibm-watson-computer-nasa-research.html https://www.space.com/35042-ibm-watson-computer-nasa-researc...
- paulclinger 9y ago> Not sure how we fix that. Easy: just say that all Watson systems have the hardware needed for cognitive computing and full dialog support.
- xster 9y agoIn my limited understanding, isn't this just the state of A.I. in general? I don't know of anyone trying to solve the general intelligence problem. Everyone's just finding formula for specific applications and using M.L. to curve fit.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThis is not just Watson and IBM. Many, many people in AI make grandiose claims and throw around big words like "Natural Language Understanding" "scene understanding" or "object recognition" etc. And it is a very old problem, at least from the time of Drew McDermot and "Artificial Intelligence meets Natural Stupidity": https://homepage.univie.ac.at/nicole.rossmanith/concepts/papers/mcdermott1976artificial.pdf https://homepage.univie.ac.at/nicole.rossmanith/concepts/pap... From which I quote: However, in AI, our programs to a great degree are problems rather than solutions. If a researcher tries to write an "understanding" program, it isn't because he has thought of a better way of implementing this well-understood task, but because he thinks he can come closer to writing the _first_ implementation. If he calls the main loop of his program UNDERSTAND, he is (until proven innocent) merely begging the question. He may mislead a lot of people, most prominently himself, and enrage a lot of others.
- rubyfan 9y agoIt’s a pretty serious problem if public company executives who choose how to spend investors dollars actually believe SpaceX’s famous people are on Mars. Then they pay SpaceX to start carrying goods to Mars to sell to the Martians. SpaceX obliges with multi-million dollar contracts, knowing they don’t have a way to get to Mars but have some rockets that can put satellites into orbit (not the same). We’d all see the problem with such a situation. People with a 6th grade knowledge on space travel understand that the commercials were BS marketing and we should fire the executives for not knowing the same or doing their due diligence. We’d be mad at SpaceX for taking advantage of companies and failing to reach Mars as promised.
- loceng 9y agoFalse advertising laws?