13 ms·
Detroit Was Crumbling, Now It's Reviving
- curiouscat321 9y agoI grew up in the Metro Detroit area and moved out to the coasts after graduating from Umich a couple years ago. There’s more excitement around Detroit than I’ve seen at any point in my life. As somebody from the suburbs, my family would actively avoid Detroit unless we were going to a baseball game. That’s changed. There’s many great restaurants and downtown feels more like a real city. But, all of my friends still left the state. If you’re college educated, there’s a 60/40 chance you’ll leave Michigan right after graduation. Even worse if you graduate from UMich, which is scary since it’s the state’s flagship university. The white-collar jobs are there, but they can’t compete with the jobs in other parts of the country. I graduated CS and I can’t name a single friend that didn’t move to the west coast. Even after the COL differences, you still come out ahead by leaving the state. I want Detroit to grow and I’d love to move back. I just need some solid jobs to attract me back.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoDetroit is an odd place. For years of going there for work it was tough to find locally owned restaurants in favor of chains, it’s do-able but you might end up in weird places like a polish restaurant literally in the basement of a house a few blocks off Woodward. The people who identify with Detroit really do so. There is at first an inexplicable pride of being “from the D”, but it’s nice, there are really diverse art scenes, I’ve had great food, and really most people are quite friendly for being eastern half of the country. It’s an odd place.
- api 9y ago> It’s an odd place. This is the most bullish thing you can say. An odd place is special vs. the rest of generica.
- ch4s3 9y ago> It’s an odd place. That's exactly how I felt living in Baltimore. Now that I live in New York, everyone and everything seems so normal, but in a dull kind of way. America's downtrodden and resurgent smaller cities have a lot going for them in terms of culture, character, the resiliency of their people. I really hope they can find some measure of economic success.
- hackeraccount 9y agoI live in Baltimore - I've always thought Detroit was our sister city. Both totally F'd. I still like B'More though. Dunno why.
- dionidium 9y agoSt. Louisan here. Arguments for why we're actually your sister city: 1) Both independent cities. There are only a few in the entire country. St. Louis and Baltimore are the two largest. This dynamic plays out in very similar ways in both cities. I hang out on r/baltimore a bit. The people there use the terms "City" and "County" almost exactly as we do. 2) Similar demographics, crime rates, and issues. Detroit is down to about 10% white. The splits in Baltimore and St. Louis are more even, which informs quite a bit of the racial politics in each city. (I can't imagine there's much of a white voting bloc left in Detroit, but it still makes a big difference in St. Louis and Baltimore.) 3) Very similar population peaks. St. Louis peaked at ~850k. Baltimore once had about 950k. Detroit was much, much larger at its peak. 4) The Baltimore Orioles used to be the St. Louis Browns. 5) Similar architectural patterns. Where Baltimore has row houses: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/55/7e/11/557e11d75dd3b45ed3efaca2b2269aa6.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/55/7e/11/557e11d75dd3b45ed3ef... St. Louis has red brick: https://misfitstream.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/25.jpg https://misfitstream.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/25.jpg The prevalence of each form creates very similar vibes in each city. Detroit doesn't seem to have any such dominant form. 6) Detroit's boom (driven by the automobile) came later than either Baltimore's or St. Louis's. Baltimore and St. Louis are much more from the same, earlier era and that definitely comes through when walking around in their older neighborhoods.
- busterarm 9y ago
- hpcjoe 9y agoMario's[1] for excellent Italian food. Xoxhimilco[2] for excellent Mexican food. Antonio's[3] in the burbs. New Peking[4] in GC for excellent Chinese food. I've lived in Michigan 30 years now. Came here for grad school, first at MSU, then down to Wayne State for Ph.D. Never left. There is something about this place. Even when we are getting the crap kicked out of us ... we don't give up. It took a long time to get rid of most of the corrupt city management. Some are still there, and the city council are generally throwbacks to the bad time. Detroit school system is still ... crap. Private and charter schooling is doing a great job of fixing that, giving parents a choice, and forcing the schools to compete for students. This helps. There are many other anachronisms throughout the region and state. Some of these are quaint, some of them are incredibly frustrating, off putting, etc. If we could only attract more money to the area, this would be a great place to form small companies seeking to be large companies. Low burn rates/costs. Lots of talent that wants to escape the autos, and other failed regional initiatives (life science corridor anyone?). Ann Arbor has a nascent/tiny startup scene. Should be bigger. [1] https://www.facebook.com/detroitmarios/ https://www.facebook.com/detroitmarios/ [2] http://www.xochimilcorestaurant.com/ http://www.xochimilcorestaurant.com/ [3] https://antoniosrestaurants.com/ https://antoniosrestaurants.com/ [4] http://newpekingusa.com/ http://newpekingusa.com/
- trisimix 9y agoRep for Wayne State
- jacquesm 9y ago> Private and charter schooling is doing a great job of fixing that, giving parents a choice Free private schools? If not they are giving parents that can afford it a choice. Just like wealthy expats tend to place their kids in good private schools in poor places because they can afford it. As long as education isn't good for everybody it's just another way to stack the deck.
- sremani 9y agoI would be really interested what you did with your kids'(if you have any) education. Tell us what you practiced.
- tjr225 9y agoI went to that restaurant after I ran the 2014 Detroit Marathon...locked my wife(then girlfriend's) keys in her car. Great food!
- dopamean 9y agoI make several trips to Detroit each year (entirely music related) and after every visit the voice in my head that says "move to Detroit" get's louder and louder. The place is definitely still having a rough time but it feels so much more promising over the last couple of years and I'd love to be there permanently. Just have to convince my wife...
- wpietri 9y agoFor those in tech, I recommend checking out TechTown Detroit: https://techtowndetroit.org/ https://techtowndetroit.org/ A former colleague from decades ago runs it, so I visited it late last year. I was really impressed. They are very interested in enabling all sort of entrepreneurship in Detroit, including that of the tech kind. For personal reasons, I'm pretty tied to San Francisco. But if I were starting a new business, I'd look hard at Detroit. In 1998, SF/SV was the heart of something new and different. But the Internet's success over the last 20 years means that much of what was then specialized local knowledge is now available everywhere. Michigan's universities produce a steady stream of graduates; UMich Ann Arbor's CS program is well ranked. For hiring established talent, being able to actually afford a house is a big draw, and for those not tempted remote work is getting ever easier. There's plenty of educated non-tech labor; you could open a customer service center there or in one of many medium-sized towns nearby for prices that seem ridiculously low. I think the only real drawback is that the shiniest VCs seem very reluctant to invest in companies that aren't in shiny places. But given what a devil's bargain VC money is, and given how much of it goes right into shiny-place prices, I suspect that many could have better odds of long-term success by taking money with a local or long-term focus.
- helipad 9y agoI lived in Brush Park and still walk through it on the way to Tigers games. What's interesting about the handful of Victorian restorations is that there are large apartment buildings behind built around them, sometimes directly adjacent. When they were being restored there were green vacant lots around, within a couple of years they could be in the shadow of the new buildings. In walking through the neighborhood, I wondered if I'd move back there. I doubt it. It's still a bizarre city where there is very little downtown shopping, eerily quiet to walk around, almost no grocery stores. With the new bars and restaurants popping up, everyone said they wanted to live there, no-one I knew actually did it.
- rayiner 9y agoWeird that the article does not cite a single economic or demographic indicator to support its assertion. For example, Detroit's population has declined so far this decade at about the same pace as it declined from 1990-2000 (though not at the disastrous pace it declined from 2000-2010, when the city lost a quarter of its population). Sounds like far from a revival.
- trisimix 9y agohttps://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detroits-startup-scene-is-exploding/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detro...
- Bartweiss 9y ago> Take this at face value: Detroit has 50% more venture-backed startups than it did three years ago. This comes from a study from the Michigan Venture Capital Association (MVCA) which found there are 35 active venture-backed startups in Detroit. Sure, that’s not a huge number compared to other regions, but the growth is notable. The actual change here is "Detroit had a net gain of 12 startups over three years". That, and the comparable stat for Michigan as a whole, are the only growth numbers actually present in the article. And even the author rightly admits that we're talking about a tiny starting number. Remember that XKCD about rapid growth and small populations? (https://xkcd.com/1102/ https://xkcd.com/1102/) To be a bit cynical, this looks like a submarine piece for the Michigan Venture Capital Association, which is the source for 100% of the article's data, including the filler stuff about investment sectors that adds more statistics without advancing the actual growth thesis.
- padobson 9y agoThe relevant PG essay on submarines: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- jessriedel 9y agoWhat are the economic indicators that things are looking up? The place is still losing population as of last year, and it's not even clear if it's slowing down. http://www.dailydetroit.com/2017/05/25/detroit-continues-lose-population-according-new-census-data/ http://www.dailydetroit.com/2017/05/25/detroit-continues-los... (2016 appears to be the last year census data is available.)
- trisimix 9y agohttps://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detroits-startup-scene-is-exploding/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detro...
- jessriedel 9y agoOK, that just says that the number of VC-backed startups in Detroit went from 23 to 35. This doesn't tell us much about Detroit as a whole.
- trisimix 9y agoHi I'm from Detroit, I love seeing my city talked about. A lot of people are claiming decline of residents as a lack of proof of revival. Heres a counterpoint: https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detroits-startup-scene-is-exploding/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2017/07/10/detro... Detroit is spectacular for many reasons. We have retained and nurtured our resources from before the decline such as our art museum, libraries and ISPs (not the consumer ones). In the midst of our decline for some reason downtown detroit developed some kind of renaissance, despite the decline people decided to cling harder to things like the eastern market, architecture, and art. We are full of things like artistic movie theaters, plays, public displays, interesting cuisine, and startups. Yet you will not find a theater showing avengers, or a traditional supermarket until you get to around dearborn. There are also many quirks in the worse parts of Deteoit, a huge spread of people instead of concentrations, and many people taking what we have left behind to make something. I have visited every major city in the US outside of california and New York and I have never seen anything like detroit. We have somehow through disparity been blessed with the ability to be almost meritocratic, the amount of opportunities and equality In have experienced coming from a lower class, and the genuine people that remain is what I imagine to be higher than other cities. Anecdotally of course.
- unit91 9y agoDo you work for the city, a university in Detroit, etc?
- trisimix 9y agoI am a peer leader on Wayne State, the university inside Detroit, I dedicate a lot of my time to trying to organize students to come together and accomplish tasks. However no, I do not work for the city of Detroit, why do you ask?
- karpodiem 9y agoHi there, fellow Detroiter here. I would certainly say there is definite momentum in Detroit but I'd like to see additional angel funding / 1MM+ Series A rounds before I would use the word 'exploding' to describe the tech scene. Second - there are some very interesting software problems that the Tier 1 suppliers (Delphi/Magna/AAM/etc.) are working on but you never hear about it. Generally working for a tier 1 supplier sucks (suppliers are always subservient to the OEMs) but you there's nothing quite like getting your hands dirty in bringing together the real world and code.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt would be nice if that's true, but how many times has more or less this exact story been written?
- probably_wrong 9y agoWhen my country faced crippling recession, I remember someone mentioning that even bankrupt countries don't go anywhere - it's not as if someone will take the country and annex it. A failed country just lingers around until things eventually get better. For that same reason, I've always regretted not having money to buy real state in Detroit. No matter how bad things are, a city this big is bound to rebound sooner or later. I wonder how long it will take before "Detroit gentrification" becomes a thing.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoNot necessarily on a timescale that can benefit you. Population decline, crappy weather, pollution, water supply, politics, war, so many things can influence the value of land. There's a reason no one is clamoring to buy land in Somalia.
- walrus01 9y agoI am really skeptical of the financially strapped detroit city government's ability to maintain water and sewer services to many of the mostly razed blocks. People who own hosues that are the only remaining occupied, in good condition residences on entire city blocks may need to be prepared to go fully off grid in the future. The tax base just isn't there to support the scale of the city's street, sewer and water infrastructure anymore. From an ISP perspective: very sparsely populated areas are also going to see the cable TV company (DOCSIS3.0 or DOCSIS3.1 based cablemodem internet) and POTS/Copper phone line ILEC (ADSL2+, VDSL2) ISPs abandon or neglect their infrastructure. It does not make economic sense to maintain an aerial coaxial cable plant and DOCSIS3.0 CMTS systems throughout a region of a city that has only a few houses per block. Expect to be required to DIY your own internet as well.
- dizzystar 9y agoDetroit, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Toledo, and so on got absolutely destroyed after all the mills were shut down. The bar for reviving is incredibly low. Those that could leave, left. The very people that could quicken the recovery of the fallen Midwestern towns are the same people who left. Detroit has UM, Cleveland has Case Western, Pittsburgh has Carnegie Mellon which are all top-flight schools. In a strange way, they all have great local resources, but these are all, culturally, working class blue collar cities, and there is really nothing wrong with that. These cities ought to do better to embrace that identity. I'm from Cleveland. The city was fighting hard against the impending collapse by building out the Rock Hall, rebuilding the Browns stadium and discouraging the Dog Pound, along with and other things to make it more like a major city, ripping out the soul along the way. When LTV steel went under, the dominoes fell one after another, which destroyed the day and night life of the flats.1 Everyone in America doesn't want to stare at a computer, drink $5 latte's, and eat farm to table food. There is nothing wrong with a town that has $3 beers in a plastic cup and a crowd of people screaming until at the TV until they are horse. There is nothing shameful about marrying a man or woman while holding each other's calloused hands at the alter.
- ebbv 9y agoI'm sorry I have to do it; Detroit does not have U of Mich. U of Mich is 45 minutes west in Ann Arbor. Some U of M grads go over to Detroit, but it's not like U of M students live in Detroit. They are very separate. Detroit is mostly reviving because Ann Arbor, where U of M is, is way too expensive. The Ferndale area of Detroit is becoming what Ann Arbor was when I grew up in the 80s; all about its local community and full of young people trying to do new stuff. A big reason is that Ferndale was very cheap to live in, and while it's come up a lot it's still a lot cheaper than Ann Arbor (and a lot of other parts of Michigan.)
- wcunning 9y agoCheck Zillow right now -- Ferndale is not particularly cheaper than Ann Arbor these days. More importantly, my Ann Arbor Area to Detroit-ish commute is shorter (in time, not distance) than my friends working in the same building coming from Ferndale. When Ferndale was "cheap," I could have bought a literal mansion in Detroit with my sophomore intern money, cash in hand. To the GP's comments, Detroit has done a lot to come up in the world on its own, though I'm not sure I like the idea of Ford buying the old train station, nor am I entirely in love with the $2~3000/mo apartments in midtown and I kinda wish it still had more of its grunge pricing to go with the definite grunge feeling that still lingers... To argue more specifically with the parent's point, the statistical area certainly counts Ann Arbor, and that count is no less reasonable than Oakland being counted with SF. Commute times from Ann Arbor <-> the rest of Metro Detroit are entirely reasonable compared to the rest of the major cities in the country. Whether you're willing to accept any commute longer than walking across the street is a personal decision, clearly a significant fraction of the population will accept it.
- sneak 9y agoCertain parts of Detroit have seen rents double or triple in the last 3 years or so. I am hesitant to say that the city as a whole is “back” but downtown and other parts are definitely worlds more viable now than they were even just a few short years ago. There are fair numbers of (mostly white) people moving into the city to capitalize on this. Police/911 response times are way down and the halo of Gilbert/Quicken businesses have certainly made downtown a lot more livable (eg Rocket Fiber lighting a bunch of condos and apartments downtown). I swore for years I would never go back to my hometown, and I just bought a (still cheap, thankfully) condo there (although not as my primary residence). It’s much better than it ever has been in my lifetime (I’m 35).
- dyeje 9y agoSurprised by all the skepticism in this thread. As someone who grew up in Metro Detroit, moved away, and came back it is very obvious that Detroit is on the rebound. I'm not sure what metrics show it, but it's real.
- randcraw 9y agoBut the rebound is very uneven and not yet walkable. Unlike other rust belt urban centers like Pittsburgh which is walkable (especially near the universities), Detroit's layout was shaped heavily by the priorities of the automobile, which famously have impeded pedestrian friendly ecosystems everywhere. Until Detroit can carve out car-free zones that attract hip daytime hangouts that combine residential with retail, its urban costs will continue to outweigh its urban charm.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsschnau 9y agoP sure its just DG and the Illitch family exploiting it and calling it a 'revival'
- werber 9y agoI live less than a mile from my job downtown, and ended up hospitalized this winter while walking home because the city still doesn't take care of the streets (let alone the sidewalks). The downtown core and some adjacent neighborhoods (Corktown, Midtown, Lafayette Park, Brush Park, Cass Corridor, among a few others) are rapidly changing, but it feels like outside of the T shape that those neighborhoods make ( https://mogodetroit.org/system-map/ https://mogodetroit.org/system-map/ , the bike share system doesn't extend outside of this) you're in a completely different city. When I go for a walk at night and there isn't a weekday sports event, the downtown is still incredibly quiet and mostly empty. I have this constant nagging guilt about the revitalization of Detroit being for people like me (young white tech professional) and not the people who stayed and didn't give up on the city, because I had no faith I'd ever be back a decade ago. The artsier people I know are already moving to the edges of the T into places like Hubbard Farms and the North End, and it feels inevitable that people will be displaced by the "rebirth".
- bischofs 9y agoThere is a rebound, but it's very slow. The big issue is that automotive money has always been channeled outside of the city and there is little to nothing that will replace it. Everyone is convinced of their ideas of what Detroit needs but I really think it needs to have some new industries and an economy that is diverse enough to support it in tough times.The problem is the only real industry to bring the kind of wealth the city was used to in the mid 20th century would be the tech industry and the Midwest is a bit too homey to be the next SV. People here deep down are still weary of sitting in front of a tube all day.
- gilbetron 9y agoDetroit seems to be no longer in freefall, certainly. And, I suppose, it is technically reviving, but the upward progress is slow, especially in comparison to the depths it has fallen. My nephews like to go down there with their friends, but only to a small portion heavily protected - and that's cool. But they have been taught by their father on the places to avoid and what to do if you accidentally get in one - he owns a business that is downtown and that business often gets robbed. Feel free to take a view of a summer night in Detroit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztGzzvchcUQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztGzzvchcUQ
- venning 9y agoI have often cited the NYT Interactive team for creatively designed articles, but this one has serious problems. On a modern Android phone, I can't see all of the article text, with an undetermined amount being cut off at the bottom. Swipe back doesn't work if you don't start the swipe from the center of the page (which is unnatural and not the same for swiping forward). There are no obvious affordances to indicate that tapping on the left brings me back. And an un-dismissible subscription dialog appears, obscuring almost all remaining text. I'm just assuming that it renders perfectly for iPhones. Serious question: is testing for Android just not done?
- indemnity 9y agoSame problem on iPhone X.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI talked with a friend who lives 1/2 time in Detroit and 1/2 time in the bay area last week and they were not very hopeful about the future of that once great city. They said it was not uncommon that once a property didn't have anyone around for a couple of weeks people would come in during the night and strip it. It sounded sad and dystopian.
- BubbleFett 9y agoOne thing that most peeps from the East/West coast don't realize about Detroit is how big it is, compared to it's population size. The city limits of Detroit proper encompass about 143 square miles. While it's not that large of a city compared to others, you can fit the cities of San Francisco (46.7 sq miles), Boston (89.6 sq miles), and Manhattan (22.8 sq miles) within Detroit city limits. While you process that, the 2017 population of Detroit is about 672,000 people, compared to the 3.12 million people who live in SF(860k), Boston (618k), and Manhattan (1.64M) While it's growing for sure, if you get off the highway you'll see really fast that Detroit is still a ghost town. There are entire neighborhoods/subdivisions with streets lined with houses except all of those houses have been abandoned. For DECADES. It's like the Walking Dead minus the zombies. I'm psyched for Detroit (I grew up in the Detroit suburbs) and am rooting hard for it's recovery. With that said... the city of Detroit has lost 61% of it's population since it's peak in the 1950s. 61 PERCENT! While I remain optimistic, I'm also realistic. I'm psyched that Detroit is on an upswing, but there's a long way up to go.
- 80386 9y ago> While it's not that large of a city compared to others, you can fit the cities of San Francisco (46.7 sq miles), Boston (89.6 sq miles), and Manhattan (22.8 sq miles) within Detroit city limits. Sure, but Boston is only a part of what people think of as Boston. When Paul Graham talked about Boston in "Cities and Ambition", he meant Cambridge. If you add the cities and towns with a T stop: - Boston (89.6) - Cambridge (7.13) - Somerville (4.2) - Quincy (26.87) - Malden (5.1) - Revere (5.9) - Braintree (14.5) - Brookline (6.8) ...you have a 'city' encompassing 160 sq mi, which is bigger than Detroit. That standard doesn't generalize -- I grew up in the DC area, and the metro there goes all the way out to Rockville, which is generally considered to be an exurb, practically flyover country. (IMO, that's an unfair assessment, but it is what it is.) But it seems about right for Boston. Does Detroit have central parts that aren't part of the city proper, the way Boston has Cambridge and Somerville and San Francisco has Berkeley and Oakland?