4 ms·
Wow, what the hell is going on in the comments? A few climate change deniers and someone blaming Hawaiians for living on the island, jeez.
by StavrosK 9y ago
Wow, what the hell is going on in the comments? A few climate change deniers and someone blaming Hawaiians for living on the island, jeez.
- elorant 9y agoI've noticed that during weekends the quality of comments in HN degrades.
- digi_owl 9y agoCould have sworn that applies to the articles hitting the front page as well...
- chronotis 9y agoSometimes I feel like there's a bot-army monitoring all channels for new articles invoking the words "climate" or "global warming" and forwarding those pages to a waiting battalion of troll-soldiers.
- radicalbyte 9y agoIt's probably true, the oil companies have enough money to pay for the astroturfing.
- amelius 9y agoFake-news spreading organizations are not limited to just Facebook.
- dhimes 9y agoIt actually seems like several armies. It's like certain groups/companies try to control brand image by discouraging criticisms on this board. Sometimes I wonder if disallowing downvotes without a counterpoint would have an effect on that.
- maxerickson 9y agoWould a committee evaluate each counterpoint to decide whether it was genuine before counting the downvote?
- dhimes 9y agoThat would be pretty difficult. Just discouraging reactionary downvoting would be the point.
- 300bps 9y agoIs it so unbelievable that people could just disagree with you that you have to assume they’re espousing a fake or paid for position? I consider myself a conservationist so I think outrageous and easily falsifiable claims like “this was caused by climate change and we can expect more of this” destroy the credibility of the people making the claims and the dangers of climate change in general. The most famous was the 2000 article that claimed snowfall was a thing of the past which was finally deleted after years of mocking: https://wattsupwiththat.com/2015/11/12/one-of-the-longest-running-climate-prediction-blunders-has-disappeared-from-the-internet/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2015/11/12/one-of-the-longest-ru... There are so many more examples including Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth being released shortly after Katrina and being advertised with a hurricane coming from the smokestack of a factory saying we can expect hurricanes like that will be much more common going forward. Instead we had hardly any hurricanes make landfall for over a decade. https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0497116/?ref_=fn_al_tt_0 https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0497116/?ref_=fn_al_tt_0
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chronotis 9y agoUnbelievable, no. I'm making a meta-observation about a pattern of social commenting on this particular subject that spans many sites.
- dhimes 9y agoeasily falsifiable claims like “this was caused by climate change and we can expect more of this” If it was easily falsifiable we wouldn't be having this discussion. Not much on this board concerning astrology, for example. Instead we had hardly any hurricanes make landfall for over a decade. Since you're running at 300bps you have apparently missed some news. The fact of the matter is that by the time Al Gore put out his movie (disclosure: I never watched it) even skeptical scientists like myself were taking note. It's not that there was proof, but something happens with scientific measurements when you start sniffing the truth: As you look closer, with better technology and more detailed measurements, the results tend to go in one direction. Not always, and it's certainly not proof, but it's enough to make our spidey senses tingle. The danger in this game is that the system is chaotic (indeed, chaos theory was invented around weather prediction). So there is a point where even a small, incremental change will lead to wildly non-proportional changes. And we still have no idea where that point is. Hell, some politicians are trying to stop people from even talking about it.
- dmlorenzetti 9y agoSometimes, when a climate-denial comment on HN seems especially troll-like, and when I have time to kill, I'll look at the comment history of the apparent troll. Occasionally the person's comments only include political opinions, but I would say that, for the majority of these posters, the technical/programming comments outweigh the political ones. I don't know about other discussion boards. HN is the only forum on which I actively participate -- maybe because it's so good at self-policing that the trolls don't tend to survive long here.
- mikeash 9y agoI’m not surprised. It seems like engineers tend to have a strong contrarian streak. Climate change is an ideal target for contrarian tendencies: it’s controversial enough to not feel like you’re just tilting at windmills, but it’s still extremely lopsided. And it’s fuzzy enough that a smart person can dig into it and come up with a lot of good-sounding reasons to hold the contrary position. It’s not just climate change. Another prominent example that comes to mind is dark matter. HN posts about dark matter tend to have lots of comments about how it’s a cop-out, or how MOND is a better theory despite failing to match many observations, or whatever.
- cryptoz 9y agoIt seems to me that for the last 10 years Hacker News comments have always leaned towards denying climate change if not outright calling it a hoax. Many HN comments are not like that of course, but it has always been this way here. A very vocal part of the community here has always denied climate change.
- dpark 9y agoI’ve been here regularly for over 10 years and I disagree. There have always been some climate change deniers, just as there are everywhere online. But comments in general have not leaned that direction.
- cryptoz 9y agoI would say that from my memory, HN has a far above average number of climate change deniers who post regularly. It frequently distracts and drowns otherwise useful and productive conversation on the topic. It is hard to quantify of course, I'd be interested in doing a study of that some day. HN is the most environment-hostile and climate change denying community I have regularly participated in, and I say this as a personal experience.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAbove average compared to what? In real life climate change denial is very common. What other online communities are you participating in that are much better? Surely not reddit.
- asfasgasg 9y agoIt's hard to get a read on the politics of the "typical" HNer. As people are always quick to point out, HN is not a single person, but a group of people, each of whom may have ideosyncratic positions. All the same, people are not special snowflakes, and in the general population you can normally say that X will be associated with Y. In my experience, HN seems very: - Liberal/socialist on economic politics. - Liberal on privacy/digital freedom. - Conservative/leaning regressive on gender politics. - Conservative on climate change. I model the "typical" HNer as a young white male techie, and this set of positions does not seem particularly surprising in that context.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]