9 ms·
I look forward to the day when all drug offenses are vacated, and all drugs are legal. This is a cognitive liberty issue. One should be allowed to alter one's
by pmoriarty 9y ago
I look forward to the day when all drug offenses are vacated, and all drugs are legal.
This is a cognitive liberty issue. One should be allowed to alter one's own consciousness any way one sees fit.
- rubatuga 9y agoBut obviously that isn’t in any country’s interest
- HarryHirsch 9y agoOne should be allowed to alter one's own consciousness any way one sees fit Crime in the pursuit of drug addiction exists, meth- and cocaine-induced paranoia exists. There is a public health problem mixed in there. Anyone who thinks they can disregard the public health issue really needs an alcoholic in the family.
- scarface74 9y agoSo what's your proposed solution? "The War on Drugs" is actually a "War on poor people and minorities". Far more harm has come from locking people up for non violent crimes that disrupts families, gives police more power, and makes it almost impossible to find meaningful employment after being released. There have been plenty of studies showing poor and minorities get treated much harsher by the "justice" system.
- icebraining 9y agoIt's not necessarily my opinion, but one can decriminalize use without fully legalizing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- donarb 9y agoBesides employment, it also prevents citizens from voting after they have served their time.
- c22 9y agoNot everywhere. In Seattle, for instance, voting rights are restored after serving time and any probationary period.
- maxerickson 9y agoVoting rights are eventually restored in most of the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felony_disenfranchisement#In_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felony_disenfranchisement#In_t... A lot of states do restrict the vote for those on parole or probation, but once the supervision ends the vote is restored.
- forapurpose 9y ago> it also prevents citizens from voting It is widely believed, and I think established by White House recordings, that Nixon established the War on Drugs to attack people he didn't like: Hippies and blacks. I believe that in public affairs and politics, the way to evaluate and act is to look at the (expected) outcomes and to ignore all the rhetoric. First, the outcomes are what matters and there's not a high correlation with the claims made ahead of time. Second, politicians are sophisticated enough to know what the outcomes will be; I think it's reasonable to assume that they know what is going to happen.
- hapnin 9y agoRe: Nixon using drug laws to criminalize dissent: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16885281 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16885281
- coredog64 9y agoNot from recordings. From a second-hand quote by a single person, now deceased, who was hung out to dry by Nixon after Watergate. It may be true, but it’s worth considering who the source is, their motivations, and why it took so long for the quote to come out.
- djcapelis 9y agoThe crimes there aren’t taking the drugs, they’re the actions which harm and endanger others. Focusing on those crimes makes most sense. Under the current system, we prosecute drug use, distribution and sales way more than we prosecute the actual crimes that harm others. It’s completely backwards. You should be free to alter your cognition, but also held responsible for your actions. Orthogonally, there are also many other mental health and non-mental health related public health issues we should continue to pursue, regardless of the current state of substance legalization.
- opportune 9y agoCompletely agree. There are always going to be people that want to try drugs, and a portion of those people are going to be successful. A portion of those people will use drugs on a semi-regular basis, a portion of those people will become addicted, and a portion of those people will commit crimes as a result of their addiction. But why attempt punish everyone that takes drugs because some percentage of them commit crimes? Why set up the system to amortize the public cost of addiction over long periods in the form of hospital visits, lost productivity (both directly due to addiction and indirectly as a result of former criminals' difficulty rejoining the job market), public assistance, court costs, jail costs, and prison costs, rather than focus on rehab and breaking the addiction itself? If you look at history, drugs were almost never criminalized because they posed a public health crisis - and when they arguably did (as in alcohol prohibition), criminalization created more problems than it solved. Usually the motivations had something to do with xenophobia, moral panic, or politics. Alcohol prohibition was fueled by general animosity towards immigrants (Irish) and a growing Catholic population, with a smattering of both moralism and public health concerns spearheaded by women's rights groups. Marijuana was criminalized largely due to xenophobia toward mexicans and black people. Crack carried harsher penalties than regular cocaine because black people used it. LSD was cracked down on to quell anti-war sentiment in the Vietnam era.
- arca_vorago 9y agoIt's because so many people don't know, forgot, or choose to ignore that the US was founded on enlightenment principles of individualism. So they always say stuff about some amorphous "social contract" to focus on what is essentially thought-crime, saying "let's stop them before they do the thing that then induces them to commit the crime" instead of just prosecuting them for the crime. Talking like this frames the narrative and too many of us let these anti-american rhetorical tricks pass without calling it out. The government has no right to tell me what I can and can't put in my body, whether that's lettuce, Devils lettuce, a cigar, or a soda... doesn't matter. It's a matter of individual freedom.
- psyc 9y agoDon’t need to ignore all downsides in order to prioritize values.
- ddingus 9y agoThis isn't hard. Education, treatment, alternatives are the answers. We have the means to do all of these things and get much better value for society per dollar than we do now.
- fouc 9y agoSo the reasoning is X thing might cause crime (of the real variety), so let's make X illegal, so that anyone that does X is automatically a criminal, even if only a subset will actually go on to commit real crimes. As for the public health implications, there's probably way more effective ways of mitigating that than making them criminals. It's a range though, those that cause significant harm to others should certainly be taken out of the system. Alcoholics are frigging annoying, and highly disruptive, but many aren't actually violent criminals.
- tdb7893 9y agoIts more than just violent vrimes, if you weigh the benefits to society of drugs the negative aspects clearly outweigh the positive aspects. With alcohol alone there are the deaths from overdose or accidents from drinking (drunk driving is the biggest but not the only cause of accidental alcohol related deaths) and the tole that addiction takes on people. I think in a world where enforcement worked there would be a good argument that the societal problems are more important than a personal freedom that brings little benefit (even if I'm not sure I would agree with that argument). As it stands enforcement doesn't work so obviously legalization is the best choice but people who are very pro-legalization often ignore the fact that recreational drugs currently seem overall bad for society.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"people who are very pro-legalization often ignore the fact that recreational drugs currently seem overall bad for society" I don't think it's the drugs that are the problem, but the way people use (or rather abuse) them, and the conditions that drive people to abuse drugs. Lots of social conditions are bound up in problems for which drugs alone are blamed. Too many people are poor, desperate, lonely, outcast, downtrodden, hopeless. These and other social ills are what encourage drug addiction (and other types of addiction and destructive behavior), and they are the things that society will have to squarely face and overcome before they can effectively treat addiction. Merely making drugs illegal hasn't and isn't going to work. Locking people up for seeking a way out of their misery hasn't and isn't going to work. Merely making drugs legal isn't going to work either, but at least it isn't making the problem worse or adding all sorts of other problems to it. One day you're an addict, the next day you're an addict and shot by the police or in jail and your life is ruined and it's likely to get even worse once you're out. That doesn't help anyone.
- philipkglass 9y agoI've seen a family member commit slow-motion suicide with alcohol. Nothing I saw made me think that it would be better if he had to pay a black-market markup to get his fix, or that incarceration would have benefited him, or that his incarceration would have benefited the people he hurt.
- pmoriarty 9y agoI've seen family members commit slow-motion suicide with food -- overeating until they're morbidly obese, and suffering all sorts of horrible health issues as a result, up to and including death. Yet there isn't the same moral stigma attached to overeating as there is to drug or alcohol addiction, and no one is suggesting throwing obese people in jail or raising the price of food so high that food addicts have to commit crimes in order to feed their addiction. Obesity and alcoholism are seen as health issues, and treated accordingly. The same should be the case with drug addiction.
- lopmotr 9y agoSoft drink tax is proposed in the UK, so it's similar to cigarettes or alcohol in that respect.
- pmoriarty 9y agoIf the tax is high enough, it encourages organized crime to form a black or gray market, as is the case for cigarettes in the US, which are smuggled and sold on the black market. This results in a quasi-prohibition which has many of the same downsides as full-on prohibition, such as the enabling and funding of organized crime, people getting killed or thrown in jail, and other types of violence. Though the profit margin for smuggled soft drinks is likely to remain too low for organized crime to bother getting involved, I'm not convinced it's the right way forward compared to voluntary, education- and health-based approaches. On the other hand, I am in favor of the $0.10 charge for plastic and paper bags in California, where lots of people often bring their own reusable bags rather than pay the fee for a disposable bag. Perhaps a reasonable surcharge on soft drinks could make a difference to overall public health.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Crime in the pursuit of drug addiction exists, meth- and cocaine-induced paranoia exists. There is a public health problem mixed in there." Does that outweigh the whirlpool of violence that the War on Drugs has stirred up by its very existence? All the money funneled in to organized crime by the War on Drugs, enabling and incentivizing them to kill their rivals and corrupt the judicial and political system? All the people killed by police during drug raids? The decades of life wasted in prison by hundreds of thousands of nonviolent drug offenders where they are tortured, raped, killed, or groomed in to far more serious criminals? All the families broken up, devastating them emotionally and financially? All the children left to be raised by just one of the parents or made parentless when their parents are imprisoned or killed? Crimes committed due to drug addiction are often committed in order to get money for the next fix. It's the illegality of drugs that keeps the prices so incredibly high that they're unaffordable to poor people. That need not be the case if they are made legal. Cocaine paranoia is a medical issue, and it and other health issues related to drug use should be treated medically, not by throwing people in jail -- which doesn't work anyway. Drug use is rife in prison. The War on Drugs is an abject failure that makes the failure of Prohibition pale in comparison.
- clarkevans 9y agoOne more... massive effects on entire countries who lose rule of law because the local population simply can't compete with the drug/gun money of the narcos. In fact, a caravan of people displaced, in no small part due to our war on drugs, are now at our boarder to ask for asylum. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-immigration-caravan/busloads-of-migrants-from-caravan-arrive-at-u-s-mexico-border-idUSKBN1HW031 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-immigration-caravan/b...
- viraptor 9y agoThere's more nuance here to discuss. One is throwing people in jail - you can still make production and distribution illegal while keeping the use itself legal. Another one is that availability of various drugs allows people to make relatively safer choices - see the difference in opioid addictions between states with different pot laws. We can still jail people actively distributing/producing highly addictive drugs, while at the same time giving mostly free choice and helping rather than harming (potential) users. Monitoring actual results in the society can affect the thresholds of what's done.
- mikeash 9y agoCrime in the pursuit of cars, houses, and shoes also exists.
- bdcravens 9y agoSo prosecute those crimes. I don't think the criminality of drugs have any effect on addicts in the status quo. No one is calling for decriminalization of crimes to support an addiction, only decriminalization of drug possession and use. There's a public health issue with alcohol, tobacco, McDonald's, and sugary sodas as well.
- jMyles 9y agoOf course it's true that these are public health matter. But having been through trial and turmoil with family members in the depths of alcoholism, I have never found myself wishing to return to alcohol prohibition; have you?
- greggarious 9y ago>Crime in the pursuit of drug addiction exists Drugs are artificially highly priced due to their illegality. Legalizing drugs would drive down the price, removing a major motive for crime. People will still be addicts, but in my experience bums who have alcohol as a drug of choice manage to get by without engaging in muggings/robberies to feed their habit.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoI've had my fair share of family alcoholics. In every case, it has been a response to existential emptiness, and if they weren't destroying themselves with alcohol they'd be doing it some other way. In fact, I think this is a big part of the reason so many people are obese. This view is supported by science. Research has shown that rats housed in isolation, or with stimulus deprived environments compulsively use cocaine when given the option, while rats housed with other rats in enriched environments use it sporadically. We need to take a long hard look at our society.
- superkuh 9y agoThen put them in jail, or prison, for comitting a real crime with real victims instead of some imagined future offense. Future crime being normalized is more evil and does more damaged than any drug could or has. Statistical judgments against classes of people are bad, and worse when backed up by government violence. The vast majority of murders in the last 200 years have been because of this kind of thinking.
- wellboy 9y agoIt's not really that. Legalizing drug use and abuse reduces overall crime, drug usage, and damage done by drugs through more help, less stigmatization, clean tools, clean drugs. It's literally the dream solution, however, politicians are too dumb to understand that. It's proven scientific evidence, see Portugal.
- icebraining 9y agoPortugal didn't legalize drug use, we decriminalized it, which is not the same. It's still illegal, you just can't go to jail for using or carrying small amounts. Usually you get a trip to the police station, you're searched for drugs (which are confiscated), and you get a date to go to a meeting with a psychologist, who will usually try to convince you to give them up or, depending on the case, to enroll on a treatment program.
- gepi79 9y agoCriminalization allows crime. IMO the government should sell drugs and use the money to treat drug addicts.
- lopmotr 9y agoHow about school is optional too? That alters consciousness. The problem with both is they can cause you to be less able to contribute to the society. You do have some responsibility to do that because your life is supported by the other people in that society. You can't survive well alone in Somalia with no support network.
- ythn 9y ago> One should be allowed to alter one's own consciousness any way one sees fit. And to what degree is one accountable for the things they do in pursuit of and under the influence of altered consciousness?
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoIt isn't a problem if one doesn't commit crimes nor greatly harms another (Sure, someone can fall over and accidentally harm someone else, but that is hardly a crime). The main crime most drug users commit is... buying and using drugs. If someone commits some crime while on drugs... prosecute them for the crime.
- josephh 9y agoI'm fine with that, as long as they waive their right to public welfare if they become a societal burden caused by drug addiction/abuse. If one should be allowed to alter one's own consciousness any way one sees fit, then one should also accept full responsibility for making that decision without putting burden on the rest of the society.
- viraptor 9y agoI'm not sure that people who escape their situation by using drugs should lose the help from the rest of society. That's actually backwards - addiction clinics, safe injection sites, housing for homeless, and many other services should be sponsored by the rest of society. Otherwise, what's the inventive to stop taking the drugs? And what path out do you think those people would have?
- flatline 9y agoIt is not a cognitive liberty issue equally for everyone. Many alcoholics are born that way. They do not have the same liberty with regard to alcohol as others do. Their agency is impaired when confronted with decisions about alcohol. Alcohol is a potentially dangerous drug that I believe should be regulated more heavily than it currently is, while I also believe that other intoxicants such as marijuana are far milder in their overall impact and should be regulated less. But in any particular case, I think that we must face the social implications of substance abuse as a real issue. I’ve talked to addicts that say that the intervention of law enforcement saved their lives. Of course this is not generally the experience for poor people or minorities. So if you are going to be more permissive in what people can legally acquire, I think that we have a moral obligation to provide intervention and support services for individuals affected by substance abuse. I don’t see a lot of people actually talking about this aspect of decriminalization in the US. Yes, blanket legalization will cure some ills but it will create many others. I don’t see any way to tell which side the weight comes down on at this point.
- DataWorker 9y agoAn important factor to consider in seeking to regulate such things is the ease with which they can be produced. Marijuana is a weed and wine is fermented grape. And what about the obesity epidemic? I’m inclined to agree with your views, but there is a practical aspect that needs to balanced against the desire for more effective public policy.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoLegalize, educate, regulate, tax and treat abuse as a medical problem. Subsidize the medical treatment and sponsor research for mitigating abuse from the tax revenue. People will pay obscenely high taxes on this stuff if it’s made legal. Dismember the government apparatus setup to deprive so many of their liberties.
- grogenaut 9y agoWe've got some non trivial percentage of America hooked on legal opioids as an experiment. That's going well. Seems smart to get another good pct hooked on h. And before you say the price will drop... My understanding is weed is more expensive per intoxicating amount than alcohol in seattle. So let's get everyone hooked and in debt, seems like a different route to the same place. They won't be in jail but they'll be struggling financially just the same. But they'll at least get treatment. Which we can also charge for. Apparently I've angered the libertarians who can't concieve of Any bad consequences to anything. Look I Live in Seattle and don't see any bad side to the mj legalization currently. I also think we should have heroin treatment in many areas. And opioid. Doesn't mean I think you should be able to buy h when you hit 18. I know plenty of people who use alcohol and mj responsibly. Many who don't. I have anecdotal data on opiods and lots only know one person who used h personally and that didn't go well. More for meth, most had some pretty severe problems before or because of it. But apparently I can't disagree with you, only the pure ideals are acceptable.
- dqpb 9y agoDrugs destroy your mind and then the rest of us have to live with you. Eventually, we'll also be faced with the shitty choice of either ignoring or taking care of you when you can't take care of yourself.
- tomohawk 9y agoAlcohol related death are up around 88,000 per year in the US. https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-consumption/alcohol-facts-and-statistics https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-co... It's the 3rd leading cause of death behind tobacco and sedentary lifestyle. Should people be allowed to do what they want? Sure, as long as no-one else is impacted. Good luck meeting that criteria, though. Do you really expect someone who has OD'd on some substance to have zero impact on what other people are doing? The other day, a woman at a store lost consciousness due to opioid overdose. Her toddler was wandering around, wondering what was going on. I'm sure the paramedics who showed up had nothing better to do that day.
- adventured 9y agoNot impacting other people isn't the sole criteria. It's also not the correct premise: not initiating violence and or traditional crime upon other people is the criteria, not a vague 'do not negatively impact other people in any manner.' Libertarian-leaning thought in regards to social liberty does not argue that you should/can have no negative impact whatsoever. It argues you are to not initiate violence upon others. Legalization and decriminalization are also the sole rational alternatives, broadly, to prohibition. We've tried prohibition every possible way across two generations, and have spent truly vast sums of money attempting it all. It was an extreme and total failure without exception. Legalization & decriminalization have a minimum of three very strong arguments in their favor. Each of the arguments alone decimates the prohibition argument. These three arguments encompass nearly every spetrum politically, except for most of the very far right traditional wing of old conservatism. Argument one: it's your body, as an adult liberty means you largely have a right to do with it as you see fit. The government should err to the side of staying out of my life. That's the more libertarian, government leave me alone, argument. Even conservatives should universally go for this one, however they betray the principles they pretend to believe in here. Argument two: the obvious dollars & cents argument. It's radically more cost effective to treat people with addiction or mental health problems. It's not cost effective to put them in prison at a cost of $40,000 per year (a million dollars over ~25 years). It's also not cost effective to maintain a police state system that costs hundreds of billions of dollars per year. It's like maintaining a second military. That money should be going into healthcare, infrastructure, education, job training. This is another argument on which a lot of conservatives betray their claimed principles: what's more anti small government than a giant bureaucratic police state system? It also destroys the economic value of the person put into prison, making them a non-contributing person and dependent on big government: another thing that should remove conservatives from supporting the prohibition approach. Argument three: compassion. It's illiberal and very cruel to put a non-violent offender into prison for 15 or 30 years out of their life (drug addicts are often repeatedly arrested), for drug use or drug addiction problems. You know your premise about the opioid lady (or anyone like that in general)? Putting her in prison repeatedly, disappears her from the child's life as well, at a very high cost to society and the child. With the treatment approach, you at least have an opportunity that the parent can be present. It's worth noting here that prohibition does not stop overdoses, it amplifies the lethality of the situation by pushing overdoses into the darkness.
- sizzle 9y agoThere are some chemicals that have caused certain individuals to feel invincible and harm to themselves and the public at large e.g. PCP What do you think about the the prevalence of these types of crimes given complete legalization of all drugs?
- pmoriarty 9y agoPCP gets an unjustly bad rap. Most people would be quite surprised to find out it's quite similar to Ketamine, a drug that many don't hesitate to party with and has recently shown positive results for treating depression. "PCP makes you feel invincible and violent" is an urban myth -- one that Ketamine somehow doesn't share, despite its great similarity to PCP. Of all drugs, the one most strongly associated with violence is alcohol. Yet hundreds of millions if not billions of people think nothing of using it at parties, bars, at home with their family, in front of their kids, etc. -- often with disastrous results -- yet it's perfectly legal.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoThat is one of those "most villified drugs" from drug education in the mid-80's through the early 90's. Now, I haven't met very many people that have done PCP (as opposed to things like LSD, MDMA, and cocaine, for example)... but they've never described it like you do. It isn't hard to imagine that since the drug education deceptively describes LSD, MDMA, and cocaine, that they'd be deceptive on this one. I've always guessed these sorts of stories were outliers: They might have happened once, and it is good to know there is some slim chance of weird reactions, but definitely wouldn't be a common thing.
- tim333 9y agoThe trouble with that is it can upset family and friends. You may want freedom to use drugs yourself but would you want people selling heroin to your kids at school? Hence we have drug laws basically everywhere on earth.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- quadcore 9y agoAgreed, as long as it doesn't impact someone else's freedom. For example, if one has a vehicle, one shouldn't be allowed to take drugs. Though it's ok to me if one doesn't fasten his seat belt.
- lossolo 9y agoAnd I don't. Anyone that had contact with addicted people to heroin will tell you the same. You don't know what you wish for. I am all in for marijuana to be legal but not hard drugs. Look at prescription opioids problem in US. This is public health issue, you should research how New York looked 50 years ago[1]. Making all drugs are legal would be irresponsible and hurt society as whole. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/1970/02/16/archives/heroin-epidemic-hits-schools-heroin-epidemic-is-enveloping-schools.html https://www.nytimes.com/1970/02/16/archives/heroin-epidemic-...
- lurquer 9y ago>One should be allowed to alter one's own consciousness any way one sees fit. You state that as a self-evident fact. It clearly isn't. I can think of no human society where limits and restrictions were not placed on intoxicating substances. Objectively, as all societies have such restrictions, why should I believe your conclusion?
- rossjudson 9y agoOpiates are legal painkillers. How's that working out?
- r3vo 9y agoI would agree with you on a lot of drugs. Definitely Marijuana for one thing. However the thing that is less obvious about drug use is how it effects everyone around the user. I'm from a low income rural area in the south and had a close friend, and a sister who both became hooked on metamphetamine and opioids. My sister absolutely destroyed her life. The drugs cost money, and a drug addict is not stable enough mentally or physically to hold a job. The only option is for them to commit crime. My sister lied to our family constantly, and stole from us. A serious drug addict is like a tornado destroying everyone in their vicinity. Maybe for light drugs like marijuana it is a cognitive issue, but for hard addictive drugs it is very much a societal and criminal issue. Drug addiction causes user to commit crime out of desperation. A drug addict will harm the community around them.