6 ms·
So what's the real story here then? Was the alleged lie actually true? Or was NPR just unable to verify whether it is true or not? Many people held up this sto
by modeless 9y ago
So what's the real story here then? Was the alleged lie actually true? Or was NPR just unable to verify whether it is true or not?
Many people held up this story as a justification for the "right to be forgotten", but if it turns out that even a respected news agency can't figure out whether censorship was justified in this case, I think it rather supports the case against censorship.
- dingo_bat 9y agoGood luck understanding the whole picture when everybody is so fucking keen on censorship! I'm fed up of this. Censorship is never the answer. Publish a correction. Publish a retraction. What the fuck is this!?
- gnarbarian 9y agoIt's simple, many people are fine with censorship as long as they're in charge of what should be censored.
- jamesrcole 9y agoI think it's slightly different. They're fine with censorship of ideas they disagree with.
- cmiles74 9y agoWhy wouldn't you censor ideas that you know are false, harmful or both?
- aidenn0 9y agoBecause you might consider it immoral?
- cmiles74 9y agoMy thinking is that if you really think that an idea is false or harmful or both, you would feel morally compelled to remove that idea. That is, morality is often the first justification for censorship.
- aidenn0 9y agoSorry, my pronoun might have been unclear. I'm saying that you might consider censorship itself to be immoral.
- cmiles74 9y agoThat's the real crux of it, isn't it?
- sverige 9y agoNo, when I think that an idea is false or harmful or both, I feel morally compelled to present the reasons I think that as clearly and cogently as possible in an effort to provide additional information both to the person presenting the false and/or harmful idea and anyone else who might be observing the exchange. Censorship is inherently immoral. My hope is to persuade others that the initial idea is false and/or harmful, not to prevent others from hearing the bad idea. If I succeed, the bad idea still exists, but others can understand why the idea is bad and recognize similarly bad ideas in the future. If you simply censor the bad idea, at least two bad things happen as a consequence: 1) the bad idea is not refuted, and so is likely to be reintroduced later with fewer people who understand why it is a bad idea; and 2) the person who originated the bad idea does not have any reason to change their mind, but rather is more likely to resent being censored and so hold that bad idea more tenaciously and attempt to spread it more surreptitiously. I am frankly frightened by this relatively recent promotion of the idea that preventing the public utterance of bad ideas and distasteful speech is good for society. Based on my understanding of history, it is, in fact, a precursor to totalitarian society.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jamesrcole 9y agoLots of people think they know ideas are false, harmful or both, even though they don't. Take any belief you think is objectively false or harmful, and there'll be plenty of people who think it's objectively true and good. So making censorship acceptable is pretty dangerous. It just favours whoever is currently in a position of power. And I tend to think it's counterproductive to censor ideas. You can't stop people from believing them, and trying to censor them can increase divisions between groups. Argument and education seem better approaches in general.
- simias 9y agoDoes it even make sense to talk about censorship if you remove your own content? If you delete your comment are you censoring anything? If you think that NPR shouldn't have made the original story unavailable I see your point but I really fail to see how that's censorship, especially when they pinpoint precisely why they did it and how exceptional it is.
- moate 9y agoIt looks like them publishing a retraction. Who do you feel is censoring them in this instance?
- DoctorOetker 9y agoYou are not the same person as a year ago, it is perfectly possible for a person to try and censor their past opinions.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Publish a retraction. What the fuck is this!? ...this is a retraction?
- neolefty 9y ago> But NPR did not contact the alleged author. Upon review, NPR cannot say for certain who the author or authors were or what their motivation was. In fact, in court proceedings, the people listed as "staff editors" of the site were identified only by initials, and we have not been able to establish their identities. It sounds like they tried to get the other side of the story and got nowhere. Makes sense given that, if the NPR story is even generally accurate, it is not in the other side's interest to corroborate it (they are accused of slander). And given that the other side is geographically pretty far away from the US, it could be hard to get anything solid.
- sjsjxhhc 9y agoIf that’s all that happened, they could add “x declined to comment”.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoIf they had tried to get the other party to comment at the time of writing the original article I think that would be fair enough, but they didn't. Apparently after the story was published they were sent an email from > someone who said he was representing the person NPR had identified as the "author" [of the purportedly slanderous website] and then they retracted it. (https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/npr-issues-rare-retraction https://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2018/04/12/601650762/...)
- nostromo 9y agoThere are so many problems with the story. It's fairly embarrassing for NPR. Besides being a one-sided story, it's also obvious PR for Ervine's new company, which is dutifully linked at the end of the story. Secondly, the story presents Ervine as the heroic protagonist. An interesting choice for someone that turned in his middle-eastern clients to the FBI because they took a cab and didn't talk like typical rich people. Ervine's response to this is to hand over all of his client's private information to the FBI, without a warrant, after which his client is jailed and deported.
- scandox 9y agoI have to say I laughed outright at the whole "taxi-cab -> call the FBI" thing. That was kind of mad.
- lmm 9y ago> An interesting choice for someone that turned in his middle-eastern clients to the FBI because they took a cab and didn't talk like typical rich people. Ervine's response to this is to hand over all of his client's private information to the FBI, without a warrant, after which his client is jailed and deported. So he suspected someone was breaking the law and reported them to the appropriate authorities? Or are citizens supposed to always cover for criminals unless and until the government gets a warrant?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]