9 ms·
Damning Zuckerberg IMs confirmed
- code_duck 16y agoYou mean there are still people out there who who have doubts whether Zuckerberg is a sociopath with zero ethics? Why would that be?
- edanm 16y agoI don't know about other people, but I have doubts. I'm actually willing to bet Zuckerberg is very far from being a sociopath. Most of the "damning" stories about him are of the same caliber as this story. And this article, IMO, proves nothing. So he joked around about privacy in IMs 4 years ago. We don't have any context, we don't know almost any of the surrounding circumstances. In fact, since people are publishing these IMs but aren't publishing reports of him leaking actual data, I'm willing to bet these IMs really were just jokes. Other stories are similarly void of content. The truth is, I know almost no one who I'd consider a sociopath with zero ethics. The chance against Zuckerberg being one is pretty small. The chance is much higher that the media have chosen to focus on him because he is: a) rich b) powerful and c) made some moves that some people didn't like in regards to privacy.
- thinkcomp 16y agoYou're wrong. There are, in fact, published reports of him actually breaking into Crimson reporters' private FAS (Harvard) e-mail accounts with information he gleaned from Facebook. http://www.businessinsider.com/how-mark-zuckerberg-hacked-into-the-harvard-crimson-2010-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-mark-zuckerberg-hacked-in... You don't know anyone you'd consider a sociopath with zero ethics because the vast majority of people aren't. Just the same, the people who up hugely successful by most people's standards, which is to say "rich," have a much higher probability of having gotten there at someone else's expense.
- rbanffy 16y agoI remember a somewhat disturbing piece I read a couple years ago that pointed out that a disproportionate number (as compared to the general population) of C*O's are borderline (the article used the term "subcriminal") sociopaths.
- panacea 16y agoWithout a citation, it's impossible verify your claim, but even with one, I'd be dubious about a 'piece' that purports to 'point out' (read: make an authoritative claim as proof) that... well, let's just say I don't think you read an article that was grounded in verifiable facts.
- rilindo 16y agoWould these do? http://articles.latimes.com/2005/jul/08/entertainment/et-boss8 http://articles.latimes.com/2005/jul/08/entertainment/et-bos... Original article: http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/96/open_boss.html http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/96/open_boss.html
- loewenskind 16y agoI wouldn't find that surprising. In the current world, the only thing most big companies ever have to care about is the bottom line. Given that, it's unsurprising that people willing to do anything to get what they want would rise to the top.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoJust the same, the people who up hugely successful by most people's standards, which is to say "rich," have a much higher probability of having gotten there at someone else's expense. You're wrong. Or at least, we have no reason to believe that you're right, other than small-mindedness borne of jealousy and self-righteousness.
- thinkcomp 16y agoThere are countless stories of well-known and incredibly wealthy software CEOs such as Bill Gates and Larry Ellison crushing their competition, sometimes in ways that went beyond what was necessary to merely succeed. Outside of software, you only need to look at the financial sector to see rich people who got to their present position at the expense of others. I don't think my comment was small-minded at all!
- code_duck 16y agoOkay, so he joked around about being a total sleazebag who can't be trusted with people's private data, or be trusted to do the right thing. Now that he's in control of millions of people's private data, WOW, those 'jokes' are SO FUNNY! He should retire and become a stand up comic, it's the BEST!!!
- tfh 16y agoI won't say he's a sociopath. But he's a guy with too much power. And we all know : Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. That's the main reason I don't like facebook.
- kareemm 16y agodo you know mark zuckerberg? have you spent any meaningful time with him? "a sociopath with zero ethics" is a hell of a label to hang on him when you only know him through a few articles you've read on the internet.
- code_duck 16y agoNot just that, I know the CEO and founder of Facebook through a legacy and record of actions. Actions speak louder than articles on the internet, and perhaps even louder than personal impressions based on having a beer with someone or a conference, or whatever you're talking about. Nobody in the public eye such as this is ever going to 'spend meaningful time' with an equal amount of people as the number whom will choose to cast a judgement on their character. So, this will have to suffice. If he has a problem with that, please ask him to sell out and go away. Or maybe not. code duck is sorry if he was mean.
- kareemm 16y agoYou've judged him as a sociopath by his actions, not his intentions. In other words, you assume he's actually a sociopath, instead of assuming that perhaps the narrow view we see from 72-point headlines doesn't paint an accurate picture of the whole man. from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actor-observer_bias http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actor-observer_bias actors tend to attribute the causes of their behavior to stimuli inherent in the situation, while observers tend to attribute behavior to stable dispositions of the actor i'm hardly a zuckerberg apologist (see previous comments during the whole facebook privacy hoo-hah). but wanted to point out, really, that calling someone a "sociopath with zero ethics" based on a few articles without actually knowing the guy is likely unreliable way to judge someone.
- varjag 16y agoNothing to add about those IMs. His friends suck though.
- notaddicted 16y agoI find it humorous that while Zuckerberg is: * offering the information, but hasn't actually leaked it * offering phonebook / directory type info, which is semi germane to the actual purpose of the site, especially in the early days Meanwhile Boingboing is making public a recording of a private conversation held over IM.
- dillydally 16y agoI've read all these IMs before. IIRC, they were in the trial transcripts. I believe at least one of the "FRIEND"s is Adam D'Angelo, former Facebook CTO and now founder of Quora. In any case, it's not as if Boing Boing hacked into Zuckerberg's computer to get these. They're freely available.
- thinkcomp 16y agoActually, they were under seal in ConnectU, Inc. v. Facebook, Inc., and Mark's attorneys fought very hard to keep them that way. They're only freely available now because they were leaked. Given my personal stake in it all I'd like to know what the rest of the still-unpublished ones say.
- jrockway 16y agoMeanwhile Boingboing is making public a recording of a private conversation held over IM. Yeah, but it's okay because the Boingboing offices are not bugged and you didn't get to hear the editors say that they were going to fuck Zuckerberg in the ear.
- gregpilling 16y agoDidn't they just fuck him in the ear by publishing the stupid comments?
- thinkcomp 16y agoMore IMs: http://www.thinkpress.com/authoritas/timeline.pdf http://www.thinkpress.com/authoritas/timeline.pdf
- jacquesm 16y agoImpressive that they could put together such a detailed timeline so long after the fact.
- mahmud 16y agoUGH. Read the thing in its entirety and that Aaron guy comes off as too helpful and naive. Fuck, you can tell from the tone Zuck takes with him. Zuck is nice when he needs something, and cold as ice when he knows he did something. Pretty fucking sad and annoying at the same time. UGH! [Edit: Oh, the parent is ThinkComp/Aaoron! My sympathies dude. Too bad, you're a typical flat-footed computer programmer; how come you haven't seen this guy for what he is the moment he told you to take down the ads featuring his site? then he returns to you, repeatedly, for advice, help, testing, feedback and insight. Why did you allow that?]
- thinkcomp 16y agoI am "that Aaron guy," and it was my job to be helpful. At the time, I ran the only entrepreneurship club at Harvard available to undergraduates. In retrospect, I was naive, but so was Mark. Ironically, I think he underestimated the value of having friends, and the negative value of having enemies.
- mahmud 16y agoAlright, I see you settled for $65MM, that's about fair, even if the lawyers take half of it. Next time, please get yourself a human hound to sniff out people. You seem like an all too nice and too trusting person.
- thinkcomp 16y agoI was not part of ConnectU so I didn't settle for $65 million, actually. I settled separately.
- rsbrown 16y agoI've really wanted to avoid joining the list of friends who have expunged their Facebook identities. This makes it very tempting to jump ship, though.
- fname 16y agothough, with comments like that is the data really expunged? Would you trust that your account and information is actually removed? Or conveniently archived for future use?
- brown9-2 16y agoWhy? Either you are comfortable with the amount of personal information you are publishing on Facebook's systems or you are not. If you are comfortable about the personal information you are giving them then I don't see why out-of-context IMs from years ago change how you feel about your actions. If you're not comfortable with your own sharing then what the heck are you doing?
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoThe line between comfortable and uncomfortable can change based on one's perception of the company holding the data. That perception is highly subject to the perception of the guy running it.
- rsbrown 16y agoThe temptation to leave Facebook is motivated by principle, not pragmatism. Of course whatever personal information I have submitted to websites over the years has been snooped at some point or other. That doesn't make mean we should meekly accept such behavior. EDIT: To clarify -- I am comfortable with the personal information I have shared. Such comfort does not imply permission for the holder of that information to snoop it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- coryl 16y agoI'm a nice guy, but honestly, if I was a kid with that much power, I probably would have acted the same. People were feeding him their emails, photos, personal info straight to his servers. And they still ARE! Still, he might have still been treating Facebook as a goofy side project at this point. And IM chat doesn't express jest or joking around. Call a spade a spade.
- vinhboy 16y agoI agree with you. If the shit I say in IM to my friends get published, it would look exactly like this. It doesn't mean I would ever do anything like that. It's just excited bragging. Some guys brag about women, money, physical accomplishments. Nerds like me brag about stupid computer tricks we can do...
- jimbokun 16y agoYou should consider changing your IM habits, if you expect to ever be in a situation where someone somewhere wants to sue you.
- thinkcomp 16y agoThis is a really weak argument, to say the very least. For one thing, just because a lot of kids are immature doesn't mean that they have a license to break the law. Joking obviously isn't a violation of the law, but breaking into private e-mail accounts is (18 USC 1030). For another, Mark had already been formally disciplined by the Administrative Board for Facemash when he wrote these, so he clearly knew better. Aruging that Facebook has the right to misuse people's content just because they provide it is clearly wrong. In addition, there are five people including myself who ultimately filed legal action against Mark and/or Facebook, Inc. because of what happened at Harvard. Lastly, at roughly the same age, I ran the same core product at the same time in the same place with the same name with the same people's information, and I didn't do that. I didn't joke with my friends about it, I didn't make fun of my users, I certainly never intended to abuse people's trust, and I never did. One of those users was Mark and I have his SHA-1 password hash sitting in my database, as well as his cell phone number--but I'm not going to share it with anyone, nor have I ever. Clearly it's possible to run such an operation in a different way than Mark. "Call a spade a spade" indeed.
- zaidf 16y agoLeave him alone already!
- acabal 16y agoThis is just a few IM's of a kid joking with his college buddy about what was then nothing more than a side project. It's not like he could have known that in a few years it would have become one of the world's biggest web sites. It sounds like he's just having a laugh with a friend. Honestly if I was in his position at the same time at that same age I would have joked in the same way. I doubt his views on the matter are the same now that he's many years older and his site has a dictionary entry. Give the kid a break.
- stanleydrew 16y agoIn 2006 Facebook was way more than just a side project. Zuckerberg had already dropped out of Harvard to work on it full time and had raised investment if I recall correctly.
- thinkcomp 16y agoThe main link on this thread is incorrect. The IMs are from 2004, not 2006.
- brianpan 16y agoAgreed, the New Yorker mentioned 2006 as the date when the IMs were discovered and the boingboing article screwed it up. http://www.businessinsider.com/well-these-new-zuckerberg-ims-wont-help-facebooks-privacy-problems-2010-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/well-these-new-zuckerberg-ims...
- thinkcomp 16y agoSee my reply below as to why you are completely wrong. Normally I wouldn't emphasize a point so much; in this case it's quite personal and aside from my personal connection, I believe, quite important. Intellectual property theft affects a lot of people who work on software, and it's crucial that the community appreciate the nuance of a case as informative as this.
- detst 16y ago
- gojomo 16y agoI don't think they're 'damning'. 22-year-olds say silly things. People use facetious language and braggadoccio in private conversations that shouldn't be taken literally. And even if his statements are taken literally, if the student info had been volunteered without a promise of strict single-purpose confidentiality, students should have expected their info might be shared for any legal purpose at the discretion of the site proprietor. That's why explicit privacy policies are important; at least in the US, without a promise to the contrary, almost anything goes.
- jacoblyles 16y agoI'd hate to have people criticize everything I said or did when I was 19 years old. I said and did some pretty immature things, hell I had only been living away from my parents for a year. 19->23 was a time of big change for me and I think it is for most people. Poor Zuck.
- daniel-cussen 16y agoIrony is, between the lawsuits, the disclosures, and the movie, now nobody has more embarrassing information about them available to the public than Mark Zuckerberg.
- seltzered 16y agorelax everyone, diaspora's developer release is tomorrow! "Addendum (8/30): To clarify, September 15 will be our open-source developer release. At that time, we will open up our github repository, publish our roadmap, and shift our development style to be more community oriented. We intend on launching a consumer facing alpha in October. Join our mailing list to get an invite." via http://www.joindiaspora.com/2010/08/26/overdue-update.html http://www.joindiaspora.com/2010/08/26/overdue-update.html
- kno 16y agoThese are 22 yo words, at the time he was still uncertain of the future as all of us have been at some point in our lives. It will be wrong and kinda unfair to hold these words against him.
- rewind 16y agoI read this more as a young kid said something stupid over IM, maybe to be cool, maybe not, but people -- especially young people -- say dumb shit all the time to be cool, even if they don't mean what the say. Yes, he's now the CEO of a hugely influential company, but to apply those comments to his current situation is to take the comments somewhat out of context. Are they relevant? Sure. Are they as relevant as if he said them two weeks ago? Not even close. People blow this stuff way out of proportion. Does anyone REALLY think that he'd leak personal information now the way he talked about in these IMs? He has had to grow up a lot faster than most people his age, and he has handled it pretty well, as far as I'm concerned. People love to flip out over this stuff. Sometimes it's worth flipping out over. I don't see this as one of those times.
- scotth 16y agoBet Zuckerberg is wishing that Schmidt's "let kids change their names" idea was implemented a few years ago.
- thenduks 16y agoReally? Personally I'd guess Zuckerberg will never even read this story... and if he did I doubt he'd care.
- nphase 16y agoI'd just like to say this: instead of immediately "going to fuck them", he went and created one of the largest websites in the world. Sounds like a much better outcome (at least for him) to me.
- jacquesm 16y agoThe take home lesson here is that all your online activities can be used in court against you some day in unbelievable detail, so if you plan on being 'successful' start acting responsible today, no matter what your age. Impressions matter, during a lawsuit evidence matters, this provides plenty of both.
- ams6110 16y agoI don't know why you got downvoted. The phrase I like to use is that "what happens on the internet stays on the internet"
- rbanffy 16y ago"what happens on the internet stays on the internet, forever"
- jasonlotito 16y agoSame reason Eric Schmidt get's ripped for his privacy comments.
- Sam_Odio 16y agoI haven't asked Zuck personally if he made these comments. However I can say that after working with him on privacy and photo related issues that these comments definitely don't characterize his approach to the subject. He seems like a pretty normal guy just trying to make the world more open and connected. I agree with jacquesm...this is a great lesson. Don't email, IM, text, etc anything you wouldn't want to read on Valleywag.
- thought_alarm 16y agoMeh. I canceled my Facebook account years ago. But these IMs are just typical of the immature little kid he was back then. We all say and do stupid things when we're that age. It's not a big deal.
- tlrobinson 16y agoHaven't these been circulating for years?
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoSo at what age are you old enough to be held accountable for what you say? Maybe I'm old-fashioned, living in a world before the term "Emerging Adulthood" was coined and people were expected to be reasonably mature by the time they were old enough to graduate from college. He deserves EVERY single piece of negative response he gets for those comments. Even then, he was being trusted with people's private information, a trust that he not only disdained, but he openly expressed a desire to abuse. If that were the only insights into his personality, I'd agree that "context, age, blah, blah, blah", but when taken with everything else about him, it paints a picture of a guy that I would want nothing to do with. The real question, though, IMO, is whether interacting with Facebook is really having anything to do with Zuck. I wouldn't want to actually have business dealings with FB, but, at this point, to what extent could Zuck "fuck them in the ear" (to use his eloquent phrase)? I think the answer to that is not so much (I do have an account) but enough that I'm not going to go overboard (minimal status updates; photos are backed up not stored on FB; no use of places or likes; etc).
- danielha 16y agoI'm inclined to agree with you regarding accountability. But, I dunno, I really don't want my company or business ethics judged by stuff I said to friends in college... through IM. People say stupid stuff all the time.
- msie 16y agoI agree. It's amazing how much I have to police my coworkers not to say the wrong thing, but I don't consider them evil. They say stuff, but they are just joking around. Sometimes I must seem to be a PC prude to them.
- jimbokun 16y ago"They say stuff, but they are just joking around." I've found that jokes often reveal a lot about what people actually believe.
- SoftwareMaven 16y ago
- 16s 16y agoWhere is the confirmation? IMO, he would have to admit he did it. Maybe I missed that in the article. IMs are not PGP signed or anything like that. It could have been someone pretending to be him. Maybe he left his laptop unlocked and a roommate or friend typed those words as a joke. There are hundreds of things that may have happened. Zuck may have nothing to do with it. Don't rush to judgment. Anyone can pretend to be anyone on the Internet.
- bond 16y agoIn Vargas's story, Zuckerberg admits he wrote the IMs and says he "absolutely" regrets them. http://www.businessinsider.com/embarrassing-and-damaging-zuckerberg-ims-confirmed-by-zuckerberg-the-new-yorker-2010-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/embarrassing-and-damaging-zuc...
- qq66 16y agoI've said much worse things, both online and offline. These are a teenager's IM's. Nothing to see here, move on.
- klbarry 16y agoI've definitely joked around just like that. This means nothing about Zuck's character.
- dimarco 16y agoI hardly call the IMs "Damning" considering how he's continued to grow into one of the most powerful people in the tech industry.
- Charuru 16y agoCan anyone explain the context and relevance of the IMs? Is he being sued for privacy violations or some such, so is it just a random/in general smear?
- Andrew_Quentin 16y agoTo be fair, it is slightly dumb to give some site your real name, university e-mail, your address, etc. I remember back when I signed up with a fake username, to be requested to sign up with my real name and uni e-mail, etc. No wonder I haven't really used Facebook much at all. But, whatever he said in the IMs is just "normal" that is, just something we all might have said. So, I do not think that the lesson here is as jacquesm suggests, but rather that we might be entering an age and time when the gods of politics, commerce, science, and whatever other field are shown to be just normal people more vividly.
- igorgue 16y agoremembers me the latest xkcd comic: http://xkcd.com/792/ http://xkcd.com/792/
- adlep 16y agoI think that this is a warning to all of us. Please, be a respectful and civil net citizen. If you troll around like crazy it may come up in the future and come back to hunt you. P.S. I have done my share of occasional trolling and silly comments. I don't think that they were offensive though.
- nitrogen 16y agoWere these IMs obtained from server logs, or from participants in the conversations?
- wakeup 16y agoIn germany its called letter secret? Anyone who uses private conversations to attack someone should be exterminated the fuck out! And if you ask me he didnt get mature, he became a bitch. Serves you right facebook fags!
- loup-vaillant 16y agoTo sum up in 5 words what many here said in more: "Great Powers imply Great Responsibilities." At 19, Zuck had big powers and no responsibility. It's not excusable, and I'm not sure it's forgiveable either. Now, Mark Zuckerberg has immense power. I doubt that he's responsible enough to make up for it. I even doubt that anyone can be responsible enough. And if the responsibility needed to wield the power of Facebook doesn't exist, well, maybe wielding it at all is not excusable, or even forgiveable.