13 ms·
Google’s new Chat service shows contempt for Android users’ privacy
- gregknicholson 9y agoOh, I hope this is Google having their “Facebook moment”!
- ColinWright 9y agoIt is, it absolutely is. People will run around going "Google is horrible! Google is terrible", and then ... Nothing will change.
- scarface74 9y agoWhat realistic choices do people have? I use iOS, but given the choice between a decent Android phone like the Moto E that you can get for less than $150 and a $650+ iPhone, I wouldn't advise most people to get an iPhone.
- peatmoss 9y agoI prefer the Android experience, but switched back to iOS / iPhone a couple years back precisely because I did ask myself how much Apple’s better-but-not-robustly-verifiable privacy posture was. I decided that, over the life of a phone, that was worth at least $500 and the associated lesser UX. I don’t know that a smartphone has to cost $650, but I don’t think most US corporations will sign up to deliver a $150 smartphone that doesn’t mine your privacy.
- crystaln 9y agoSame. I really want to switch to Android for various reasons but can't bring myself to give up Apple's core respect for privacy.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoLineageOS + MicroG is all you need to cut out Google and get enhanced, per-app privacy controls.
- crystaln 9y agoSure. I'm not interested in spending my time hacking my phone tho, and I want to use Google services. I want privacy by default. Also I'm less concerned about Google having my data than my messages being sent plaintext through carriers.
- gregknicholson 9y ago> What realistic choices do people have? That's the problem. A market without competition is a cabal.
- gilrain 9y agoLove that can-do attitude.
- ColinWright 9y agoThe power of accurate observations is commonly called cynicism by those who haven't got it. -- George Bernard Shaw
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lawlessone 9y agoIt isn't . It will have to be bigger, like something huge leaking. A lot of people wont care until everything google knows about them is known by the general public.
- dredmorbius 9y agoJohn Podesta's emails, say?
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoHardly. The reason Facebook ceased to get a pass for everything it did was because user data was harvested without their permission (friends of friends) and was used for nefarious means. That was a huge shock, and just goes to show how complacent we are about digital privacy. Google’s “Facebook moment” is still very far away.
- HenryBemis 9y agoPeople using Android should live with the notion that Google siphons absolutely everything from their devices. One way is to block any application is not needed to "speak to google" (or Facebook, or any advertisers). I always use and suggest to other Android users the NoRoot Firewall [1], and then disable/uninstall everything not needed. Of course that applied to IT pros, as tweaking things without the appropriate knowledge may/will result to a phone bricking/reset. [1]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.greyshirts.firewall https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.greyshirts...
- igorkraw 9y agoTHANK YOU for linking this app
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoI have to admit it feels really good to block all these background requests.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThere's no way you could brick the phone by using the NoRoot Firewall. In general, my problem with these apps is that you shift your trust from one company to another. I have no idea who created this app, what their motives are, how securely they guard their signing key and so on.
- Oletros 9y ago> The information obtained includes vehicle speed, coolant and oil temperature, throttle position, engine temperature and engine revs. This information is then reportedly sent from Android Auto to Google on a real time basis. Android Auto is now a component of Google Assistant. This was denied by Google, isn't?
- canuckintime 9y agoYes, and no proof from those making the accusations was ever forthcoming.
- opencl 9y agoIt's ironic that the photo for the linked article about the Android Auto allegations is a Tesla, because Tesla does not support Android Auto and actually does collect that sort of information. https://www.tesla.com/about/legal https://www.tesla.com/about/legal
- bitmapbrother 9y agoNot only was it false, but the representative of the company that made the accusation works for VW - the same company that lied and defrauded customers by installing emissions cheating software on their cars.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoMRW I stumbbled onto the fact that Gboard has a opt-out keylogger. Edit: Title change made my wording look like a drunk redditor stumbled over to HN. The original title was "Google Accused of Showing 'Total Contempt' for Android Users' Privacy". I too accused Google of 'Total Contempt'.
- realusername 9y agoIt's not even the creepiest one for me, the creepiest one is receiving a notification while you are at the restaurant from Google Maps saying something like "We know you are there, please send us pictures of that place"
- bittercynic 9y agoNice how they use a notification to ask you to do work for them for free.
- berberous 9y ago>> MRW I stumbbled onto the fact that Gboard has a opt-out keylogger. Explain? Edit: I think the parent poster is incorrect insofar as it may be read to imply that keystrokes are sent to Google. While on iOS you can indeed give Gboard (or any keyboard) "Full Access", Google's privacy policy for iOS GBoard is below (Android's is similar). It seems reasonable to me, and only logs your keystrokes _on your device_. What Gboard sends to Google: - Gboard sends your searches to Google's web servers to give you search results. - Gboard also sends usage statistics to Google to let us know which features are used most often and to help us understand problems if the app crashes. What Gboard doesn't send to Google: - Other than your searches, Gboard doesn't send anything you type to Google, whether it's a password or chat with a friend. Gboard will remember words you type to help you with spelling or to predict searches you might be interested in, but this data is stored only on your device. This data can't be accessed by Google or by any apps other than Gboard. - If you’ve turned on contacts search in Gboard search settings, this allows Gboard to search the contacts on your device so you can easily share. None of these queries are sent to Google.
- proaralyst 9y agoI really wish there were a third phone OS: I don't want to buy iOS devices because the hardware is only manufactured by Apple and on Android you can't get away from Google. There's the new Purism phone but it probably won't be able to run WhatsApp.
- worble 9y agoIf you're concerned about phone privacy I'd be concerned about using WhatsApp too, considering its owned by Facebook.
- dboreham 9y agoThere were third phone OSes (and fourth, fifth...). Nobody wanted them.
- gif653490 9y agoBecause none of these OSes offer any of the apps people use and want, Same as with Linux and Windows, the vast majority choose the latter because that's where the industry leading applications (Office, Photoshop etc) Drivers support and best games are, Period.
- JoshMnem 9y agoPeople buy Windows, because it's hard to buy computers at the store that have Linux on them unless you know where to look (or buy locked-down Chrome OS). People don't need MS Office (Libre Office) or Photoshop (GIMP). Games run fine on Linux (see GOG and Steam), and the number would increase if more manufacturers sold laptops with Linux. Most people don't choose their OS -- they are fed.
- dwighttk 9y agoPeople buy Windows because they want wifi to work
- 9y ago
- therealmarv 9y agoThis accusation is wrong. Chat is using a protocol which is a successor of SMS. It's an interface to this protocol and not a 100% WhatsApp/Telegram copy. And this will be also the reason it will fail... it's not all on Google's control, even the network providers will have control and iOS will be missing (that means no entire market reach). The problem with this new standard (RCS I think) is that it was never designed for end to end encryption.
- hahainternet 9y agoYours is the only post in this entire thread adding the needed context. The article doesn't either. Yet somehow you were at the bottom of the page for me. I don't understand why.
- crystaln 9y agoApple has implented a solution with iMessage, albeit a proprietary one only for iOS communications. If Google prioritized the privacy of users thet would build a similar product as the default Android messaging service, hopefully as an open platform. I have been very reluctant to switch to Android for precisely this reason. It represents a lack of concern for user privacy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kyrra 9y agoIt is easy is to send an insecure message via iMessage. When the app will fallback to SMS, there isn't any clear indication that this is less secure. Sure you get the green vs blue bubbles, but security isn't exactly pointed out.
- crystaln 9y agoSure it's not perfect. The point is a default that respects and enforces privacy. It is night and day from Android. I wish Apple would open the protocol.
- kerng 9y agoMany years ago (starting 2010 or so) Google "simplified" their privacy policies, meaning they threw them out of the window and have a central profile about you and your behavior. Some of Google's tactics are creepy, like Microsoft late 90s creepy. They should be called out more often. Reference to some of the things that happened back then: https://www.pcworld.com/article/248715/googles_tracking_plan_offers_users_benefits_privacy_concerns.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/248715/googles_tracking_plan...
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoFrom what I understand, RCS is not encrypted so that the carriers can implement it as a SMS replacement and still comply with wire tapping regulations (IANAL, so if anything I just said is wrong, please respond). However, once RCS is implemented by the carriers, I see no reason Google's Allo couldn't be updated to use RCS and still implement an encryption layer on top of it.
- arbitrage 9y agoAbsolutely. Google won't do that, however.
- ViViDboarder 9y agoOr just ignore it altogether. Why bother implementing RCS if you can already ensure Android phones can talk with whatever protocol you want and iPhones will probably only support SMS and iMessage anyway. What value does it really add to customers? The value to Google is it’s a protocol they don’t have to maintain and an excuse to ignore encryption.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoThis is a valid point. By backing/pushing RCS, Google doesn't have to maintain the infrastructure (servers, protocol, etc) to support messaging as this would be on the carriers.
- pmontra 9y agoPeople will keep using WhatsApp, Messengwr and to a lesser extent Telegram. Chat is the nth Google attempt in that space and everybody remembers that the previous ones failed. That memory is all it takes to make this one fail too. The only chance: make it replace the stock Messaging app, the one for SMSes. Then route messages trasparently to the SMS gateway or to RCS.
- Eridrus 9y ago> The only chance: make it replace the stock Messaging app, the one for SMSes. This is exactly what is happening.
- nmeofthestate 9y agoReminder: millions of people send SMS's and don't care one bit about encryption, and they only use WhatsApp because it's free to send messages, and pictures are supported.
- ViViDboarder 9y agoSure. That’s even more a reason why Google should be proactive. Apple defaults to secure if iOS users are texting each other. Google has always done the opposite. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that Google is the one who’s business model depends on sucking up as much content as possible.
- yoz-y 9y agoThis is the sad part I think. SMS being shit is why people actually had obtained some privacy. If the RCS is good, then it is back to square one.
- freddie_mercury 9y agoWhatsapp came out in 2009. Encryption was added 7 years later in 2016. Why would anyone who cares about encryption have been using it for the almost decade up till now?
- fredley 9y agoMillions? Literally almost every user of WhatsApp. Those who care about encryption are a miniscule minority.
- 0xfffff 9y agoJust because people don't care about privacy, doesn't mean they dont deserve or in fact need it. But in fact most people care, or assume they have privacy. why does Google not show a red icon to users that these messages are not protected for instance. something browsers do? A company like Google should care about their user's privacy, but well thats the entire point of the article.
- kerng 9y agoSo, why not make it better? Or, why not educate users the messages are in clear text via UI indication that the message is not protected? That would help with users understanding what's going on and allowing them to protect themselves.
- htk_ 9y agodownvote this if you don't care privacy, Google never "really" cared about users' privacy, they just do it in a little better way than zuck does, they pretend to be transparent while they're not, lots evidence showed that Google is such an evil company, yeah I know most people here don't care anyway, every time I say something like this, I get downvoted
- fredley 9y agoI dream of a service which I can use to send a message to a contact. It knows if that contact is on WhatsApp, Telegram etc. (or plain old SMS) and chooses the best option for that contact automatically. It merges the inbound messages from any of those apps I have so they're all in one place. I no longer have to use all [n] chat apps installed on my phone just because for each of them, there are a few people only contactable via that particular app.
- Mister_Snuggles 9y agoThis is the one thing that Blackberry got right - unified messaging. All messaging apps could feed into the system messages app, you'd see it all in one place and could read/reply/etc regardless of what app was actually doing the messaging. From what I could see it worked really well.
- ecshafer 9y agoThis was a solved problem back in the day. Pidgin was a desktop application that let you put aim, msn, yahoo, or whatever chat you wanted together. You had one list and you messaged people on there. It was the same regardless of what platform they were on. It was great.
- glenneroo 9y agoThe Windows equivalent was Trillian, which even had IRC support.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nvarsj 9y agoIt's pretty hilarious, this has been a solved problem many times. But there doesn't seem to be much money in unifying chat systems, all the money is in making new proprietary ones.
- zelos 9y ago> Google’s own app Allo has an option for end-to-end encryption but the company says it will no longer invest in it. I really don't understand Google. Wasn't Allo a tent-pole item at Google I/O a year or so ago, and now it's no longer being invested in?
- telchar 9y agoThey're the oil-rich nation of companies. They can afford vanity projects and woeful mismanagement as long as that sweet sweet advertising money keeps coming in. The sectors of the company that keep that running are run well, but side projects like this seem to come and go with little rhyme or reason as far as I can tell. Much like how the militaries of some countries are well-run and competent (and control the oil) while the rest of the government is a clown show.
- carapace 9y agoYes, exactly this. "You can get away with all kinds of BS when you're sitting in an open fire-hydrant of money." One obvious symptom of this is that Google's internal codebase is organized like a flea market rather than a phone book.
- Kalium 9y agoFrom what I read, Allo didn't get much in the way of support from carriers and OEMs. Practically speaking, Google needs their support to get something in the hands of users. Google has developed a habit of trying multiple approaches to any given thing, and keeping what's most successful. For definitions of "successful" that aren't always what the rest of us might expect.
- gknapp 9y agoI gave Allo an honest shot when it first came out – I was excited by its feature set, and I was hoping for a far improved messenger app. My first message went to my wife, who's on an iPhone. It was really difficult to suss out exactly how Allo wanted to handle this conversation... It seemed to both want to fallback to a default SMS while also trying to do some of the Google Assistant things, failing at both. There are certainly some countries where the vast majority of users are Android, but it seemed pretty unfathomable to me that they'd push a product that didn't function appropriately cross-platform.
- dcomp 9y agoI think RCS is being framed incorrectly. It isn't a competitor to WhatsApp/telegram/iMessage it's an update to SMS If they bought out another competitor all that would happen would be one more chat client that 20% of your contacts use if that. With RCS, in order to supplant SMS it requires co-operations with telco. It's there to see increase base line support. Maybe telco would have been okay with e2e encryption although I highly doubt it. Once the baseline RCS standard is put in place. It maybe possible to implement e2e with an OTR client side extension. RCS is the successor to or replacement of SMS/MMS. I for one will be happy when I no longer have to ask: "how do you want me to send that to you? Email WhatsApp or telegram?"
- Eridrus 9y ago> Maybe telco would have been okay with e2e encryption although I highly doubt it. I don't think it's even about whether they would be "ok" with it, telcos are highly regulated, it is probably illegal to have e2e crypto in a carrier protocol in some jurisdictions.
- _bxg1 9y agoThis is pretty alarmist. In addition to the other comments here about RCS simply being SMS++, privacy and Google have been incompatible for a long time already. If you care about privacy, don't use Google software in the first place. I always have to plug LineageOS on articles like this. It's a wonderful Android ROM which provides additional privacy settings and which you don't have to install Gapps with. I'm happily using a modern smartphone without a single piece of software from the Big Five tech companies.
- hi41 9y agoWow! This is something ... getting evicirated by Amnesty International!
- monkeynotes 9y agoWell, I guess someone missed the point that the carriers control SMS, not Google. 'Chat' is a consumer friendly name for Rich Communication Service (RCS) which is built on top of SMS. Google is simply advocating adoption of RCS after failing to get adoption for any of their own rich messaging protocols. Blame lazy, cash obsessed carriers if you want to blame anyone. Next we will be blaming Google for making a phone app that only uses A5/1 stream cipher which the FBI can intercept and decrypt easily when they want to snoop[0]. Yes Google failed so many times to compete with iMessage, but they did try. I can't blame them to rethink their strategy, I mean most people are using SMS already, I for one would like to at least be able to send full res photos. [0] https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/mar/29/feds-fbi-warrantless-cell-tracking-very-common/ https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/mar/29/feds-fbi-wa...
- ajross 9y agoThere are sort of two issues here: The first is that RCS is a flawed specification with inappropriate features for the modern world and shouldn't be adopted. It's being pushed hard by carriers, among others. The second is that somehow Google has ended up as the punching bag for this gripe for the crime of implementing RCS. I mean... no, that's not really fair (and most of the folks here really should know better). But... meh. I mean, they still implemented it. People need to stop looking to carriers and software giants to secure their privacy. There are multiple good options in the open source world for secure messaging. We need to be pushing those.
- mankash666 9y agoI bet the reporter willfully hung this around Google's neck though it was a carrier standard. The story's just bait-ier with an evil-Google vs people plot
- emptyfile 9y agoSorry to be that guy, but no one in Europe uses SMS. Also it's ridiculous that Google never made a simple WhatsApp clone.