14 ms·
In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity
- vixen99 9y agoAnd is the UK government behind the erosion of free speech identified at a large number of institutions who have banned and actively censored ideas on campus? Shall we assume they are helpless in the face of demands from Whitehall? http://www.spiked-online.com/free-speech-university-rankings http://www.spiked-online.com/free-speech-university-rankings
- triplesec 9y agoCould you please explain your Whitehall (prsumably Civil Service) rhetorical question? I don't follow, and I suspect it's a little brief for others also.
- mayniac 9y agoI have a few issues with that link. Namely that a traffic light system is a huge, huge, HUGE oversimplification of complex issues. While the analysis seems fairly transparent, I don't think many people will actually look into it past the traffic light. I checked out the uni I went to: apparently the students union got an amber light because of "no tolerance to sexual harassment". How exactly does that violate free speech? The right to free speech unequivocally does not give you the right to harass people in any way. Similarly "Rules and Regulations for the Use of Information and Communications Technology" is an amber for institutions: does that mean all AUPs are in violation of freedom of speech? Most of them come down to "please don't hack our infrastructure or download anything that will make the police come round". Also when things like "bans on specific ideologies" are very likely to get misconstrued. Banning groups which verbally harass others is likely going to be seen as a ban on free speech, despite the fact that such bans may be warranted. The whole analysis and ranking system seems biased, and completely garbage to me. Edit: since I'm an idiot and didn't realise that you could expand the amber/red points on the site, my uni SU's "no tolerance to sexual harassment" was due to them adopting the NUS (National Union of Students) guideline that sexual harassment is defined as ‘any unwanted comments which makes someone uncomfortable’, and the ICT rule was ‘Users must ensure that the content and tone of their email messages cannot be considered offensive.’ Both of these appear reasonable to me. There's some genuine debate to be had over the issue of no-platforming but all this site is doing is furthering their own agenda, which seems to be that they should have the right to insult and harass people however they want. As always, this is relevant here: https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- Angostura 9y agoApparently my old university gets an amber light too because " Sexual Harassment is Never OK".
- SuoDuanDao 9y agoThat particular xkcd gets linked a lot in this debate. I really wonder what happened between when the author drew that comic and when he drew this one: https://www.xkcd.com/137/ https://www.xkcd.com/137/
- aninhumer 9y agoMaybe he realised that speech has consequences beyond an employer not hiring him, and decided to take responsibility for those consequences? And that rather than "watering down" ones thoughts, understanding the implications of language and avoiding unintended ones actually expresses your ideas better? Or, in short, he grew up.
- sudosteph 9y agoI don't see any incompatibility there? Seems like in 137 he's saying that he doesn't want to sacrifice individuality and creativity for the sake of maintaining a banal existence that doesn't deviate from the norm out of fear. He's accepting the risks that come with making his opinions public, and challenging assumptions that he should just shut up, in part because he has confidence in the validity of his beliefs and a willingness to defend them. The more recent one is about people who publicize poorly constructed opinions with no consideration to the potential consequences it will create for their interpersonal and community relationships. Those folks are welcome to say "fuck that shit" like the character in 137 and go build their own forums or whatever to spread and defend those ideas. But most of these types would prefer to whine and call themselves victims.
- henryaj 9y ago> he doesn't want to sacrifice individuality and creativity for the sake of maintaining a banal existence that doesn't deviate from the norm out of fear Exactly. Just apply that to the fear of running afoul of draconian speech codes designed to reduce the amount of "offence" people experience.
- neel_k 9y agoYes, the UK government is behind the erosion of free speech on campus. The Counter Terrorism and Security Act of 2015 imposes a statutory duty on universities to have a "due regard to the need to prevent individuals from being drawn into terrorism". This means that institutions now have a statutory duty to participate in the government's Prevent strategy. This means UK universities have a legal obligation to narc on students who are too Muslim. As a whole, universities have tried to finesse this attack on free expression this by defining violent radicalism as a signal of mental illness and telling us lecturers that we should feel obliged to refer struggling students to mental health services. Ultimately, though, when the intent and design of the rules is fundamentally bigoted, there is only so far that technical compliance can mitigate that.
- beaconstudios 9y agowhat is a preferable way to handle what you call "violent radicalism"? If the rule is only targeted at those who are drawn into beliefs that would see those individuals commit violent acts, what makes reporting them bigoted compared to reporting other violent groups?
- DanBC 9y agoHere's some information about CHANNEL / PREVENT: http://www.teescpp.org.uk/prevent-channel-referral-process http://www.teescpp.org.uk/prevent-channel-referral-process People who are referred are assessed, and most appropriate help should be provided. For some people this will be mental health services. For others it might be befriending services, or access to non-radicalising social groups. People have mentioned external speakers. Here's the guidance for Higher Education in England and Wales. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/445916/Prevent_Duty_Guidance_For_Higher_Education__England__Wales_.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... ---begin 6. We would expect RHEBs to be delivering in the following areas. External Speakers and Events 7. In order to comply with the duty all RHEBs should have policies and procedures in place for the management of events on campus and use of all RHEB premises. The policies should apply to all staff, students and visitors and clearly set out what is required for any event to proceed. 8. The RHEB clearly needs to balance its legal duties in terms of both ensuring freedom of speech and academic freedom, and also protecting student and staff welfare. Although it predates this legislation, Universities UK produced guidance in 2013 to support institutions to make decisions about hosting events and have the proper safeguards in place: http://www.universitiesuk.ac.uk/highereducation/Pages/Externalspeakersinhighereducationinstitutions.aspx http://www.universitiesuk.ac.uk/highereducation/Pages/Extern... ---end https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/445977/3799_Revised_Prevent_Duty_Guidance__England_Wales_V2-Interactive.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- watwut 9y agoYou mean the ranking that ignores all religious and private institutions with much higher restrictions?
- pjc50 9y agoSpiked online is not a reputable news source, it's a professional troll organisation. They're currently libertarian but are the successor paper to "Living Marxism".
- bannedaccount 9y agoIn my college in US there was a "Free Speech" group that would bring in different radical speakers to "expand the minds" of the student body. Well that was it's stated goal anyway, in reality every single speaker was a hard right-winger and the groups was entirely funded by a conservative PAC. When nobody actually showed up the group shut down after only a year. Also this article isn't really even about free speech in the context of personal or political expression.
- Xuper 9y agoIt would be nice to see some STEM-affirmative universities without any x-studies leaching. Professional complainer is a viable career path these days and it starts at uni.
- collyw 9y agoListening to Jonathan Haidt its pretty scary stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IBegL_V6AA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IBegL_V6AA
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoListening to Jonathan Haidt its pretty scary stuff. Don't listen to it then. By the way the, UK isn't the same as the US, our problems aren't necessarily the same as yours.
- collyw 9y agoIgnorance is bliss.
- pjc50 9y agoIgnoring fake news from rightwing idealogues is even more bliss.
- TheTrotters 9y agoBut I thought we were talking about Jonathan Haidt?
- TheForumTroll 9y agoI have no idea what you two are talking about. Could you enlighten those of us that don't know?
- purple-again 9y ago
- Angostura 9y agoThere's also the issue of what has happened now that students have to pay through the nose for courses. They are now customers who expect high grades for their fees. This has certainly changed the dynamic with regard to rigorous marking in some areas
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI can't help feeling we would be better off if responsibility for grading was taken away from universities as it is for A levels and GCSEs. There are some problems with that but I suspect they would be outweighed by the benefits.
- sgt101 9y agoTough to do this within the constraints of academic freedom; if an institution wants to offer a new course and they need to get certification by an authority and find externals to mark it... well could stall things by years?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoAs I said there are downsides. I will say though that the courses on offer to my children when they went to university looked very similar. I'm not sure this would be a huge problem.
- golergka 9y agoOffer a course without a certification. Then, those students who are only in uni for the grades will not take it, but students who actually value knowledge will opt in for the course.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoWhich then will be penalised by mainstream employers, because there's no certification - automated CV scanners will dump your application as it's "not a proper degree".
- Hasknewbie 9y agoI agree with the article but I can only note, once more, that it is from The Guardian, who did run multiple articles in support of no-platforming in universities. But look who comes crying about freedom of inquiry now, once said "erosion of integrity" is done by right-wing bureaucrats. But the no-platforming happens mostly in the US, while government interferences is happening in the UK, so they will probably get away with their double standard one more time.
- unfunco 9y agoWhenever the theme turns a little bit orange on the Guardian, you're reading an opinion, there are lots of opinion columnists at the Guardian and many of them have differing views. If you want a more consistent view from the Guardian, then stay in the news sections (the theme is red for that), this case, the opinion is by a professor at the University of Cambridge, it's not an unbiased report from a journalist.
- DanBC 9y agoGuardian have run lots of articles saying that no-platforming is bad, but also telling people that no-platforming isn't really that common. Many of the so-called no-platforming events either didn't happen, or didn't happen in the way they were reported.
- joshsyn 9y agoI have lost confidence in the western university system. Too much high exorbitant fees, with no future prospects but debt, so I have taken it myself to learn online via open courses.
- glogla 9y agoNot all of West has it this way. US and UK yes, but rest of EU mostly has free college in same or higher quality.
- joshsyn 9y agoUS, UK, Australia, not sure about south africa. I will be eyeing on EU.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoScotland is nowhere near as bad as the rest of the UK although you have to have put up with their dreary weather for three years before attending.
- funkythings 9y agoIt's very disingenuous of the author not to mention free speech issues, the massive administrations that are run by radical left-leaning activists essentially, and pseudoscience like gender studies or gender studies. I agree otherwise
- pjc50 9y ago> the massive administrations that are run by radical left-leaning activists essentially Name one of these people and provide an example [2 marks]
- te_chris 9y agoAccount created 7 months ago.... Sigh.
- terriblechat90 9y agohttps://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/03/02/eight-ten-british-university-lecturers-left-wing-survey-finds https://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/03/02/eight-ten-b... Yes I know it's just the story not the report. A quick search shows plenty of examples. I'll have a link in a minute.
- terriblechat90 9y agoThere you go: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/56eddde762cd9413e151ac92/t/58b5a7cd03596ec6631d8b8a/1488299985267/Left+Wing+Bias+Paper.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/56eddde762cd9413e151a...
- pjc50 9y agoThat's a reprinted press release from the Adam Smith institute. I'm still looking for the name of a specific person who can be deemed to (a) run a university administration (b) be a "radical left-winger", with an example of their behaviour or published works which qualifies them as such.
- titanix2 9y ago
- pjc50 9y agoThis should probably be seen in the context of the ongoing industrial action in response to a sneaky attempt to convert pensions from defined-benefit to defined-contribution, thereby halving their value. This was based on an extremely questionable financial scenario ("what if all UK universities went bankrupt?")
- peoplewindow 9y agoEr is it a questionable scenario? UK universities all have very similar businesses, customer bases, staff unionisation levels and risk profiles. It's quite imaginable that if there was a sudden drop in the number of students attending university they might all get in dire straits simultaneously.
- pjc50 9y agoThey have very different financial reserves, especially the Russell Group ones, and this also presumes that the government would let its entire tertiary education system collapse without intervening.
- peoplewindow 9y agoWell, the intervention is to change the pensions, surely. And the goal is to intervene before a collapse occurs rather than afterwards. If the argument is "we don't need to change the university pension scheme because when they go bankrupt the government will bail them out", I suppose that should be made directly.
- noodlesUK 9y agoAs a university student in the UK I find myself reminded of these problems on a very frequent basis. The purpose of universities seems to have shifted from providing academic research and learning to simply being another stage of school, with the sole objective of handing out degrees. One of the metrics that I feel indicates this most strongly is the radical change in hiring at universities in recent years. It's shocking to know that many universities (mine included) now employ more full time non-academic staff than full time academics.
- Shivetya 9y agoI am a bit confused by the last statement. It can take a lot of man power to support the academics at any university. Now this is not to say that there isn't a lot of staff padding going on. From supporting the physical site of the university which can be across multiple campuses to managing the life and well being of the students. Then top it off with administrative people and their support staffs the numbers can add up quickly. I think a better metric is how many students, undergraduate and graduate/professional compared to academics and then separately non academics. If the the ratio of those who teach to those there to learn tips is outside of averages we have a real concern
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoNot parent but, your statement doesn't explain why the ratio of academics to administrators should have fallen, do academics now need more administrators than they did. Are the newly employed non-academics really serving the research aims, or are they meeting the schooling requirements?
- wastedhours 9y agoPart of it is that, yes, the non-academic staff help with the mountain of non-academic work lecturers would otherwise have. I used to work in a support role at a university, and although many of the roles will inevitably be automated away, you'd be amazed at how much administration a student on a course requires (from room bookings for lectures, enrolment information, pastoral support, cleaning, cooking, supporting with IT systems, reviewing coursework and exams, QA-ing courses, assisting with research proposals, lining up interviews for PhD candidates...). It's not something that scales well, the more students you have, the more of these things you need to manage, and the less it makes sense for academic staff to do it (on top of their other publish or perish commitments). When you have a building that can hold 250 students, and 5 courses with 75 students each, each needing a lecture booking at around about the same time, but not the same time as some will overlap modules, so they can do practicals in the afternoon, whilst potentially needing to book in placement meetings throughout the day with the placements officer, and having the part-time staff in the academic office available for coursework hand-ins... this is where it gets messy. This will all be solved by technology in the future, but the "industry" is growing faster than the infrastructure allows. When you need to solve the problem now, and you're not a digitally-minded organisation, you throw bodies at it. That being said, I'm not in agreement that 50% of the school-leaving population should be forced into a traditional university setting just because we as a society only value that route as being rigorous enough.
- PeterStuer 9y agoIt's the infestation of 'market' philosophy that is the grindstone on the academic values. Everything gets beaten into submission of an amoral self-referential quantitative utility framework. This has become so ingrained that many, if not most, don't even see it as a choice but simply accept it as some sort of universal law.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>amoral self-referential quantitative utility framework My goodness, that's quite a phrase. What do you actually mean?
- PeterStuer 9y agoWhich part is confusing you?
- pas 9y agoWhat makes a framework self-referential? What does submission of ... mean? What is this framework? Or which one is this?
- oldcynic 9y agoIt's quite appalling how UK universities seem to have changed since tuition fees. Most saddening is the effective destruction of the Open University as they now charge the same fees as everyone else. Few can afford to take an OU course for interest, or mid life career change any more. The youngest is looking very unlikely to attend university at all thanks to feedback from those already in the system. I rather get the impression that paying £9k per year has turned academic excellence into a simple commercial production line.
- pjc50 9y agoThe OU was actually one of the great British success stories, a "MOOC" before the Internet. It's a tragedy if that's coming to an end.
- oldcynic 9y agoIt's not quite as bad as attending, but cost of a degree is about £18k or so - at £3k/year if you do the typical spread over 6 years. The cost has been going up markedly ever since £3k fees first came in. They still offer bursaries and grants for those on low income, but seem to have been trimmed to be only partial help, with the rest on a student loan. I'm fairly sure you used to be able to apply for 100% help. So it seems far less appealing for those on low or middle income, and all their traditional successes like those who never did a degree at 18 etc.
- c12 9y agoOmi, so the OU is no longer free? :o
- icc97 9y agoThis compounds some major long-term problems for education in the UK. 1. Their school systems are the most elitist/unequal in Europe [0] (from this TED talk [1]). There are many things I love about the UK but I can never go back as the school I send my child to now for free would cost £4000-6000 per year of post-tax income in the UK. 2. Because of underpaying teachers (In comparison to Belgium the mid-level art teacher I know gets paid €100/hr) and burying teachers in red-tape there is a significant shortage of teachers. This has led to the ridiculous lottery system they now have for picking schools. 3. The Brexit is going to hit the number of European students hard. Outside of Oxford and Cambridge, most of the top 10 UK Universities are all in London with a huge contingent of European students. So Universities are going to lose their European influx and the incoming generation of students are going to be poorer. [0]: https://imgur.com/a/qqKDgMd https://imgur.com/a/qqKDgMd [1]: https://www.ted.com/talks/andreas_schleicher_use_data_to_build_better_schools#t-288035 https://www.ted.com/talks/andreas_schleicher_use_data_to_bui...
- padthai 9y agoI always wondered if non-EU students are going to keep coming in the long term too. Only Chinese for example, there are 60k undergrads coming every year. That should be about $1.2B/yr for three years only in tuition fees. It is not that much money at the end of the day but it has to be important because universities are building campus overseas to capture all those students. And at some point Indian, Chinese, etc. universities will become more attractive and that money flow will stop too.
- nunya213 9y agoHonestly that's just kind of cute. Good private schools in the US regularly cost over $40,000 per year.
- icc97 9y agoI'm talking about an average school for ages 4-11. But this is not a competition about who has the most expensive schools. I'd rather live in a country where education is free.
- YellowCode 9y agoHere is an interesting read http://www.culturewars.com/2002/potter.html http://www.culturewars.com/2002/potter.html
- pjc50 9y agoWhat does a 2002 article on faxes and children's books have to do with the present-day UK education sector?
- YellowCode 9y agoIf you read it, you'll know.
- eesmith 9y agoYeah, I tried, it started with gushing over James Dobson - the man who believes that beating children is a good thing (this is personal; my parents used his books for parenting advice) - and C.S. Lewis. Eg, it complains about Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone as being a "deeply incoherent work", and praises Lewis. But the Narnia series is also a deeply incoherent work. It describes the book as a narcissistic fantasy, which is a literary description and an opinion. It then spends paragraphs describing the psychiatric condition known as narcissism. But the connection is still an opinion. The author then gives this horrid homophobic nugget: > One of the most blatant forms of magic through ingestion is, of course, homosexuality, and through its connection with narcissism we can get some inkling of the purpose behind the major cultural offensive in favor of homosexuality. The homosexual is the consumer culture’s version of the ideal citizen because he takes all of the strains of narcissism to their logical antiessentialist conclusion. Yeah, I stopped there.
- YellowCode 9y agoYou're not going to make it.
- eesmith 9y ago
- EnderMB 9y agoDespite being a British citizen, I don't understand the university model all that well, but one argument I see being banded about over the creeping levels of control over UK universities is why the more elite-level universities haven't opted to go private. Sure, there was a legitimate argument a while ago with no/low tuition fees. The government was footing the bill. Now that tuition fees have risen, and seem to want to continue to rise, what benefit is there for the likes of Oxford, Cambridge, UCL, and co to remain public? Someone I used to work with attended the University of Buckingham, one of the few universities in the UK that is private, and he said that while it was no Oxbridge, the flexibility of graduating in two years made it completely worth it. Ironically, a lot of pressure is put on the ex-polytechnics and middling universities in the UK to justify their high costs, low quality of content, and average employment figures, with the government often pointing towards the need for flexibility (i.e. two year degrees to save money). If the government want to get their claws in, I'm surprised that those with the freedom to go private haven't decided to, or at least as a way to one-up their competitors.
- terriblechat90 9y agoUgh, boo hoo. "Autonomous" Universities have become political and a source of left propaganda. Only time they complain about it is when the politics are on the "wrong" side.
- keithpeter 9y agoI finished an undergraduate degree in 1980, when there were around 25000 undergraduates [1] p13/14. Now there are at least 10 times that many. Inevitably, the system has had to change to reflect that increase in volume within the span of a single career - quite a lot of change. Not sure where the answer lies, but an increasingly large proportion of my teenager students are opting not to go to university directly at 18, so there could be a 'correction' on the way over the next generation or so. [1] http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN04252/SN04252.pdf http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN042...
- throw2016 9y agoSome significant issues in western democracy can be traced back to the 1980's and before the fall of communism. Untill then it was important at least for appearances to show western capitalism and democracy as the best and fairest political systems for all round prosperity. Reaganism, Thatcherism and neoliberlism of the Friedman kind unleashed a toxic ideology that legitimizes and surrenders all decision making and thinking to markets. It's like a religion and magical thinking. This disproportionately benefits those with economic power as it is intended to, but under the Orwellian use of words like 'freedom' and 'efficiency'. This concentrated economic power is then used to co-opt dissent by economic means or disarm it to make it meaningless. Academics along with a free press were a bulwark against unchecked power and provided dissent. Now they are too tied up with administration and securing grants to perform that role, and this is not an accident. The free press similarly have become too intertwined with entrenched interests and government and have been reduced to a mouth piece for propaganda and special interests.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dbuder 9y agoUnis in Australia suffer from the same issue. When I was there the uni was constantly patting itself on the back for building more accommodation for international students and even then I thought to myself, this place doesn't seem to have the right priorities.
- triplesec 9y agoUniversities in the UK have turned into administrator-heavy (as in the US) property development companies made to enrich the administrators and top brass, it seems. Here's a story that hints at the issues (UCL and others have been doing this a lot) https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/25/students-sit-in-university-social-cleaning-london-stop-elephant-castle https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/25/studen... While looking for this, I also found this, (slightly off-topic, but somewhat salient) which makes for sobering reading. https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/bnk3vm/vices-most-evil-university-awards https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/bnk3vm/vices-most-evil-un...
- neumann 9y agoYou argument is not in favor of the poor. Given the way taxation works, free healthcare and education provide opportunities for lower incomes that aren't available for private services. When education is free (popular phrasing for government paid), a poor person with no income can get a free education and usually financial support and actually get a degree. If healthcare is free, the burden of the individual is carried by the society. As for 'standard libertarian arguments', you might as well say 'myopic perspective'.
- andersonnnunes 9y agoHere in Brazil, in a public university, I saw a policeman (among others) cheating on exams and professors knowingly ignoring it. Just one case, there were many others. Beware of Brazilians. The de facto rule here is "fuck everybody not in my circle".