9 ms·
Quantum radar will expose stealth aircraft
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> *Quantum radar...works by sending one of the [entangled] photons to a distant object, while retaining the other member of the pair. Photons in the return signal are checked for telltale signatures of entanglement, allowing photons from the noisy environmental background to be discarded. This can greatly improve the radar signal-to-noise in certain situations." Why do they need to be entangled? Aren't there other ways of checking if the photons coming back are the ones you sent?
- morcheeba 9y agoWe do that now with spread-spectrum and chirps - you correlate the signal sent with the return signal and you can pick out reflections below the noise threshold. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_compression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulse_compression I'm guessing that this might be more effective at very small returns, where the reflection is so small that it suffers from shot noise - the fact that the energy comes in discrete packets makes it hard to correlate. This is another way to verify that the photons received are the same ones sent out (and not background noise)
- IncRnd 9y agoThey check for entangled photons, as that lets them easily filter out noise inherent in all the other particles. It's really an idea not a complete system, needing a way to quickly entangle photons on-demand. Cool idea, definitely!, but not yet completed.
- mathw 9y agoPhotons with identical properties are indistinguishable from each other, so not really! You can get really picky about sending out only certain kinds of photon and filtering them when they come back, but you might have some of that kind of photon in the environment anyway, or the target might be capable of generating them to swamp detectors. What it can't do is generate photons which are entangled with another photon you already have, so it kind of cuts through all the incremental stuff you could otherwise do (and which has been done already). At least, that's how I understand the physics involved at a fairly superficial level. This sounds like it's a long way away from being useful though, that slight issue of not having an abundant source of entangled photons is a huge blocker.
- everdev 9y agoTLDR; University of Waterloo is investing $2.7M to speed up the process of photon entanglement. One photon will be beamed to the object and the radar response will be checked to see if it was an entangled photon that came back.
- throwaway84742 9y agoI thought stealth aircraft is already visible on the latest Russian gear. They just use different frequencies to see it. The problem now seems to be not in seeing the plane per se, but homing the missile on a low observability target. http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/americas-f-22-f-35-stealth-fighters-vs-russias-s-300-s-400-s-17394 http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/americas-f-22-f-35...
- wbl 9y agoLatest? L-band early warning has been around for ages. The problem is the range and angle accuracy is not enough to guide an interceptor for fundamental physical reasons: the angular resolution is proportional to frequency and antenna size, and the range resolution is proportional to bandwidth.
- gandhium 9y ago> I thought stealth aircraft is already visible on the latest Russian gear That's just a usual FUD stuff from Russians.
- throwaway84742 9y agoSure. That’s why our government pisses itself every time Russians try to export S400.
- burfog 9y agoAlways remember that stealth is not a boolean. The enemy is constrained by size, cost, power, and heat dissipation. What can be done on the ground is not the same as what can be done in a fighter plane, and that isn't the same as what can be done in a small-diameter missile, and that isn't the same as what can be done in an anti-aircraft shell. The enemy might be able to briefly detect at close range, reliably track at long range, or anything in between. Because of this, stealth is not simply defeated, and it does not suddenly become 100% useless.
- Steve44 9y ago> Always remember that stealth is not a boolean. And also it's not just about the technology in the design of the aircraft. It's a combined strategy such as knowing where the radar stations are and flying a path to minimise exposure. I remember seeing a visualisation of what ISTR was a stealth flightpath into Iraq giving an idea of how they maintained their extremely low visibility. I've just has a search but can't find it at the moment.
- msl 9y agoThe F-117 was retrofitted with the ability to fly a computer generated flight plan, which would not avoid radar sites but also adjust the plane's attitude in order to minimize the radar cross section. [1] [1] Skunk Works: A Personal Memoir of My Years at Lockheed by Ben R. Rich and Leo Janos (page 101 on my copy) The relevant Wikipedia article also mentions the system, but in less detail: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_F-117_Nighthawk#Avionics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_F-117_Nighthawk#Avion...
- mistercow 9y agoAre there interesting spinoff technologies that having an efficient entangled photon source would enable? My very spotty understanding makes me wonder if this could have an impact on quantum computing. It seems like an interesting question, since military funding is involved.
- krastanov 9y agoYes, so much so that I would not call it a spin-off, rather one of the main tasks that people building quantum computing hardware are dealing with. Entanglement is one of the main phenomena that permit quantum hardware to do things infeasible on classical hardware. In the context of communication it permits quantum key distribution, whose security depends only on quantum mechanics being a not-too-wrong description of nature (while classical schemes depend on less tested computational complexity conjectures). In the context of computing, it is an integral component of many of the "fault-tolerant error correcting" schemes, necessary in order to protect the extremely fragile qubits (similar to what ECC RAM does for classical computing). In the context of sensing, it does permit some cool unbelievably sensitive detectors (the case discussed in the article), but it is only one of the avenues of intense research.
- mistercow 9y agoDoes quantum computing require entanglement of more than two photons with each other? One of the reasons I could see this not actually advancing QC is if what's needed for quantum radar is easy generation of entangled pairs, while QC requires something more difficult.
- dschuetz 9y agoQuantum radar will expose quantum stealth of quantum aircraft. I'm getting quantum sick.
- krastanov 9y agoWhile it is true that quantum is used a lot as a buzzword, here it is used in its literal scientific sense. And it is an exciting technology that has taken a lot of effort to be created that does not deserve such knee-jerk derisiveness.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIt’s not at all clear this isn’t a buzzword boondoggle. RF photonics is barely even a thing, and no one is going to get much joy from more comfortably photonic frequencies operating in the Earth’s atmosphere. Besides, entangled states are very delicate and disappear after any environmental interaction. So I’m not entirely clear how you’re supposed to maintain an entangled state while bouncing photons off a large object.
- archgoon 9y agoI'd say that a technology that attempts to exploit entanglement can reasonably be called 'Quantum'. Now, whether the technology is feasible is a separate question from whether it is accurately named.
- dschuetz 9y ago"Quantum" is a science-y sounding word which sensationalist scientists use to push their otherwise inexplicable "exciting" ideas for fundraising. It's a joke in itself. A parody of what physics actually is. Even the actual scientist who formulated Quantum Electrodynamics didn't quite understand what quantum is and what to make of it, nor did he find a way to properly explain it. This term and the theories behind it were used just to explain some connections in phenomena, not to invent new ones! Quantum laser, quantum liquid, quantum crystals, quantum nose, quantum ass! There was a post here somewhere, discussing that science isn't exactly science anymore when it very closely resembles its own stereotype. A philosopher for example today isn't someone who actually thinks, but rather a person who writes non-sense papers just for the sake to be published in a major journal, because otherwise they can't find a job. So, it's not the scientists who publish science-y papers who deserve credit. I don't know who deserves any credit anymore. Academia makes me sick to my stomach.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoWhat really is horrible here is the asymmetry of cost- the development of stealth technology costed billions and took from drawinboard to reliable implemenetation close to half a century. And it seems that detection is always easier and cheaper. I wonder wether radar and quantum "noise"-bombs that basically spam the enemy detection methods would be a cheaper approach.
- TickleSteve 9y ago"quantum noise bombs"... this wont work as the photons that hit the receiver wont be entangled with the one you sent out... This makes it potentially un-jammable in that sense. Of course, overloading the receiver may be an attack worthy of investigating.
- jabl 9y ago> What really is horrible here is the asymmetry of cost That's the fate of most military technologies throughout history, why would stealth be different?
- tiredwired 9y agoSpam the enemy with thousands of drones.
- danbruc 9y agoWhich reminds me of a paper I once submitted to HN, »Gravimetric Radar: Gravity-Based Detection of a Moving Point-Mass« [1]. But I don't remember much about it, especially how far this was from being practical and not even how credible the paper looked. But given that I submitted it, I must at least once have thought that it is not total nonsense. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8369812 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8369812
- Steve44 9y agoGoing slight OT but related is the use of Gravity Anomaly Maps to aid submarine navigation. There are quite a few diverse papers about it but I think information about any real capabilities are largely under wraps.
- blauditore 9y agoLol, it's pretty ambitious to try tracking planes with gravitational effects. But now that gravitation wave detection works, I think there are plans (or at least ideas) to build such devices in earth or solar orbit for triangulation of distant objects like stars and black holes. Detection arms could be much longer and disruptions much lower than on earth, so results would me much more accurate.
- jcims 9y agoI did some noodling a while back to see if LIGO could detect the mass energy conversion of a fission 'event' in North Korea. If memory serves it was definitely within the range in terms of impact to the gravitational field, but correlating a infinitessimally short pop of noise would be much more difficult than the death waltz of binary black holes. However, a larger array of more sensitive detectors that are immune from the tremendous amount of terrestrial noise might make short work of it.
- StormChaser_5 9y agoWhy would an event in NK cause a change in gravity? Wouldn't the energy liberated in a nuclear event would cause the same amount of gravity to be felt elsewhere as the mass it came from?
- KaiserPro 9y agoStealth aircraft haven't been stealth for a while. The Serbians managed to destroy one F117a (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_F-117A_shootdown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_F-117A_shootdown) and damage another. This was because the Radar battery were using a different frequency. You don't need a direct hit with a missile, just be close enough when you explode it. Also, all the "shared battle information" is done via radio, which with passive radar will give wonderfully accurate positioning with cheap off the shelf hardware.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 9y agoI'd note that the Serbians kinda lucked out and got it when it was at its least stealthy: > According to Dani in a 2007 interview, his troops spotted the aircraft on radar when its bomb-bay doors opened, raising its radar signature.
- greedo 9y agoNot really. The opsec was poor; the aircraft had been using the same ingress/egress routes, so the SAM batteries knew where to look. That helps tremendously. Also, the F-117 has to open it's bomb bay to release its weapon. When it does so, it increases it's radar return dramatically, if only for a very short period of time. This helped the Serbians a lot. And passive radar isn't a thing. There's passive radio sensors, that can theoretically detect a transmitter, but frequency hopping etc make that tough.
- KaiserPro 9y agoPassive radar is a thing, because I use it. it works by using known radio sources (ie tv transmitters) which has the advantage of being powerful , continuous and reasonably unique signal pattern (for timing) radio sniffing is where you listen for the aircraft directly, and there are a number of offerings on that front too. Phased array antenna with SDR front ends, are smashing bits of kit. now frequency hopping spread spectrum means you need more DSP to find the signal, but its still there. In fact it provides nice timing signals because they hop frequency so much. There is more, but thats for another time In theory the frequency hopping can be random, but that requires a shared random source, which is hard to sync.
- jk2323 9y agoAn opinionated post about another quantum radar: Chinese "quantum radar" is a thing that cannot exist https://motls.blogspot.com/2017/03/chinese-quantum-radar-is-thing-that.html https://motls.blogspot.com/2017/03/chinese-quantum-radar-is-...
- andrewflnr 9y agoI think that guy has gone too far in pushing against quantum woo. Also, I'm not aware of any actual science that forbids closed time like curves, either; AFAIK they're allowed by GR and anything that rules them out is strictly speculative.
- sbisson 9y agoBack when I worked on skywave HF OTHR systems in the late 80s we knew that they could detect and pinpoint stealth aircraft easily. Most stealth systems are designed to either absorb or reflect millimetric point source radar. HF long wavelength systems reflect nicely off the top surfaces of the aircraft, which aren't designed to dissipate and absorb those frequencies. To one of those systems a stealth aircraft shows up brighter than a 747... So while this is neat science, it's not economical compared to the systems currently in use. The only real downside of OTHR systems is that you need a couple of miles space for the transmit antenna and a big empty space for the receiver; plus plenty of CPU to process the data.
- arthurz 9y agoI am quite offended by how the news provider phys.org reacts to me using an ad blocker: "It appears that you are currently using Ad Blocking software. What are the consequences? Click here to learn more." -> Will never ever click