15 ms·
My startup was approached by a corporate VC that wanted to make a strategic investment. Based on the attendee list from our meeting, which included very high up
by gnicholas 9y ago
My startup was approached by a corporate VC that wanted to make a strategic investment. Based on the attendee list from our meeting, which included very high up folks from the company, I felt good going in. They expressed interest in our technology that makes reading on screen easier [1], but they were surprised to learn that we didn't use machine learning to accomplish this.
I indicated that it was actually quite effective without ML, and that it was easier to explain to users this way. They kept prodding around on the ML stuff, and how we might be able to use ML to accomplish roughly the same thing.
A week later they said that they were no longer interested because, although they liked what our tech was able to accomplish, it didn't fit with their investment thesis — which was all about ML.
My wife asked me why I didn't just make some stuff up and say we could do v2 using ML. Perhaps she was right.
1: http://www.beelinereader.com/individual http://www.beelinereader.com/individual
update: in response to feedback below, I edited the link to point to a page with relevant content instead of our generic landing page. Lesson learned!
- Someone 9y agoIf your code has even a single magical constant (I guess it likely has, if only because your code has to figure out whether a period is sentence-ending), you can and, now that it is cheap and easy, probably should use machine learning (a moniker that includes such algorithms as gradient descent) to optimize that constant. Also, if you ever have considered two code variants where one is a bit better in situation A and the other in situation B, you can use machine learning to combine the two methods, (e.g. using a random forest (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Random_forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Random_forest)
- guy98238710 9y agoYou don't need AI to find values for free parameters. Unless you consider all of statistics to be a subfield of AI.
- disgruntledphd2 9y agoI personally consider all of modern AI (i.e. statistical pattern matching) to be a subfield of statistics. Mind you, I'm probably just a grumpy old man.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoNo, you're being fairly accurate.
- halflings 9y agoWhy use the term "AI" when the GP specifically used the less ambiguous Machine Learning? Machine Learning = statistics + linear algebra + computer science, mostly. Naive Bayes and Graphical Models are pure statistics, but they are mostly used for toy problems. Machine Learning scales these approaches to high dimensionality problems, and tasks where data is abundant.
- gaius 9y agoIf someone had something as basic as logistic regression or k-means clustering in a production app they are already ahead of the vast majority of ML practitioners
- peatmoss 9y agoGods, maybe I should stop telling people that I don’t have much in the way of a machine learning background.
- nkozyra 9y ago> Naive Bayes and Graphical Models are pure statistics, but they are mostly used for toy problems. I think they just feel "toy" because they've been used with great accuracy for so long. Complex problems are rarely solved by a single approach. The harder the problem the more likely a suite will be used, and often naive bayes will be part of that in some capacity.
- db1 9y agoI went to your website, and I can't figure out what your product is or does. I had to click in to individuals before I figured out what it does. Why not put "BeeLine Reader makes reading on-screen easier, faster, and more enjoyable. We use a simple cognitive trick — an eye-guiding color gradient — to pull your eyes from one line to the next." on your front page? Maybe you guys have already done some kind of testing and found out that the current layout is optimal?
- tejasmanohar 9y agoAgree with db1's feedback. I almost immediately closed the page after not finding the pitch.
- gnicholas 9y agoAppreciate the feedback. We recently redesigned the website to offer silos, and one of the goals was to make the landing page not offer too many specifics that would make some audiences bounce. But perhaps your suggestion is just what we need to do. Thanks for taking the time to share! One lesson learned: I should have linked to the /individual page instead of the generic landing page in my comment. Updating link now...
- azernik 9y agoIt's good to keep market-specific language to market-specific silos, but you need to put some little (milquetoast, plain-info) bit up front. Otherwise you turn off every market.
- gnicholas 9y agoTotally agree. Would you say that GP's suggested language is sufficiently plain? I would worry that it would turn off publishing partners, who want to hear things like "increase audience engagement" not "read easier". Maybe something generic like "improve focus while reading", which could appeal to individuals and publishing partners? Appreciate your taking the time to share feedback — this sort of stuff is not something we're skilled/experienced at.
- mindhash 9y agoThis seems pretty cool. I found a good difference reading your education product. It was easy on eyes. I read a lot of blogs. Thought you could add a wp plugin if it doesn't exist. Also you must have a ml/ai roadmap for tracking user interactions, etc for possibility of further personalization. Leaving aside the buzz of ai/ml, I think every business has opportunity to apply ml/ai. It doesn't happen often but when it does, its gold for any business
- gnicholas 9y agoIt's true, we could use AI or ML to do stuff not related to the core product. But these investors thought that we should be using ML in the coloring algorithm itself. Even if this made sense to do (that is, if it improved reading ability for people compared with our current product), it would be much harder to explain. Right now, it's easy to say it's a color gradient that wraps from one line to the next, guiding your eyes. I don't know how I insert "machine learning" into that sentence somewhere and not sound like I'm trying to trend-surf.
- vidarh 9y agoIf you can apply any kind of approach that automatically feeds measurements of user success back in to an algorithm to automatically adjust e.g. the colors used for the gradient based on measuring what works best, you can justify saying you're using machine learning. I think people are too often too quick to assume that machine learning necessarily implies deep learning and neural networks, when often it can reasonably be reduced to simple statistical approaches.
- xevb3k 9y agoCan someone explain the dynamic that’s going on here? I somehow can believe that VCs are so stupid to be purely hype driven, so what is pushing them to make this their investment focus? Do they just jump on every bandwagon in the hope that one of them might pan out?
- manigandham 9y agoYes, due diligence is rare. This is portfolio theory in action, investing in many losing bets because the 1% will win big and create the returns. Disqualify the easy "no", then everything else is a "maybe". Invest and move on.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- azernik 9y agoThey put a lot of study into hyped categories, so they at least understand the businesses they're investing in. They can evaluate the caliber of talent, understand the depth of your moat, etc. Whereas with businesses outside of the hype (or outside of their specific specialty) they're not confident in their ability to even evaluate the potential of an investment. (I'm working on a startup right now that's in a similar position - non-hyped B2B segment. VCs are all "hey, look, we don't understand X market very well, maybe go to Y VC?" And Y VC is all "hmm, you're only tangentially related to Z market that we actually understand, so you'll need to get to Series A-sized revenues before we'll put in a seed-size investment.")
- joewee 9y agoVCs raise money the same way startups do, only with more regulation. For that bucket of money they likely presented a thesis for how they would used to invest in the ML/AI wave. Investors have rights if the money isn’t used they way they were told it would be. VCs raise money from fund managers (sovereign wealth funds for example) who also present a thesis to their stakeholders for how the money will be managed. Depends on the timing but I think VC focus on ML is a good indicator of where smart money thinks the money is going to be made. But there are a lot of people that catch a trend in the tail in, I don’t think we’ve gotten anywhere close to that for ML investments.
- azernik 9y agoAwesome product! Been using it for a bit, and does indeed help. Just a quick bug report - it does the wrong thing on right-to-left text. e.g. on this article [1], it highlights the beginning (right side) of one line and the end (left side) of the next line in the same color, which doesn't actually reflect the flow of reading. There's also a weird effect on LTR text embedded in the RTL (on my setup, the "a" in "axios" on the third line of the body is bright red, while the rest is complete black). EDIT: [1]http://www.maariv.co.il/news/world/Article-633899 http://www.maariv.co.il/news/world/Article-633899
- gnicholas 9y agoCan you share the link? I thought we fixed the right-to-left issue a long time ago. Feel free to share screenshots or more info with contact@[domain].
- azernik 9y agoAh! Sorry, forgot to paste the link in. It's here: http://www.maariv.co.il/news/world/Article-633899 http://www.maariv.co.il/news/world/Article-633899 Sending a screenshot by e-mail now.
- parmesan 9y agoWow this is amazing! I don't understand the VCs input about ML, why and how would it help in this use case?
- gnicholas 9y agoI think they wanted us to do something with NLP and ML, to make it syntactically-based. I happen to have studied linguistics and know how complex this would be — and of course it would have to be custom-built for every language. The current version, which just uses line position, works fine and is language-independent. Another explanation: they didn't actually know how they wanted us to us ML — they just knew they wanted us to use it.
- nl 9y agoI do ML/NLP, and recently have been doing color related things. I think you are underestimating how useful NLP could be in your application. I tried out one of your test cases, and I did find it useful. However, I think that blending colors based on entity recognition along with your line based system could focus attention on important parts. Have a look at [1] (sorry for the long URL) and imagine the colors blending with yours, so entities were slightly brighter than the rest of the text. [1] https://explosion.ai/demos/displacy-ent?text=John%20Fitzgerald%20Kennedy%20was%20born%20in%20Brookline%2C%20Massachusetts%20on%20May%2029%2C%201917.%20He%20was%20the%20second%20son%20of%20Joseph%20P.%20Kennedy%2C%20Sr.%2C%20and%20Rose%20Fitzgerald.%20Rose%20was%20the%20eldest%20child%20of%20John%20Fitzgerald%2C%20a%20prominent%20Boston%20political%20figure%20who%20was%20the%20city%27s%20mayor%20and%20a%20three-term%20member%20of%20Congress.%20Kennedy%27s%20ancestry%20was%20predominantly%20Irish%2C%20and%20all%20eight%20of%20his%20great-grandparents%20had%20immigrated%20from%20Ireland.%20Kennedy%20lived%20in%20Brookline%20for%20ten%20years.%20In%201927%2C%20the%20family%20moved%20to%20New%20York%20City.%20In%20the%20summertime%2C%20Kennedy%20and%20his%20family%20visited%20their%20home%20in%20Hyannisport%2C%20Massachusetts.%20At%20Christmas%20and%20Easter%20holidays%20they%20went%20to%20their%20winter%20home%20in%20Palm%20Beach%2C%20Florida.&model=en_core_web_sm&ents=person%2Corg%2Cgpe%2Cloc%2Cproduct%2Cnorp%2Cdate%2Cper%2Cmisc https://explosion.ai/demos/displacy-ent?text=John%20Fitzgera...
- nefitty 9y agoThank you for your work on Beeline. I've been using it for several months and it definitely helps when diving into large Wikipedia articles, research papers, blog posts, etc. I found that it facilitates my reaching flow quickly when investigating large problems.
- gnicholas 9y agoI'm curious to know where you heard about BeeLine a few months ago. We haven't had press in a long time, and most HNers who know about us found out from our Show HN way back in 2013.
- nefitty 9y agoI tried to track down what it was, and I think I stumbled across the name while looking at the ReadMe! Android app. It was pay to use, but I was eager to try it. Thankfully I found your /pasteboard tool and it helped me dominate wiki articles, whitepapers, research papers, etc. I was sold because of the pasteboard and moved to paying for the desktop chrome extension
- payasr 9y agoI have been playing around with the reader, and it doesn't seem to play well with mathjax-enabled pages.. Is it a known issue?
- gnicholas 9y agoNot before now — thanks for flagging! A couple questions: what do you mean by not play well? Does it undercolor (not color the text you want to have colored), overcolor (accidentally color text that should not be colored), or something else? Thanks for sharing this feedback. As another HNer pointed out via email, we need to have a contact/help link in the Settings panel so that we can gather more feedback like this.
- payasr 9y agoThe coloring is correct, but the chrome extension 'undoes' the equations rendered on the mathjax-enabled pages. In other words, without the beelinereader extension I can see the equations, with it I see only the latex source code. You should be able to check this on any Springer article.
- gnicholas 9y agoOK thanks for describing this in more detail. Sounds like we just need to skip these nodes when coloring. Look out for an update in the next month or so, and in the meantime perhaps you can blacklist auto-run (via Settings) on the Springer domain.
- brod 9y agoI posted that link in slack and it's twitter:* meta content is really strange: Parade of Fans for Houston’s Funeral NEWARK - The guest list and parade of limousines with celebrities emerging from them seemed more suited to a red carpet event in Hollywood or New York than than a gritty stretch of Sussex Avenue near the former site of the James M. Baxter Terrace public housing project here. I found an example [1] with the same content so I guess you just haven't updated it. 1: https://gist.github.com/blairanderson/85cc961295fd03a6c4b3 https://gist.github.com/blairanderson/85cc961295fd03a6c4b3
- gnicholas 9y agoWow, how embarrassing. Thanks for pointing this out. I have no idea how we didn't catch it sooner.
- bytesandbots 9y agoOn a related note, the link to twitter:image is also on wrong domain.
- fny 9y agoGreat product idea! I'm glad people find it useful. Hypotheses: > corporate VC that wanted to make a strategic investment They want to put money in your company to make sure they don't have to compete with you or compete with someone else who might buy you down the line. > They kept prodding around on the ML stuff, and how we might be able to use ML to accomplish roughly the same thing. They're looking for secret sauce, barriers, friction. Something patentable. Something to keep others out and keep them ahead. Perhaps something that they don't think they can do themselves or maybe rip off when they realize it's useful. Remember Flux?[0] They're investment thesis makes sense from this perspective: they're thinking like classic, amoral businesses. Also note that if your product is simple and popular enough, people will likely make free clones. You'll need to be a good steward to keep your value. Best of luck! ---- A bit of feedback: you need to be more transparent and up front about what how and why you're using analytics, and let people opt-in. I was a bit disconcerted to see you using Google Analytics in your extension without informing me. [0]: https://justgetflux.com/news/2016/01/14/apple.html https://justgetflux.com/news/2016/01/14/apple.html
- gnicholas 9y agoAppreciate the feedback! Regarding analytics, I think this is some A/B testing, which I don't think is even active in the current version (though still in the sources). More importantly, we don't tie GA or any other usage analytics to individual users. We basically just use it to see where the extension is used and where people are blacklisting sites. We use this data to make the extension run better on more sites. We don't monetize user data in any way. You're right that we should make this point more salient. In our Privacy Policy, we do describe how to opt out by blocking GA, but we should put this somewhere more prominent. Thanks for the feedback!
- asfdsfggtfd 9y ago> we don't tie GA or any other usage analytics to individual users You may not identify individual users but Google probably do... > we should put this somewhere more prominent You should make it opt in by default. Or stop doing it!
- gadders 9y agoFirst time I've heard of it, but that app is actually pretty cool. I can feel it dragging my eyeballs RTL :-)
- bayesian_horse 9y agoWell, they probably want engineers with ML experience, and companies who already have a foot in that door when an opportunity arises for an actual profit maker. You may have pitched a perfectly fine product to somebody in the market for a perfectly fine acquihire.
- coldtea 9y ago>I indicated that it was actually quite effective without ML, and that it was easier to explain to users this way. They kept prodding around on the ML stuff, and how we might be able to use ML to accomplish roughly the same thing. Just call what you do ML. IBM, for one, never shied from calling any old BS "AI" and branding it Watson.
- JepZ 9y agoThat is just how larger corporations work. They probably decided they wanted to be part of that future market about AI and therefore want to invest in AI/ML startups. Someone sold your company internally as being a nice fit for the AI portfolio, but when you answered the question about ML with "No" the door was shut. From someone who makes large trade deals as his daily business, I learned "Never say 'No'" (during a negotiation). In most cases, it is better to be diplomatic. So might have been better off with something like: 'So far we had decent results without ML, but we are constantly evaluating options to improve our technology, which includes optimizations based on machine learning.' That way, some might hear '[...] includes optimizations based on machine learning.', while you just said 'we do not use machine learning' ;-)
- adriand 9y agoYou should never mislead a potential investor. Why would you want an investor who is misaligned with your core technology/strategic direction?
- Traubenfuchs 9y ago$$$
- JepZ 9y agoWell, nobody wants a misaligned investor. But I had the impression the negotiations already failed, because one buzzword could not be satisfied. My comment was meant more as advice to overcome such problematic situations during negotiations, than to mislead someone about what you are actually doing.
- carlmr 9y agoI remember every dishwasher and washing machine had "fuzzy logic" in the 90s (at least according to stickers). Just because it was the AI/ML/Deep Learning/Big Data/IoT of the time. No, fuzzy logic won't make your washing machine better. Yes, you can implement some stuff in fuzzy logic.
- arghwhat 9y agoYou should definitely have made something up. Up front, many investors only seek buzzwords before they shift focus to numbers. Be a sales(wo)man, and feed them the ones they want. Later on, once you end up making them money, they're not going to care much about what technologies are involved. I wish you the best of luck with your startup in the future. (P.S. I had a FOUC on your webpage. The icons in the "want more" section were missing, and haphazardly popping in. Might want to fix that.)
- qbaqbaqba 9y agoSeizure/Nausea warning!
- duckqlz 9y agoIs there a white paper or a clinical study to back up the claims on bee reader? I have read numerous studies claiming the exact opposite especially on a light projecting surface. I personally found the colour changing on each line to be extremely distracting and straining on my eyes. Furthermore, this seems like a bad joke for someone who is colour blind. Finally, VCs asking for ML are really asking how your technology fits in to the general future. With a script that reads line length and changes text between 3 colours, let’s be honest, I could have made beeReader when I was 10. Perhaps the VCs were initially wow’d by how profound you believed your product to be but then were underwhelmed by the tech (I’m guessing that’s why the individual page is burried). And if any publishers are in talks with you about using this in printed media (welcome to imaginary land) just keep nodding to what ever they say take their money and run.
- gnicholas 9y agoYep, there have been several studies done, ranging from media to education to optometric. • CNET found that readers were 35% more likely to finish reading an article if they were reading with BeeLine turned on. See more on the CNET study in this article in The Atlantic [1]. • An optometric study using eye-tracking glasses found that BeeLine reduced the number of regressions and/or skipped lines for the vast majority of participants. • Various educator-led studies (some more rigorous than others, and none as informal as the "case studies" that are unfortunately common in edtech) have found strong gains in reading fluency and/or comprehension. I totally appreciate your skepticism, which is especially reasonable for someone who does not personally see a benefit from the tech. The response from doctors who work in vision has been very positive, and our tools are recommended by doctors at Stanford Med School and UC Berkeley School of Optometry. We even got featured by the American Optometric Association. The AOA committee that evaluated our technology said that this was the first time they'd ever had a unanimous vote in favor of anything. Apparently to them, it was quite obvious that this has beneficial effects (without having run any formal studies on it themselves). To your point about colorblindness, I would note that I regularly come across people with red/green colorblindness who love/use our product. You can change the colors to be whatever you want, or use it in grayscale. We are talking with publishers, but mostly on the digital side. Thanks for the input and questions! 1: http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/05/a-better-way-to-read/482127/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/05/a-bett...
- mort96 9y agoSo, I went to the page, clicked the button for the Firefox extension, and was greeted with this page: https://s.mort.coffee/d/img/scr-4494758.png https://s.mort.coffee/d/img/scr-4494758.png You should probably link to the add-on page (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/beelinereader/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/beelinereader...) instead of directly to the .xpi file. I would never accept to install a plug-in from a random link even if it hadn't been for the dialog's scary language.
- gnicholas 9y agoThanks for the feedback. We tried to make it as easy as possible, but I can see that it comes across as more legit if the install comes from the Firefox Store, which requires vetting.
- wlesieutre 9y agoJust rename your company BeeLine Reader Blockchain and you'll be fine.
- zhte415 9y agoGeneral comment on colour highlighting - I read the updated /individual page and found it very... difficult. The colours led me to speed up and slow down at an uncomfortable rate, to the extent I had to re-read it three times. I typically receive 200-1000 emails per day which all need to be read (yay!) plus at least 30k words per day out of email (business stuff but excluding newspapers, books, etc). I speed-read about 6-10 words per flick of the eyes (for a short document), which is about 50 words per second. Do slow down to ponder: careful phrasing, a needingly precise written document, some graphics, and this is not for detriment. I found the colour-coding very difficult, however.
- qwerty456127 9y agoWow! Would you mind sharing some practical advice on how to actually train to read this fast?
- zhte415 9y agoAfter writing this, I realise you may need to speed read it! My first company provided a speed reading training course for the best part of a day. It wasn't the best targeted course for most people there. We mainly read legal and policy documents which by their nature are terse, and the method of speed reading taught traded-off retention against speed against accuracy. It was more of a concept, which you can go off with an develop yourself. So here's the idea - 1. Start with a text that is quite verbose but not overly so. A code specification or Brett Easton Ellis novel is a no. A light news article should be fine or non-technical book should be fine. 2. Recognise that when you read, you don't read a word from letter start to finish, you basically look in the middle of it and the word is recognised. If you have dyslexia, this technically probably doesn't work; but if you have dyslexia, you've probably invested countless painful hours to something a lot of us take for granted and hats off to that. You might not notice, but you probably read multiple-words at a time already. Commonly paired words are often read together, like 'a few'. YMMV. Harness that. 3. Mentally split a page of text into narrow columns, perhaps the width of 2 medium length words. Flick your eyes across a line of text. Only focus on the middle of the mental column and absorb the words, like a snapshot (no need to blink). This is where accuracy starts to degrade. If the text consists of obscure words or lots of figures, accuracy can hurt at the start. Grammar patterns are important too - as long as the text is written by a native or very close near native speaker, anticipation and auto-ordering in this mini-snapshot can be hard or impossible; likewise unfamiliar or complex sentence structures from a native speaker. 4. Now, start to speed up over a paragraph. This is where retention starts to hurt. You certainly don't want to be wording-out words, as this will slow you down and defeat the purpose. But when you've read a block of text, have you been able to follow the meaning at the end. Again, using well written, non-overly terse training text is important. 5. You should be tired by now, having done this for several hours. Our trainer then suggested changing the 'snapshot' from one line, to two lines, so you're essentially reading the start of the second line before finishing the end of the first line. I can do this but your text needs to be super non-terse for this to work at the start, and even then it's weird. If you can cover a single line pretty fast in less than a second certainly, then this starts to become feasible. tl;dr Went on a training course. Was pessimistic as were my colleagues at the start. Persisted afterwards by trying a few minutes per day. Became a habit, especially when seeing articles or documents that I needed to read but didn't need to scrutinise. Important to choose the right tool for the right job. I'd not use this technique to read a document where I'm not familiar with the content-scope; I wouldn't use this technique to read a contract I'm signing, or where specifications/requirements are being very clearly outlined. I do use it to read things like bloomberg.com articles, or PMBOK Guide :) Hope a little useful, and the above can set you on some kind of direction to learn more. I highly recommend a half-day instructor-led course to kick you off. I imagine there's a college near you which has something.
- matchagaucho 9y agoOften times the output of ML/AI will result in writing code for an expert system. The system doesn't actually use ML or AI in realtime. ML just validates the correct conditionals and decisions are used in the software. Most ML models can be distilled down using the Pareto principle anyway, and the 80/20 rule written into the code. A politically correct and high-integrity story to tell investors might be "We use machine learning regression analysis to validate our expert systems are operating on optimal statistical models."
- sixhobbits 9y agoI did your test. Interesting idea. Feedback: I got "It looks like BeeLine didn’t improve your reading speed this time through." which I think needs another pass from your copy editors. Interesting idea overall. I've been using spritz a lot recently and I'm liking it more and more though it doesn't seem to have progressed from when I discovered it a few years ago. Re the investors blindly wanting ML - we have this problem too (and it's definitely a problem - I can see this in spite of having a masters in ML). On the bright side, some investors - often the better ones - have said things like "I was interested the moment you didn't use ML or blockchain in your pitch", so stay true to your vision :)
- vivekd 9y agoWhy would anyone think you need ML or AI to make letters on a page fit a color gradient. Are these investors crazy? I can't even think of an application for that technology in bee line reader.