17 ms·
The ‘Terms and Conditions’ Reckoning Is Coming
- bobm_kite9 9y agoWhat I want is a standardized set of icons, which grant or deny specific things, that all websites can agree on, sort of like the ones available for software licensing, here: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ It would be great if we could "standardize away" the whole T&C fiasco.
- ape4 9y agoIcons are good. But would be even better if they were switches the user can turn off/on.
- lev99 9y agoThat sounds like a GPL loophole to me. It would be much easier to extend and replace if someone could turn off the condition " You must cause any work that you distribute or publish, that in whole or in part contains or is derived from the Program or any part thereof, to be licensed as a whole at no charge to all third parties under the terms of this License." [0] I'm all for making these easier to read, but they shouldn't be line-item veto. [0]http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-2.0.html http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-2.0.html
- ape4 9y agoI agree you should not be able to change a software license but if Facebook had an icon for each thing they did like: [share with 3rd party] [sell your info] ...
- waynecochran 9y agoWould that hold up in court? An icon?
- haZard_OS 9y agoLike many things, it depends. As long as one can demonstrate that the icon in question has a clear meaning to a "reasonable person" or "typical user", then use of the icon would likely hold up in court.
- grabeh 9y agoYou're in luck at least when it comes to privacy in the EU! The GDPR makes various references to the creation and use of standardised icons to give a meaningful overview of the intended data processing. I know, I know, another GDPR reference but I thought it was interesting to note that a piece of regulation is pushing implement precisely what you were talking about, albeit in the field of privacy.
- mmcconnell1618 9y agoWe have standardized nutritional labels in the United States and I would like to see a similar standard for terms and conditions. Icons could be part of it but also leave room for text and listing of what common data (email, ip, name, etc.) the service will collect and how they will use it.
- kenning 9y agoThis is a great idea
- alex_young 9y agoHow can PayPal rationalize closing accounts because users opened them years ago when they were too young? Is that really an issue for a 28 year old? Contract or no, PayPal looks really bad here. One would think they would be looking for good will rather than this kind of press in such a competitive market.
- jschwartzi 9y agoYeah, why wouldn't they just contact her and lock her account until she re-signs? That way they both win. She's clearly of legal age now and penalizing her so severely for something she did as a child is really unnecessary. When my landlord discovered she didn't have a rental agreement on file for the garage space I was renting from her she didn't evict me, she left a note on my door.
- jstarfish 9y agoThere are financial incentives. Paypal is a lot like shady ad networks in that they let you accrue a balance while waiting for you to do something they can justify terminating you for. When that happens, they lock you out and keep your money. Unlike your landlord, Paypal profits from eviction.
- ams6110 9y agoBecause they have an ass-covering-oriented legal team who will say "the user was unable to legally agree to the terms" thefore we (PayPal) will be vulnerable if they were to do something fraudulent.
- jve 9y agoWhy not ask accepting terms NOW or else account will be blocked on m/d/y?
- haZard_OS 9y agoLikely they didn't do this because of concern that a person could update their agreement to the T&C, then do something fraudulent, then claim the updated agreement was coerced because the person's livelihood was somehow attached to the PayPal account.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 9y ago> If a typical user wouldn’t understand the [user agreement documents], the consent that companies rely on for their business activities would be legally invalid. I’ve not had time to read the GDPR, so this is news to me.* Especially surprising, because it’s exactly what I want the law to say, and I’m not used to that. I’d also like that principle to apply to the law as a whole, but I appreciate that’s as much wishful thinking as hoping to read and understand the full source-code of everything on my phone. * fortunately not my problem, family matters replaced the day job.
- SketchySeaBeast 9y agoIf agreement for a contract requires easily understood English, what does that mean for my mortgage?
- chrisBob 9y agoI don't typically have my lawyer review the TOS of each website I sign up for, but I did have him review my mortgage. Everyone picks a different place to draw the line between careful understanding (or hiring out a review from someone with careful understanding), and just blindly signing on the dotted line. For me that is somewhere between purchasing a tractor and purchasing a house. The point is the no sane person includes Netflix in the "needs careful review" category, but I sincerely recommend that everyone take their home purchases seriously.
- howard941 9y agoCurious if you tried to change any of the boilerplate terms and if you did, how did it work out?
- ben_w 9y agoA friend of a friend changed the “we will send you advertising” into “we will not send you advertising”, then when the bank sent them advertising anyway they demonstrated that the bank manager had signed the changed document and therefore the bank was in breach of the mortgage contract and technically they could keep the house without paying for it. For whatever reason, they then said it would be fine if the bank never sent them more advertising rather than actually trying to get a free house. For a slightly more reliable story, Argakov v Tinkoff seems fun. At least the first round, the reports I’ve seen are a bit dated and further escalation and retaliation may be less fun.
- jgh 9y agoWhy is obfuscating the intentions of a document in dense language most people can't properly understand a thing that's allowed to be upheld? They might as well write the damn things in Esperanto for all they're worth to most of the folks who click agree.
- ams6110 9y agoI can only think it must be analagous to why programs have a lot of features people don't understand or use. Git might be a case in point. Smart programmers think of every possible edge case and "what if" and try to cover all those things. The result is a confusing mess for people who just want to get the "happy path" work done. Lawyers try to think of every interpretation and circumstance and try to be sure the agreement addresses those unambiguously. Ironically, the dense language that results is anything but unambiguous to the untrained reader.
- haZard_OS 9y agoMildly pedantic complaint: Esperanto is actually easier to learn than many other languages so the analogy doesn't work. But I get what you mean.
- igammarays 9y agoJust like an underage person or drunk is unable to give consent, it should be illegal to coerce an average Joe untrained in the law to agree to a 50-page document filled with legalese, unless you pay for them to be advised by a lawyer.
- liberte82 9y agoWhen exactly did it enter the public consciousness that drunk people are unable to give consent? I feel if this is true, there are many drunken hookups that become questionable. I'm in my mid-30s, and I feel this concept wasn't really a thing in my clubbing days.
- ams6110 9y agoObama's 2011 Title IX "Dear Colleague" letter was a big part of it, establishing the lowest standard of proof in claims of sexual assault on college campuses. Schools responded by saying, effectively, that if you have sex with someone who's had a drink, and that person later regrets it, regardless of what they might have told you at the time, you have no defense. It's all ridiculous because universities have no competence in investigating or adjudicating such claims, but that's another topic. So anyone who was in college in the past 10 years will have had drummed into their heads that there is no consent possible by an intoxicated person.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> So anyone who was in college in the past 10 years will have had drummed into their heads that there is no consent possible by an intoxicated person. Which creates all kinds of weird outcomes when both parties were equally drunk.
- haZard_OS 9y agoWell, it would if logic were the overarching guideline on these topics. As it stands, the male is presumed guilty on college campuses when both parties are drunk and he must then meet a draconian burden of proof to extricate himself from the situation. At least, that has been my experience.
- ams6110 9y ago> If a typical user wouldn’t understand the documents, the consent that companies rely on for their business activities would be legally invalid. I like that standard, seems to comport to the "meeting of the minds" requirement for a valid legal agreement/contract.
- dvdhnt 9y agoI totally agree. The terms and conditions, or some offering of them, should be available in the same way that quick start or full guides are - in a form that adds to the usability of the service. E.g. "when you upload a photo, ____ owns the photo, for _____ period, and may do a, b, c, and d with it"
- amarkov 9y agoThe problem is that legal terminology doesn't always match conventional descriptions of what's happening. Copyright is actually a perfect example of this. In order to send my photo over the Internet to other people who want to view it, you need much more than the legal right to display my picture. Sending a picture over the Internet involves copying, distributing, and sublicensing the image countless numbers of times. So any site with user-uploaded content will have something very close to (Imgur's for reference): > With regard to any file or content you upload to the public portions of our site, you grant Imgur a non-exclusive, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable worldwide license (with sublicense and assignment rights) to use, to display online and in any present or future media, to create derivative works of, to allow downloads of, and/or distribute any such file or content. There's no way the typical user will understand this, but that's not because it's obfuscated. The typical user just doesn't have the background to understand what all these rights are or why Imgur requires them. It would be severely misleading to write the literal meaning in layperson's terms: > When you upload pictures, you have to give us the right to make as many copies of the pictures as we want, modify them however we'd like, and send those copies to whoever we want anywhere in the world.
- grabeh 9y agoI'm sorry, I don't follow why the plain English version is severely misleading, or couldn't be supplemented to capture the full extent of Imgur legalese. Why do you think this is the case?
- dyladan 9y ago>”I don’t think the average person likely reads that whole document.” This is my favorite quote in the whole article. Sums up the pompousness of the company quite nicely I think. This is one of the largest companies in the world. The quote could easily have been “we go to great lengths to make sure that’s the case,” or “that’s the point, grandpa.” At least it wouldn’t have come across as dishonest and cowardly that way.
- jve 9y agoThat is actually quite honest. Do you read temrs for all services? Or do you read terms at least for most important services? If you do, great. Many don't and just complain or are surprised when they learn what almost every service on the web does with his data.
- aesh2Xa1 9y agoOP is saying that it is actually the intent of the company that the end user does not read the ToS; it's an accusation that the quote demonstrates deceptive intent and therefore not honest in a way you haven't considered (in your response).
- heymijo 9y agoI assume Facebook has data showing how long each user stays on the T&C page before consenting or not. I wouldn't be shy to conjecture that time elapsed before consenting is a very small fraction of the time it would take an average reader to get through, let alone comprehend the terms and conditions.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoThere is one thing I'm curious about. Imagine Facebook's terms stated: "We will scrape any and all information we possibly can from you. We will use it in any and all ways we see fit. You agree to never sue us for anything whatsoever. We also have the right to do whatever we want to your account for any reason we want. We can also add or remove anything from these terms at any time and for any reason we like without telling you, and with immediate effect." That is probably a fairly reasonable cliff notes of their actual terms. Would this actually deter anybody from using their software? In other words, are companies piling on the legalese to protect themselves or to deceive users? Maybe I'm overly cynical but I think even those terms would not really stop any meaningful number of people from signing up.
- komali2 9y ago>Martin Garner, an analyst at technology consultancy CCS Insight, suggests companies walk readers through their policies step by step. That way they could opt out of selected provisions—limiting, for instance, third parties that can gain access to the data or restricting the kinds of information companies may stockpile. Merging t&c with settings... I like this idea a lot. Privacy controls with the agreement right there. You and the website clear on exactly what the relationship is. Gonna bring this up during checkin today.
- gizmo385 9y ago> That way they could opt out of selected provisions—limiting, for instance, third parties that can gain access to the data or restricting the kinds of information companies may stockpile. Am I understanding this incorrectly or are you suggesting that we allow people to selectively opt-out of portions of a T&C document? Because good luck getting any legal department to buy into that whatsoever.
- komali2 9y agoMore like, it would look like this: 1. You agree to allow us to share your email address with 3rd parties (have useful targeted advertisements? y/n) 2. You agree to allow us to parse your messages internally (enable auto-reply suggestions in messages? y/n) Something like that. I mean I think there would still be "hard-coded" T&C, "standing order" type things you agree to just by using the app at all. Like, not uploading goreporn or something.
- PeterisP 9y agoOf course company legal departments won't do that on their own initiative, however, they will help arrange that in a sane manner if the legislature forces them to do so. The GDPR requirement is that companies will have to allow people to selectively opt-in to the portions of currently typical T&C documents which currently say that the user allows you to use their data for various purposes, or these portions will automatically be considered null and void. This is already now implemented in a bunch of places - e.g. I got a mobile internet contract recently which involved being asked a bunch of questions about what private data uses I'd be okay with or not, and that resulted in customized/removed/added paragraphs in the agreement that I signed; but the other companies have still about a month until GDPR requires everyone here to do so or stop using people's data.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoDisclaimer: I hate complex / abusive T&C's, and I'm keen to see them abolished. But... It seems to me like we as a public are blaming corporations for our failures. As adults we're responsible for what contracts we enter into, except in cases of coercion. 99% of us were stupid enough to state that we accepted terms that we didn't even read. Especially in cases where the product/service was purely optional (Netflix, Call of Duty, etc.), I don't see how this is anything but our fault. IMO, we have not been acting as competent, responsible adults. Should we change our laws to make complex and/or abusive T&C's go away? Absolutely. But are corporate lawyers the only flawed agents here? IMO, no.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> 99% of us were stupid enough to state that we accepted terms that we didn't even read. I don't think that's fair. These things are written at a high reading level (worse than Beowulf: https://theconversation.com/googles-terms-and-conditions-are-less-readable-than-beowulf-19215 https://theconversation.com/googles-terms-and-conditions-are... ; https://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/unreadable-card-agreements-study.php https://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/unreadable-card... says credit cards require a reading level half the population lacks), with domain knowledge the vast majority of us lack. Reading them is pointless - even with a college education we don't have the information needed to detect many legal traps laid in these things. They're also extremely lengthy, and generally "subject to change at any time without notice".
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoI agree with your points about the incomprehensibility and onerous terms of such agreements. And in cases of coercion or semi-coercion (e.g., it can be hard to get a job without owning a cell phone), I can understand accepting the T&C's despite those problems. That's why I'm limiting my argument to other situations such as Netflix and video games. For those situations, I'm arguing that adults should accept full responsibility for choosing to accept those horrible T&C's.
- deleted 9y ago
- dawnerd 9y agoOne thing I’d like to see outlawed is forced arbitration. Waiving someone’s right to a lawsuit is just wrong and only serves to benefit the company.
- Someone1234 9y agoWhat's even more odd, is that in some cases the company gets to select the arbitration company (and repeat business is based on outcomes).
- flother 9y agoThey're outlawed in some countries, notably in Europe. EU rules presume pre-dispute arbitration clauses in consumer contracts are invalid. France and Sweden completely prohibit consumer arbitration in certain cases. Germany won't enforce a consumer arbitration clause unless it's in a separate, signed document or part of a fully-notarised contract. Lots of information available at https://www.hausfeld.com/news-press/mandatory-arbitration-in-the-united-state-and-europe https://www.hausfeld.com/news-press/mandatory-arbitration-in....
- jkaplowitz 9y agoAs another example, Quebec has similar rules for consumer contract. They also forbid contracting for a different choice of law, and unless through a notarial act (in the civil law sense of notary rather than common law notaries public), also forbid stipulating a different domicile to avoid the jurisdiction of their local courts. Just like with your European example, none of this applies to business-to-business contracts.
- username223 9y agoI was amused to read recently that, thanks to having an ancient Yahoo! mail account, I am now subject to binding arbitration when I have a disagreement with a Yahoo! spinoff called "Oath." Also, I cannot participate in a class action or jury trial. That should work out well for me the next time they leak all of their user data.
- 9y ago
- cabaalis 9y agoIf I walk into a McDonald's, I wager that the social normality requirements and laws that permit my access there and permit the owner to legally throw me out is longer than the 50,000 words cited in the article. However, I fully understand enough of them that I'm able to transact the purchase of my hamburger and leave. All the rules there are in the owner's favor, and very few are in mine. I'm not trying to be reductionist, I understand the backlash, but there is no inherent right to use PayPal.
- protonfish 9y agoI don't remember having to read and sign a license the last time I bought a hamburger from McDonald's. Has that changed?
- cabaalis 9y agoYou legally entered someone else's property, which is governed by many laws.
- xoa 9y agoAt a really high, generalized level (with contract law being a subset), I think the legal system (and in many ways society in general) has yet to really get a grasp on the concept of resource exhaustion attacks. We all know about DDOS as it applies to digital systems, but individual humans and the social systems we make also all have actual, hard limits on how much information we can possibly process, store, and communicate/move around. A lot of the foundations of law and debate date back to long before we entered the sharp part of our current information production J-curve, when it was much more possible for a single human to be more generalist and it was simultaneously simply more difficult and expensive to pump out hundreds or thousands of pages of contract and law. But those days are past, and at some point, to the extent we want (and we should want it) law to work for humans, there need to be actual principles around the fact that if something exceeds the time/memory/intelligence a human could reasonably apply to it then it shouldn't matter if "they could in theory". Let alone if they really couldn't, even in theory (not enough seconds left in their lives). Organizations may be able to act as superhumans here, able to subdivide work and specialize towards a single goal, but for regular actual humans resource cost should be a fundamental consideration of legal validity. I'd like to see this improved for both sides of the equation though FWIW. I agree that as a user/consumer, the EULA/TOS situation is intolerable and that there's a lot of sketchy or outright bullshit stuff in many (maybe most) of them. But I do think some of the contents are also genuinely guarding against liability that frankly really just shouldn't exist by default either. If someone writes up some software or makes a service and just puts it out there on the open market with no promises, they shouldn't need any sort of contract at all saying they won't be liable if it's used for life-safety critical applications for example (EULAs/TOS are full of this, right up to "this is not for nuclear reactors you fucking idiot" clauses). The law should provide for minimal basic standards and simple money-back guarantees for lack of performance, but just as users shouldn't have to read a 50 page EULA that somewhere buried within tries to take lots of their rights and lay claim to as much of their information as possible and such, so should developers not have to worry about being sued because there was a bug unless they've actually affirmatively promised there wouldn't be a bug. Major liability should tie into things application promises and SLAs, which would be more generally negotiated between entities who can reasonably handle the increased information and legal complexity and think it all through. I do really hope we see some standardization all the way around. It seems like there could be some real win/wins in this area, and that it's not necessarily that politicized either.
- doomslice 9y agoI've been thinking of writing my own Terms of Service for my cryptocurrency-related web startup -- with plain and clear language that the average person should be able to understand. Several people have advised me that this is a horrible idea and that I should enlist the help of a lawyer to write it instead. Some things I want to protect myself against: - People suing if they lose their private keys and are no longer able to make transactions - People suing if they forget their passwords and can no longer access their email they signed up with to do a recovery. - People suing if they lose their 2FA code and can no longer access their account - People suing if a bug in my software causes them to lose access to their account or coins - People suing if I decide to close down my service (I will give 90 days notice --- or maybe more, haven't decided yet) and did not deactivate their accounts. Basically trying to protect myself for anything that is not fraud on my part. Seems like most people here are pro-"short and sweet" ToS -- what do you think about writing it myself?
- hshehehjdjdjd 9y ago> People suing if a bug in my software causes them to lose access to their account or coins Everything else sounds pretty reasonable, but this doesn’t. If you cause someone harm, you should expect that they will attempt to recover damages from you, regardless of what your T&C says. I cannot fathom why you think you should be protected against this eventuality. Buy insurance instead. Regarding your question, notwithstanding the hand-wringing on this page, a given T&C clause tends to exist because someone has been sued over the matter being clarified. If the law specified each point, or if society were less litigious, these clauses would not be necessary. But this is not the case. I think you would be a fool to risk your company’s wellbeing to satisfy the whims of uninformed HN commenters. Almost all of them will blindly accept and be bound by your T&C regardless of their stated beliefs on this site, and, even if that were not the case, they are a tiny, unrepresentative slice of your market.
- doomslice 9y agoFair enough. I guess this is why I should get a lawyer involved! I was assuming there was some distinction between accidental negligence and fraud as far as what could be protected against.
- paulie_a 9y agoPayPal is a company that just needs to go away. They screw people out of their money left and right. And for the cherry on top their ui is complete garbage
- zmmille2 9y agoI see a lot of people talking about Terms of Service being too long. This is a problem for governments as well: How many laws do you think apply to you right now? How long do you think it would take for you to understand exactly what you can and cannot legally do? Do you think the average police officer, or even federal agent, has a full understanding of those laws? I hope that this is a problem that we can fix in the future.
- Finnucane 9y agoSure, we're covered by many laws, but also many rights--the right to fair trial, the right to legal representation, the right to petition the government, and so on. If a law is poorly or vaguely written, it can be challenged on those grounds--many laws are tossed as unenforceable. But when you click on a user agreement, there's no negotiation or possibility of redress. Take it or leave it, and they just cut you off if they feel like it. The comparison to laws is nonsense.
- mooneater 9y agoTrue of legalese in contracts, but also Law in general has multiplied like Gremlins. Hammurabi's code of laws, was written in common language, and was brief enough every subject could understand them. It makes no sense that we should be subject to a volume of law that we could never even read, let alone understand. Musk is correct in insisting that laws should expire, and it should be easier to remove a law than add one. Minimum Viable Law. Long ago lay people had no idea what the bible said because they could not read Latin. Well lawyers are the new priests, legalese is the new Latin.
- kodablah 9y ago> Law in general has multiplied It's no surprise reading the comments here and elsewhere these days. The media helps build a furor amongst people, and people believe there is no other choice but to use the heavy hand of the government to solve their issues. Many times it's done without alternatives attempted first with the proponents criticizing those against a law as against its intentions. We see it with the Patriot Act, GDPR, etc. And as global internet laws are written more and more by governments of citizens who implicitly trust them a lot (often just guessing at what can solve the problem instead of empirical evidence based on timid baby steps), their tentacles spread to the point where only those with resources can abide. Things happen in waves and I can only hope we'll come around to not adding laws and regulations all the time.
- lovich 9y agoThe power of corporations is at this point like a smaller government with some companies wielding more power than smaller nation states. We are currently in an upswing of corporations extracting more and more money out of people and trying to control them more and more. What are people supposed to do? Wait for companies to just change out of the goodness of their hearts? You cant even talk with your wallet anymore when many practices that are anti consumer, such as tracking every bit of data about you and selling it to anyone, are industry wide practices, couple with the fact that the larger corporations are inching closer and closer to the same level of monopoly power as the robber barons 100+ years ago. Government overreach is bad, and the government is frequently a bad actor itself, but at least if they are trying to cancel out corporations power we end up with both groups hobbling themselves a bit
- vannevar 9y agoWe need something akin to the Uniform Commercial Code, which solved a similar problem with proliferation of contracts in the B2B realm. And I think there should be a strict limit on the amount of verbiage that a B2C contract can contain to remain enforceable, due to the highly asymmetrical nature of the relationship economically.
- solomatov 9y agoIMO, this is a question of consumer protection. It's ok to provide complicated contracts to corporations who can afford to hire lawyers, but it's not ok to do so with consumers. If we make a requirement that for consumer products, contract should be now longer than 1 page written in a language understandable by 10 year old, it will solve problem.
- jstarfish 9y agoI like the elevator pitch approach. If you can't explain your T&S in as many words as it takes to explain your product, one or the other needs to be revised.
- solomatov 9y agoIt sounds good in theory, but in practice there're aspect which prevents it from being applicable. See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=16886176&goto=threads%3Fid%3Dsolomatov%2316886176 https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=16886176&goto=threads%...
- jstarfish 9y agoYes, you have a valid point. The one I was more trying to make is that a product should not be simply marketed as "a platform for sharing pictures with your friends" if it is actually "a platform for sharing pictures with your friends in exchange for your participation in unspecified and ethically questionable social experiments." The T&S can stay the same for all I care, I just think companies shouldn't be able to hide behind them when they dramatically oversimplify the nature of the product in the process of selling or promoting it.
- protonfish 9y agoEven if EULAs were easily understood, they are still ultimatums: you either take it or leave it with no room for negotiation or repercussions for demanding far more than the product could reasonably ever be worth. There is no motivation to ever write these in good faith. There should be a general federal law to protect users and businesses from malice, privacy laws (similar to CAN-SPAM,) and a ban on all other end-user license nonsense.
- mattferderer 9y agoStartup Idea - An AI language translator for legal language to English. It could convert a 20+ page contract to a 1 page bullet list. Maybe this has already been done or does the language of law require quantum computing?
- kbenson 9y agoAn interesting idea, but complicated by the fact that as often as not the terms expressed are affected by the domain and locale. For example, for every employment contract that contains a non-compete in California, there is relevant California state law that means it's probably unenforceable. What do you show for that? Additionally, new case law is being made all the time. Laws aren't static, they are added to, amended or removed through legislature and case law. To my understanding, the case law changes are also more about the specific circumstances of the case as well, so may apply narrowly or widely, depending on ruling. And may be appealed.
- grabeh 9y agoI would make a few points: - I don't think legalese is the issue. Even if you wrote terms in plain English they would still be at a similar length if you wanted to capture the same content of the base terms, and people would still not read them. I don't think there is a high proportion of people who are put off by legalese but would read terms if they were in plain English - the article has a GDPR bent. Certainly when it comes to uses of personal data, that should form a bigger part of the sign-up experience and be separated out from the main terms. - when you are looking at general terms & conditions outside of privacy, European consumer law and I imagine most consumer law protects customers from unreasonable actions by corporations toward consumers. It allows the user to assume the company will behave reasonably towards the consumer, and is arguably the appropriate remedy to cure the issue of over-long terms & conditions. - There is of course limited scope to this and there will be a range of transactions where you are not acting as a consumer and are expected to thoroughly understand the full implications of the transaction you enter into. - the reckoning in the article is already one partially addressed by the above steps at least in the European Union around consumer law protections, and requirements on the data protection side to call out data uses in the sign-up process rather than bury them in the terms.
- anoncoward1234 9y agoSeems to me this is easily fixed. If a jury of peers cannot understand the legal contract during an arbitration, rule in favor of the signor of the contract and against the writer. You'll see that shit disappear with a quickness.
- imglorp 9y agoThis is a great idea but I don't think it goes far enough. It means that 12 lay people can eventually, after some coaching, study, and debate, understand a contract. Or one lawyer, presumably. The problem remains though, that one lay person needs to understand it without study or coaching, and without taking days to do so. Most of us have probably clicked through hundreds or even thousands of EULAs and other crap without having days to understand each one. Every app, every shrinkwrap, your toaster, and even the bloody nav on your car with its OK button: there's just too much.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThe jury should get as much time to read the contract as the average user spends reading the contract and should not get the help of a lawyer. If the company doesn't collect data about how much time users spend reading the contract, then it should be presumed that they didn't read it at all and then only terms that the jury can guess would be in the contract without reading it should be valid.
- methodover 9y agoFacebook's Privacy Policy, Terms, and Principles are actually written in very clear, plain language. I've read them. They're easy to understand. I was frustrated by Senator Graham's remarks because he absolutely could understand them, if he bothered to read them. (He said that he didn't understand them.) The problem though, isn't the Terms. It doesn't matter how plainly written they are. People won't read them. What matters is designing your product with correct privacy affordances. Put yourself on the shoes of the user, and make sure your app isn't sharing information in a way that would be jarring or unexpected. For example, Facebook made a mistake with its posting dialogue experience pre 2016. You could say that a post should only be shared "with friends" in a choice box next to your post. However, that post would also be shared with any apps your friend has installed. That's probably not what the posting user would have expected, so it's a poor experience. If you have inadequate privacy affordances, you shouldn't just hide behind your terms. That's the point. Edit: I don't understand why I'm being downvoted. If you disagree with something, please let me know. I'm designing our own privacy affordances in our app following the above thinking, after all...
- Digit-Al 9y agoI'd just like to refer to this: http://www.plainenglish.co.uk/ http://www.plainenglish.co.uk/
- Digit-Al 9y agoThe thing nobody seems to be talking about is 'why do we need all these complex Terms & Conditions anyway?' If I buy a fridge I don't need to read and agree to reams of T's and C's before I can use it. The same with a toaster or an oven or a washing machine. If I buy a knife I don't have to agree to indemnify the manufacturer if I kill someone with it. What's so special about software? I'm starting to think that there should be an agreed set of national (or maybe even international) software indemnifacations covering anything that is agreed to be considered a sensible exclusion. Any software use could then be covered by the relevant law with no need to read a new set of terms for everything. Any company trying to add their own terms on top of these could then be considered with much caution or suspicion. Hopefully they would be written better than this was, but I hope I have got my point across.
- dredmorbius 9y agoHave you looked at user agreements, warrantees, and software licences that come with appliances lately? Often not revealed until accessing via some interface, or being modified on software upgrades.
- bencollier49 9y agoHilarious. Bloomberg harp on about GDPR but their own cookie notice violates it by using assumed consent and tying consent to use.
- kenning 9y agoOh my god, can we have one article on this topic without this comment? The whole problem is that 99% of websites people visit come with trackers.
- everyone 9y agoAs far as I'm aware those type of contracts do not hold up in court. (At least here in Ireland) Its well known by both parties that in 99% of cases the consumer will just click 'agree' without reading it in order to get access. So as far as the judge is concerned it doesnt exist.
- dhimes 9y agoZuckerberg admitted as much.
- tobltobs 9y agoThis is one of the many baffling details of the GDPR, a TOS should be understandable for average humans (plain english), but at the same time it has to pass the scrutiny of a court? That is just impossible.
- mhneu 9y agoYes. There are two separate issues here, I think. 1. When corporations "negotiate" with consumers, this is an abuse of the legal system. Contract law was conceived for situations where both parties have at least some amount of negotiating power. Handing a consumer some long contract written by a set of well-paid lawyers, and asking them to sign it or walk away from any benefit from a product, is not the kind of contract we want in our society. In the past, we've used group association - collective bargaining, class action lawsuits, etc. - to solve this problem of many consumers, each with almost no power, negotiating with a big corporation with all the power. Arbitration clauses, and non-competes, are often examples of abuse of this power imbalance. This situation is the kind of thing government exists to do - solve problems for its citizens by working collectively. So perhaps regulation is also a remedy. 2. Informed consent, vs. terms-and-conditions consent. Click-through agreements with many pages, written by a legal team, in which the alternative for the consumer is to walk away, cannot be seen as informed consent by the consumer. When Facebook asks users to click "yes" for disclaiming privacy rights, that's not informed consent. We already have a definition of informed consent in scientific experiments, and it requires understanding every word of the consent and no penalties for saying no. (If a scientist offers subjects $10 for participating, the scientist must pay that $10 to anyone who declines the consent form.) Consent forms must evolve to match informed consent in science. If as a society we deal with these two issues, we'll be in a much better place, and we'll be dealing with wealth concentration (into the hands of corporations), a key issue for our time.
- mhneu 9y agoOne other comment for non-lawyers here: When two companies negotiate a contract, typically what happens is this. One team of lawyers drafts the contract. They send it to the other lawyers. Both business teams consult their lawyers, and the lawyers update the contract with their desired changes. Then the first company comments on desired changes and they negotiate. The result, after perhaps many rounds of negotiation, is often a far different contract than was originally proposed. That is NOT what happens with consumer terms and conditions agreements, or cell phone contracts. There, the company's lawyers draft a contract that is as favorable to them as is legal. The consumer does not have the legal team or negotiating power to push back: their choices are to sign, or to walk. These quite different contract processes are worth thinking about. Is this the way we, as a society, want contract law to be used?
- tzs 9y ago> Waving a 2-inch-thick printed version of the social network’s user agreement, Senator Lindsey Graham quoted a line from the first page, then intoned: “I’m a lawyer, and I have no idea what that means.” Anyone have a link to that document? Looking for the terms I'm supposed to agree to if I want to use Facebook as an ordinary user, I find this page, which purports to link to everything [1]. Looking at the "Statement of Rights and Responsibilities", the "Data Policy", and the "Community Standards", I don't see anything that would take 2 inches when printed. Those seem to be most of what would be necessary for an ordinary user to agree to. There are several links to other terms and policies and such on the left, but those are mostly for things like developers, payment handling, and other things that that an ordinary user would not need to agree to. [1] https://www.facebook.com/policies https://www.facebook.com/policies
- cestith 9y agoPerhaps a more pertinent question is whether or not Lindsey Graham understands and expects every American citizen and resident to have read all 51 titles of the US Code and all of the Code of Federal Regulations which carry the force of statutory law by inclusion.
- textmode 9y agoMaybe of interest: https://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdf https://www.sec.gov/pdf/handbook.pdf Lawyers who prepare submissions to the SEC in the US have long been advised to use "plain English".
- drsopp 9y agoWhy cannot we, as consumers, gang up and define a kind of universal and fair ‘reverse contract’ that defines rights and duties that a potential service provider needs to conform to? If they don’t, we just don’t use their service.
- tzs 9y agoI think the legalize issue is a bit exaggerated. Yes, many (too many) sites and companies have a lot of legalize in their terms...but there are also many that do not. Nevertheless, as far as I've seen people aren't any more likely to read the latter, or any more likely to understand them if they do read them. I think there are two main factors that make people not read these things. First, as Joel Spolsky noted in his writings on UI design, "In fact, users can’t read anything, and if they could, they wouldn’t want to" [1]. He does not mean, of course, that users literally cannot read. They just act like, at least when you are trying to get them to read something that they didn't actually ask to read. Second, terms and conditions tend to be long, and because they want to be precise tend toward more complicated language and structure. That's going to lose a lot of people. [1] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-people-who-have-better-things-to-do-with-their-lives/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-peop...
- paulmd 9y agoI mean, you could rewrite the same contract in plain english ("heads we win, tails you lose") and it wouldn't make it any less exploitative. The legalese is not the real issue there.
- grellas 9y agoThe basic law relating to online terms and conditions has been stable for some years now and should remain so. It certainly is not headed for a "reckoning." When private parties transact business in a free society, the law of contracts steps in to provide rules enabling them to do so in a well-defined and orderly manner. Contract law has some fundamental principles that anchor it and, beyond those, has a vast number of intricacies that potentially can come into play in individual circumstances. Concerning fundamentals, for most executory contracts to be enforceable, you need to have mutual consent and some exchange of consideration. That is, a meeting of the minds on material terms and an exchange of value. When these elements exist, the law considers a contract to be binding and imposes legal consequences for any breach or failure to perform. In order to avoid chaos, it further stipulates that the core principle (meeting of the minds) is not based on purely subjective factors but on what a reasonable person would believe in the circumstances. This objective standard enables commercial transactions to proceed without endless second-guessing about what the parties might have desired or meant when they contracted in any given transaction. Because of this, while it can easily become messy in any given case, most contract situations can be legally evaluated with a fair degree of certainty and parties can plan their affairs and determine their rights accordingly. The above describes what might be called a very high-level summary the central tenets of the common law of contracts in the Anglo-Saxon legal tradition. If someone reasonably can be said to have consented to a given transaction involving some exchange of value, legal rules applied to govern how that exchange took place and what would happen if some breached his or her agreement. When it comes to terms and conditions in online commerce, the law generally applies this body of contract law but does so via what might be called the fiction of mutual consent between the contracting parties. It is well known that the vast majority of persons do not bother to read such terms and conditions when they click on the "Agree" button. Nonetheless, the terms and conditions are legally binding upon such persons. Why? Because it is assumed that the person read and understood them in clicking. And that assumption is what makes it a fiction. In effect, the law says, "we will pretend that the person read through the terms and knowingly agreed to them." Given that this legal fiction effectively substitutes for a true consent, the law can proceed along its merry way and treat this contract as it would any other, i.e., treat it as binding and enforceable upon the "contracting" party. In effect, to preserve orderly rules of contract in such transactions, the law effectively says that the terms and conditions are legally binding if they are such that a reasonable person who had taken the time to read through them would have understood them to have a certain meaning (that is, the "reasonable person" meaning that the law will enforce upon the person doing the clicking). This fundamental approach to terms and conditions in online transactions has not changed one bit in some years and is under no risk of being changed. Because, without it, you could not practically have any semblance of legal orderliness in online transactions. Moreover, while it is often said that dense legalese is undesirable in such situations, courts generally enforce such legalese without hesitation, even if a complaining consumer says until he is blue in the face that it could have been put in easier-to-understand plain English. There is no legal rule that requires contractual language to be put into plain English and there are some types of contracts where an attempt to express the legal requirements in that way would cause a loss of precision or lead to other problems. Whether something is expressed in plain English or not, then, typically does not affect its enforceability in online transactions. Again, nothing pervasive is happening in the law affecting online transactions so as to require use of plain English to make terms and conditions enforceable. None of this is to say that there are no protections in existing law when people try to use weasel language to defraud others or use language that is so imprecise as to mislead consumers or use language that is so ill-defined or vague as to leave important matters uncertain to the other contracting party. In all such cases, existing common law has remedies of varying kinds to say that such contracts are unenforceable or that some remedy applies in favor or an aggrieved or defrauded consumer. But, in practice, these are edge cases, the ones that wind up in dispute or in court. The vast bulk (99%+) of the commerce that occurs is covered by the general contract rules and proceeds in an orderly way because the rules are known and predictable. Against this background of the common law contract rules, it is possible for persons to want to modify the existing rules on grounds that such rules are unfair to the consumer and or are not based on true consent by that consumer or for some other public policy ground. This is where special public-policy-driven enactments come in to modify the standard contract rules. Legislatures can adopt special laws dictating outer bounds to how businesses can use the private data of consumers as such data may entrusted to them. In this area, perhaps, a form of "reckoning" may occur if it is determined that companies such as Facebook ought not to be able to sell or misuse private data to the detriment of their users. This is an important development and serious changes may be afoot affecting such special areas. But this does not affect the general principles by which online contracting occurs. There could also be proposals mandating that plain English be used in terms and conditions or requiring this or that form of mandated disclosure to help ensure greater consumer understanding but all such proposals come with decided trade-offs that typically make them impractical. The reason for the fiction of legal consent in the current system is the supreme utility that comes from allowing millions of online transactions to occur every day without incident based on orderly rules known to all. You can change all that through legislative enactments saying that public policy requires a different system that is more fair to consumers. But at what price? That is why the current system is and remains solidly in place. To underscore the importance of utility, I have been legally trained and have years of experience such that I could easily read through and comprehend the legalese that is found in most online terms and conditions. Yet, with rare exceptions, I am just like everybody else and will click "Accept" or "Agree" without reading anything and without a second thought. As a lawyer, I can't say that I am proud of this but I can say this is human nature. The issue is not primarily that legalese or plain English will make a difference in understandability. It is that we take the path of least resistance when not much is at stake and we don't want to be bothered. Try as we might, no law will solve that problem.