8 ms·
The carriers are idiots. It's where innovation goes to die. We had to pull them kicking and screaming into the smart phone and data era. (Remember When AT&T se
by exabrial 9y ago
The carriers are idiots. It's where innovation goes to die.
We had to pull them kicking and screaming into the smart phone and data era. (Remember When AT&T sent a paper copy of every image you downloaded on your iPhone in a bill?)
Quite frankly the core problem with Google's strategy is involving then at all. Instead, go the manufacturers and campaign against supporting sms at all. It's insecure, slow, unreliable, monitored, among many other things. Push the manufacturers to an open Android messaging api that runs over TLS (or double ratchet) and bypasses the carriers completely, but the manufacturers can still rebrand.
The other issue is Apple. For as much as they claim "privacy is a human right", they have been jerks about making sure iMessage drags it's feet using secure technologies to communicate outside of their ecosystem. Apple wants to ride a white horse on encryption, but in reality they're having an opposite, negative, effect on the vast majority of the world's population.
- jimktrains2 9y ago> Quite frankly the core problem with Google's strategy is involving then at all. Instead, go the manufacturers and campaign against supporting sms at all. It's insecure, slow, unreliable, monitored, among many other things. Push the manufacturers to an open Android messaging api that runs over TLS (or double ratchet) and bypasses the carriers completely, but the manufacturers can still rebrand. But it's universal. I would never buy a phone that doesn't support sms. How do I contact people with flip phones? People with iPhones? Also, Gchat is "monitored" as much as sms. Imessage claims it's not, but has that/can that be verified?
- sethhochberg 9y agoIts both universal _and_ relies on the voice network rather than the data network (if the device even has one). SMS is a fundamental part of the GSM spec, has been for over 30 years, and is one of those super lightweight battle-tested technologies that there are certainly some pretty great IP-based alternatives to, but which replacing wholesale for some yet-another-IP-based-rebranded-messanger seems crazy. The beauty of SMS riding on the voice network is that it gives you redundancy. Phone doesn't have a data signal, but can get voice? SMS still works. Until we live in a world where GSM and friends are dead and everything everywhere is VoLTE, SMS still has a place as a fallback. I'm always a little surprised to come into HN comment threads about SMS and see so many people rallying for its replacement, yet we go into a thread about Slack and see many of the same arguments being made to defend IRC, etc.
- goalieca 9y agoIRC is more modern in a sense. It usually works over an IP network.
- azinman2 9y agoiMessage is end-to-end encryption.
- arkadiytehgraet 9y agoHow do you know that? Have you seen sources and verified that those sources are actually compiled and shipped with the final product?
- Analemma_ 9y agoUnless you write your own compiler, look at every line of the source by hand well enough to ensure there no "underhanded C code contest" backdoors, compile the application yourself, load it onto your phone, and do the same for your friends and share keys with them in person, you don't have this kind of assurance for any communication app. You have to draw a line somewhere and accept some level of trust proportionate to your threat model. iMessage is good enough for most people who aren't Edward Snowden.
- prepend 9y agoThat’s a good point. Apple attests that it’s end to end and people have tried to track and fail and leaks don’t reveal vulnerabilities. By comparison, no other majors attest that (eg, Google explicitly says it’s not end to end) and leaks have shown data accessed in clear text by government actors.
- scrooched_moose 9y ago> unreliable Really? It's the only messaging format that works without a data connection and is an absolute godsend when I'm out camping, rural biking, or at large sporting events and the towers are absolutely swamped. I'm in a situation at least once a month where the only reliable communication method is SMS.
- nmcfarl 9y agoWow - infrastructure varies. Here in Eastern Oregon the pattern is pretty reliably that data and signal drop out at the same time, at least on Verizon which is the carrier with the best coverage. I really thought the pattern that you describe, which I've seen plenty of in the past, had just died out over time and tower upgrades.
- megaman22 9y agoI routinely see SMSs fail to deliver, deliver multiple times, deliver weirdly out of order, or deliver at random times, hours or days after they were sent. And this is in a relatively well-served area fifty miles out of Boston.
- sli 9y agoI still have the issue where MMS seems to just sometimes not work for days or even weeks on end, then suddenly start working again. No OS updates and no APN settings changes in the meantime. Normally it's not an issue, since I don't really use SMS all that much anymore, but my mother and I tend to send pictures back and forth a lot and she still uses SMS. SMS itself usually works fine, but MMS is particularly bad.
- reiichiroh 9y agoIt all depends if there's a 2G network to fall back on if 3G+ data goes down. Most places have shut down their 2G.
- djrogers 9y ago
- Piskvorrr 9y agoThis is caricature, but based in reality: https://xkcd.com/1810/ https://xkcd.com/1810/ - SMS, like email, is ubiquitous. Unlike email, it doesn't even require a data connection, just a cellphone signal. (Yes, this is a thing, even in supposedly civilized countries) Unlike email, it doesn't even require a feature phone - even the dumbest of the featurephones can read SMS, from the venerable Nokia 3210 up (yes, even e-mail can be too complex for Grandma). And the other thing - asking Google to stick to a messaging API? Google, which has launched-and-killed more mutually incompatible messaging platforms than I've even managed to use? Not gonna happen. "Use Talk! Use Hangouts! Use Allo! Use TwoCansAndAString!"
- pas 9y agoThe point is not to kill SMS, just to make the default an IP-based protocol, that's not tied to the carrier/operator. Currently people are dependent on phone numbers for too many things. (Too many "2FA" uses SMS.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wyldfire 9y ago> The carriers are idiots. For decades, ISPs/cell networks' biggest fear is becoming "dumb pipes". But they all seem to land there eventually.
- exabrial 9y agoYes.... lack of vision is what seems to define an ISP. Creating content, while 'sexy', is fleeting and incredibly expensive. Delivering the content reliably and quickly is a predictable busy model. ISPs should be clamoring to advertise how they deliver Netflix the fastest, or offer equivalent to Cloudflare's service but for their customers. Instead, we get an XFINITY VOICE REMOTE O.M.G. and a platform thats update once every 5 years.
- glogla 9y agoLook. Its simple. Signal work on Android just like iMessage - you set it as SMS app, and it uses Signal messages with people who have Signal (even on iPhone) and SMS otherwise. We already have iMessage-style app on Android. It's just that pretty much nobody is using it.
- philipwhiuk 9y agoBecause no carrier installs Signal as the default messaging app.
- infonull 9y agoAgreed, SMS needs to stop being supported by handset vendors so people stops relying on it as the universal text platform. When a communication system silently drops messages, this is unacceptable. But people are ok with it because they're accustomed to it being shit. The sender wonders why you never responded, and you are unaware they contacted you. Or the sender asks if you want to meet for lunch, and you get it 8 hours later. Group messages? I've compared phones on a table and we all have a different context to the conversation because each phone has different set of missing messages. The messaging platforms are in silos and it sucks, everyone is annoyed about having 3-4 chat apps. But at least they work reliably, and that's the better alternative to garbage SMS.
- beegeezuz 9y agolol are you on drugs or something? never in the last 18 years or so have I experienced a single missed of failed txt message, if you live in the woods it doesn't matter what you use, your internet connectivity will drop too you know
- Pharylon 9y agoSMS is important. It's universal, and it can be used as a way to communicate with anyone. I have friends that I chat with exclusively over SMS. They use Facebook Messenger, and I won't use Facebook anymore. They could join me on Signal or something, but I'm not going to ask them to download a whole app just to chat with me. It's the one messaging platform that's not in a silo, and that's just as important (maybe more so?) than 100% reliability.
- AnssiH 9y ago> When a communication system silently drops messages, this is unacceptable. But people are ok with it because they're accustomed to it being shit. Or they are OK with it because they have never had their SMS messages dropped, like me (that I know of). At least here (Finland) SMS is used for a lot of stuff like bank transfer verification and postal package pickup notifications, having many dropped messages would seemingly make it unsuitable for those purposes. Of course, MMS is a completely different story and I've seen issues left and right on various phones and carriers. I don't think anybody really even uses MMS group chats here.
- usmannk 9y ago>Remember When AT&T sent a paper copy of every image you downloaded on your iPhone in a bill? I'd never heard of that, fascinating. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/300-page_iPhone_bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/300-page_iPhone_bill
- djrogers 9y ago> Remember When AT&T sent a paper copy of every image you downloaded on your iPhone in a bill? No, no I don't - that has to be apocryphal.
- exabrial 9y agoFrom another comment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/300-page_iPhone_bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/300-page_iPhone_bill