4 ms·
Squandered electricity has no value, bitcoin are not imbued with any value from the mining process, their value is strictly a function of what someone is willin
by maxerickson 9y ago
Squandered electricity has no value, bitcoin are not imbued with any value from the mining process, their value is strictly a function of what someone is willing to pay for them.
(I imagine you agree, but clarity is useful)
- bob_theslob646 9y agoI think he/she misspoke about what they meant by "squandered electricity." I think what they were referring to is how electricity is allocated or stored. Currently, we cannot do so effectively. It is ironic that Bitcoin is being referred to as a store of value. I would hesitate to say that squandered electricity has very little value but it is all dependent on what your definition of value is, potential or realized.
- maxerickson 9y agoSquandered electricity is like burning cash. It's obvious waste. Hesitate all you want. Note that chemical batteries and pumped storage hydroelectric both store large amounts of electricity very effectively (there lots and lots of deployments that were done by commercial interests seeking to improve the economics of their operations, some going back decades).
- marvin 9y agoBurning cash is a poor analogy, apart from the destruction of the physical paper (which is very cheap). Burning cash causes a small amount of deflation, which increases everyone else's fortune a tiny amount, but does not waste any human effort. A better analogy would be digging a hole and filling it up again. Or maybe better, causing a small amount of destruction to something that other people value.
- craftyguy 9y ago> causing a small amount of destruction to something that other people value. Yea, like the environment.
- hn0 9y agoSo if I take a truckload of 100$ bills, a bottle of gin and a can of gasoline, drive into the dessert, out of sight of the authorities, and burn the entire lot, then the next night all retailers will have a vision which tells them to lower their average prices by 0.573%?
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoIs this comment sarcastic? I can't tell. The money supply affects prices. It's basic econ.
- vageli 9y agoHow fast does a change made by a private actor to the money supply propagate? Surely not instantaneously?
- marcosdumay 9y agoBy the time you fill your truck with those $100 bills, the prices will have already adjusted. If you decide to not burn them, but spend them quickly, the prices will adjust again.
- marvin 9y agoIt's a hypothetical point; a small reduction in money supply will affect prices far less than the uncertainty or random fluctuation in the measurement of prices.
- wufufufu 9y agoBitcoin miners work fine as heaters too
- hinkley 9y agoWe were “storing” that electricity as natural gas or coal until someone fired up more bitcoin miners and someone else adjusted production upward to keep the power lines steady.
- criddell 9y agoBitcoins are sooooo 2017. I'm thinking about liquidating my hodlings and moving into tulips.
- simias 9y agoThere is a relation though, although admittedly it's the other way around: the more expensive bitcoins are the most money can be invested into the mining process which correlates strongly with the total amount of energy "wasted" mining it. If BTC was worth $4 the hash rate would probably be a tiny fraction of what it is today.
- jonnydubowsky 9y agoBitcoin is the single largest coordination of encryption in history, and this delivers a store of value which cannot be seized. This has incredible value to those who already utilize offshore banking havens and complex legal coordination mechanisms to protect their wealth. Within a growing number of use cases, bitcoin via the lightning network provides access to financial services to the unbanked who are able to also establish their self soverign identity. To those individuals these edge cases are incredibly valuable.
- maxerickson 9y ago>Bitcoin is the single largest coordination of encryption in history What is that supposed to mean? Blockchain isn't encrypted. It's secured with cryptographic hashes of course. >and this delivers a store of value which cannot be seized. Make sure to watch what happens when/if the US government and China have both decided it is a problem worth much attention.
- majewsky 9y ago> a store of value which cannot be seized Police can absolutely seize the physical artifacts on which your wallet resides. And if that storage is encrypted, consider https://www.xkcd.com/538/ https://www.xkcd.com/538/ - You may not be able to seize the bitcoins, but you can absolutely seize the person owning them.
- downandout 9y ago>Police can absolutely seize the physical artifacts on which your wallet resides. They have to find it first, which can be easy or difficult, depending on how motivated you are to make it difficult. You can quite easily make it more difficult than it is for them to walk into a bank and say “freeze this account”.
- rufugee 9y agoHonestly not sure why you're being downvoted here. Your point seems reasonable and true based on how easy it is to create a paper wallet and make that paper sheet all but unfindable.