4 ms·
Why doesn’t the IRS send me a tax bill based on the info they already have?
- olskool 9y agoThe tax preparation companies such as H&R Block and Intuit spend a lot of money lobbying Congress to keep this from happening.
- thathappened 9y agoThis might be true but it's not needed. I'm looking for the documentary about the US economy and the silent industries that secretly prop it up. Taxing people is work. To make an industry responsible allows both government to not invest and risk additional losses but allowing people to overpay gives them a surplus while allowing for those that make mistakes that cost the government to recoup in justice fees. I remember the video having lawyers asked what the most profitable industry in America was, they all claimed the legal system when it was accounting.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoCalifornia tried this for a trial of their state taxes. Response was overwhelmingly positive. Yet lobbyist for big tax firms fight against it.
- mullen 9y agoIt still there and very popular, but it is opt-in. However, the majority of people who use it, opt-in.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoOh, I didnt realize that still. Thanks!
- OnlineCourage 9y agoArticle 1, section 2 of the US Constitution prohibits direct taxation. If the IRS sends you a bill, that's becoming a little more 'directy' because they are just assuming that every single head had a W2 with no deductions outside of the narrow info that they know and now you have to proove them wrong. Whereas asking you what you think you should owe and giving you an opportunity to present all facts is more of a levy, and much more just. What this person is asking for on Stackexchange is just pure laziness and super narrow thinking about what activities one could potentially get involved with in one's life. Those who point toward H&R block as being at fault: well yes they would certainly want to maintain a horrible IRS UX, but that is completely separate from how taxes are levyed, which is constitutional. Also I love Sweden but just because Sweden does it does not mean automatically the best solution.
- otterley 9y agoArticle I Section 2 was amended by Amendment XIV (“The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.”). The original text is legally void.
- kahnpro 9y agoThere's no reason why they can't. If you're an employee and/or a student then everything you do should be reported to the government, taxes should have automatically been withheld, and the government should be able to figure out everything on their own. They always double-check your calculations anyway. Only if you're self-employed or have special situations should you need to file anything, and even then, many of these situations can be something where you tick a box or submit a document and then they still do everything automatically. The situation in the US and Canada is ridiculous.
- LorenPechtel 9y agoDisagree. For such people the government will generally have everything on the income side. They won't necessarily have everything on the deduction side. However, even partial data like that would be very useful. The IRS sends you pre-filled forms. You can change anything that's wrong, add anything that's missing. Do your taxes, or just submit the changes and let them deal with the rest of it and send you a bill if need be.
- kahnpro 9y agoIf you have things on the deduction side that the government doesn't already know about, you can submit a self-assessment or an amendment. Deductions themselves should be simplified. You bring deductions up as if it's a problem but many other countries, like the UK, do it this way without problems. Most people here do not submit tax returns.
- eh78ssxv2f 9y ago> If you're an employee and/or a student then everything you do should be reported to the government, taxes should have automatically been withheld, and the government should be able to figure out everything on their own. In such cases, isn't it already super straightforward to file taxes? Just copy-paste information from W2 to 1040ez, and you are done?
- PeterisP 9y ago
- wmil 9y agoThings are more complicated than you think. There are many SSNs in use by multiple people. It's an immigration issue so the IRS turns a blind eye. Also there's a larger number of cases where the address the IRS has on file is incorrect. So there's a huge risk of the refund going to the wrong person with pre-filled returns.
- IshKebab 9y agoYeah PAYE is really really hard and complex. The only countries that do it are Germany and the UK and France (from 2018) and Australia and New Zealand and Ireland and ... etc. etc.
- oarla 9y agoPopulation of: USA: 325 million Germany: 81 million France: 65 million UK: 65 million Australia: 21 million New Zealand: 4.7 million
- krageon 9y agoThis is a tired trope, because this seems to forget that more people also equals more resources to deal with more people. It's not a substantive argument to just say "well there's more of us so this can never work", which is what I assume you're trying to say here.
- swrobel 9y agoGrover Norquist.
- oarla 9y agoThe IRS doesn't always know everything. For example, they don't know how much medical expenses were incurred in the tax year. If there's a centralized place where all relevant expenses and incomes are logged, then maybe they should do it for everyone. Else, it's going to be a problem going back and forth with IRS over the right amount of taxes to be paid.
- MR4D 9y agoThey don’t need to know that, though. For instance, the irs could send you a statement with everything they know and a total at the bottom. You can either pay that, or if you think you should pay less, prove it by filling out a bunch of 1040/1099/etc forms with supporting evidence. Frankly, I’d love it. If it’s close enough, I think many people would pay a bit more just to eliminate the hassle.
- eip 9y ago"A silent weapon system operates upon data obtained from a docile public by legal (but not always lawful) force. Much information is made available to silent weapon systems programmers through the Internal Revenue Service. (See Studies in the Structure of the American Economy for an I.R.S. source list.) This information consists of the enforced delivery of well-organized data contained in federal and state tax forms, collected, assembled, and submitted by slave labor provided by taxpayers and employers. Furthermore, the number of such forms submitted to the I.R.S. is a useful indicator of public consent, an important factor in strategic decision making. Other data sources are given in the Short List of Inputs. Consent Coefficients - numerical feedback indicating victory status. Psychological basis: When the government is able to collect tax and seize private property without just compensation, it is an indication that the public is ripe for surrender and is consenting to enslavement and legal encroachment. A good and easily quantified indicator of harvest time is the number of public citizens who pay income tax despite an obvious lack of reciprocal or honest service from the government."