8 ms·
Why Tesla is having a harder time than SpaceX
- sunstone 9y agoBecause SpaceX has almost all the bugs worked out of it's workflow now and Tesla doesn't yet.
- wallace_f 9y agoI don't understand this headline. It didn't tell me why building electric cars is harder than orbital, reusable rockets. It told me that the difficulty in competing in the market for cars is relatively quite competitive, and that for reusable rockets was virtually stagnant--Which I already knew, and believe most readers here do. But we wouldn't read it if that were the headline. The headline is open to all sort of interpretation. Most of them, misleading.
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoWelcome to news media outlets... sensational titles, speculation and no real content
- Certhas 9y agoIt's also obviously not actually harder. SpaceX has built a few dozen reusable rockets, Tesla alone has build tens of thousands of electric cars. Nevermind that people have been building electric cars for a century or so. But then, the question: "Why is doing things cheaply at scale at high quality harder than creating a few items by hand?" wouldn't draw so many clicks...
- hyperpallium 9y agoMass market products are harder to build, to a cost.
- agumonkey 9y agoyeah it's mostly a scale/optim problem, otherwise musk has enough brains in his team to make the finest cars.
- nimish 9y agoAnyone can build a $1MM car. There's tons of low volume hypercar makers. It takes real engineering and business genius to sell millions of a $20000 car that doesn't suck and turns a profit. Honda's finest engineers are likely working on the civic and the accord, not the NSX.
- aurizon 9y agoElectric cats are far easier to build than reusable sockets...
- stephengillie 9y agoWhat would they do with electric sheep?
- aurizon 9y agoMake a BAAAAD joke...
- IncRnd 9y agoYea man, I saw some of those electric cats a walkin' by. I got back to the crib and saw the old lady stickin' her finger in the wall socket. That musk man, he sure is a mean old dude. xD
- api 9y agoIt's harder in different ways. Mass production of any complex product comes with a whole set of challenges that are unique and different from what SpaceX is facing. It could be that Musk's style is better suited to SpaceX's sort of challenge than to the mass production challenge. The latter is less sexy leap forward and more a matter of a billion boring little "six sigma" style optimizations.
- perl4ever 9y agoIt could also be possible that he just doesn't care as much about Tesla and is therefore not contributing something crucial to it.
- taneq 9y agoThis was my (admittedly cynical) take. SpaceX is Musk's means to his self-declared primary goal. Maybe the best of the best candidates get nudged SpaceX-wards.
- IkmoIkmo 9y agotl;dr Why are electric cars harder to build than rockets: 1) they're not. 2) a different question: why an electric car company may be more difficult to succeed than a rocket company, is because the former competes with a trillion dollar internal combustion engine industry with more than a billion drivers of vehicles, deep-pocketed incumbents, and the latter has relatively little competition.
- azernik 9y agoI've been following the SpaceX trainspotting (rocketspotting?) community for a while; in the process I've read bits and pieces about the launch industry in general. The heavy-lift launch market is, indeed, an easy one to compete in; Bezos is slow out of the gate, and the rest of the competition comes from some truly wacko engineering organizations. The car industry already optimized its products and processes for cost and efficiency, while the (American) competition seems not to have even tried. (The European and Russian programs have their own handicaps, and India is doing just fine in the adjacent medium-lift market.)
- kuschku 9y agoAnd it's not like SpaceX revolutionized the launch market yet — a decade and 10 billion USD later they're still launching for similar prices as Arianespace. The only reason the launch market seems to be easy to compete in is because the US launch market has historically been a prime example of corruption.
- annerajb 9y agoThe importance is the cost. they are lower priced on reused flights with a 10-20million discount. Regular non reused flights they are about the same price as competitors (if you count 20millions less the same) New design launching in three weeks would reduce cost even further price will go down maybe by 10 million but cost should go down by around 50 million
- nkoren 9y ago> about the same price as competitors Um, no? The competitors have had to drop their prices very substantially in recent years, due to competition from SpaceX. Yet they're still somewhere between 50%-300% more expensive. That's far from "about the same price".
- kuschku 9y agoI suggest taking a look at launch prices for a single satellite in an Ariane 5 dual launch, which is cheaper than any non-reused launches SpaceX offers.
- SQL2219 9y agoBecause you're building for a million customers not 6.
- blocked_again 9y agoYeah. It's easier to make reusable rockets than Nike pants.
- perl4ever 9y agoIt seems like a tangent, but I think it may be. If you make reusable rockets, I would think you can sell them based on a straightforward list of technical capabilities. If you want to compete with Nike, and your shoes or clothing don't look right and don't have the Nike logo, you may not get anywhere even if you have all the technical boxes checked.
- perl4ever 9y agoSpaceX has blown up, according to a quick search, something like 2 rockets out of ~50. They make reliable, reusable rockets from the perspective of the launch industry, but if they sold a million cars and 40,000 of them exploded into huge fireballs when first used, then Tesla would not be considered successful. On an absolute scale, cars may be easier, but they're not easier relative to the competition.
- whalesalad 9y agoIt all comes down to battery technology.
- walrus01 9y agoWh per kilogram, Wh per cubic cm, number of charge cycle life, $ per kWh cost to build. If you look at how many kJ are in one gallon of diesel, it's kind of amazing. Even when 50 percent is lost to heat in an internal combustion engine.
- borntyping 9y agoThere are millions of working, reusable electric cars; and tens of working, reusable rockets (maybe even less than that). Tesla is having problems building factories, but that certainly doesn't mean electric cars are hard to make.
- walshemj 9y agoHard to make at an affordable price and there is a lot of difference to how a production line works and small batch high cost items like rockets.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- _pmf_ 9y agoQuality at any cost is easy. Quality at low cost is hard.
- manicdee 9y agoMy guess is that Elon realised that rockets are hard and handed the important decisions over to the experts (namely Gwynne Shotwell and Tom Mueller) who were able to start from blank paper. At Tesla on the other hand we have a business that seems a lot simpler at first blush, with Elon reportedly terminating or driving away anyone who disagreed with him. Now Elon has finally admitted that fully automating their first large scale assembly line was a bad idea.