9 ms·
Apple’s HomePod Isn’t a Hot Seller
- threeseed 9y agoSlice is the same company that said the Apple Watch wasn't a hot seller either. So I would be taking this with a grain of salt. The fact is that we just don't know what Apple's internal targets are. Nor do I think lacklustre sales are all that worrisome anyway given that the HomePod quite firmly locks users into the Apple ecosystem e.g. only works with HomeKit and Apple Music.
- jrimbault 9y ago> Apple Watch wasn't a hot seller Is it a hot seller ? I don't know, but I don't see many smartwatches around me. The only one person I know who has one and wears it is the boss of a friend and they make iOS apps specifically. But I don't have any numbers, and I can't find really any...
- Twisell 9y agoApple Watch is the to selling smartwatch now as far as I know. So even if this is a niche market, Apple Watch is not a failure. Is smartwatch a hardware segment that will last is yet another question.
- votepaunchy 9y agoApple was the #1 global watchmaker by revenue before Apple Watch 3. https://www.wareable.com/apple/watch-sales-rolex-tim-cook-556 https://www.wareable.com/apple/watch-sales-rolex-tim-cook-55...
- jandrese 9y agoThat statistic seem cherry picked. Their competitors either sell absolutely tiny numbers of luxury watches or are basically commodities and operate with relatively thin margins. Competition in this space with both volume and profit margin is what? Rolex? Apple is basically a corporate behemoth that moved in next to the Mom & Pop boutiques.
- threeseed 9y ago8 million units shipped in 4Q 2017. 57.5% year on year growth. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/01/idc-data-apple-watch-on-top-of-wearables-market.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/01/idc-data-apple-watch-on-top-...
- jrimbault 9y agoIn the same article they say the market of wearables also has less choice and other makers are already pulling out.
- threeseed 9y agoBut that isn't a statement at all on the strength of the wearables market. It is just as likely to be a repeat of the smartphone market where we saw that Apple's ability to take all of the margins from an industry caused competitors to exit.
- y_molodtsov 9y agoOther manufacturers are pulling out since there's no new chips for the watches being developed, so it's getting much harder for them to compete with Apple and Samsung, the only companies able to produce their own chips for those.
- mrweasel 9y agoIs the Apple Watch er success? They sold reasonable well initially, but pretty much everyone I know who bought one sold it again within a year.
- RBerenguel 9y agoI got one without knowing whether I would be using it or not, and it has proven way more useful than expected (or, at least, way more "expected to be in my wrist), something I didn't realise until I had to bring it for repairs and went watchless for a week. Worth noting I had been watchless for the past 15 years or so (after wearing a watch daily before), so the change has been surprising even to me. Also, anecdata: I see a relatively large amount of people in the London tube with AWs. For a supposedly failed product they represent quite a sample.
- coldtea 9y agoPerhaps your friends are not representative then. They have been continuously selling more each year, and have multi-billion share of Apple's sales now. Apple speaks of "50 percent unit growth for 4th quarter in a row". (And of course eclipse in sales any other smart watch -- more than 10x times more). "Apple Watch Sales Soar To 8 Million In Last Quarter, Apple Owned 2017 Wearables Market" https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidphelan/2018/03/01/apple-watch-sales-soar-to-8-million-in-last-quarter-company-owned-2017-fitbit-huawei-garmin/#603395367e91 https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidphelan/2018/03/01/apple-wa... Report: 2017 brings huge Apple Watch growth, 18 million units, up 54% YoY https://9to5mac.com/2018/02/06/apple-watch-2017-sales/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/02/06/apple-watch-2017-sales/
- SirHound 9y agoI believe it. Siri is woeful. Plus they sell it as a high quality speaker yet it has no line-in for me to use with my entertainment system. For £350 that’s a hard pass from this Apple fanboy.
- make3 9y agois Siri that bad compared to the other home assistants? from what I've seen at least, it feels pretty similar to google assistant and alexa (which imho is strictly worse than google assistant, but that's just an opinion)
- SirHound 9y agoI can’t speak for the other voice assistants but I use Siri purely for setting timers. If I try to ask anything remotely more adventurous it’s a crapshoot. Something as simple as “Hey Siri turn the living room lights off” is often turned into a full discussion because it misheard “turn” and is too stupid to infer it from the rest of the sentence.
- briandear 9y agoTry this: “Hey Siri, how do you say ‘what is the correct voltage for this outlet?’ in French?” The real time translation for the 5 or so supported languages is pretty incredible. I use it when I can’t think of the correct French to use if I have a worker visit my house (like an electrician, etc.)
- Spooky23 9y agoI think Siri is better than Alexa, worse than Google. Apple’s lockdown on the api makes it less useful in some ways, but I think it handles queries better. Alexa seems formulaic to me. Google is under appreciated — imo its way more capable. HomePod Siri is dumber, which 10x the irritation.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoWould agree. We started with the Echo and replaced with the Google home.
- aqzman 9y agoAs with all Apple products, I'm sure Apple will iterate on this and keep making a better product until it can rival Google Home and Amazon Echo. It seems quite often that Apple first generation of new products (huge exception for the original iPhone) can't really compete with competitors, but very quickly, in two or three generations, they end up with the best product on the market. Although what really surprised me in this article is that Google Home only has 14% of the market share while Amazon Echo has 73%. I had assumed that their market shares were much closer, but according to the article Echo is out selling Google Home more than 5 to 1!
- simcop2387 9y agoA large part of that I think is that Amazon got to the market first. That let them get into consumer hands earlier, and 3rd party Dev hands too. Thats given them an edge in support for most random home automation stuff and other services.
- realusername 9y ago> huge exception for the original iPhone That was the case the original iPhone as well, I would say the iPhone really took-off on it's second version.
- struppi 9y agoYes. The original iPhone was: Firs, a big wow. Then a longer series of disappointments over the next few months. I remember I didn't buy the first iPhone because you could not write apps for it for the first 9 months or so (Just with JavaScript or a hacked version of XCode). And it was slow and could not do many things that other phones could do at that time. Bought an Android soon after and so far, I have stayed. But that might change, because of the different privacy policies of the two companies.
- jammi 9y agoI bought the first iPhone a couple of months after release, which was in August or September 2007. The first jailbreak allowing your own software to be run on one was the reason I got one. I and everyone I showed it to were blown away by what was doable with it with custom software. The CLI-only hacked SDK was pretty hard to set up and use, but it was still better than what was available for other phones. Used it jailbroken into 2011, when I finally replaced it with an iPhone 4, which in its turn ran jailbroken until 2014. That was when I got an iPhone 6, which I'm still on and I haven't jailbroken it, because Apple more or less caught up in stock iOS with the more important jailbreak hacks around that time. It seems like iPhone 6 will be phone I'll use for the longest time, because it's still fast enough and works fine.
- kondro 9y agoI'd prefer to see the HomePod compared to the speaker market. I would bet that it sells better than Sonos.
- Robadob 9y agoThe article includes market share and revenue share for Sonos One, which HomePod is higher in both.
- opencl 9y agoIt included the Sonos One, but none of their other models because they aren't smart speakers.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoSelling only 2 million in 2018 sounds pretty bad. Google sold 6 million in just 10 weeks. https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/5/16855982/google-home-sales-figures-holidays-2017 https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/5/16855982/google-home-sales... Google sold over 6 million Home speakers since mid-October - The ...
- coldtea 9y agoOr that's what some report says. They were numerous such reports about the iPhone X -- after it was made available and until Apple published their quarterly results, and it became evident that all those reports and analysts speaking of bad sales were all bogus. HomePod might or might not have sold well. But not because some BS report says so.
- guyzero 9y agoThe single largest app used across all smart speakers is Spotify, so it's not surprising that the lack of third-party streaming service support hampers HomePod.
- spiderfarmer 9y agoTrue. I went for a Spotify Connect enabled receiver with quality speakers. If see no need for Siri.
- ddjfaegjhc 9y agoYou can also get a chromecast audio for $35 and even connect it with optical. Great way to get support for spotify and multiple other services.
- jandrese 9y agoI did not know that. It's Apple Music or the highway on the HomePod? That seems like a serious design flaw for a smart speaker.
- kristianc 9y ago> During the HomePod’s first 10 weeks of sales, it eked out 10 percent of the smart speaker market, compared with 73 percent for Amazon’s Echo devices and 14 percent for the Google Home, according to Slice Intelligence. Time and again, Apple has shown that they just don't really care about market share metrics. Apple cares about making money, and it is very good at it. It's self-evident that an expensive device that works only with iPhones isn't going to command the market device of a $50 device that works across many different services. What is the ASP of those other devices? How much revenue is Amazon / Google making per user? > Apple had an opportunity to put the HomePod at the center of a new ecosystem of smart home and other gadgets that aren’t glued to the iPhone. But the small, wireless speaker is not that product. Though the HomePod delivers market-leading audio quality, consumers have discovered it’s heavily dependent on the iPhone and is limited as a digital assistant. Apple clearly hasn't chosen that strategy, otherwise, by definition, the device wouldn't be limited to iPhone and Apple Music. Amazon and Google's strategies make sense because Amazon is invested in getting you buying more stuff, and Google wants your data to train its model. Apple doesn't actually have that much other stuff to hook you into - it has HomeKit-enabled devices, but it is the other manufacturers that make money from those, not Apple. And how many people actually have a Nest anyway? If a HomePod becomes a thin client for expensive HomeKit gear, it becomes less, not more useful. It's a profitable smart speaker product for audiophiles, and it doesn't _try_ to be anything else.
- baldfat 9y ago> consumers have discovered it’s heavily dependent on the iPhone and is limited as a digital assistant Wouldn't this be based on Apple's privacy policy and lack of ability to do AI well with the data only available on a single device? https://www.barrons.com/articles/is-apple-falling-behind-in-the-artificial-intelligence-race-1504625700 https://www.barrons.com/articles/is-apple-falling-behind-in-...
- have_faith 9y agoAlso: "first 10 weeks of sales, it eked out 10 percent of the smart speaker market" If you worked at a company and released a product that took 10% of the market within 10 weeks of launching you would be celebrating.
- heavymark 9y agoWe bought several HomePods with the intention of replacing our Echos and Sonos. Though we knew the current version would only be a Sonos replacement and would take a few software updates before closing the gap with Echo/Google. Apple knows it can't compete with them yet, which is why it focused as a Sonos competitor at launch until presumably iOS 12 when Siri will see a sizable update to better compete as well as offering more basic offerings such as multiple user recognition, stereo paring, brevity mode, intercom mode, Home App automation integration and such. It will be a great product and think the price and being limited to Apple Music for now isn't a major problem but the Siri limitations and other items noted above are even for people in the Apple eco system. Once those are fixed and most heavy Apple users have one, then they will eventually lower the price, open up to third party apps, and the masses will come. Let's just hope they update throughout the year often rather than waiting for long stretches like the other product lines.
- vondur 9y agoIt's not surprising, it's basically a luxury item at its current price point vs. the Amazon Echo.
- snissn 9y agoI didn't realize it was released
- natch 9y agoIf Apple Music was cheaper, maybe they would sell more. I mean sure, Apple Music is great, but I'm doing just fine without it. But I would consider it if the price was lower. Yes the price could be considered low by some people when you look at the value, but I have to look at all my different subscriptions, and it sticks out as higher than the others.
- candiodari 9y agoIn that regard, does anyone know a way to get either the google speaker, alexa dot, or apple homepod something like that playing mp3 files ?
- ariwilson 9y agogoogle home: bluetooth from your device or upload from your device to google play music and use that
- NathanOsullivan 9y agoGoogle home works as an audio Chromecast target, so you can play MP3 from any app that supports Chromecast audio playback. Personally I use Plex.
- lowtolerance 9y agoYou could AirPlay it to the HomePod. It also supports FLAC.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoYou can upload 25000 mp3s to Google Music for free — no subscription and no ads. Then just ask the speaker to play them or cast from your phone.
- jbob2000 9y agoI've been subscribed to Apple Music for about a year now. I like the tight integration with the Apple ecosystem, but it leaves a lot to be desired. For one, the curated playlists and radio stations are garbage. It seems like Apple has some deals with a few artists or labels and shoves them down your throat. Their recommendation engine is terrible too, it's just another way for them to promote these artists. The front page of Apple music is often filled with hip hop and pop artist garbage as well. I don't listen to this, I hate seeing trashy looking hip hop artists and empty-faced pop divas every time I open the app. In Canada, they have an entire section dedicated to Francophone music. This isn't Apple's fault, our government requires it, but it's just wasted space for me, I don't listen to french music, give me an option to hide this crap. It does one thing well, and that's it: "I have a song stuck in my head and want to listen to it now". Even then, I find myself going to YouTube more often than not.
- kristofferR 9y agoI would have bought it if it had Spotify and/or Bluetooth support.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoSurprised that Apple released in current state as clearly not ready. Saw estimates are now for 2 million to be sold in 2018. https://9to5mac.com/2018/04/13/kgi-homepod-sales-cheaper-model/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/04/13/kgi-homepod-sales-cheaper-mod... KGI: Apple could sell just 2 million HomePods across all of 2018, company 'mulls' low-cost model
- forkLding 9y agoWhy is Apple HomePod worth so much more than Amazon Echo? Is the technology fundamentally more advanced? Or is this just a marketing position to elevate the price point so that it can be seen as a luxury good?
- berberous 9y agoHomePod is a _much_ better speaker than the Amazon Echo. For playing music, the Echo is terrible. The more appropriate comparisons would be to the Google Home Max ($400) or the Sonos line (Play:1 is $200, Play:3 is $250 and Play:5 is $500, with the HomePod probably somewhere in between the 3 and 5 in terms of sound quality). All that said, Apple is foregoing a big opportunity by not making a cheaper equivalent of the HomePod like Echo Dot or Google Home Mini. Those devices sound terrible, but consumers are happy enough with them given the price point.
- gormz 9y agoconsumers are happy because no one listens to music from an echo dot
- dragonwriter 9y agoI don't know about Echo Dot, but I definitely use my Home Mini for music. It's nothing special in that role, but actually better than I would expect, and music isn't the main use (controlling content being cast to the TV is a lot bigger use than listening to music from the speaker.) I guess I can understand getting one of the premium (Home Max, HomePod, etc.) smart speakers if direct music playback on the speaker is your main use case, though even people for whom that is the main use case often seem happy with the mid-range units like the regular Echo and Google Home.
- gormz 9y agoYeah for sure. I just think that the full sized echo or the google home plays fairly good music. I don't see much of a use for the home max or the homepods. What do I know though, I have 3' tall cerwin vegas in my living room and can't comprehend why someone would want something smaller
- vosper 9y agoReviews that I've read of the HomePod consistently say that the sound is fantastic, possibly class-leading. But they all also consistently complain about the degree of lock-in to the Apple ecosystem. Most of them conclude that the lock-in is a crippling flaw that drastically limits the appeal of the speaker.
- throwaway84742 9y agoI suppose it’s the same as Apple Watch which initially “didn’t sell” and now dominates the smart watch market and is pretty much the only sane choice for non-nerds.
- Someone 9y ago”it eked out 10 percent of the smart speaker market, compared with 73 percent for Amazon’s Echo devices and 14 percent for the Google Home” Given the earlier ”grabbed about a third of the U.S. smart speaker market in unit sales”, let’s assume this is in units, too. Guessing at average sale prices of $100 for Amazon, $129 for Google, $350 for Apple and $150 for ‘others’, that would give them about 25% of the market (1) in dollars. _If_ that’s ballpark correct and _if_ they manage to keep that up, I wouldn’t call it a failure, certainly not considering that, in their other products, their margins are higher than those of their competitors. (1) if that’s their market. That’s arguable. Some people think they compete with audio systems more than with smart speakers (¿for now?)
- realdlee 9y ago$30-40 for average sale prices for Amazon/Google is probably more accurate.
- talltimtom 9y agoApple wanted to use it as a vehicle to compete against Spotify. Which ironically just meant people didn’t cinder it a competetor to google home and Alexa.