9 ms·
In fact, I think the author is underestimating the impact, right here: "Of course, making this change will have a dramatic impact on your revenue for single-vis
by rossdavidh 9y ago
In fact, I think the author is underestimating the impact, right here: "Of course, making this change will have a dramatic impact on your revenue for single-visit traffic, because you basically have to design your ad model to work completely differently from how it works today."
No, it will basically make a newsmedia site unprofitable. I think it is the EU that has not fully thought this through. Most of the news industry is already sickly, financially, and they mostly have no model other than advertising (with a very few exceptions). The reason all this data got collected, was to try to make the advertising valuable enough that they could sell it. It may be that it never really worked, but it sure won't work without it. I think either the EU will backtrack on this once they see that Google and Facebook can easily force people to consent (because people consider those websites too valuable to do without), but most other advertising-supported media cannot; or they will see that the long-term impact of this is that it accelerates the current death spiral of newsmedia, as all ad spending goes to Google and Facebook and almost no one else.
I leave it as an open question as to whether this would be a good or bad thing.
- beojan 9y ago> No, it will basically make a newsmedia site unprofitable. I think it is the EU that has not fully thought this through. Most of the news industry is already sickly, financially, and they mostly have no model other than advertising (with a very few exceptions). We have publicly funded broadcasters in most EU countries. The ad-supported news sites, on the other hand, are generally doing more harm than good. News outlets existed before the web, so they're not going to be threatened by breaking the ad-supported website model. If anything, the traditional newspapers will be saved by this, because if free online news disappears, people will start buying newspaper subscriptions again. > I think either the EU will backtrack on this once they see that Google and Facebook can easily force people to consent They can't. The consent has to be for a specific purpose.
- Eyas 9y ago> News outlets existed before the web, so they're not going to be threatened by breaking the ad-supported website model. If anything, the traditional newspapers will be saved by this, because if free online news disappears, people will start buying newspaper subscriptions again. We're also seeing very concerning trends in the readerships and profitability of print media (because of the Web, many think). So I don't think you can use the "News outlets existed before the web" line, without much more justification.
- ozim 9y agoI do not think it is bad, I think that is evolution. Ads only content is total crap. We have to teach people to pay for content. Second part is we have to teach publishers not to be greedy. Just like iTunes with music, easy small payments, not subscribtions no one wants. Maybe they could make actually some use of crypto currencies but there would have to be strong player like apple to press for consensus. Otherwise each one would like to have its own payment system and charge others for using it.
- beojan 9y ago> Maybe they could make actually some use of crypto currencies but there would have to be strong player like apple to press for consensus. I doubt it. Cryptocurrencies seem to be terrible for micropayments.
- beojan 9y agoThat's my point. Get rid of the free “news" sites and people will start paying for print media (and digital subscriptions) again.
- dragonwriter 9y agoPrint news media was dying for decades before online media came online, and was almost entirely paid for by ads (many local publications were and are free of charge, and many of the paid ones charged primarily to have paid circulation numbers and shape the socioeconomic demographics of their audience, both of which were and are mechanisms to boost advertising revenue.)
- distances 9y ago> Print news media was dying for decades before online media came online Any sources for this? I don't think this was the case at all at least in my part of Europe.
- 9y ago
- krotton 9y agoPublically funded TV is prone to become a propaganda tube of the government. In some cases it already has (in Poland for example). Relying on it as the only news source would be silly (relying on a single news source in general is usually silly, but even more if the government directly handles the staffing).
- lossolo 9y agoBBC is counterargument to what you wrote. It shows that publicly founded news outlets can work without being government propaganda tube.
- filoleg 9y agoHis argument wasn't that all state-funded news media is a propaganda machine. His argument was that it easily can become one, and you won't have a better option, since all the other news media would be choked out of existence.
- lossolo 9y ago> since all the other news media would be choked out of existence. There are other private TV outlets in those countries in EU and this legislation will not change it. Lets stop being paranoid and portraying legislation that should protect our privacy as something that will destroy democracy.
- andromeduck 9y agoThat's just going to fuel nationalism.
- tormeh 9y agoYou should never rely exclusively on domestic media. There's always too much conflict of interest. In state media this is obvious, but it's there for private media as well.
- davidcbc 9y agoYou don't see the potential problem if the only media that is able to exist is that which is state sponsored? You may be happy with the state sponsored options now, but will that always be the case? Would you feel the same if you living in the Soviet Union or Germany circa 1940?
- adventured 9y agoHow about Hungary 2020? Poland 2022? Strong emphasis that I'm not equating those to your examples. Rather, pointing out that even a subtle version of undesirable or extreme politics can lead to a similar concern. Given the wild political swing going on in about half of Europe, it's a legitimate concern today, no need to look back 80 years. Not to mention persistently growing censorship and criminalization of speech in more liberal countries such as France.
- martin_bech 9y agoHow is CNN, Fox News and the sinclair group, working out for you guys? I trust state paid media in the EU, way more than any US news media. The reason why most EU countries have state paid media, is so that its non commercial, non partisan, and cant be bought. There are different principles in place, so government has no say, in what is broadcast/not broadcast. This also means that all political parties get the same amount of exposure etc.
- home_boi 9y agoI don't read news but I'm sure that GDPR would hurt the smaller, independent news websites or aggregators that people find reputable more than CNN, Fox News and sinclair group. The latter at least have TV advertising. Their website is just horizontal integration for them.
- davidcbc 9y agoCNN isn't great journalism, but it isn't the only source of information. The problems with Fox News and Sinclair aren't based on advertising, they are based on ownership. State sponsored media isn't going to be any better under an autocrat and will in fact be worse than the situation in the US because there may not be any other options.
- return0 9y ago> We have publicly funded broadcasters in most EU countries. That would be a terrible dependency for eastern europe, you wouldn't want putin-friendly government media teaching people what to vote next.
- lossolo 9y agoThere is only one "eastern europe" country that is really Putin friendly and it's Hungary, the rest is anti Putin.
- bklaasen 9y agoMany urban, educated folks in Serbia see Putin as a better ally than any European leader.
- lossolo 9y agoI think you could find a lot of pro Putin people in EU. Some of my family members are pro Putin while I live in probably the most anti-Putin country in EU. I could elaborate more about reasons for that but I don't want to digress too much from original discussion.
- distances 9y agoThat's probably due to the rather unusual recent history of Serbia I assume
- tomaskafka 9y agoLet me tell you how it works in central/eastern europe - ad-supported sites are financially sick, but more and more 'info' is spread out by well funded russian propaganda sites (imo they carry the ads only to seem 'legit'). They will thrive even more :(.
- tormeh 9y agoIs there anything that can be done about this? The whole situation is surreal. Surely it must be possible to decrease these sites impact without having to resort to censorship. It's just 21st century propaganda. Fun fact: oligarchs in Greece have been doing this to their own country for financial gain for decades. Most Greek newspapers are mouthpieces for the interests of the great families.
- Bizarro 9y agoWe have publicly funded broadcasters in most EU countries. The ad-supported news sites, on the other hand, are generally doing more harm than good. Why am I not surprised that a European is saying that the government-backed "broadcaster" are all so good, and evil private American new sites are bad. this pretty much sums up the real agenda behind GDPR. It would be better to call the bluff of these EUrocrats and see what they'll really do. Other countries can retaliate.
- ItsMe000001 9y ago> Why am I not surprised that a European is saying that the government-backed "broadcaster" are all so good, and evil private American new sites are bad. You are not surprised because you have a gigantic filter in your head that turns everything into exactly what you already expect regardless of what it is. The second part of that sentence makes it quite clear what your mindset is.
- ionised 9y agoWhy am I not surprised that an American is crying over potential harm to unethical business practices of some of its most darling corporations by an EU rule to protect its citiziens. Every time the EU implements some law or regulation regarding control of personal data and privacy, someone (an American) has to dismiss all the problems those laws are intended to address entirely, and go on to post some defensive, nationalist spiel about it being an attack on US companies. Perhaps the problem is that these companies make their money in an incredibly unethical way that an increasing number of people are very uncomfortable with? Stop turning this into something it isn't. All you are doing is poisoning the debate.
- elaus 9y agoWhy am I not surprised that a European is saying that the government-backed "broadcaster" are all so good, and evil private American new sites are bad. Nowhere in that comment I can find a reference to American (evil) news sites. There are more than enough private news sites based in Europe, so I wonder why you are so hell-bent on making this an EU vs US thing. Most EU residents will read news in their own language (which in most cases isn't English).
- GijsjanB 9y agoPrivacy first, profit second. I think that is a wise decision the EU makes (disclosure: I'm an EU citizen). 'The media' surviving on a distorted revenue model is not healthy and I will not believe it is necessary to break your customers privacy in order to make a profit.
- shripadk 9y agoOr it could go the other way. If all media outlets decide to put up a paywall it forces people to actually pay for reading the news. Currently there are a few news outlets who plead for ad blockers to be turned off while still offering content for free. And since ad blockers allow you to add exceptions this doesn't create a level playing field between those outlets that advertise and those that are locked behind a paywall. GDPR might end up forcing the outlets reliant on advertising to also shift to paywalls effectively creating the level playing field that was lacking earlier. Let's face it, despite social media being a great enabler for realtime news the quality of news is sub-par. The biggest bane of social media is the transfer of responsibility of filtering real news from a firehose of fake news, to the end user. Until that issue is solved people are going to probably pay for news. This is just my speculation of how things might go after GDPR.
- rimliu 9y ago> No, it will basically make a newsmedia site unprofitable. Good. We don't need that much "news" anyway. And I think my need would be more than covered by national TV which is sponsored by taxpayers money and BBC, which also has no advertising. There really won't be much of the value lost if we won't have sensationalized and invented news any more. Another point to consider is that need for news or just for some brain filler: I am puzzled by appareant inability of many today to be alone and in silence. As if then some thought that they cannot be comfortable with start to be loud enough to be heard.
- Bizarro 9y agoGood. We don't need that much "news" anyway. The "we" is where you have a problem.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rimliu 9y agoOk, care to share why you personally need to be fed news 24/7. What's so important and fulfilling to know about the latest antics of some celebrity, or some crime blown out of the proportion so much that you will think a killer is waiting for you on each corner, etc. What value does it add apart from creating more anxiety? Not to mention that news tend to misreport things a lot. (https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-gell-mann-amnesia-effect-is-as-follows-you https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-ge...)
- Arqu 9y agoI completely disagree with this. Firstly, the media currently are too lucrative for my taste and thats why we have everyone being a journalist and publisher. By cutting down on the easy money, only those worth surviving will probably stand. This will seriously cut down on more than just ads, ie fake news and unverified sources. An alternative I'd love to see is sponsored articles as the main source of income for these. Let the corporations have to pay bigger bucks to have their posts published. This will hopefully reduce the clutter, force the media outlets to provide quality content to keep a certain level of trust and quality to attract businesses as well as a good targeted audience. Personally I'd live to have most media completely in the dark about visitors to solely speculate on the quality of their own content. Only metric they need is daily visitor count. Everything else can be shaped by type and quality of content. A great example is HN where we have a very targeted audience due to the content it serves. It obviously also has some sponsored articles but also the indirect benefits it has on new startups and so on. Just treat it as TV marketing and not a per person customized monetization strategy.
- nopriorarrests 9y ago>This will seriously cut down on more than just ads, ie fake news and unverified sources. Why do you think so? I don't see clickbait industry seriously affected. They churn out a ton of crappy content which costs almost nothing to produce (at least if compared with reputable journalistic work), monetize it with low quality ads for shitty CPM rates, but as long as part of their content goes viral, tons and tons of pageviews allow to balance everything. GDPR changes nothing in this business.
- Arqu 9y agoThere has to be some limit to how low they can go cost wise in delivering crap. Also as it becomes harder to get big bucks, people will shift to other lines of crap work. GDPR in my mind influences this indirectly in the long run. It's not like it will kill fake news the week after.
- exolymph 9y ago> Firstly, the media currently are too lucrative for my taste and thats why we have everyone being a journalist and publisher. As someone who works in media: I'm sorry, what? Publishing is certainly not more lucrative than ever, and publishing online now is a far worse business than publishing a physical newspaper pre-cable TV. The proliferation of outlets is due to lower barriers to entry and less need for capex. Plus a little bit of VC optimism.
- majani 9y agoPublishers are getting squeezed out of the web by various forces. There is this GDPR, then there is also the web giants Facebook and Google squeezing them with their algorithms and in-app browsers. However, I'd say the net effect is positive because I'm seeing the lowest quality aggregator type blogs getting squeezed out and the only ones that are standing strong are the well funded publishers, which means better content.
- tanilama 9y agoI thought about it before. Yeah it will make analytics driven journalism unprofitable. But why this is a bad thing anyway? The old subscription model works and the quality of the content is high.
- home_boi 9y ago> In fact, I think the author is underestimating the impact, right here: "Of course, making this change will have a dramatic impact on your revenue for single-visit traffic, because you basically have to design your ad model to work completely differently from how it works today." To add to this, the quote paints complying with the legislation as a simple redesign. It would require much more than a redesign. The technical, administrative and legal costs of implementing the new system from scratch would be magnitudes higher than implementing the current system from scratch. And add on changing requirements as the legislation is in its infancy.
- harperlee 9y agoTelevision and newsPAPERs were viable businesses before the advent of the internet. And on the internet, the need to spy your reader is also quite new. What makes privacy-sensible internet newsmedia nonviable might very well be the much more profitable spying on the client. If regulation makes that competition illegal, and demand for news is unaffected by GDPR (and why wouldn't it be), then it becomes more difficult for advertising companies to find newsmedia that provide tht extra illegal profit-taking sugar, so they will go back to more traditional advertising plans. This, in turn, will make newsmedia's lives easier in regards to finding advertiser's that do not demand spying on their readers. At the end, sellers still need to advertise, providing ads supply, and readers still demand free newsreading, providing ad demand. The market still exists.
- eksemplar 9y agoI don’t think the EU has thought it through. I work in a municipality in Denmark, one of the most digitized public sectors in the EU and we’re not anywhere close to being ready. None of the hundreds of suppliers we use are truly ready, and how would they be? It took 45 years to build this tech, you can’t just replace the innards in a few years. Estonia is the only country that is close to ready, and that’s mostly because they’ve build their entire system with a focus on sharing and securing data. Nobody else has anything close to it. It’ll be interesting to see how this plays out in the courts. I mean, keeping privacy data safe should be an important concern, but do we really want to close hospitals and schools because we can’t afford to pay the fines when it fails?
- tscs37 9y agoNothing about ads on the internet implies tracking. The most simplest solution is that newspapers host the ad on their own server as a .png or .jpg that gets shown to all visitors. It's tracking free and GDPR compliant.