7 ms·
Tracing doping use by amateur athletes from wastewater
- davesque 9y agoPretty interesting. I worked in the athletics (cycling) industry for around 5 years and I always suspected that there's a lot of doping among amateur athletes. From what I understand, it's most common in amateur cycling among masters racers.
- mi100hael 9y agoAnabolics are also very prevalent in the lifting/bodybuilding world at all levels including amateur circles. IIRC it was legal up until the 90s, and enforcement is a low priority for LEO. Hell, Ronnie Coleman was a cop for a long time.
- scott_s 9y agoBodybuilding and powerlifting have both tested and untested federations. The untested federations tacitly approve PEDs. (And people in the tested federations, at least for powerlifting, are often caught for PEDs.) Weightlifting, as far as I know, has no untested federations. To the grandparent post, you'll probably be interested in the recent documentary "Icarus". It's on Netflix.
- kurtisc 9y agoThere's the 'American Weightlifting Federation' which was created primarily so the founder could slam barbells.
- scott_s 9y agoI actually thought about that, but I didn't know if they were still around. I want to say I figured they tested, but I doubt they were big enough or organized enough to.
- trenninghard 9y agoComing from an amateur bodybuilder yes it is everywhere. I've been on for a couple years now. Once you've done some cycles you realize how many people use especially what is known as 'fake nattys', people who claim to not use publicly in interviews and Instagram etc but have physiques which could never be possible without gear. Most amateur sports from what I've found such as cycling (bikes not gear), martial arts, football, you can bet most people are using to some degree. The op mentioned masters class, and there's a tight correlation there to older men being prescribed trt. A lot of people also take that and then up the dose a bit more to the point where they're running a full cycle and should be taking an AI. That's another aspect as well where people will claim it's just trt dose, but no I'm sorry but when you got puffy nipples because of your trt dose and no AI you're on a full cycle.
- rmcpherson 9y agoDo you know why that is? It seems possible that it could be because masters racers started doping back before testing was prevalent/sensitive and now can't stop without a precipitous drop-off in performance that would raise eyebrows. Just conjecture though.
- mandrake-c-papi 9y agoMore likely because the masters guys have more disposable income and very little at stake if they get caught. With spare cash they've probably bought all the bike upgrades they can and are training as much as their spare time allows so doping is the easiest way to improve. Also, anything to slow the decline with age...
- sjburt 9y agoLikely a factor of financial means as well. There's a lot of spare-no-expense weekend warrior types in the Masters ranks, whereas the younger open racers tend to be scrappier. Also, it's probably somewhat of a "who cares anyway?" attitude. They're not gonna go pro, they're not getting tested, etc. Any kind of competition involves someone bending the rules, like it or not.
- obmelvin 9y agoThe difficult thing about anti-doping in amateur athletes is that the stakes are way too low to be testing that frequently, unless you are at the very top of the amateur range. And when you stop doping your fitness gains don't disappear if you continue to train. One of EPO's main benefits (as I understand it) is to improve recovery and allow one to train harder. So an athlete could use EPO for a year, training harder and more frequently than they otherwise would and then stop the next year and enter competition with a lot of their previous fitness gains carried over.
- notatoad 9y agothe reason masters racers dope is because nobody tests masters, and nobody really cares if masters racers dope (except for the other competitors).
- 9y ago
- OhDagny 9y agoThe most common abuse is probably steroids in weightlifters. They don't even have a sport, they just want to look buff.
- nradov 9y agoOutside Magazine had a great article where an amateur athlete experimented on himself by doping and reporting on the effects. https://www.outsideonline.com/1908791/i-couldnt-be-more-positive https://www.outsideonline.com/1908791/i-couldnt-be-more-posi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jbob2000 9y agoThis detection is easy to circumvent: use an outhouse or septic tank.
- CNJ7654 9y ago"Easy"
- lopmotr 9y agoThat's neither easy (where will you find access to those?) nor will it circumvent testing. It'll concentrate your waste in a septic tank that's clearly yours, not mixed with all the neighbors. These researchers measured waste water downstream where it was mixed from many people so they can't identify anyone individually.
- sevensor 9y agoI'd never heard of 2,4 DNP, so I looked it up. Nasty stuff, and I can't see how it would help performance. Apparently it reduces body fat, but has been deemed too dangerous to use since 1938. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2,4-Dinitrophenol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2,4-Dinitrophenol
- rjeli 9y agonot used for performance. used by bodybuilders to cut before competition
- stevenwoo 9y agoGenerally for most endurance sports, losing weight is gaining time. It's why one might see someone using a cocktail of drugs, some to help with endurance/O2 uptake others with lowering weight to affect both sides of the power/mass ratio.
- loeg 9y agoIt's a weight loss drug. I've done a rough categorization of the full list here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16777656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16777656 As far as why it counts as "doping" — it is probably used by body builders to drop body fat to competition levels. Anecdotally, without chemical help you are hungry all the time at 4-8 %bf. Also, the common wisdom among runners is that body fat is dead weight and losing it makes you faster and reduces load on your joints. So it may help there too. Cyclists probably see less benefit, but less fat may help acceleration and hill climb ability.
- refurb 9y agoFor those sports where there are weight classes, losing 5-10 pounds rapidly can move you from a weight class we're your average to a weight class where you dominate.
- nradov 9y agoYes this article confirms that professional cyclists in the Tour de France are under 6% and hungry all the time. But they have to be careful not to go too low or they run the risk of getting sick and dropping out of the race. https://www.outsideonline.com/2099881/how-skinny-are-top-tour-de-france-riders-really https://www.outsideonline.com/2099881/how-skinny-are-top-tou...
- mind_heist 9y agoHmm, How effective is this? I recently watched ICARUS and I have been reading a lot about doping and how athletes circumvent the tests done by WADA labs ( World Anti Doping Agency). I have a couple of questions regarding this and in no particular order of importance (1) Should a state decide to implement something like this, isn't this some sort of privacy violation by the state? People could have been prescribed these Anabolics by a physician too, don't they also come under the scanner? (2) Also, I don't clearly understand the sampling here, tons of gallons get pumped into the wastewater system. How much quantity of samples would be collected for testing purposes? and what is the frequency of these samples being collected? (3) Please totally excuse my ignorance here, the major banned substances for which athletes have been banned are "Methylhexaneamine", "Methenolone","Oxandrolone", and a lot of "Stanozolol" and "Turinabol" ( I m getting all this from this wiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doping_at_the_Olympic_Games#Disqualified_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doping_at_the_Olympic_Games#Di...). The table in the paper doesn't seem to mention any of these substances. Are they mentioned under a different name? (4) Also, in the light of new information (ie) state-sponsored doping, Lance Armstrong escaping some 500 Lab tests & going completing uncaught by WADA and so many other labs around the world, as a spectator I already know that a ton of Olympic athletes are doping. Isn't the actual problem trying to prove that "individual" athletes are doping? A collective evidence is probably not as useful anymore since all watchdogs, sports committees and spectators are more skeptical from the get go.
- Someone 9y agoI think part of the thinking behind this is just scientific curiosity (“let’s see if we can do it”) They collect the wastewater kilometers from the sporting events, so spatial and temporal resolution (where was this dumped into the sewer? When?) will be too low to target individual users. Application I think will at best be for policy development (what sport should the doping agency focus on? What chemicals? Do people use that new thing that’s being talked about?), not for catching individual users, and probably not even for use at the event being monitored.
- loeg 9y ago(1) This is being measured in aggregate. It's no more privacy violating than, say, measuring the amount of non-recyclable trash that ends up at the recycling sorting facility. (2) Consult the methodology section. (3) Methylhexaneamine (DMAA, spelled "methylhexanamine" in the article) is the 3rd highest thing in the table. There are several other anabolic steroids in the table (see list below). Chemicals tend to sell under several different brand names and your list may intersect the article's list. It's also possible the article's list just contains a different set of chemicals. To categorize briefly (the list is heavily steroid-focused): Aromatase inhibitor (prevent aromatization of androgens into Estrogen): Anastrozole, Clomiphene, Tamoxifen Masking steroid use: Finasteride (new tests obsolete this, at least for pros) PED/Weight loss: Clenbuterol Stimulants: Norephedrine, Ephedrine, Methylhexanamine (DMAA) Steroids: Trenbolone, Nandrolone, Metenolone, Mibolerone, Metandienone Weight loss: Sibutramine, 2,4-Dinitrophenol Also note Table 1, which shows (basically) how quickly various PEDs degrade at different temperatures. Several of them degrade in 0-1 days at 20° or 4°C. So unless a large population is taking them (ephedrine), they tend to drop off of test results. The other consideration is LOD / LOQ (limit of detection, limit of quantitation) — lower levels here ease detection and measurement. (4) This study is targeted more broadly at the recreational athlete population, rather than pro athletes.
- homero 9y agoWhat if you flush a lot just to mess with anyone testing it?
- gitgreen 9y agoIt's less about catching violators and more about understanding the epidemiology of PED abuse. It may be possible to isolate populations that need direct testing but by that point you're putting traps on every sewer pipe associated with an event, it'd just be easier to test everybody directly.
- BRAlNlAC 9y agoor, you know, just piss on the ground outside.
- nradov 9y agoThe same basic technique was used to study the prevalence of cocaine use in several European cities. They analyzed the level of drug metabolites in sewer water. http://www.emcdda.europa.eu/topics/pods/waste-water-analysis_en http://www.emcdda.europa.eu/topics/pods/waste-water-analysis...