12 ms·
What are Pros supposed to do in the mean time? Keep buying PCs I guess. Why haven't they kept selling the cheese grater is beyond me. They are spending a fortu
by tambourine_man 9y ago
What are Pros supposed to do in the mean time? Keep buying PCs I guess.
Why haven't they kept selling the cheese grater is beyond me.
They are spending a fortune to understand what Pros need, while we have been screaming for the better part of the decade: lots of user accessible RAM, storage, PCI & GPU. How much would it cost R&D to update the Mac Pro? Teenagers can do it for peanuts, I'm sure the largest company in the freaking world could manage. If they were truly sorry or marginally “cared”, that's what they would have done years ago.
I'm fine with them playing the “let's reinvent the Pro computer” game as a side project, they have this massive amount of money burning a whole in their pockets after all, but some of us need to work.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoPros are supposed to buy an iMac Pro in the meantime, and then buy the modular Mac Pro Pro with all the pro trimmings - iPads for touch control, and such - when it all arrives next year. It's going to be interesting to see if they stick with Intel for the Pro. It's entirely possible they won't, especially given Intel's security issues. What that means for performance remains to be seen.
- jbigelow76 9y agoIt's going to be interesting to see if they stick with Intel for the Pro. Wouldn't the apps that the pro users dictate that to a large extent? If the truly "pro" apps don't get rebuilt against ARM then it would be like Apple never really released the Mac Pro if they ditch Intel so early into its return.
- walshemj 9y agoI think they meant go AMD Reyzen2 or more likely Eypc (or possibly Rome.) Arm is not going to cut it in the dual Zeon workstation role
- kevindqc 9y agoAren't Apple developing their own CPUs?
- std_throwaway 9y agoThey are supposedly not directly x86 compatible and thus will need to emulate it at a performance penalty. Not something you'd want in a "pro" machine.
- jsight 9y agoI don't see that as the major problem. It seems like they could rely on third parties to have them ported in a matter of a few months. I'm more doubtful of their ability to produce something sufficiently competitive.
- wlesieutre 9y agoEven if they were fast enough you would still want to launch those chips on less performance critical machines first and give the pro apps plenty of time to update before migrating the pro hardware. Usually consumer software moves faster to adopt new tech stacks anyway. OS X supported x86-64 in v10.5 in 2007, but Photoshop didn’t go 64-bit on Mac until 2010 with CS5. My best guess is that it’s because big pro applications have a mess of dependencies and some inner guts in the high performance code where it drops to assembly. Building that for alternate architectures isn’t as simple as checking a box in Xcode.
- walshemj 9y agoIf going from almost a standing start to fabing chips that compete on par with intel was that easy some one else (elon musk or china) would have done it already. I am sure major shareholders of apple will not want to bankroll a 7nm fab and the massive massive costs in producing a competitor to AMD and INTEL
- solarkraft 9y ago
- plussed_reader 9y agoRosetta 2: Stone Harder
- solarkraft 9y agoNo Intel != no x86. There's this one company that also makes x86 CPUs.
- Redoubts 9y agoThey could at least spec bump the trash can. Thermal design issues aside, performance per watt has only gotten better for the design they already had, right?
- dfabulich 9y agoThey said they can't spec bump it. https://daringfireball.net/2017/04/the_mac_pro_lives https://daringfireball.net/2017/04/the_mac_pro_lives > I think we designed ourselves into a bit of a thermal corner, if you will. We designed a system with the kind of GPUs that at the time we thought we needed, and that we thought we could well serve with a two GPU architecture. That that was the thermal limit we needed, or the thermal capacity we needed. But workloads didn’t materialize to fit that as broadly as we hoped.
- steve_musk 9y agoSeems like a poor excuse. Just add in modern CPUs with the same TDP, and for the GPUs two Quadro 5000s (I think even the 6000 would work) have lower TDP than the FirePro D700s currently used.
- ksec 9y agoTo be more precise, according to Anandtech, their design wasn't able to cool 250W GPU in it. This significantly limit the GPU selection they had. The biggest problem is how they didn't know this when they were designing it? And how they managed to find out in 2014 and didn't spoke a word until 2017. And now their answer is 2019. Not to mention, as the OP suggest, they could have fitted Modern Intel CPU and 150W Vega GPU in it, and sell it for lower price.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoNo, they're spending a fortune redefining what "Pro" means in order to make everyone feel like they're a pro and need pro hardware.
- gutnor 9y ago> What are Pros supposed to do in the mean time? Keep buying PCs I guess. > How much would it cost R&D to update the Mac Pro? I hope/think that Apple is thinking that bringing back the cheese grater or in other word a PC running MacOS is not going to be enough to bring back the pro. They need to come back with something that has something unique. The TrashCan failed but you can see where Apple was going. A small, silent, powerful machine infinitely customisable on the fly via TB. So of course if failed and this attempt has a good chance to fail too. I'm not quite sure that Apple has in its DNA the deep understanding of the type of Pro that are not content with either the iMac Pro or MBP in the same fashion they get the consumer sphere. It is just that for a long period of time the intersection between the 2 world was large but are now diverging. Perfectly happy for me to be wrong though.
- sangnoir 9y ago> I hope/think that Apple is thinking that bringing back the cheese grater or in other word a PC running MacOS is not going to be enough to bring back the pro. Before they can think of "bringing back the pro", they need to stop the bleeding: pros who need to upgrade this year have no choice but to go PC. An upgraded cheese-grater would have been a good stop-gap while they go back to the drawing board on their 2019 product.
- copperx 9y agoCertainly. Right now I program Rails on an old 2012 MBPr. I want to get a faster machine. Possibilities: 1) Spend 5k on a iMac Pro. That's an absurd amount of money. 2) Get a new MBP limited by USB C, new keyboard, and the abominable Touchbar. That's a lot of money for a downgrade. 3) Get a decent specced iMac or Mac Mini. Most viable option. 4) Ditch Rails, start learning .NET, so I can go Windows 100% to build my own PC. I save money. I lose a lot of time. 5) Build PC, install Linux. Viable but might be a configuration nightmare. I just want to work. 6) Run Linux under Windows host as a VM. Second most viable option. I'm pretty frustrated. Suggestions?
- 88 9y ago7) Build a Hackintosh
- robbyt 9y agoThe margins are too thin on a boring desktop PC. If they spec bump the cheese grater, that will cannibalize the ground-breaking new Mac Pro. Same reason why they won't put it out this year, they don't want to cut into the imac pro sales.
- rbanffy 9y agoA crappy PC with a best-in-class 5K monitor can easily get more expensive than an iMac Pro.
- lancewiggs 9y agoSteve would have unreasonably said get it shipped by June 2018. And it would have shipped.