12 ms·
Pharo MOOC
- cosarara97 9y agoThis is kind of an offtopic question, but regardless: Is there any application written in smalltalk in the debian repository? (or any other linux distro)
- monocasa 9y agoThe only people I've heard of using Smalltalk at all other than in dogfood situations are people using Gemstone. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemstone_(database) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemstone_(database)
- spooneybarger 9y agoI know of a number of smaller business that are "as a service" that are built using Smalltalk.
- dunham 9y agoWay back in the day, "DabbleDB" was written in Smalltalk. (It was a Zenkit/Airtable type web app.) If I remember right, they had a separate image per customer and it took a moment to bring up the VM if hadn't been to the site in a while.
- e12e 9y agoSadly they got acqu-hired by twitter - and judging by some (not bad, just in lack of enthusiasm) comments, I got a sense that they sold dabbledb at peak technical/architectural debt... It's a bit sad, I appeared to be a Google sheets meets office 365 flows on steroids before either was any good: https://youtu.be/6wZmYMWKLkY https://youtu.be/6wZmYMWKLkY (i think that's from 2006 or so, archive.org has more info, but it's a bit painful to navigate on mobile) Avi Bryant comments on hn from time to time: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=avibryant https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=avibryant As I understand it, each customer got an image/vm - and data was just stored as Smalltalk objects. It'd been interesting to see where they might have gone if they coupled the dabbledb front end with gemstone/s.
- luser1024 9y agoGemstone provides a database. There are very large Smalltalk based applications that run using Gemstone as the backing database[1] . These applications are, for the most part, very large in-house applications that don't have much external visibility. [1] http://seaside.gemtalksystems.com/docs/OOCL_SuccessStory.pdf http://seaside.gemtalksystems.com/docs/OOCL_SuccessStory.pdf
- gaius 9y agoJPMorgan have a fairly serious Smalltalk app http://www.cincom.com/pdf/CS040819-1.pdf http://www.cincom.com/pdf/CS040819-1.pdf However, only one. Make of that what you will.
- ben-coman 9y agoThey only have on app because Smalltalk if agile enough they build everything they need into it as the need arises - and this has been maintained over many years.
- ben-coman 9y agoGemstone is not "using" Smalltalk. Gemstone "is-a" Smalltalk. Here are commercial companies that believe in Pharo (in the money on the table way of measuring belief) http://consortium.pharo.org/ http://consortium.pharo.org/
- flubert 9y agoInteresting. So am I right in assuming there are: - 9 bronze level (1k Euro/year) - 5 silver level (2k Euro/year) - 11 gold level (4k Euro/year) - 5 platinum level (8k Euro/year) ...members of the consortium (based on the color of the surround on the member label/icon)? So that would be ~103,000 Euro per year? Or is that signifying a one-time contribution (vs. recurring annual)? It doesn't look like there has been a consortium report published since 2015: http://consortium.pharo.org/web/reports http://consortium.pharo.org/web/reports ...any ideas what that means? (i.e. they stopped publishing them for privacy reasons, the consortium no longer has meetings, the consortium is no longer active, etc.?) Any ideas on what projects they are currently funding, and how many man-hours of programmer time are being purchased for Pharo in 2018?
- ben-coman 9y agoIts a recurring fee. Of course, its dependent on members feeling they are getting value for money and continuing each year. The platinum level was only recently created. I don't know what it means that there is not later reports. The consortium is definitely active. It arose because open source software is about people scratching an itch, and often the focus is on the fun stuff and not on the boring, difficult, dirty engineering required to make a product reliable and successful (e.g. operating a CI infrastructure). Pharo arose out of INRIA[1], one of France's publicly funded national research institutes. But their mission and governance structure is not suited to managing non-research engineers dedicated to working on Pharo. So InriaSoft[2] was created to fork off its successful software into consortiums funding pure engineering work on the software as an ongoing concern. At the moment the consortium has one full-time engineer, but hope to get another in the next couple of years if the consortium continues the current growth rate. AFAIK (I am not directly involved), the main efforts decided by consortium members were: * Stabilizing 32-bit to 64-bit conversion for Pharo, utilizing and contributing to the OpenSmalltalk-VM project. * Stablizing Iceberg as our Git/GUI interface * Maintaining CI infrastructure btw, There is also the Pharo Association with 82 individual members. [3] [1] https://www.inria.fr/en/institute/inria-in-brief/inria-in-a-few-words https://www.inria.fr/en/institute/inria-in-brief/inria-in-a-... [2] https://www.inria.fr/en/news/news-from-inria/launch-of-inriasoft-software-community https://www.inria.fr/en/news/news-from-inria/launch-of-inria... [3] https://association.pharo.org/ https://association.pharo.org/
- luser1024 9y agoThe first one that comes to mind is the scratch package[1]. The entire scratch language, as far as I know, runs on top of squeak [1] https://packages.ubuntu.com/source/trusty/scratch https://packages.ubuntu.com/source/trusty/scratch
- fusiongyro 9y agoDrGeo is a geometry package for education. http://www.drgeo.eu/ http://www.drgeo.eu/ MOOSE, which is some sort of code analysis tool: http://www.moosetechnology.org/ http://www.moosetechnology.org/ I've never been able to make heads or tails of it, but it's kind of an architect-level tool and I'm just a lowly engineer.
- smaili 9y agoIs anyone else having trouble viewing this on their phone?
- protomyth 9y agoOh yeah, it goes really slow and scrolling is broken and really off center. I gave up.
- jchook 9y agoCame to comments to see what this even is.
- shock 9y agoWorks well for me on Firefox/Android besides the video making the page wider than the screen width. What trouble are you having? Which browser/OS?
- jayonsoftware 9y agoEven if you are not going to develop any major apps in Smalltalk, its a language worth learning. Teaches you a lot about OO programming
- daveFNbuck 9y agoIsn't Pharo a different language from Smalltalk?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 9y agoThat's sort of like asking if Scheme is a different language than Lisp.
- leoc 9y agoIt started out as a fork of Squeak; IDK how much it has diverged since then.
- agumonkey 9y agoDon't know either, but the pharo MOOC I did a few years back only mentioned differences once or twice. I left with the feeling that beside a few, maybe syntax tweaks and new libs, it's 'same' enough.
- pronoiac 9y ago"Pharo is a pure object-oriented programming language in the tradition of Smalltalk. It offers a unique developing experience in constant interaction with live objects. ... When programming in Pharo, you are immersed in a world of live objects. You have immediate feedback at any moment of your development on objects representing web applications, code itself, graphics, network."
- evv 9y agoRandom off-topic feedback: the video is not correctly configured in Firefox (on MacOS). The pervasiveness of Chrome scares me sometimes.
- JepZ 9y ago> It is very easy to learn... > This Mooc is demanding but rewarding... So the language is easy to learn and yet the course to learn it is demanding? Interesting logic... Nevertheless, probably a good exercise for anybody who wants to learn what real Object Orientation is about and who didn't learn Smalltalk yet.
- CodeArtisan 9y agoThe language itself is simple[1] but the environment and tools aren't. Smalltalk is a world in itself which is both its strength and weakness. https://learnxinyminutes.com/docs/smalltalk/ https://learnxinyminutes.com/docs/smalltalk/
- JepZ 9y agoI am well aware of that as I had my own trouble learning Smalltalk. Yet in hindsight I like the clean design of the language. Nevertheless, I find the argument on their website kinda odd and a bit confusing. I mean, I see a lot of Smalltalk advocates claiming the language is so simple to learn and at the same time I see a lot of programmers having trouble learning it. Maybe it is just wrong to call it 'very easy to learn' just because the syntax is simple.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- FractalLP 9y agoThe difficulty for me isn't the syntax, so much as not knowing how to use the tools. Examples are extreme like other niche languages. You get either hello world or writing a web server. I'd like to see someone build a YouTube channel with a lot of very small applications that show adding methods, classes,debugging, and deployment.
- JepZ 9y agoI don't know about Pharo, but I have seen very few IDEs which make it as easy as Smalltalk environments (e.g. VisualWorks) to do what you asked for as they provide you with GUI a for all that stuff. Pharo is probably no different. I think the first important step, is to understand the different columns of the 'System Browser'. From a quick search that video playlist might help you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xF4fnGaE2w&list=PLqbtQ7OkSta0ULYAd7Qdxof851ybh-_m_ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xF4fnGaE2w&list=PLqbtQ7OkSt...
- CodeArtisan 9y agoPharo is great for doing Test driven development: 1. write a test 2. run the test 3. test fails; debugger pop up 4. implement/fix the method inside the debugger 5. repeat at 2 until the test succeed. it's usual that a coding session is entirely done in the debugger which is like an interactive coding environment where absolutely everything is inspectable. demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymITEeAOtEA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymITEeAOtEA
- zerr 9y agoVideo lectures are in French.
- martin-t 9y agoI had the "pleasure" of attending an OOP course at uni taught by Stéphane Ducasse. I didn't learn much OOP but i learned that pharo is an utter piece of garbage. The IDE randomly crashes, corrupts images (all your work is in the persistent image) and randomly ignores clicks making it insanely frustrating to use. Git integration is "WIP" which means it sometimes silently deletes files or you just don't get it to work at all. Branches are not implemented, glhf resolving conflicts on a team project. Oh, and it saves your passwords in plain text. Error messages will keep opening until you kill the "IDE" and undo will sometimes delete half your code with no way back (maybe that's why you're supposed to keep methods small?). It's a bit ironic that Mr. Ducasse calls himself an "expert on software quality". Here's our final project, the weekly reports document our "learning" experience: https://gitlab.fit.cvut.cz/taibrmar/sokoban-using-bloc https://gitlab.fit.cvut.cz/taibrmar/sokoban-using-bloc Most students had similar feelings and the response to the course was overwhelmingly negative.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- crististm 9y agoThe entry log from 2017-12-27 is appalling: one true namespace to rule them all and wreak havoc!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zerr 9y agoWhat about other Smalltalks? Some are used in industry, so probably should be more reliable.
- FractalLP 9y agoFrom what I've gathered, Cincom is really good but very expensive. There are a variety of proprietary language vendors with great products (Cincom Smalltalk, Dyalog APL, Wolfram language that is part of Mathematica), but it is a weird sale in the modern age. Why use a better tool if you have to pay for it and your entire business's IP is tied to another company pulling the strings. Even if they promise their tools are 10x more productive, is the risk acceptable?
- ljw1001 9y agoI've used Pharo, and, way back, programmed professionally in Cincom (then ParkPlace), IBM VisualAge, and whatever the Windows version of Smalltalk was called was called (Visual Smalltalk?). Also tooled-around a bit in Squeak. All three of the professional environments were very good. When Pharo kicked off, it was supposed to have been people building a free Smalltalk you could use to build real world software, as opposed to the research-oriented Squeak community. They didn't stick to that path, tho. As another post described, Pharo is a mess, and it doesn't get more reliable from release to release. It's too bad. The idea that any Smalltalk environment today is state-of-the-art is just misguided. I would rather use Intellij IDEA any day. Smalltalk is still a beautiful thing, tho.
- nstricevic 9y ago> As another post described, Pharo is a mess, and it doesn't get more reliable from release to release. Can you share this post, please?
- ben-coman 9y agoI guess he is referring to the criticisms by martin-t.
- philippeback 9y agoIt is like fitness. One just hates it when it aches all over the place and then quits. Or keeps on moving through the pain/grind and grow a lot in all kinds of ways. And saying that VA or VW give a better user experience when coding vs Pharo, I beg to differ.
- martin-t 9y agoExcept the pain in pharo doesn't come from the difficulty of learning new things or self-improvement but from the buggy environment itself. Learning to save your work every 5 minutes because it might crash any time doesn't make you a better dev, it just lowers your standards.
- billsix 9y agoSmalltalk was the first language I loved. It was great to write, but I had difficulty understanding the structure of other's code. Even with that great integrated debugger, I couldn't figure out how Morphic actually worked. These days for graphical programming, I prefer C with nuklear (https://github.com/vurtun/nuklear https://github.com/vurtun/nuklear) over smalltalk.
- ben-coman 9y agoMany people find that about the depths of Morphic. It has high technical which Pharo is addressing by creating a new system Bloc (its getting close, but not there yet). Then Morphic will be deprecated.
- ekvintroj 9y agoI see many comments talking about teaching objects with Pharo, we used to use it in the UNQ (a university in Argentina), now we use another Smalltalk flavour, because of the complexity of it. It's called CUIS, developed in Argentina too, the first days we use a framework that uses some similar to prototypes, so the students can start learning objects without the overhead of classes and inheritance. And then we switch to the classical class hierarchy way. It's a nice tool! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_e3_3MyTBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_e3_3MyTBY
- ben-coman 9y agoYes, Juan and community have done a good job with Cuis. Cuis is a fork of Squeak same as Pharo, and all three use the same OpenSmalltalk-VM. Both forks arose to deal with a large technical debt in different ways. Cuis has been paring back class sizes while Pharo has been focused on a full source-code only bootstrap from a null-Image (i.e. no carried over state in an Image, that is one of Smalltalk's typical criticisms), replacing old subsystems, as well as adding new features. I'd say Pharo is more ambitious and we are starting to see the payoffs for this. btw, which was the CUIS prototype framework you used? There should be little reason it couldn't be made to run on Pharo.
- ekvintroj 9y agoThe framework is called Denotative Objects. https://github.com/hernanwilkinson/Cuis-Smalltalk-DenotativeObject https://github.com/hernanwilkinson/Cuis-Smalltalk-Denotative...
- lukego 9y agoI chose Pharo for a project recently (http://github.com/studio/studio/ http://github.com/studio/studio/). I am enjoying using it in production. The Glamorous Toolkit framework (Inspector and Spotter) is saving me a huge amount of work. I see Pharo as two universes: the stable (now Pharo 6) and the development (now Pharo 7.) I work on the stable one and I don't concern myself at all with what is happening on the development one. The yearly release cycle of development-to-stable feels about right to me. I have had to spend some time working out how to fit Pharo into my wider project build system, and how to store Smalltalk source code on Github as part of a larger repository such that you can handle merges etc. This made me curse a lot. It worked out fine in the end though. I have been working on this for one year now and I haven't had problems with Pharo bugs or instability.
- analognoise 9y agoI couldn't even tell what the Glamorous Toolkit was or how to use it; what's the best resource for it? I remember checking out the website when it was released but couldn't make heads or tails of it.
- philippeback 9y agoYou haven't been looking much then. http://gtoolkit.org http://gtoolkit.org
- philippeback 9y agoI have been using Pharo since its 1.x releases and deployed commercial solutions using it. Very stable. Quite powerful. And it was/is a pleasure to work work with it. One has to invest time and effort to master it. I would say that this is best suited to people who actually know what they are doing. Syntax is easy but frameworks are very advanced. So, do not go there without support. I see comments that are not that kind to Pharo. I do to care to be honest. I do not think that Pharo is for the masses. It has imperfections but nothing is at the core. And things are moving forward very well. As a Pharo consortium member I vote with cash and usage.
- mapcars 9y agoSome videos don't even have english subtitles, eg 2.1 Understanding Messages :(