5 ms·
This is really the wrong time for Zuck to decide to not commit to literally any privacy request someone has. They already have to meet GDPR in Europe, it's act
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
This is really the wrong time for Zuck to decide to not commit to literally any privacy request someone has.
They already have to meet GDPR in Europe, it's actually easier to not maintain two separate sets of rules, so the decision to not give people worldwide the same protections as in Europe is an intentional choice to do more work to give people less privacy.
- RyJones 9y agoIs Facebook available in China? Do they comply with Chinese law? I'm not sure I'd want to have Chinese law applied to me here in the US.
- monocasa 9y agoIt's been blocked for nearly a decade.
- fastball 9y agoYeah, except GDPR is demonstrably only good for the consumer.
- foota 9y agoI mean, nitpicking, but it might mean your favorite service can't provide some feature, either due to prioritization or some other reason.
- oh_sigh 9y agoDemonstrably?
- hueving 9y agoIt cannot be 'demonstrably only good' because there is no way to know all of the services this will prevent from being viable.
- taurath 9y agoI think we have a pretty good idea of the services that no personal privacy creates.
- crpatino 9y agoIt is demostrably good for teenagers that liquor stores cannot sell to them, no matter how much they wish to get drunk. Given the degree of willfull ignorance displayed by your average social network user, with regards to the safety of their own personal data, a case could be made that they should be treated like minors and not be given legal right to decide unless they subject themselves to recurrent awareness education. Of course, half of HN crowd does not give a flying fuck either... so I will not be holding my breath.
- skybrian 9y agoI honestly can't tell whether you're being ironic or not. But it seems like a complex law and it's likely we won't know the hidden downsides until well after it's implemented.
- cjhopman 9y agoCheap effective advertising is very good for the consumer.
- ionised 9y agoGonna need a citation on this, and a definition of 'very good'.
- ggregoire 9y agoI don't get how the GDPR and the censorship in China are related here in any way. Is the GDPR bad for your freedom of speech?
- dingo_bat 9y agoFor one, both are the law in a particular region of the world.
- electricEmu 9y agoSome laws are ubiquitous. Others are common or even unique. Each can, and should be, evaluated on their merit. Can you enuciate where the GDPR excels and fails, or is national origin insinuation enough?
- icebraining 9y agoI can see why being forced to apply the law of another country can be bad. I don't see why merely deciding to do so is necessarily bad.
- kerng 9y agoHaving GDPR applied in USA also is arguable a positive thing, so why not entertain the idea, or at least leave the door open rather then prematurely shut any efforts down? Maybe its best for Mark Zuckerberg to take a break. It might help him to step back and see the big picture, what happened at Facebook is the perfect example of Normalization of Deviance: http://lmcontheline.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-normalization-of-deviance-if-it-can.html?m=1 http://lmcontheline.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-normalization-o...
- chipperyman573 9y ago>Is Facebook available in China? No
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> I'm not sure I'd want to have Chinese law applied to me here in the US Facebook could incorporate the bulk of the EU's GDPR into its privacy policy without violating U.S. law. The same could not be said of Chinese policies.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoIndeed they will set up so they can meet the letter of the law of GDPR. They just will look at the GeoIP of where the submittion was made, and rote deny if out of European jurisdiction.
- willow9886 9y agoGDPR actually applies to all EU citizen data, regardless of where the citizen resides. "If your enterprise has a presence on the internet in the form of a website and if your enterprise collects personal data from customers regardless of where those customers are located, it is subject to the provisions of the GDPR." [1] [1] https://www.techrepublic.com/article/the-eu-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr-the-smart-persons-guide/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/the-eu-general-data-pro...
- neinzero 9y agoSo will users have to set a new site-wide "citizenship" setting on their profile? Short of actually requiring you to upload your passport, how can Facebook make sure only European citizens get the added privacy? Because I know, as a non-European, I want to get in on this action.
- dannyw 9y agoThe specifics is an implementation detail, but as an european citizen (residing anywhere) you have rights under the GDPR and should assert those rights.
- FridgeSeal 9y agoSame here: I'd already made the decision that I want to move to an EU country, GDPR just makes me want to accelerate that so I can get in on the action sooner. It's not the only, or the biggest reason of course, but it's a nice benefit.
- cesarb 9y ago> So will users have to set a new site-wide "citizenship" setting on their profile? What about users who have two or more citizenships? What about users who have none? What about users who have citizenship only in countries the site doesn't recognize? > Short of actually requiring you to upload your passport Given that this is about the GDPR, wouldn't that only make things worse for the site? Edit: also, what about people who have neither a passport nor an identity card?
- downandout 9y agoit's actually easier to not maintain two separate sets of rules The GDPR version of Facebook really can’t function as a social network - at least not the kind of social network that we would recognize today. So it may be easier to have one version, but that’s not going to happen, and it would be a disservice for the 99% of users that don’t care about privacy but do care about all of the features they are going to have to give up.
- acjohnson55 9y ago> The GDPR version of Facebook really can’t function as a social network Could you explain that?
- downandout 9y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16751431 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16751431
- 0xfeba 9y agoDistinguishing between who is a EU citizen, or who is in the EU right now is problematic. My company is applying the law to everyone.
- chc 9y agoThere seems to be a strange friction between this statement and the reasoning behind it. You say GDPR's restrictions on collecting more information than necessary or storing it longer than necessary would prevent Facebook from functioning as a social network — but if that's the case, then it sounds like the data collection and retention was necessary after all. Am I missing something here?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- downandout 9y agoThe problem is that we don’t know. It doesn’t specify a definition of necessary. Necessary for whom? It isn’t necessary for Facebook to solicit people to make wall posts, so arguably they’d run afoul of the law by simply offering the option to do so. My point was that the law leaves massive room for interpretation. The threat of aggressive application and interpretation of this law could deliver significant leverage to the EU over these companies in matters reaching far beyond privacy.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI would trust Zuckerberg to understand better if something is easier or harder to implement at Facebook. Also considering that they make money from data, it might be very expensive to throw away everybody's data.
- oculusthrift 9y agono. he knows it’s harder. but it’s worth it for him to sell your data and abuse his users.
- icantdrive55 9y agoIt's greed. Plus--he knows his idiot (I believe he used this word?) members really don't care, as long as they get likes, and can leer at fishmouth posers. I guarantee there's a bunch of people coding a new social site right now--with ethics in mind--hopefully? I hope one succeeds, and FB is a footnote in history.
- mikenew 9y agoYour second point does not support your first.
- MR4D 9y agoSure it does. Data is an asset from which they derive revenue. Implementation of rules is just a cost. Throwing away a huge asset would also reduce revenue. Am I missing something?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- systoll 9y agoYou’re missing the distinction between easy and profitable. Going back to the top of the thread, the idea was that this is a decision that looks bad in a moment where everyone’s looking at Facebook. If extending the behaviour worldwide were a difficult engineering feat, that’d provide a simple outward justification for Facebook to not bother. But in reality, It’s more difficult to keep the two systems around. Taking that path implies that Facebook actively benefits from breaking the EU law, and justifying it outwardly in the current climate means establishing how the EU law actively harms Facebook’s users... while not admitting that they violate user’s privacy, and profit from doing so. [And as others have suggested... even if it’s the right move to implement things this way — it makes ~0 sense to draw attention to it.]
- grigjd3 9y agoIt's not hard to maintain separate sets of rules and companies already do so. Try taking a look at Maine's laws on data with regards to minors.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> This is really the wrong time for Zuck to decide to not commit to literally any privacy request someone has Forget decide--why did he feel the need to make a personal announcement? He is too busy to testify in front of the United Kingdom's MPs [1]. Yet he can find time to personally throw dirt on the EU's privacy rules? For the head of a social network, this man is shockingly clueless. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-cambridge-analytica/facebooks-zuckerberg-to-testify-before-congress-source-idUSKBN1H3121 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-cambridge-analyt...
- on_and_off 9y agoLooks like zuck is victim of the echo chamber of facebook feeds.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- geodel 9y agoIf livelihood depends on not understanding something, it is impossible to make them understand.
- amarkov 9y agoWhen national legislatures call people to testify, that's not a neutral information-gathering exercise. The MPs are going into that panel with a very clear idea of what the witness is going to say, and how they can spin it towards their preferred talking points. Zuckerberg isn't a UK citizen and didn't authorize any misconduct specific to the UK; why should he personally participate in Parliament's ritual shaming of Facebook?
- rmc 9y ago> why should he personally participate in Parliament's ritual shaming of Facebook? Because it sends a bad message, and Parliament et al have the ability to materially affect facebook's revenue by passing & enforcing laws like the GDPR etc
- nugget 9y agoFacebook's fear isn't privacy requests made directly by individuals (likely a tiny number), but rather privacy requests made programmatically, on behalf of users, by third party services who can use clever marketing and growth hacks to scale quickly. There are some interpretations of GDPR that would allow this broadly and it could create some meaningful competitive scenarios.
- mathie25 9y agoCould you link to some of those interpretations or give the article/recital where you think this could be possible ?
- nugget 9y agoI don't know that much has been written about this yet, but consider data portability as one example. If an EU court rules that Facebook must allow extraction of a social graph with an email address and consistent ID included for each contact, it dramatically weakens their network effect and lowers the barriers to on-boarding users onto competing social networks.
- kolmogorov 9y agoIn that scenario I could also write a quiz app that gives you your personality based on that export. That would be an amazing data set for a researcher at e.g. Cambridge and an example of the EU supporting researchers.
- tanilama 9y agoHello n, what you described is what Cambridge Analytica did. Zero chance Facebook would risk their business, AGAIN.
- craftyguy 9y ago> it's actually easier to not maintain two separate sets of rules But it's more profitable to maintain two separate sets of rules in this case.