31 ms·
Rental car companies have been waging a quiet legislative war against start-ups
- varjag 9y agoRather ambivalent about this tbh. We've seen many times how the online marketplaces initially targeted at grassroots providers evolve into professional domains again. Ebay, Uber, AirBnB, in the end casuals are pushed out and you get fulltime sellers, drivers and purpose rental properties driving the market. Only this time most of the profit ends up with members of a one pool party somewhere in California. They want to disrupt the market, well be ready to bust your asses this time.
- wutbrodo 9y ago> in the end casuals are pushed out and you get fulltime sellers, drivers and purpose rental properties driving the market. Have casuals been pushed out of Uber? Maybe my market is weird, but I tend to talk to every Uber driver I have and I take a lot of them: I'd say less than 50% are full-time drivers.
- lordnacho 9y agoReally? I don't recall meeting an Uber driver who didn't do it all the time. I think GP's point is valid. To start with, it's beneficial and fair that lots of little people can rent out their cars for some extra change. But when it ends up being a loophole to sidestepping existing rules to make essentially the same service with fewer rules, it's worth paying extra attention to. Not saying it needs to be outlawed, just that it's not obvious what to do.
- ForHackernews 9y agoIt'd be very easy to have legislation that regulates small-timers (only owns one or two cars, rents it out less than 30% of the time, etc.) differently from professional operators, even if they advertise on the same platform. Some jurisdictions have started doing this for AirBnb.
- Shivetya 9y agowe already have too much of this type of regulation which does just what you state, keeping small timers out to benefit the established interests. occupational licensing sounds beneficial to the public as a whole and at one time it was but once established businesses found they could use it to block competition its original focus was lost. It really clobbers low income workers and fattens pockets of companies which "train" for licenses and the like. Nearly a third of all jobs are regulated as such and many are prohibited to former convicts which is yet another road block. You can end up spending more money gaining your license to braid hair than serve as an EMT.
- ForHackernews 9y agoI'm proposing the opposite: regulate big operators more heavily than small-time amateurs. If you want to rent out a spare room in your own house a few weekends a year, the government probably doesn't need to be very involved in that. On the other hand, if you're a company that owns 50 condos and lists them all on Airbnb, you should be carrying insurance, you should be subject to inspection for bedbugs, etc.
- wutbrodo 9y agoSure, I'm not disagreeing with the point as you state it. I was just surprised by the claim that casuals are pushed out.
- ams6110 9y agoAfer accounting for their costs, Uber drivers don't make much money. As a casual gig a lot of people with other sources of income have probably found it's not worth their time. If you have no other options, working 80 hours/week as an uber driver might make you enough to eeek out a living.
- wutbrodo 9y agoI'm not speculating from first principles as to what might be happening, I'm saying what I've seen from a fairly large sample over the years. Though again, it's limited to my market (SF).
- varjag 9y agoMy country has no Uber service, so I use it on foreign trips. Initially everyone seemed amateur, now it feels full of pro drivers. But of course could be market specifics, and I don't chat up with every driver too.
- yardie 9y agoDepends on time of day. I tend to meet causa Uber drivers late nights and weekends. Day tend to be full time drivers. Quite a few are recent immigrants. At various stages of job searching. Full time? Yes. Professional? Definite no.
- wutbrodo 9y agoRight, which would belie the notion that casuals are pushed out.
- bluntfang 9y agoIt seems like you're make a subjective value judgement on what 'professional' is. If they are making money, they are a professional.
- yardie 9y agoNo, you are confusing occupation with profession. Most of the drivers I have ridden with would not consider being a driver their profession. Some were retired accountants, others were freshly arrived immigrants saving up for school. A UPS, longhaul or UberXL may consider driving this their profession. As for ridesharing very few were professionals.
- jstanley 9y agoeBay, Uber, and AirBnB are all great. Much better experiences than what was available before.
- apatters 9y agoIf the established players promote regulation which make it harder for new entrants to gain a foothold, that's cartel-like behavior and it hurts consumers. In general, regulations should promote competition because competition results in better products and services. The examples you list are all businesses that I wouldn't want to disappear. The problem with these businesses is that software-driven industries have monopoly characteristics, which among other things lead to the concentration of wealth you mention. Consumers would be better off if we had five Ebays or five Ubers or five AirBnBs, but for a variety of reasons this is currently unlikely--the weaponization of patent law, the high up front costs of developing new software, etc. Patent reform is a relatively straightforward area where better regulations could promote competition within software-driven industries. A more controversial approach (at least in the US, but the EU had no problem with doing this to Microsoft) is compulsory licensing of intellectual property when monopolies have abused their position. If the ultimate goal is to reduce wealth concentration and ownership, we might also consider making it easier for firms to IPO again.
- sokoloff 9y agoWe do have 5 EBays and it sucks IMO. I have to search EBay, autotrader, craigslist(s), Amazon 3PM, AliExpress, BringATrailer, FChat/RennList, Etsy, Tindie, and others to get the whole market for whatever random thing I'm looking for. For lodging, it's AirBnB, VRBO, TripAdvisor, Priceline, hotels.com, Expedia, trivago, and 15 others that I'm not thinking of, half of which are owned by one of the others. Uber has Lyft and other smaller competitors as well. Users go to where the vibrant market is; they aren't, in general, helped by having the market sharded for arbitrary reasons. Even back to the days of Trajan's Forum, local produce markets, or modern-day "Auto Mile"s, consumers seem to prefer the convenience of one place over many.
- varjag 9y ago> If the established players promote regulation which make it harder for new entrants to gain a foothold, that's cartel-like behavior and it hurts consumers. It's called level playing field and it's not catered to multinationals in particular. There is no shortage of independent car rentals and hotels around the world. In fact am writing this from a non-chain beach condo and there's a mom&pops car rental maybe 250 meters away. Somehow they are able to comply to a few simple regulations, it is a bit dramatic to paint comparatively huge centralized corporations as victims of oligopolies here.
- yardie 9y agoAlmost nothing in this article seems unreasonable. If I give you money for your goods for X amount of time, that is renting. You are engaged in commerce and fall under the laws and regulations of commerce. Not sure why it’s being called a war. None of the legislators have called for an outright ban.
- varjag 9y agoWhat really happens here is foreign companies monopolizing local black/grey markets. Unlicensed taxis or rental properties were a thing before the internet. Just that municipalities know how to deal with them; they went in stupor when global billion dollar companies started doing that too, giving it a whiff of legality but not really. Governments are notoriously slow to react to changes in ecosystem, and in this case it's other businesses pushing back, in a way that should make any free market advocate proud.
- cornholio 9y agoI think enforcing by legislative means the profit-sharing system traditional players have with the airports is completely unreasonable. They go out as far as to call it a safety issue. Yes, the playing field is not level, but that's what competition means: the sharing companies have found a way to go around the onerous taxes imposed by airports and there is almost nothing the airport can do to stop a private individual drop a car in it's short term parking lot for another individual. There's no safety or congestion issue, it's the entire point of the short time parking spaces.
- CPLX 9y agoThere's no obvious reason why airports charging people who use the airport as a transportation hub is unreasonable or onerous by definition.
- rocqua 9y agoThere are to reasons airports need to charge rental companies if we ignore 'they are abusing their local monopoly'. The first is congestion due to the pick-up process. Clearly, this affects both the new players and the old players. The second reason is land-use by the parking lots in which available cars are stored. This doesn't affect the new players. Now, airports might be charging for both, and simply be afraid that the cash-cow of charging reasonably for the land-use of parking lots is going to disappear. For a real answer, you'd need to actually compare the difference in cost between congestion and land-use.
- pjc50 9y agoCtrl-F "insurance" - no results. If I use a startup to lend my car to someone, and they're involved in an accident, whose insurance covers it?
- gaius 9y agoWhen playing poker, if you don’t know who the sucker at the table is, it’s you
- amdavidson 9y agoIgnoring the irrelevance of this comment to the parent, this is a bizarre aphorism. Why is it so hard to believe that the players at a poker table couldn't be evenly matched?
- gaius 9y agoHow is it irrelevant? If you don't know who's insurance covers it and no-one will tell you, it's safe to assume that you are the one who will be liable.
- dazc 9y agoThe reason I rent from Enterprise is that I don't have to worry about insurance or breakdowns. My financial loss is set at £100 maximum and the cars are nearly always brand new so unlikely to breakdown. To start using some unregulated operation like 'AirBnB for cars' I would need do be paying virtually nothing as an incentive. And, from the examples I've seen so far, this is no way the case.
- switch007 9y agoI must be super unlucky. I find their maintenance well below par. They're the only company that attempts to rent me cars/vans with: oil service lights, bald tires, cracked windscreens. This isn't limited to a single branch either. Also £100 is not their standard excess, so you're paying for the reduced liability. (Also, they like to tell you every time in the hard sell that the £1,000 excess is for each and every incident and the full amount will be taken immediately... ?! Not sure how true that is) However, they have the most branches in the UK of any rental company, so they're often extremely convenient.
- arkades 9y agoThere have been many comments here in the past about how sticking a digital intermediary into a traditional business model doesn’t somehow magically absolve you of regulations on that business model. This article doesn’t actually present any unique obligations on Turo (the rental car Airbnb). As far as this article presents, the legislation is to explicitly make clear that if Turo is going to work in the rental car space, they can’t just ignore regulatory burdens that all their competitors are subject to. I see no problem here.
- mcherm 9y agoDo you also feel that Uber and Lyft should constrained from day 1 not to operate without following all the regulations for taxi services like a requirement to have a medallion and to only allow drivers who have undergone an extensive background check? Do you also feel that Airbnb, if it is going to work in the room rental space, should be required to comply with all of the regulations for the hotel industry (including collecting of hotel tax, posting of room rates on a placard affixed to the door, and installation of better-than-consumer-grade fire suppression systems)? It sounds good to say "innovators can do whatever they like but need to follow the same rules as everyone else". But perhaps the existing rules are specifically tuned to the existing business model and will not be rewritten to support another business model unless that business model has been proven in practice. Or perhaps the existing rules are just excessively restrictive.
- michaelt 9y agoIf there's one thing I've learned from Uber and AirBnB, it's that if you say "less regulation for micro-businesses in Field X" the huge multinationals in Field X will declare they're not _actually_ in Field X, they're just brokers directing customers to the 5,000 micro-businesses that provide services.
- fthssht 9y agoHave you learned that you wish Uber and AirBNB were strangled by regulation before they got off the ground?
- john_minsk 9y agoThese are 2 different business models. Centralized one with scale effects and decentralized one where participants take care of different aspects of car maintenance on their own and platform creates network effect. You can't apply the same rules to these systems as regulation mechanisms are different. Funny bit: we trust Uber's driver rating MORE than the fact that official taxi drivers are "pro" and comply with regulations i.e. the value of this regulation is negligible. So enterprise car rentals need to ask following question: where in the process of making money we forgot about delivering value to customers.
- michaelmrose 9y agoI had to avail myself of cabs on a number of occasions over the years in a backwater town. There were a number of outfits that were all perfectly compliant with the law and regulation and although they were independent cabs they were all dispatched by the same idiots. In no particular order I was... - Only picked up an hour late because a different cabbie stopped by the shop I was in front of to shop and took me home after he got his groceries. - Picked up by a cab that had been in an accident earlier and the steering was in some way totally screwed in a fashion that made the car veer to the side unpredictably when it hit a bump. I thought at first he was blind drunk until he showed me that it took a quarter turn of the wheel to make the wheels turn at all. - Picked up by a cabbie that was showing his little brother how to maximize revenue by picking up and dropping off as many people as possible along an optimal route while talking about his time in prison along with a colorful story about his friend smuggling cigarettes in his rectum. Kudos for entrepreneurial know how but the trip took waaaay longer than it should have because 5 different people going different places were in the car. There was one outfit that was technically non compliant after the county I worked in in decided that county specific taxi regulation including requiring outfits to paint their cars was actually going to be a thing. These were the only people that showed up in a reasonable time, provided good service, and actually took a damn card in the cab. They also used to violate the law by dropping me off in the half assed county where I worked. So long Mr P's taxi and thanks for all the rides. The regulations that don't keep taxis from ripping people off or threatening their safety but DO ensure that the "investors" in taxi medallions earn some money can collectively burn in the pits of hell.
- 9y ago
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoSomeone tell me what I'm missing. From this article it seems that the appeal for renters is that it's a more friendly process to rent from Turo than e.g. Hertz. A renter doesn't care if the car is owned by average Joe or by Hertz. So can't Hertz and others simply fight this by improving their renting process? What's stopping Hertz from coming up with an app and completely destroy Turo? They already have the cars, they already have the distribution, they already have the compliance. Now just get an app.
- notyourday 9y agoIt is a lot more than that. I have spent last month doing quite a bit of sporadic rentals and it is a pain in the neck. (a) pricing is not transparent what so ever. I can get estimated price but I cannot get the total out of the door price. It makes zero sense in 2018. (b) i can never get a car that I am "ordering". I fail to understand why a Zipcar can do it, but neither Hertz nor Enterprise nor Budget can. If I'm getting an Tahoe, which is expensive which you claimed you have, I'm baffled why the barely coherent employee thinks that a minivan is a "similar vehicle". (c) daily insurance scams - luckily it does not apply to me because $25/trip premium insurance via Amex is easy, automated and just pure awesome but oh my god people who do not know about it are just getting screwed. (d) And finally... why is it that I still cannot search all the locations within a certain area for the cars and prices that I need? Why do I have to repeat the searches for the twenty Hertz in NYC when with a Zipcar or Maven i can just scroll through the map or get a list? If rental car companies were to fix this 99% people like me won't be likely to use "peer-to-peer" because there's nothing worse than driving someone's non-standard, modified, coolant-gauge-may-not-actually-work car.
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoThanks for this. Could you explain (c)? I don't understand what you mean. Regarding the rest, it sounds like they got used to offering a poor service because they don't have enough competition or something. You might have a point there, but for a competitor to take advantage of that they just need to execute better on those points. They don't really need to source their cars from average Joes... I'm not saying that Hertz isn't shit, I'm just saying that I don't understand how where the cars are sourced from is a real differentiating point. EDIT: I just re-read your last line and it seems you agree.
- theonealtair 9y agoTaking on a CARtel will never be an easy process.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mmjaa 9y agoHow feasible is it that companies like Turo can route around this issue by offering things other than cars to rent/lease from their owners? Like, if that F150 came with a bunch of shovels for schlepping soil, for example ... or if the Tesla came with a tour guide in the passenger seat? Wouldn't that make the whole "a duck by any other name" more of a "well, its a platypus really" kind of issue? Or are there regulations which preclude this kind of bundling of services?
- alkonaut 9y agoJust like Airbnb is a hotel business, Uber is a taxi business (meaning a ride-for-hire business and nothing else) having a car rental business is having a car rental business regardless of whether the cars are “shared” or whether there is an app involved. And just like Uber has to follow any regulations surrounding rides for hire (regarding taxes, insurance, accessibility, right to deny service, ...), so must this company with regulations surrounding car rental. I don’t see how making sure startups don’t get away with some loophole is a “legislative war”. It’s no different from cities where Hotels say AirBnb should pay hotel taxes and have hotel level fire security. If the regulations surrounding the established market is too rigid then address that. But don’t “revolutionize” markets by using some loophole and an app.
- nate_meurer 9y agoYour examples aren't helping to prove your point though. It makes zero sense to require single-family houses or duplexes to have hotel level security. Requiring a homeowner to retrofit sprinklers and fire doors, or provide 24-hour video surveillance or an onsite security guard? A hotel is fundamentally different sort of facility than my house. Insisting they be regulated the same is pure rent-seeking on the part of the hotel industry.
- alkonaut 9y agoIf you rent it out you are a hotel. Or, possibly, a landlord (which comes with different but quite burdensome regulations in most countries). What a lot of these startups do is expose areas of markets that may be too rigidly regulated. Perhaps the reasonable level of regulation for Airbnb renting is just working smoke detectors, a basic escape plan map and good insurance? Perhaps most of the remaining hotel regulations could be lifted? It’s very likely that the advent of “not quite hotels” and “not quite taxi” calls for new regulation. But what the established players “war” against is newcomers completely dodging regulation on account of being “not a hotel”, “not a landlord” or “not a taxi”.
- nate_meurer 9y ago
- kevin_b_er 9y agoTaxi company that isn't a taxi company. Hotel company that isn't a hotel company. And now, car rental company that isn't a car rental company. And, as always, all the regulations are somehow bad. The PR person compares this to lead paint certification, but I'd argue that the bulk rented apartments need that too. Instead they're fighting sales tax on the rentals. Besides this, cars are far more dangerous to others when maintenance gets lax.
- tlb 9y agoFew would claim that all regulations are bad. But regulations often age badly. Regulators and the companies they regulate are both motivated to freeze the state of the industry over time. So when new technologies like smartphones allow doing something better, the regulations often prohibit it (as they did with taxis.) Established players don't want change because change costs money, and regulators aren't motivated to make changes either. What we see is that unregulated industries (say, dog-walking on demand) can quickly adopt the new technology, while regulated ones like car rental have trouble. Car rental should be much better with smartphones. I should be able to get a car brought to the airport in front of baggage claim. The fact that I have to schlep my luggage on shuttle buses to a rental area is an artifact of a business model that no longer makes sense. But if we wait for the incumbents to do it, it could take any amount of time.
- ghaff 9y ago>The fact that I have to schlep my luggage on shuttle buses to a rental area is an artifact of a business model that no longer makes sense. Well, it's also an artifact of the reality that the rental volume at major airports is such that the activity needs to be moved well away from baggage claim. Honestly, I don't find car rentals to be that big a deal. I have priority cards for a couple of companies so I basically take the bus/train, grab a car, and checkout at the gate. Admittedly, I don't usually have much luggage.
- gamblor956 9y agoI should be able to get a car brought to the airport in front of baggage claim. You can. It's called concierge rental car service or valet rental car service at those airports that offer it, and it tends to be extremely pricey. It's not offered for the masses because it would make the already horrific congestion at Arrivals even worse, which is the primary reason that the rental car area is usually a bit away from the airport itself.
- dalbasal 9y agoOver the last year, I've really changed how I think about "tech giants," their competition with other parts of the economy, and what it all means. The realization we'll see 3-5 trillion-dollar tech giants very soon triggered it. Let's take Thiel's startup = monopoly statement seriously for a minute. He didn't mean monopoly in the traditional/legalistic sense. He meant dominating some niche, so that ordinary "margins trend towards 0" rule doesn't apply. 0-marginal costs helps. Network effects too. MSFT are a platform, distanced from market forces by network effects and lock-in. Google & Amazon are middle-men, aggregators and platforms distanced from market forces by network effects. FB is all network effects. The reason Uber could raise so much money was because they seemed to have a good chance of "dominating" a market, and playing the middle-man between taxis and passengers everywhere, forever. A 1% chance at a one trillion dollar market cap.. that's worth ten billion. For a chance at a piece of a thiel-monopoly on cars, investors will happily bankroll big loses. Big enough to sink competition. When you are playing for a trillion-dollar monopoly, losses don't matter. I dunno what to think of competition like this, at scale. This is a different flavour of capitalism. In any case, neither side wants normal, textbook laissez faire markets. One side is playing for monopoly. The other side is playing for structural stasis via legislation/regulation.
- smeyer 9y ago>playing the middle-man between taxis and passengers everywhere, forever. A 1% chance at a one trillion dollar market cap Investors in Uber had to be hoping for either a larger than 1% chance, expanding beyond taxis, fundamentally growing the taxi market, or all of the above. The existing taxi market has a total market cap of well under a trillion dollars, even including companies like Uber. The total US stock market only has a combined market cap of about 30 trillion, so I think you're overestimating the number of trillion dollar market cap industries that exist and the extent to which investors are gambling on success having payoffs quite that high.
- dalbasal 9y agoTrue, the actual outcomes and probabilities are complicated, and there are many success scenarios where uber doesn't yield a trillion dollar market cap. I was being simplistic, to demonstrate the principle. Apple, Amazon & Apple are headed towards that trillion now, so I think this is a possibility, and possibilities drive investment. If the stock market itself stays good, it is almost inevitable one of the three will tip that number soon. Once one does, I'd expect a half dozen within a decade. On the taxi market cap... This is an interesting one. I agree that uber had their eye on more/bigger opportunities (especially self driving), but ignoring that... The market cap of an industry is not only related to its size. It's related to the margins, lock-in and other attributes of the companies operating within it. Also, debt & capital efficiency. A more competitive market may have lower market caps, because margins are thinner and companies can fail. IE, while market cap of the industry might be Y, "an uber" dominating that industry might still achieve a market cap of 5Y.
- giobox 9y agoAnecdotally the only people I know who have used Turo are young people - Turo doesn't have a you must be 25 or a young driver surcharge policy for driving if aged between 21 and 25, which is typically the case at a conventional car rental desk in the US. Personally I would feel pretty uncomfortable if greeted by the private vehicle owner when picking up a rental (I know this doesn't apply to all vehicles on Turo) - people are often extremely attached to their personal vehicles in my experience. At least at the rental desk the staff could care less what I choose to use the rental for, or how I drive it.
- subroutine 9y ago> people are often extremely attached to their personal vehicles And for good reason. Cars are expensive to maintain even when driven and cared for responsibly. No idea what would be considered a reasonable listing price on Turo, but to hand my keys over to a 21 year old stranger in town for a weekend vacation, I dunno... maybe I'd do it for >$100/day.
- dawnerd 9y agoFancier cars on turo do however have age restrictions. I was looking into renting a model s and it has 30 years as the min age
- snowwrestler 9y agoI used Turo once, during a visit to SF. The owner didn't meet me (it's optional on their part), and the process of "checking out" the car didn't seem any easier than renting a car from Budget. It's an elaborate sequence of taking pictures and uploading them to the Turo app in the right order. The cost was not too different from Budget either. I used Turo simply because the closest "traditional" rental car office that was open was many miles away; while the Turo car was parked close. I haven't used Turo since. Usually when I need a car it's because I'm flying somewhere, and getting a rental car at the airport just does not seem difficult to me.
- MrFoof 9y agoThere's one actual great case for Turo: Pre-purchase test drive, especially for oddball stuff. You can likely find a car very similar to what you're going to buy, and drive it for a weekend. Luxury car dealerships will do this (esp. when you go into very high pricepoints), but they take convincing. For a lot of people, it's a better way to find out that something isn't quite what you wanted, without having to deal with depreciation after the fact. Though if you want to give a childhood dream a fair shake before actually plunking money down on one (and going through PPI, etc.) Turo is great for that. There's no shortage of high-end sports cars and "common" supercars on the platform, especially in large metro areas.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoI have mixed feelings about this. Uber is a horrible company but they created real competition for a lazy industry that sorely needed some. Turo is doing the same. When I wanted to rent a Tesla for a few days Turo was the only viable option. The majors all wanted around $1000/day; I found one on Turo for a little over $100 and the free fuel brought that down to around $80. It was a delightful experience.
- ghaff 9y agoThe majors are really in the business of mass-market utilitarian rental. And they mostly do a competent job of that. To the degree they offer anything outside that framework, they do tend to charge a huge premium if they offer the option at all. (For example, good luck renting a 4WD Jeep.) I would question the wisdom of someone renting their Tesla out like this but that's their decision.
- retr0rocket 9y agoit's not that bad actually, in general you just ask for an upgrade at the desk and if its in stock you will get it for a cheap premium if its available.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wcfields 9y agoFrom what I've noticed here in Los Angeles, Turo is exploiting the greymarket of wildcat car dealers. There are lots of people here that own 10+ late model economy cars at any one time and there are areas where you'll see 5-6 cars on the street with For Sale signs. A friend of mine who's car was totaled used Turo for a month or so until she bought the car from the guy.
- subroutine 9y agoThis is the first thing that occurred to me after browsing the cars available in my area. Nearly all of them look like they are listed by boutique / independent used car dealers (like the one I drive by every day: http://imgur.com/J3yi9qL.png http://imgur.com/J3yi9qL.png ). This is interesting given that... Title 13 California Code of Regulations, section 260.02 states: (B) Former taxicabs, rental vehicles, publicly owned vehicles, insurance salvage vehicles and revived salvage vehicles shall be clearly identified as such if the previous status is known to the seller. If the used car lot owner is renting-out his cars on Turo, it seems like they are required to disclosed this to potential buyers. I highly doubt this is happening.
- jonknee 9y agoI was rooting for disruption for a while, but after signing up for one of the loyalty programs I mostly just don't care anymore. My major gripes have been fixed, I can just walk up and take a car at most airports and unless there's a major event going on the pricing is very cheap. I can't imagine wanting to go through the hassle of something like Turo unless I was trying to rent an unusual car for a special occasion. The last thing I want to do after getting off a plane is jump through hoops. Update: I should also add there are often promo codes available on the likes of Retail Me Not that can make things even cheaper. Combine with a loyalty program which results in frequent upgrades and it's a great combo. I recently drove a brand new BMW X5 for a week for something like $30 a day after fees.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> My major gripes have been fixed, I can just walk up and take a car at most airports Maybe we have very different patterns of flying, but this has never been my experience. It's always exactly the opposite: there's a line of ten families at the rental desk, each person takes at least ten minutes (!) to process, and the desk has one, maybe two people, for a total of half an hour in line or more. It's so phenomenally aggravating once you've finally gotten off the plane and just want to get to your hotel that it has left me with no sympathy for these rental companies whatsoever. Which I suppose is the real brilliance of both Uber and Turo: if you're going to disrupt an industry by breaking the law, pick a business that absolutely no one is going to go to bat for. Despite how brazenly illegal Uber was in many cases, nobody cared because the taxis were just that awful. It's possible that things will turn out differently for Turo now that people are wise to Uber's game, but the rental companies would still do well to remember that one of the things that helps these illegal disruptors prosper is when people are so sick of the status quo that they happily turn a blind eye to the law-breaking. Make your business suck less, and then maybe people might actually stick up for you.
- jonknee 9y ago> It's always exactly the opposite: there's a line of ten families at the rental desk, each person takes at least ten minutes (!) to process, and the desk has one, maybe two people, for a total of half an hour in line or more. That was me until I signed up for the loyalty program (it's free, like frequent flier programs). Now at most airports I just go right to the vehicle (they email the parking spot number) or special booth in the parking lot or choose any vehicle in a special lane. Not only do you not have to wait behind families, but you don't go through that whole pitch where they try and sell you insurance and gas.
- julienchastang 9y agoHaving rented a number of cars recently I can attest that this is an industry that is in major need of disruption. Renting a car today at any car rental company I know of is phenomenally inefficient: 1. Long rental lines at airports. 2. Asking for information that could be provided ahead of time via apps. 3. Having to make your way to the car rental facility. What I would like and I would be willing to pay a premium for is order the car of my choice via an app. Have said car delivered to my location by a driver that then takes Lyft/Uber back to headquarters. Also it seems like the car rental companies could benefit from economies of scale by having a small number of large lots instead of numerous little lots peppered throughout a geographic area. If this existed, I would use it all the time as I only need occasional use of a car.
- brianbreslin 9y agoCheck out SilverCar. They are mostly app based.
- julienchastang 9y agoSilverCar sounds promising, but from my research you still have to travel somewhere to get the car. I want the car to come to me. :-)
- shiftpgdn 9y agoSilverCar is amazing. Traditional rental agencies look like garbage in comparison. SilverCar also has shuttles at most major airports so you don't have to go far.
- jarrettch 9y agoYou might be looking for Skurt. Although now that I Google them, it appears they've either re-branded as or been acquired by Fair.
- Rebelgecko 9y agoIf you aren't pre-registered on the rental car company's website (give them a DL # and a credit card in advance), you're missing out. Most of my car rental experiences at larger locations have gone pretty painlessly like this: 1. Walk straight past large slow line up people at front desk 2. Show my driver's license to someone at the fast pickup counter 3. Get keys (may take an extra 30 seconds if I ask for an upgrade) 4. Leave Some rental car places leave the keys in the car, so you can check your email to go straight to whichever car is yours or just grab any one that's available
- kozikow 9y agoAlthough car rental user experience is not perfect, it gets the job done well enough. Not every type of business in the world needs VC funding, react.js SPA, chatbot and "sharing economy".
- joelrunyon 9y agoI don't understand the appeal of Turo. I hate car rentals, but can't believe renting from a random to be a superior experience to them. SilverCar on the other hand, is amazing. They just need better accessibility at airports.
- drasah 9y agoيتواجد لدي شركة دراسة لخدمات البحث العلمي العديد من الانواع المتميزة للخدمات التي يحتاج اليها الباحث بصفة دائمة ومستمرة حيث يتواجد لدينا فريق عمل كامل ومتميز لتنفيذ مهام هذه الخدمات علي درجة علية من الجودة والتميز http://drasah.com/ http://drasah.com/
- drasah 9y agoتتمكن من خلال شركة دراسة لخدمات البحث العلمي الحصول علي العديد من الانواع التقنية العالية في الجودة والتميز لجميع المهام التي تتعلق بتنفيذ الابحاث العلمية http://drasah.com/ http://drasah.com/