4 ms·
Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scientists
- mratzloff 9y ago> The project, a collaboration between scientists at MIT and a private company, will take a radically different approach to other efforts to transform fusion from an expensive science experiment into a viable commercial energy source. The team intend to use a new class of high-temperature superconductors they predict will allow them to create the world’s first fusion reactor that produces more energy than needs to be put in to get the fusion reaction going. Etc.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThe article talks about new, smaller, and more powerful magnets that could enable real advancement toward positive energy fusion.
- zeth___ 9y agoFusion is the energy of the future and always will be.
- Zeta_Function 9y ago“Always” is a long time, but its definitely fair to say that barring a series of unforeseen and radical breakthroughs in a number of disciplines, fusion as a reliable source of power is nowhere near being a reality.
- berbec 9y agoThat seems to be the sad point; fusion is always in the future.
- gus_massa 9y agoUntil they have a working prototype, this is the equivalent of vaporware. Moreover, it's not clear if they will have a working reactor in less or more than 15 years, it's not clear if they are building a research reactor or a production reactor, it's not clear if they are going to collect the heat and use it to produce electricity, ... Also, the article say that: > A newly available superconducting material – a steel tape coated with a compound called yttrium-barium-copper oxide, or YBCO – has allowed scientists to produce smaller, more powerful magnets. but if I understand correctly the new material is just a new type of superconductor wire that is more efficient than the current wires, it is not a superconductor magnet. If they have better wires, they can make better electromagnets, but it is confusing. Also is not clear if they have tested the new kind of magnets or it is just a theoretical application. Also, 15 years is a lot of time, usually it means they don't have a clear idea of how to solve all the technical details. https://xkcd.com/678/ https://xkcd.com/678/
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y ago> but if I understand correctly the new material is just a new type of superconductor wire that is more efficient than the current wires, it is not a superconductor magnet. If they have better wires, they can make better electromagnets, but it is confusing. Also is not clear if they have tested the new kind of magnets or it is just a theoretical application. Both: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4&t=32m35s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4&t=32m35s This work is being done by the head of MIT's Nuclear Science department, in collaboration with most of the top grad students there. You can go look through all the publications that have resulted. They're going into great detail with practical engineering concerns, not just vague concept. It's really disappointing and frustrating to me to see all the shallow dismissals here. The original article/press release didn't have much concrete information. But instead of making the reasonable assumption that some of the best people in the field actually know what they're talking about, and the article is poor, instead HN commenters are deciding their zero content, zero knowledge, shallow dismissals are more likely than what the experts are saying. Nearly all the information about the ARC project is out there in the literature. If you don't want to read it that's fine, just try to have some awareness that you can't dismiss things without actually knowing what they are.
- IshKebab 9y agoBut that is the basis of all the new fusion startups. It didn't really explain what is unique about this one. http://csef.ru/en/nauka-i-obshchestvo/direction-topics/obzor-termoyadernyh-startapov-mira-6408 http://csef.ru/en/nauka-i-obshchestvo/direction-topics/obzor...
- throwaway84742 9y agoAt this point I’ll believe it when I see an independently confirmed measurement of a working prototype. This stuff seems to be perpetually 20 years out.
- royjacobs 9y agoIt's the "year of Linux on the desktop" of alternative power.
- throwaway84742 9y agoIt’s worse. At least Linux _can_ be viable on the desktop. The challenges surrounding fusion are so staggering that putting any definite timeline around solving them is pure bovine manure.
- digi_owl 9y agoYeah, there is nothing technical that stops Linux. It is mental and political/financial.
- dgreensp 9y agoSomething that pretty much everyone in the world wants to see happen, but still faces a few technical hurdles, is much more likely to ever happen than something that is already possible but not enough people want, it seems to me. Achieving ubiquitous nuclear power is more like achieving ubiquitous electric cars than achieving ubiquitous flying cars. It’ll probably happen any decade now, vs maybe never.
- iamdave 9y agoI think I grok what you're referring to when you say "political" but if anyone Dell came closest to fixing the financial problem with their Ubuntu laptops wouldn't you say?
- jimmaswell 9y agoHas Linux desktop caught up technically to Windows yet? The last time I used it there were still problems like double clicking a jpg from the Firefox downloads list opening an "open with" dialog pointed to /usr/bin or something. And it seems like where Windows will put things in places that might not technically be a perfect categorization but are convenient and make some sense, like monitor/video/screensaver properties from right clicking the desktop, this seemed to happen a lot less in Linux DEs. Aside from them seeming somewhat less responsive in general and lacking equivalent GUI system utilities to things like "Computer Management" or the device manager.
- royjacobs 9y agoLike other fusion projects all of this is pure speculation, sadly. However, I truly think it is wonderful that there seems to be a resurgence in the area of nuclear fusion. After Fukushima any project that had "nuclear" in its name was put on hold for political reasons and it's good to see that people don't have cold feet anymore.
- newnewpdro 9y agoNuclear fusion substantially eliminates the "meltdown" risk associated with contemporary fission-based nuclear energy sources. But it's no panacea [1], there's still substantial radioactive waste produced and radiation hazards to those working near the reactor. If you operate under the assumption that we should pursue nuclear energy, then this is great. But if you operate under the assumption that between solar wind and storage, we have everything we need without any radioactive waste or radiation hazards to workers, this is pretty uninteresting beyond academic purposes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power#Safety_and_the_environment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power#Safety_and_the_en...
- TillE 9y ago> In general terms, fusion reactors would create far less radioactive material than a fission reactor, the material it would create is less damaging biologically, and the radioactivity "burns off" within a time period that is well within existing engineering capabilities for safe long-term waste storage. There's really no comparison; fusion is vastly cleaner and safer.
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoI think the problem here, is that all those environement protection groups fighting fission, would cease to be after they "won" and thus are desperat in search of a new "evil". Has there ever been a activist group that stated loudly: "Yes, we pulled it off"- and then peacefully disolved, with the promise to reunite the day the defeated cause should return?
- yodon 9y agoAs a freshman at MIT in the 1980’s, I was impressed to hear the announcement that the MIT Group Against Smoking had just disbanded. They had accomplished everything they set out to do and felt their were better places for them to invest their time. And yes, I vividly recall the only time in my tenure at MIT I saw a student light a cigarette. It was in 10-250, the person was sitting audience right side of the lecture hall, about 1/3 of the way back in the room. She did so once, on her first day of class as a transfer student. So yes, change can happen, and be recognized, and the activists move on.
- bitumen 9y agoThe title is the worst kind of deceptive, clickbaity, untrue crap. As usual, MIT is the hub of both exciting science/engineering, and horrid press releases.
- rdruxn 9y agoThe first paragraph and the sub header is an outright lie: “Carbon-free fusion power could be ‘on the grid in 15 years’” And then later: “Prof Wilson was also cautious about the timeframe, saying that while the project was exciting he couldn’t see how it would achieve its goal of putting energy on the grid within 15 years.”
- DennisP 9y agoThe MIT team thinks they might be able to do it in 15 years. Wilson isn't on their team.
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoOnly slightly related- but what endevours would become at how much energy output per $ Helium inserted viable? Has that been studied? There must be a curve, where it can be estimated at what cost-point fission and solar are out- and for example growing ressources in vats becomes cheaper then farming/ chopping down natural grown wood. What other "uneconomic" endavours become feasible with fusion at what price?
- ianai 9y agoCarbon sequestration - not sure on what price point, but at least the current cost of oil reserves. This factor should include national security 'returns' (the huge boon from moving away from middle east controlled energy) - so say trillions of dollars per decade. Salt water desalination - at some point pumping salt water (possibly long distances) to desalination plants for agricultural and domestic use becomes feasible. Space programs - once oil is disrupted as an energy source for the masses it will be cheaper to push things into orbit.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoGenuine question: What does not using oil for mass transit have to do with reducing cost to orbit?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ianai 9y agoI didn’t say mass transit.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoYou wrote: > once oil is disrupted as an energy source for the masses I'm confused, what else do the masses use oil for? If I'm not mistaken the production of fuel for transportation is the lions share of oil use. But regardless, how does that help us get things to orbit?
- zde 9y ago“The aspiration is to have a working power plant in time to combat climate change." Let's combat global warming by producing even more heat, converting 40% of it to electricity.
- asfasgasg 9y ago> Let's combat global warming by producing even more heat, converting 40% of it to electricity. All the wattage produced by humanity is utterly insignificant in the face of the energy we receive from the sun. It will still be insignificant if we double it. (We receive about 2 × 10^18 watt hours per day from the sun at the ground. Daily human energy production is about 5 × 10^15 watt hours.)
- wcoenen 9y agoOn the other hand, at a fixed doubling period of 35 years (i.e. assuming 2% yearly growth) we'll get at that "one extra sun" level in only 500 years. Or if we take "5% of an extra sun" as the problematic power output, it will take only 150 years. (Now consider that in the golden age of oil before the oil shocks in the seventies, oil consumption was growing more like 8% per year.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- davrosthedalek 9y agoIn that scenario, we are doomed anyway: If we would generate anywhere close to that level of power via solar, we would change the albedo of earth significantly -> heating. And we would certainly affect the air currents on a global scale if we use wind power to that extend.
- asfasgasg 9y ago> (Now consider that in the golden age of oil before the oil shocks in the seventies, oil consumption was growing more like 8% per year.) At that time, per capita energy use in the US was growing by 3% per year while population would grow by 1.5% per year. Today, per capita energy consumption in the United States is falling, and the population is growing more slowly. The story is much the same elsewhere. Even China has leveled off in per capita energy consumption. India's is still growing, but it will take many years considering their baseline of 1/10 of the United States per capita before they're the biggest problem, and I guess they'll probably turn that trend around before they actually get to that point.
- sergj 9y agoSaw this video explaining in a HN comment why stronger magnets and a different approach might make fusion work. After ca. 22:00 Minutes he is done with the fusion basics and explains the new approach. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4
- ttul 9y agoReally cool.
- sebastos 9y agoMan, this was excellent. If you're passing by, definitely give this a watch. The speaker makes the material clear and understandable for the complete layman. Very exciting.
- VVyattPrentice 9y agoAt one point he briefly mentions (almost in an off-handed way) the issue of scaling the novel semiconductor production approach. Would be interesting to know how big of an ask that really is. Maybe I'm jaded by current events but figure it's only a matter of time before the science community has its Bernie Madoff moment. Especially in light of how renewables seem on the cusp of their moment to shine.
- inteleng 9y ago>semiconductor Is there a reason everyone in this thread is saying "semiconductor" instead of 'superconductor'?
- godelski 9y agoMight be because people here generally work with computers. Not many people work with superconductors, so might be a priming issue.
- neltnerb 9y agoExtremely hard, the superconductors are a ceramic that is very brittle, it's quite hard to make a nice wire out of it. If a single break in a long length ruins the whole stretch then scaling up would be massively challenging, you can't just rely on melting and cooling to nicely even out issues during drawing a wire.
- bb88 9y agoThis is old news.
- dandare 9y agoSerious question: what could be the cost of fusion generated electricity if the reactors go mainstream like fission reactors? Unlike uranium, hydrogen is for free and there is no cost associated with storing burned fuel. You can probably also save a lot on safety systems. But you still probably need a badass reactor with auxiliary power source, huge steam turbine and cooling towers. Or not? What factors will determine the cost?
- mynegation 9y agoEven if we assume for a moment that we got it working, the factors are: scale and embrittlement. Current thermonuclear technology, theoretically, breaks even, energywise, on reactors of certain scale. There is a reason to believe that once we build a reactor of a certain size, the energy output of a reaction will be bigger than the energy spent on jumpstarting it and magnetic containtainment. embrittlement of reactor structural materials is caused by radiation. After a while, reactor has to be rebuilt from totally new materials.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y ago>After a while, reactor has to be rebuilt from totally new materials. The closest parallel we have is nuclear reactors. Navy Nuclear submarines are probably the most prevalent safe small reactors (US submarine reactors not K19) and they have significant lifespans extending across multiple decades. (source: passed my navy nuclear engineer exam in a past career) The resulting embrittled can/containment does need to be handled safely, but this is a capital depreciation that can be modeled and planned for.
- DennisP 9y agoThe MIT design essentially solves those two issues. Scale is smaller with stronger magnetic fields, and embrittlement is confined to an inner wall which is easily replaced once a year.
- theothermkn 9y agoYou are correct! It’s maddening that you had to make the correction, though. Commenters in here seem incurious about the new developments detailed in the source material.
- SCAQTony 9y agoI am all for fusion but I am curious, what happens if there is a magnet failure and the plasma, which is "...hundreds of millions of degrees celsius," escapes the containment vessel? What damage will it do while it's cooling off for whatever period of time.
- ExcelSaga 9y agoIt would explode, but for any reactor we’re likely to build in our lifetimes, it wouldn’t be anything like a nuclear bomb. We’ve had nastier explosions in natural gas refineries. There would be radiological contamination from the Tritium and any neutron-activated material, but it would be more of an expensive cleanup than an environmental disaster. It would be dirty though, especially if the reactor had been running for a while, building up dust. What wasn’t radioactive would still likely be stuff you don’t want to breathe or ingest. TL;DR Boom lots of dead people in the containment structure, expensive cleanup, but nothing like a fission disaster. It would be an uninspiring explosion, but it would be dirty.
- XorNot 9y agoThis is wrong in every possible way. There isn't enough mass of hot material in any plausible fusion reactor to even breach the vacuum chamber. Or for better context: research facilities today regularly lose plasma containment. It's why we don't have practical fusion reactors, but they're already at the plasma densities we would run at (which is an order of magnitude or so better then the Sun achieves).
- mpweiher 9y agoYeah. There's even a clue in what it's called: a vacuum chamber. Densities are extremely low, so you only have a few grams of material in the reactor, even at large volumes anticipated for a commercial design. Furthermore, the reaction is extremely finicky, as demonstrated by what an incredibly hard time we are having creating and more importantly sustaining it. Any deviation from the ideal and it just goes out. So no runaway chain reactions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power#Accident_potential https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power#Accident_potentia...
- snarfy 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fusion_experiments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fusion_experiments
- Veedrac 9y agoMeta rant: I would like people to remind themselves that HN's rules explicitly disallow shallow dismissals. Unfortunately this comment section seems to be nothing but. The material science behind high temperature semiconductors has undergone radical changes in recent years. The techniques being used are largely well understood science and the downsides of previous approaches like ITER are explicitly avoided. There has been a visible explosion of commercial activity in recent years. People bander around the "always 20 years away" moniker as if we should put today's estimates on the same grounds as the guesses from those early 1970s projects that were never even properly funded. People were not screaming "20 years more" at the turn of the century. You don't get to discount something as potentially groundbreaking as this just because it's taken a little while to get here. Either put up or shut up. I would love to hear genuine substantive conversations here, if people were willing to have them.
- annywhey 9y agoI can offer some economic perspective. Oftentimes the critical advance for technology to reach deployment is not a theoretical breakthrough in the primary science but rather a change in aggregate costs, ability to organize capital, secondary technologies, etc. It's stuff that pushes the tech past a threshold of feasibility. The Industrial Revolution itself, for example, was a mix of recent breakthroughs and older ones that started to be realized enmasse(e.g. coal mining and steam engines co-evolved during the 1700's). So when researchers say, "this supporting piece of the puzzle has gotten much easier," as it is with the new magnets described in the article, that's actually a good time to listen since it might be the tipping point. Theory developments or experimental observations are exciting stories to read about but often have less imminent bearing on whether you're going to see it impact your life.
- alehul 9y agoCould you recommend any resources (articles, books, podcasts, etc.) that go into more detail on the economic factors that come together to enable periods such as the Industrial Revolution, or really any period? I think economics offers a great perspective to subscribe to, but haven't found much opportunity to learn it. Most "economics" podcasts are really just business-focused and describe modern events with little insight into the economics behind it.
- labster 9y agoAnother April Fool's headline?
- chiefalchemist 9y agoLong to short, a couple years ago, I was out for drinks and bumped into a friend. She was having drinks with a friend who is a prominent researcher at Princeton Plasma Labs. We got to talking. He assured me they were getting closer and it was only a matter of time (read: money). I'm not a politician or an investor, etc. so he had no motivation to blow smoke up my arse. Less than a week later there was this: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/china-fusion-breakthrough https://www.wired.co.uk/article/china-fusion-breakthrough 100+ seconds is not a lot of time. But if you double that every few weeks then it __is__ only a matter of time.
- rajacombinator 9y agoUmm maybe justifying his life’s occupation would be motivating, not to mention in the company of a female friend and alcohol? “Yea bro it’s always 50 years out lmao” not to be expected from a PPL researcher...
- DC-3 9y agoMaybe I'm naive, but I honestly don't understand why governments and private foundations alike aren't throwing money at Fusion scientists. It seems far and away the best possible investment one could make today in humanity's future.
- skellera 9y agoUncertainty. The risk is much higher investing in fusion than an application. I'm sure once a proven breakthrough occurs, money will begin to flood in. The potential is massive.
- fred_is_fred 9y agoIt's also a tough sell since it seems like science fiction whereas roads, schools, medicare, social security, etc are current tangible needs that people understand. I'd venture to say at least 50% of the American population believes you can get sick from being outside without a jacket and so trying to explain to them why you spent most of the budget on fusion would just make people's heads explode.
- tzahola 9y agoWhy pay for uncertain research when you can just wait for others to figure it out and then use their proven technology? Aka, first-mover disadvantage.
- teslaberry 9y agohaving been to an international fusion science conference, and a good friend having being a 30 under 30 fusion physicist, who is now at princeton advncanced fusion lab d3d and general atomics---- my beef with fusion is that people think that if we 'discover' how to pull off net positive fusion that it will suddenly result in limitless energy as opposed to a slow and centuries long process to make it profiteable. sustainably profitable fusion is NOT likely to explode in usefulness the same way nuclear fission did. we might discover how to sustain net positive fusion, but scaling it up in any single reactor might prove problematic and fusion may wind up being a very hair problem to improve to high levels of profitability and energy production for a long long time after fusion sustainability is 'discovered'. from a purely economic perspective, fusion and fission have zero reason to exist for economics. fission makes sense for fuel density for powering weaponized systems in space and at sea and remote locations. fusion would be filling the same precise needs at best, otherwise, in a world where there is limited resources to invest in R&D for global energy research for powering cities and civilizations commercial and residential energy needs, our money should be going into making our consumption more efficient, and our existing sources better. solar, wind, natural gas, hydroelectric, coal and other existing sources should all be made more efficient. we simply don't need to invest in 'new' energy sources like fusion. they are redundant from an economic perspective. and energy transmission, distribution and STOREAGE all need massive amounts of new R&D investment. that is where the economics make most sense.
- maxxxxx 9y agoJust one thought: I am glad that there are people who are trying to solve extremely hard problems even if they will never see success themselves. I much prefer money and intelligence being spent on fusion than on developing new weapons or technology to create perfect surveillance so more ads can be served. As far as I understand fusion is at a point where we know almost 100% it can be done but there is a long list of hairy problems to solve. Working on these is money well spent in my view.
- pfdietz 9y agoThis is greatly overrated. The design of the ARC reactor in the 2014 arxiv paper produced 500 MW(th) fusion power. The FLiBe bath contained some 90 tons of beryllium. The annual world production of Be is just 220 tons. If the world's entire estimate resource of mineable Be (100,000 tonnes, according to USGS) were used to make ARC reactors, they might supply 1% of the world's primary energy demand. The FLiBe also contains about 1/4 the 6Li produced by the entire US hydrogen bomb program. The facility that enriched that lithium used 10,000 tons of mercury and is an environmental problem even to this day because of leaks. That process is also now illegal in the US due to this pollution, and there is no facility in the world that could make that much 6Li. Perhaps those problems could be worked around, but there's a deeper issue. The power density of the ARC reactor is around 0.5 MW/m^3. This is an order of magnitude, or more, lower than the power density of a PWR fission reactor core. The ARC reactor is also much more complex, and will require very expensive maintenance operations every couple of years (manufacturing a new pressure vessel and remotely installing it, as the innards of the reactor will be too hot for hands-on access.) So, how could this possibly be cost competitive with fission reactors, never mind the energy sources that are currently beating fission? It's ironic that the ARC reactor is just demonstrating the fatal flaws with DT fusion reactors, flaws that were also pointed out at MIT by Lawrence Lidsky some 35 years ago. ARC is better than ITER, but that's damning with faint praise.
- bitumen 9y agoAs you can see from some here, people just want to believe. Fusion is the power source of sci-fi, and they’re scared of fission. As with self-driving cars, people just imagine what it could be like and that’s enough for them. Never mind that decades of R&D on fission has yielded breakthroughs in safety and efficiency, and by the time a workable fusion design is possible far more advanced fission will be possible. People want the future to be now, so they believe their way into it. Scientists want funding for research, so they sex it up for the media and mass consumption. The truth is that politics aside, we could be using fission today to solve the problems people want fusion to solve decades from now. Granted, if aneutronic fusion becomes possible (no time soon, even experimentally with a surplus of energy) that will be a miracle. DT fusion though, is only useful for research purposes. Most people, including most people here don’t have a working understanding of nuclear physics or the requisite engineering of a power plant. When you don’t understand the hurdles, fusion seems kind of magical. If you’re desperate for advanced space flight, fusion seems kind of magical. Even more, no one has any negative experiences with fusion, while we’ve been literally burned by fission. It’s hard to argue against a fantasy, and hoping for fusion also let’s people ignore the hard work of using fission. The politics feel intractable in the US, the waste is manageable, but scary. Fusion isn’t real yet in that sense, so like an online romance people can project a fantasy onto it.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoWhether this is likely or not, I hate articles like this. People refuse to give up even a little of their current lifestyles to make their lives sustainable and this article makes them think that is OK because technology is going to save them in the future.
- jcoffland 9y ago> Prof Wilson was also cautious about the timeframe, saying that while the project was exciting he couldn’t see how it would achieve its goal of putting energy on the grid within 15 years. So the startup seeking more funding is over promising as usual. As many others here have said, I'll get excited when someone actually achieves a net positive fusion burn and it's confirmed by a third party.
- John_KZ 9y ago>15 years Stopped reading.