4 ms·
In case anyone is wondering, this really isn’t that unusual. For the longest time you couldn’t get most console dev kits without a business address and very st
by BoorishBears 9y ago
In case anyone is wondering, this really isn’t that unusual.
For the longest time you couldn’t get most console dev kits without a business address and very strict guidelines on a separate lockable space for the hardware.
I think there’s been some relaxation on that more recently (I know at least with Nintendo there has), but it’s not that odd that a supposedly earth shattering technology have those guidelines.
- raverbashing 9y agoSounds more like a gimmick to create hype, in Magic Leap's case I can understand the case with videogames, for pre-release dev kits, but maybe it's too much as well.
- ericd 9y agoWhy can't it be a legitimate concern, where they want to maximize the amount of development time before their competitors get their hands on them and start reverse engineering? This isn't a lightly modified PC meant to run games, this is whole new tech that could spawn a potentially huge new market if it turns out to be good. There's a lot at stake.
- banachtarski 9y agoWe have this amazing pin-drop blood testing device. But no releasing papers for peer review is too risky. It's too revolutionary! No, don't ask us how it works, we don't even reveal it to family it's that amazing. - Theranos
- dmix 9y agoTheranos was able to fool people by not allowing their system into 3rd party hands and doing all of the tests behind closed doors, mostly using 3rd party existing industry machines. I don't see how that analogy applies here when the entire device is being given to actual companies and with restrictions merely because Magic Leap wants to control the full PR experience when the product launches. That PR will come out in some fashion in the near future, and it won't require a whistleblower within the company to leak it and risk losing their jobs.
- AndrewUnmuted 9y agoI work in this industry, and every early devkit device we've received from the manufacturer has come with these kinds of constraints for us. I would have been much more shocked if Magic Leap didn't require these kinds of things of its early devkit recipients. And I'm a big ML skeptic.
- IshKebab 9y agoThe Hololens doesn't have such restrictions, and that's the closest device I can think of.
- sulam 9y agoThat's currently for sale, though. It's hard to tell me to keep it in a safe when you have a web page like this: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/hololens/buy https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/hololens/buy Other people commenting on this are spot on. This is standard operating procedure for new hardware with the sort of attention that Magic Leap has.
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoThere were significant restrictions and weird PR "no go" topics with the Hololens as it was being developed. For a long time they didn't even allow photography of the physical hololens (as it was still in flux).
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoExtreme secrecy with NDAs-a-plenty also prevents massive failings from being broadcast to the public and harming your launch.
- maximilianburke 9y agoYup! I remember getting some console dev kits early on that had a number of restrictions on them, like: * Devices must be kept in an area with restricted access to those on the NDA; or * Devices must be kept in a locked office; or * Device must be chained to the desk; or * Device must be covered with a cardboard box at all times Keeping AR glasses in a safe doesn’t seem too outlandish.
- Intermernet 9y agoIt does however suggest that the early AR demos will be variations on a theme of "Escape from the safe".
- pimlottc 9y agoI'm curious, how did console manufacturers audit devs to make sure these procedures were being followed?
- Const-me 9y agoIn our case they did not. But our management strictly forbidden us to talk to outsiders about devkits or sdk, or take photos of devkits. I think that's enough in practice, and in our case an audit would be quite expensive because international flights.
- webkike 9y agoI had an internship at Google involving working on PS4 and xbox Dev kits. I wasted a month of three just getting proper documentation.
- haldean 9y agoYup, I worked on a hardware project at Google that eventually became Android TV, and when we sent out hardware units they were hand-delivered by Google employees in GPS-tracked, locked Pelican cases. Upon receipt, devs had to keep it in a safe when they weren't working on it, and if I remember correctly, we gave them little decoy cardboard boxes to put over it to hide the case design from passers-by while it wasn't in the safe. Sending out devkits always feels very "briefcase handcuffed to a dude in a suit".
- mattnewport 9y agoI've worked with quite a few console dev kits with serious restrictions, including needing to be in windowless rooms with locking doors. Usually that level of security was at the pre official public announcement stage though. It's a little unusual to have that level of security after the company has done a big PR push showing off pictures of the 'secret' hardware.