29 ms·
'PC Building Simulator' Is More Fun Than Building a Real Computer
- Kenji 9y agoHell no it can't be more fun than PC building irl.
- seiferteric 9y ago> Building a gaming PC in real life is way too hard Huh?
- jandrese 9y agoIt can get arcane getting the right socket mobo for your processor, getting the correct timings on the RAM, figuring out how much power supply you need to buy... And then there's those poorly documented nonstandardized fiddly little wire connectors for all of the front panel functions, plus another set for the USB ports and so on. To this day I'm never sure which way to plug in the LEDs, and even when I think I have it down I'll run into a mobo that does it the opposite way. And then your case has a three pin power switch (outer two wired up), but the motherboard only has two pins for it...
- chx 9y agoI think your comment is, what, a decade out of date? First of all, pcpartpicker and logicalincrements will help you choosing the right CPU with the right motherboard. Correct timings on RAM hasn't been a thing for many, many years, they work, at worst it won't use the maximum possibility the module offers. The PSU is hardly a problem, unless you are spending an extraordinary amount of money, the smallest PSU you can realistically buy is an overkill (CPU is 65W typically, very few GPUs go above 150W, and you can't even get a below 350W PSU really unless you have some office prebuilt from HP or Dell). The front I/O pretty much has standardized on Intel https://www.intel.com/content/dam/support/us/en/images/motherboards/desktop/sb/img/fp_header.jpg https://www.intel.com/content/dam/support/us/en/images/mothe... and most cases have a single block now.
- jandrese 9y agoIt's probably fine when you're buying everything new today. Building computers out of salvage parts adds a lot of complication.
- davidkuhta 9y agoSince the great subterranean migration of 2017, catching the elusive GPU outside of a mine and in its native habitat has proved quite difficult.
- slededit 9y agoThe worst part is basically all the major vendors have drastically reduced their return policies or eliminated them entirely.
- acmecorps 9y agoReally? Do you have a source for this? This would be bad for actual gamers
- slededit 9y agoMy source is Frys having giant signs saying final sale on all of their GPUs.
- nasredin 9y agoI've read that GPUs are not designed to be run 24/7 e.g. bitcoin mining.
- shadowfacts 9y agoThey’re not designed to run 24/7 but they don’t have an issue with it. The GPU and the card itself have no issues running continuously. The biggest problems come from the fans running continuously and getting worn down, and the coolers are by far the easiest part to replace.
- mellinoe 9y agoIs it really that hard to find them? I'm not that familiar with the current lineup of cards (still rocking a GTX 770 myself), but Amazon seems to have several 1050-1080 model cards in stock from various vendors. The prices do look a bit inflated, though.
- urda 9y agoIt will do you well to remember HN isn't the entire world. For many gamers out there building their first PC is a scary and daunting step.
- sp332 9y agoI've heard people say that before they actually put a PC together. Afterwards every one of them said "Oh, that wasn't so bad!" At least, in the last 15 years... The days of AGP and PCI-X and sharp-edged rolled-steel cases were a little more fraught.
- giobox 9y agoAGP/PCI-X wasn't really any more difficult to work with than today's PCI Express etc. You really have to rewind to mid 90's pre-Windows 95 in the days before Plug 'n' Play when manually assigning IRQs etc was a thing before the process of building your own PC meaningfully changes in my opinion. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug_and_play https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug_and_play
- sp332 9y agoRight, but you had to match all the parts you were buying. It's easier now that everything is ATX and PCI-e. And before Amazon and Newegg, return policies were patchy.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> And before Amazon and Newegg, return policies were patchy. OTOH, before the main consumer storefronts were the kind of flea markets of no-name sellers that used to roll into county fairgrounds every couple months, you could actually find good retailers with not only strong return policies, but also focussed on quality parts with a high S/N ratio in their catalog, that even offered added value (including, e.g., mounting CPU and memory when bought with a motherboard.) Some of those same places survived, but they don't do consumer retail anymore.
- drak0n1c 9y agoMotherboard articles proudly promote a dim view of hardware, which is unfortunate for a publication with that name.
- sincerely 9y agoit is definitely harder than most PC building enthusiasts make it sound
- ovao 9y agoI haven’t built many machines over the years, but to me it’s less like ‘hard’ and more like ‘scary’. The line about locking down CPUs feeling like breaking hundreds of dollars of hardware 100% of the time is a very real thing. Otherwise it’s the usual dread of whether the damn thing will actually boot. These days, though, they’re much better at booting than they are at not booting, so most of that nail biting is gone.
- khedoros1 9y agoHonestly, it's mostly just detail-oriented. Some people might not pick it up easily, while others will. All the hardware-building forums and such make it easier than it used to be.
- penguinUzer 9y agoA lot of it is RTFM. If someone won't read the manual for their lawn mower or car they sure aren't going to bother for their computer.
- paxys 9y agoWhy is that so surprising? It is hard even for technically-inclined users, let alone regular ones.
- maksimum 9y agoDefine 'hard'. To me, almost anything that can be completed in a fixed amount of time with high probability isn't hard; it's tedious at most. But if it can be completed within one hour it's not even tedious, it's (IMO) 'easy'. For something to be 'hard', there should be a reasonable chance of failure with associated non-trivial costs.
- Symbiote 9y ago> a reasonable chance of failure with associated non-trivial costs. Any single part of a computer is a non-trivial cost if broken, and it's not too difficult to imagine the situations where that might happen: bending a pin on a CPU, giving a static shock to a component, misapplying thermal paste. Even for enthusiasts, this is a task they do perhaps every 3 years, and every time with different components.
- wtallis 9y agoMost CPUs these days don't have pins to be bent. Killing a PC component with static shock is more difficult than you imagine and is pretty hard to do even if you aren't taking serious precautions like using anti-static wrist straps. Misapplying thermal past won't kill anything unless you use so much that it oozes out from the CPU-heatsink joint and short-circuits stuff on the motherboard (and that's assuming that your heatsink doesn't have thermal compound pre-applied, and that the aftermarket thermal compound you're using is actually electrically conductive). It takes willful ignorance and disregard for the simple instructions included with each component to even have a chance at breaking the expensive things.
- lfowles 9y ago> Killing a PC component with static shock is more difficult than you imagine and is pretty hard to do even if you aren't taking serious precautions like using anti-static wrist straps Can confirm, got a little lazy and put spare components together into a working system on the carpet this past weekend. Everything still works well enough. :)
- InitialLastName 9y agoI think folks here are missing something. It isn't assembling a gaming PC that's difficult, it's the process of building the rig; specifying parts and confirming that they're compatible can be a daunting task, much less sourcing them and recognizing the appropriate prices. It's a really big matrix of possibilities that can be pretty opaque to people who don't keep up with it.
- trey-jones 9y agoIt's been a while, but I'm pretty sure the shopping is the fun part.
- InitialLastName 9y agoMaybe for some people, but for others it can be a big, risky outlay of a significant amount of money.
- wtallis 9y agoUsing a tool like PCPartPicker takes almost all of the effort and uncertainty out of planning a build.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI've only built a couple of PCs but my method has been to find a PC for sale that is outside my price range - check for Linux compatibility by searching for problems - and then source the parts that match the spec. I can modify as I go, double up on RAM or whatever.
- onli 9y agoThere are several sites that help with that. I built one of them: https://www.pc-kombo.com/ https://www.pc-kombo.com/ - it gives you the best cpu + gpu for your budget, based on benchmarks, with fitting parts around that. The most known is https://pcpartpicker.com/ https://pcpartpicker.com/, which gives you a broad selection of parts and checks compatibility as well.
- sundvor 9y agoThere will be blood. ;) And you will put too much paste on, or not enough.
- sundvor 9y agoWhoever downvoted (and that's fine!) must only have worked on these modern cases with no sharp edges. Back in the days it was almost recommended to increase the iron in your diet prior to commencing a PC build.
- dfxm12 9y agoMeh, "gaming" is the operative word in that sentence. It's not just building a PC, it's knowing what components are required to run today's games, while leaving enough room for future-proofing against next {year|month|week}'s games.
- badlucklottery 9y agoI think it's one of those things that's super easy when everything goes right and requiring some pretty arcane tricks when they go wrong. I just recently put together a new PC and I was getting close to done. I plugged everything in before putting the side panels on, hit the power button and...nothing. No fans, no beeps, nada. Okay, I'll just disconnect the ATX power cable from the motherboard and short PS_ON to ground and see if the PSU fan will spin a bit...nothing again. Hmm. Maybe the modular cable is bad? Google the pinout for Corsair's "Type 4" PSU to make sure it's what I assume it is, drop my bit of wire down the correct pins directly on the PSU, jam my multimeter probes down a 12v + ground and...hell yeah, getting 11.something volts. Okay, bad ATX power cable, call Corsair, wait a week, problem solved. My wife was watching me do all this on the breakfast bar and kept asking "how did you know to try that?" and I really didn't have a good answer other than "been doing this or watching my dad do this since I was 8".
- jerf 9y agoI'm not sure I've ever assembled a computer without 1. exhaustively searching the internet about all the components and their interactions, finding no red flags 2. buying and assembling all the components 3. discovering some critical problem that requires some arcane setting to fix that probably downgrades performance 4. searching the internet for this particular problem and getting dozens of hits now that I have a specific symptom to go with my hardware. Clearly step 1 is going wrong somehow, but, I mean, I'm a fairly typical HN poster, you know, I've got at least intermediate-level search skills, you know?
- ansible 9y agoCertainly there are things that can easily trip up an occasional PC builder. One of the things I always do these days is look up the memory compatibility for the motherboard I've selected, and then only buy off of that list. There are so many variations in just DDR4 2400 memory, and matching up all the parameters (timing, latency, etc.) is a hassle.
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoUgh, this brings back bad memories. I had a new PC that wouldn't power up, and I couldn't figure out why for 2 or 3 days. Eventually I took the motherboard out of the case and then put it back in. Suddenly everything worked. The best guess I've got is that somehow the motherboard was touching the case in a way that was causing it to short out.
- danShumway 9y agoIt kind of straddles the worst line between easy and hard. It's pretty straightforward and easy to do, so you don't get any bragging rights when you finish, but there also aren't a ton of safety nets in case you do something stupid to keep you from ruining an expensive component. When I put together my computer, I dropped a CPU at an angle and bent one of the pins on the motherboard, then spent 3 hours flicking it with a needle to get it to realign. It's like doing taxes - not really an accomplishment, so big whoop if you do it right, but just dangerous enough to mean you have to pay attention and take it seriously.
- ethbro 9y agoWhen working with electronics, I use the CS vs EE analogy. CS person: grabs part by hand, shuffles across the floor in socks, brushes dust off a pin, presses part into place EE person: stares in horror, a grounding strap dangling from their hand CS: "What?" EE: "You know you're supposed to ground yourself to prevent static discharge from frying parts?" CS: "Bah, it worked fine the last time I did it this way." Point being there's a difference between something that works 99/100 times, and something that works 60/100 times. And when failure means a dead part, probably best to go the extra mile.
- nasredin 9y agoYou only ground yourself if you paid for the components. If it's your bud's money... it will probably be fine. Just hold the beer when you are installing the CPU :)
- Paperweight 9y ago...and then the CS-assembled computer works perfectly while the EE-assembled computer has gremlins. That's how it usually works. :/
- penguinUzer 9y agoBeing one of those "EE persons" specialized in semiconductors seeing lack of ESD protection drives me insane. I used to work on an electronics factory production floor where it was required of me to take a certification course of proper handling procedures and in the use of ESD arresting equipment. Your PC build didn't boot? Probably shocked it. It's blue screening or kernel panicking? Probably shocked it.
- ArlenBales 9y agoTwo of my friends build bicycles from scratch, but they find building a PC difficult. I argue that their hobby is ten times more complex than building a PC nowadays, as everything is mostly plug-in-play and idiot-proof. Installing the CPU in a mobo is a walk-in-the-park compared to truing your wheel or overhaul a hub.
- penguinUzer 9y agoI disagree on being 10x harder. Bicycles are the same concept just older. There is a frame (computer case/mobo) and you bolt on compatible parts like brakes, cranks, forks, wheels, etc. (cpu/memory/gpu/psu) I'm sure if you talk to someone working at a bike shop they could take your comment, flip it, and still have it be accurate: Two of my friends build PCs from scratch, but they find building a bicycle difficult. I argue that their hobby is ten times more complex than building a bicycle nowadays, as everything is mostly plug-in-play and idiot-proof. Truing your wheel or overhaul a hub is a walk-in-the-park compared to installing the CPU.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoHaving done the process a few times over the last, oh, two decades, I can say that some things have gotten easier while others have gotten a bit worse. Assembly a PC is pretty easy these days, most of the parts go together pretty easily, and your chances of everything working on the first try are pretty high. This is way different from ye olden days when it might take hours just to get a PC put together correctly unless you were lucky, hardware is a lot less fiddly these days than it used to be. But buying all the components for a PC is more challenging for novices. This can be hard for techies to understand because we just assume that everyone knows what we know. But your J. Average prospective computer building may not know whether a Core i7 8700 is better than a Core 2 Quad or vice versa. They also may not know what the heck an 8th generation Core i7 is. There are so many generations of components now and so many gradations within each generation that it can become and informational overload. If you try to go at the problem directly by just heading to newegg or amazon and browsing for parts without doing the research you're going to have a bad time. There are a zillion different socket formats, there are a zillion different motherboard form factors, there are a zillion different GPU lines and each one has a zillion different variations. How do you know which are compatible? How do you know which ones are the best? Or just the best for the price? Are higher numbers better? Worse? Not important? Is LGA 2066 better than LGA 1151? Is a GeForce 9800 better than a GTX 1080? There are a zillion of these little questions. Already knowing most of the answers makes navigating the problem vastly easier, having to find an answer for each and every one of them can be exhausting. You absolutely need some sort of guide or hand holding to get started on this problem from scratch but if you don't have any pre-existing knowledge you don't know where to go. (Personally, my favorite is http://www.logicalincrements.com http://www.logicalincrements.com but there are others.) You need someone to help you narrow the scope of the decision problem to a manageable level, otherwise you'll drown in choices and questions until you run out of will power to continue.
- penguinUzer 9y agoExcellent comment! Graphics card naming schemes are the worst of the lot. Without being an enthusiast and keeping up with benchmark reporting it's impossible to tell say, if an AMD RX560 is faster than an RX480. I mean 560 is a bigger number which means it's faster, right?
- Infernal 9y agoThe last computer I built required soldering and Digi-Key. As I found out after lots of trial and error, I got a bad molex-to-sata power adapter, and it took killing two hard drives before I narrowed it down to that cable. The SATA end was too narrow to get a multimeter in. I suspect the 12v and 5v lines were crossed. Long story short, a couple of resistors and diodes later my WD Blues were spinning up again, but it was a pain in the ass.
- penguinUzer 9y agoI used to think this way until recently. I literally have an engineering degree in electronics and it takes me hours to research a compatible set of components. A lay person stands no chance! A couple of examples off the top of my head: AMD RX480 power draw exceeds the pci-express current limit specification and bricked motherboards, hence I bought/overclocked an RX470 instead. Intel 6700k overclocking. Wow. Reading and understanding the thermal and power envelopes described in the 300 page datasheet difficult for me, it would be impossible for a lay person to comprehend.
- kunai 9y agoBuilding PCs is plenty of fun IRL too -- at least that was the case before the year began, at least. Yeah, cable management might suck, but for the most part fitting together all of these complicated pieces of silicon to create a working machine is incredibly rewarding. Now, what we have is a monopoly of those same pieces of hardware by miners, leaving much of the fun of building a PC gone, replaced by scrounging around for deals on Amazon and Newegg to see if you can find a GPU at less than 400% markup. It's taken a huge bite out of PC gaming and left the RAM and GPU market in shambles. Proof of work is an environmental disaster, and an economic one as well. Crypto needs to get its shit together and switch to proof of stake as soon as possible, because this type of gold rush helps nobody except a small few and hurts the people who use PCs for science and personal entertainment, who are a far larger chunk of the PC userbase.
- mistermann 9y ago> It's taken a huge bite out of PC gaming and left the RAM and GPU market in shambles. RAM prices have skyrocketed along with GPU? Sorry, not kept up on it....
- carc1n0gen 9y agoYes, but I don't believe it's for the same reasons
- developer2 9y agoDRAM and NAND shortages aren't new - the current supply problems started in 2016 and got progressively worse throughout 2017. The smartphone market is to blame - or rather, its consumers who upgrade/replace their phone every damn year. Apple alone drains the entire supply chain every time they ramp up for the next iPhone; add to that all the Android manufacturers, and there's just nothing left for desktop. If more people kept their phones for 2-4 years instead of expecting an upgrade every 9-12 months, we wouldn't have this problem.
- xvf22 9y agoYup, they've gone up a good amount. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/263031-ram-prices-roof-stuck-way https://www.extremetech.com/computing/263031-ram-prices-roof...
- Symbiote 9y ago> They don't tell you that closing the CPU guard feels like you're breaking hundreds of dollars worth of equipment 100 percent of the time. I had a brief summer job as a 17 year old, assembling computers. Even after over 100, I still had that feeling of imminent destruction of expensive electronics.
- cptskippy 9y agoPssssh... you don't know fear until you've tried to put a spring clip cooler on an Athlon XP or Pentium III without rocking it. Even after they added those foam circles to the corners it didn't add much comfort. Nothing makes you sicker than the sound of a corner of your CPU die crunching.
- baddox 9y agoOh, great memories. Those were absolutely terrifying, but luckily I never broke one and only had one instance of a friend breaking one. The absolute worst was when I (being a more experienced PC builder) was helping a friend with his first build, and the friend insists that I install the cooler.
- Scoundreller 9y agoMy spouse does the same thing. "Why don't you choose" == I get blamed if it's not the better choice.
- qplex 9y agoI destroyed my 600MHz Pentium III while fiddling with the cooler. A corner of the chip broke off. I used the same motherboard and bought an adapter which allowed an upgrade to a 1,3GHz PIII Tualatin. It had a proper headspreader so the installation was a breeze in comparison. The horror ensued on my next upgrade to an AMD Athlon XP 2800+ which again had the die exposed, but thankfully I never managed to destroy it.
- russdill 9y agoOr worse, taking it off.
- colanderman 9y agoNo doubt inspired by the amazing My Summer Car [1]. And presaged by the classic Onion videos "World of World of Warcraft" [2] and "Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3" [3]. [1] http://www.amistech.com/msc/ http://www.amistech.com/msc/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rw8gE3lnpLQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rw8gE3lnpLQ [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuTkgi7scKo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuTkgi7scKo
- Density 9y agoCan't recommend this game enough. Perkele.
- digi_owl 9y agoYour first link gets me thinking about Street Rod, that i played constantly on my Amiga 500. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wd4VwxBObo0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wd4VwxBObo0
- pro_zac 9y agoI played it on a NEC 286! Learned a lot about engines playing it.
- Raphmedia 9y agoCar Mechanic Simulator also comes to mind. http://store.steampowered.com/app/645630/Car_Mechanic_Simulator_2018/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/645630/Car_Mechanic_Simula...
- abritinthebay 9y agoGod I wish that game had classic VWs...
- _mrmnmly 9y agoAnd don't forget about their precursor - Gearhead Garage! :D
- dfxm12 9y agoOne of the cooler things about PC Building Simulator is that it uses a lot of real brands. Smart. If this game takes off, there's a ready made revenue stream to sell ad space in game. You can't ignore the core gameplay!
- acmecorps 9y agoThink it'll be profitable to make this free and make many just using affiliate links?
- digi_owl 9y agoFrankly i find the "problem" to be modern Windows. The 9x series had little trouble being moved around between motherboards and such, but the NT based ones seems to error at the drop of a pin (never mind how ornery Microsoft has become about copyright).
- wtallis 9y agoMicrosoft's bootloader is hilariously fragile, but once you fix that I haven't had much trouble migrating drives between fairly different systems (eg. quad-core consumer desktop and a dual-socket rackmount server).
- JepZ 9y agoYou might want to try Linux. As long as you don't compile your system with options optimized for your CPU and stay away from binary graphics drivers, you can pretty much boot it on every desktop PC hardware you like without any need for a new installation. Just don't expect everything to be perfect. Linux has its own set of weaknesses, but being picky about changing the hardware isn't one of them.
- digi_owl 9y agoI have and i used to like it. But some kind of mindrot is setting in at the user facing levels of development, and it is worming its way down the stack towards the kernel.
- jotm 9y agoI moved a Windows 7 installation between computers several times now - just clone and go. There's some whining and drivers on first boot, but otherwise it's fine. I really need to reinstall it, but can't be bothered right now, it works fine :D
- ferongr 9y agoIs this by the same writer that started crying while trying to build an actual PC?
- robrtsql 9y agoI did that when I built my PC too. I was fairly certain I had ruined $1500 in equipment.
- Scoundreller 9y agoWhile doing a bench build for a friend, when motherboards became really small, I put an AGP card in a PCI slot backwards because the port side wasn't constrained anymore. Thankfully only non-magic smoke came out.
- mikewhy 9y agoNote this is from the place that said building your own computer is too tough.
- rdl 9y agoI can't believe they left out the blood sacrifice on sharp parts of the case. Always different/unexpected parts of the case, and always miraculously sharp. (Less so now with higher end modern cases, but was definitely this way with 80s/90s/early-00s cases.)
- glandium 9y agoThe best part is that most of the time you don't realize you've cut yourself until there's blood in the case/on the motherboard/etc.
- Gracana 9y agoThose old cases were so sharp. One time I was fishing a screw out of a channel formed by some bends along the bottom of a computer case, and I felt the ragged sheet metal edge slide deep into the flesh of my fingertip. Ouch.
- nerfhammer 9y agoWindows only! I was excited at first because I always wanted to learn how to do this. But if it only runs on an OS I can't run that turns it into a chicken-and-egg problem...
- dbsvsv 9y agoOnly 99.3% of pc's can run a game about building PC's. Sad.
- lostmsu 9y agoI think it's closer to 100% due to Wine
- penguinUzer 9y agoGood thing the author of the article didn't buy that Apple he kept saying was better than assembling his own computer.
- ryan-allen 9y agoHe complains that PC gaming is too hard, but I'm pretty sure you can find companies that put together custom PCs with a warranty. In Australia there are dozens of well known places that do it. Saying that, you _can_ build a PC if you hop along to reddit /r/buildapc, they seem pretty happy to help you out if you can be bothered with the effort. I love building my PCs, haven't done it in a while due to it not being economically worthwhile, so now I just browse the parts for fun!
- penguinUzer 9y agoYes I read his original article and he should have bought a assembled and shipped gaming machine. Kinda like complaining it's difficult to build a fast car with zero domain knowledge and looking up a few websites. Either put in the time to learn or just go buy a performance package Mustang GT/Camaro/Challenger/etc.
- dmurthy 9y agoNever thought I'd need a tweezer until I met jumpers.
- harlanji 9y agoFun. Lately I have a growing pile of RasPis and SD cards everywhere. I guess I built enough PCs in the 00s and now they’re $50 so why not build clusters/etc? Back then PC games were around $60 or upgrades $200, now weekend projects with whole computers are too. I dig the idea still, would probably play before my next build which will surely be of expensive gear (eg. big Swarm/k8s nodes).
- meuk 9y agoI've found the older article 'PC Gaming Is Still Way Too Hard' to be quite amusing, but not very similar to my experience (although I only built two PC's). In my experience, the process of checking compatibility of the parts, and getting the parts can be a bit tedious (I had to wait multiple months for some parts). I did order DDR3 memory for a mobo that only supports DDR4 and bought a powersupply that was way too big for the small form factor case I was using (luckily I could return it). I found the actual build to be, by far, the easiest part of the process. Everything was basically plug and play (in the sense that the colors, annotations and connectors made everything very obvious to me). I also never experienced a crunch when I mounted the CPU. To be fair I didn't really use the manuals. If I would have broken something I would have a very different story.
- huffmsa 9y agoConsidered downloading this to do a few practice runs before rebuilding a $10k machine yesterday, decided to do it live. The game should definitely have other people standing around saying stuff like "should it make that crunching sound?"