8 ms·
In watching the evolution of USB-C over the last few years, it seems like it's extremely hard to implement correctly with the huge number of modes, alternate mo
by zdw 9y ago
In watching the evolution of USB-C over the last few years, it seems like it's extremely hard to implement correctly with the huge number of modes, alternate modes, and power delivery in the spec.
When you connect two USB-C devices today, you have almost no idea what is actually going to happen, which device is the master, and which way power will flow.
While having one connector and cable type for everything seems like it would be a good idea, in practice it's turning out to be a giant mess. Maybe it'll clear up in a few years, but given the race to the bottom in price and quality in the accessory market, this seems doubtful.
- arghwhat 9y agoThere needs to be a way to decide which device is the master, like the prompt on Android devices asking if you wish to power or be powered.
- spookthesunset 9y agoWonder if you could do it on the cable with little embedded LED lights. One end turns red for "charging" the other turns blue for "supplying power". Would add to the BOM cost on the cable for sure, but it would not only be cool looking but rather useful.
- woodrowbarlow 9y agooh yeah, because my bedroom doesn't have enough glowing devices when i'm trying to go to sleep. let's add LEDs to every cable too!
- spookthesunset 9y agoHah. Good point. Yes, too many devices want to put big giant blue LED's on their product.... even ones that are specifically targeted for the bedroom and specifically designed for sleeping...
- gargravarr 9y agoBarring the comments about adding more sources of light in a dark room (yep, I agree with this), I still appreciate the MagSafe adapter for my MBP lighting a tiny LED to say charging/full. The new USB-C MBPs we have at work don't have any indication whatsoever that the adapter is working unless the machine is booted and logged in (to pre-empt comments about the chime, what if it's muted, as is often true of workplace laptops?). MagSafe tells me no matter what state the computer is in. The LEDs don't have to be bright, just dim little indicators that are only really noticeable if you're looking for them. Then you get an instant idea of what the devices are doing.
- giobox 9y agoThis. I’m always completely bemused when I first connect a USB-C charger to a USB-C battery pack before plugging into the wall - the LED on the charger lights up like the battery is powering the charger. There’s also tons of times where the device you want to power from the battery starts charging the battery instead. With both ends of the connector being identical I’m not sure there even is a _good_ way to fix this that ordinary consumers will understand, the better solution might have been to still keep different cable ends. I hope this mess eventually gets better.
- iratewizard 9y agoWhat's more annoying is when you connect a wacom tablet to your laptop and your laptop says it's charging. Only when your laptop is dead do you realize it was low battery. I had this happen during a demo and it was terrible.
- parliament32 9y agoThe simplest solutions are directional cables (remember directional HDMI cables?) or plug-in order (supplier first, receiver last).
- joombaga 9y agoNot an EE, possibly a dumb question, but... do USB-C devices know that a cable has been plugged into them before the other end of the cable is plugged in to something else?
- wolf550e 9y agoThe plug can have (has?) resistors that let the socket "feel" it, even if the cable is not attached to anything.
- cbluth 9y agoJust imagine this: Device A <--> Device B Device A receives the cable first, upon receiving the cable, Device A notices that the cable is not "hot" ("hot" in the sense that there is voltage/activity on the wire), so then Device A decides to "turn on" the cable, make it "hot". Now Device B receives the cable, it notices that the cable is already "hot" and decides that it must be the second device. I would imagine it could work that way, Im also pretty sure that the usb cables are "dumb" cables and not active cables like QSFP (these have chips at each end).
- lopmotr 9y agoThat assumes a device can tell the difference between not hot and not there, which was the parent's question.
- arghwhat 9y agoThis is not how USB Type C works. The cables are active (chipped), and the end devices have sense resistors. Each device can detect the presence and type of the cable, as well as the presence and type of an end device and total cable orientation (swapped or not). This is all done before power is applied, as USB Type C is very explicit about not going hot (apart from a weak 5V V_conn for powering the cable). Also, QSFP is not a cable, but a pluggable spec. A QSFP module is active, but the fiber optic cable you connect to it to is dumb. Link detection there works by sensing beam power.
- emddudley 9y agoMurphy's Law: If it can go wrong, it will go wrong.
- dmoy 9y agoI partly agree that it's a bit harder than before. But a lot of the faulty devices we're seeing are just straight up using an incorrect resistor value or similar, and apparently released to the public without proper testing. Maybe that's on USB spec people for not having good material, but on the other hand maybe that's on the manufacturers for not hiring EEs who can actually read a damn spec sheet properly...
- fjsolwmv 9y agoIt's cost cutting to make cheaper cables and ports.
- lvh 9y agoOr intentional trivial incompatibility to sell _more expensive_ cables and ports :)
- gregmac 9y agoThat's a scary possibility. Flood the market with barely-functional garbage in the low range so that consumers can't figure out which cheap ones are actually usable and just pay more to avoid the headache. It's not dissimilar to the box store HDMI/audio/etc cable strategy: Cheap, absolutely garbage cables at a mid-range price, or upper-mid-range cables at grossly over-inflated prices. Consumers tricked because of course the $200 HDMI cable looks noticeable better than the $20 one. Reality is the real retail prices of cables they're comparing should be more like $2 and $20, and the difference between that $20 cable and one that actually would cost $200 is only noticeable with high-end test equipment (or by 'audiophiles', who have the super-power of being able to see/hear a difference in cables as long as they know the price).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 9y agoYeah i don't get how they went from a reversible USB plug (you can already find those in the A format, that use a small lip with contact pads on both sides) to a 20(?) wire monstrosity carrying anything from several amps of 20V electricity to thunderbolt wrapped PCI traffic.
- bsder 9y agoWell, the problem is that you can't patent Ethernet anymore so they have to complexify it. I'm being a bit snarky, but if you look at practically all the modern standards (HDMI, Thunderbolt, UCB-C), they are basically 2-TX and 2-RX pairs like Ethernet. The core problem with power is that you can't really pump laptop charge wattage down a USB cable without raising the voltage above 5V. Once you accept that, the engineering gets quite a bit more complicated and you have to negotiate so one side doesn't blow the other up.
- naikrovek 9y agoIt isn't extremely hard; lots of IC vendors make USB-PD chips that are fully compliant with USB-PD. And, they're not expensive. EEs are just cheap mother fuckers, often, and they think they can do it "well enough" themselves and save a cent or two on the bill of materials.
- emilfihlman 9y agoThis is not the fault of the connector. It is the fault of the protocol. USB is a clusterfuck.
- trisimix 9y agoMore and more devices are implementing it. Whats your tource its on its way to the bottom?