9 ms·
Tesla Bonds Are in Free Fall
- fpgaminer 9y agoWelcome to the sausage factory. Being a startup is like being a gladiator. Every day is another war. Every day other startups die. Every day of survival doesn't fill you with relief; you just think of tomorrow's doom. The general public only sees the sausages that come out of the factory. They only see the glory of massively successful companies like Dropbox. They would be horrified if they saw inside. The blood dripping through the grated floor. The graveyard of bones ground up and spit out as meal for the next "lucky" founder. This week the public has gotten a taste of how Tesla's sausage is made. Truth is; every day for Tesla has been like this. The truth is, every day in Tesla's life has been the closest it has ever come to death. Those in HN who've built a company know this. But they also know _why_ they suffer this pain. A mere two months ago SpaceX launched humanity's dreams into the outer reaches. Meanwhile Tesla is single-handedly altering the course of ground transportation. Last weekend we took a trip to San Diego in a Tesla. An all electric trip, charged up using the solar panels at our home, with most of the travel time driven by autopilot. The future drove us there and back again. That's why Tesla does what it does. I don't see the point in discussing Tesla's financials and their "impending" doom. Instead, I think the only appropriate thing to say is... Nos morituri te salutamus
- Balgair 9y agoI mean, this attitude is alright for a dog-walker app. But when Uber (and possibly Tesla) kills a person, it kinda changes the whole conversation, don't you think?
- nate_meurer 9y agoHow do you mean? How do you think the risks (which are expected given the very high stakes here) should change the parent's perspective?
- Balgair 9y agoLike EVs, yeah great, love it. Great job by the engineers there. Good stuff. But it's the auto-driving that seems to be sub-par thus far. Though the data isn't public (mostly), it seems like the auto-driving software is worse than the average driver. Again, seems.
- AstralStorm 9y agoProbably is really not, just people believe they are better drivers than they really are. It is a well documented Wobegon Lake effect. That said, the failure modes are really different. And technically someone Coyle design a smoke test for self driving cars that would put in some confidence into their abilities. We do that for human drivers, it is called a driving exam. Could be extended as much as we want it.
- Balgair 9y agoUm, no. Uber has to intervene in their self-driving car every 13 miles, on average. And they killed a person at 1/4th the mileage of an average person. Again, it's one data point, but a cause for concern nonetheless. That's not a Keillorism, that's plain bad. I agree that the cars need certs though, each and every one.
- jazzyk 9y agoIt will sound terribly insensitive, but many, many more people die in "regular" car accidents every single day. The number of deaths in envelope-pushing, new tech, accidents, compared to regular traffic deaths, is minuscule.
- Balgair 9y agoI mean, yeah, that's really insensitive. It's not about the number in this situation, it's about the stats. Uber's cars kill at a higher rate than the average driver. Granted, that stat is based on 1 data point, so it's not really a stat at all. Still, like, a ton more testing is obviously needed before these should be allowed anywhere near a school. Like, you wanna test a jet-pack? Be my guest. I'll grab a fire extinguisher when/if it fails. You wanna test a jet-pack near with dog in your arms? Dude, no way.
- SPBS 9y agoBut we don't know how much of that is due to regular cars usage being much larger in volume compared to electric. Only way we'd know is if electric car usage ramps up to comparative levels, which seems quite far away given the current climate
- DrScump 9y agopossibly Tesla) kills a person There's a big difference between "kills a person" and "doesn't always prevent a person from killing himself (and/or others)".
- IBM 9y agoJim Chanos: We think Tesla is worth zero [1] I've never understood why Tesla raised debt. They should have been issuing equity and nothing else, capitalizing on the insane valuation its had for the past 3-4 years. Debt would have been fine if they executed well, but they haven't. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/14/jim-chanos-we-think-tesla-is-worth-zero.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/14/jim-chanos-we-think-tesla-is...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoYeah, clearly that $1.5 billion in capex equipment is worthless /s Jim has been trying to make a profit short selling TSLA forever. I can’t take anything he says seriously, crying wolf and all that (although Tesla is going to have liquidity issues at the end of the year if they can’t get their debt refinanced). TLDR Capital intensive business facing challenges in rising interest rate environment.
- ghazak 9y agoIf he means the equity is worth 0, then the point still stands. The bond holders would get it.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoA broken clock is right twice a day.
- paulpauper 9y agoThis guy has been negative about tesla for years. he needs to be held accountable for being wrong.
- grzm 9y agoIs there a service out there that does rate market/tech prognosticators like this? I agree it'd be useful. There are similar ones for, say, politicians or media in general, but I'd like to see an industry-specific one.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoSomehow I foresee the billionaire class of technical experts will step in and prevent the downfall of Tesla. Too many people believe in the vision of Elon to let this fall apart because of short term production issues. If anything, this could be a good thing for Tesla as it might attract other owner/operator expertise to the firm.
- stillsut 9y agoHow can an electric car company be in a bear market the week after a fusion device was patented? If Lockheed really believes in their device, they ought to buy Tesla.
- femidav 9y agoIt's about battery, not about electricity. You will need 20-40% of additional electricity production to convert all ICE cars to electric, it can be done today. But the battery can't compete with ICE on equal terms.
- ironjunkie 9y agoThis. Tesla became too big to fail and Musk became too hype to fail.
- bitumen 9y agoOn this site maybe, not in reality. Most people want a return on investment, not a shine job about living on Mars next week.
- Alex3917 9y agoIf Tesla collapses then it would negatively affect the price of a lot of other SV stocks. I bet SoftBank or the Saudis would just throw them a billion dollars before they let that happen.
- jonknee 9y agoWhy would the production issue based collapse of a highly levered manufacturer negatively affect the price of software/service companies?
- CharlesMerriam2 9y agoTruly, a financial news feed about financial news of the intraday trading of a financial instrument will affect the technology I select this year.
- Idontagree 9y agoCan you restate that? I'm not sure what you're saying tbh. You want intraday news on bonds or some other security?
- foota 9y agoI think they're saying it won't affect whether they want to buy a tesla or not.
- twblalock 9y agoIt should affect buying decisions. What would a Tesla owner do if their car broke down and the company did not exist anymore? It's not like you can just go to an auto parts store or an ordinary mechanic.
- adventured 9y agoThey should have taken this market bubble opportunity, pre recent drop, to pull the trigger on a $5 billion raise via equity dilution. Might have bought them into 2021. They had a solid 10-11 months at the recent ~$320 level to do it. This market and their own situation combined, can easily be one of those cases where you wake up in May or June with 1/2 the market cap you had in January or February.
- viburnum 9y ago8% yield doesn't sound like free fall.
- fancyfacebook 9y agoWhen your yield moves from 6 to 8% and your debt is rated junk (seven levels below investment grade) yes it is free fall. The bond price/yield chart appears to be going parabolic in the past few days.
- slededit 9y agoIts amazing your getting downvoted. Anyone who even looked at bond pricing in the last few years would be shocked by an 8% yield, and a 2% short term move. Those numbers are simply not normal for any healthy company post 2008.
- perl4ever 9y agoIt's only relevant if they need to issue more bonds, though, I would think. Couldn't they issue stock? As we see with ICOs, and Tesla's soliciting of deposit money, and other companies issuing stock with no voting rights, there seems to be a vast ocean of capital floating around that people can be sweet-talked out of for almost nothing. Heck, maybe they could start a GoFundMe.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> Couldn't they issue stock? They could, but with TSLA down almost 30% in a month and shareholders already grumbling, they are fast approaching the limits of what they can tap in the equity market. > Heck, maybe they could start a GoFundMe. Please be serious. Tesla is losing $400 million every month and has over a $1 billion in debt payments due over the next year. We’re talking about big person money here.
- perl4ever 9y ago$400 million every month? What is your source? The latest official financial filing says they lost an average of $163 million per month in 2017. See https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459018002956/tsla-10k_20171231.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459018...
- paulpauper 9y agoIf insolvency were a concern the stock would be much lower. Seems like more fud by journalists who want to see Tesla fail.
- make3 9y agojournalists want to create controversy to get views; they likely don't care if it fails or not
- twblalock 9y agoIf you can't defend the company on its own merits, instead of accusing journalists of wanting it to fail, then maybe you should consider that the journalists are correct and the company really does have some problems. By the way, the stock is much lower. It's down over 15% since Monday. You can blame general stock market volatility for some of that, but even so it's a much larger drop than the overall market experienced.
- manicdee 9y agoTesla stock is a roller coaster, with the market reacting hyperbolically to any Tesla news. Attempting to treat the stock market as a rational entity is a fool’s gambit. If you have to pretend that a Tesla shorter is a journalist you should consider that maybe your world view has some problems.
- anilshanbhag 9y agoBloomberg has an entire page to track Model 3 production. The production ramp is there: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ Credit rating agencies have defined rules and many institutions have policies on what mix of bonds they have. Investors do over-react to short term news.
- Spooky23 9y agoYou’re probably witnessing a prelude to a correction later this year. Debt markets are tightening up and junk companies will not survive. They need to raise north a billion this year. It’s reasonable to be a bear, unfortunately. If you like Tesla cars, the best investment in them is to see which automaker is best positioned to pick up what’s left.
- dragontamer 9y ago8% in this market? Wow. That's... that's pretty bad. Interest rates have been rising steadily, but a spike to 8% can only mean that bond investors have begun to lost faith in Tesla. The market however, is reacting to Moody's credit rating. Moody's downgraded Tesla to B3 and Caa1 earlier this week, which is well into junk-bond status. The TL;DR about it is that Telsa's Model 3 production isn't ramping up fast enough. Tesla's current debt deadlines are: * $230 million due in November 2018 * $920 million due in March 2019 Tesla is running out of time, and the Model 3 isn't being made fast enough. There's plenty of demand. Tesla is most likely going to be forced to borrow money to pay off its last debts.
- Gibbon1 9y ago> Tesla is most likely going to be forced to borrow money to pay off its last debts. Rolling debt, totally unheard of.
- dragontamer 9y agoRolling debt from 5.6% to 8% is killer. The question is what prices does Tesla get on its new debt? And is it sustainable?
- manicdee 9y ago$230M means about 45k Model 3 sales assuming no other income. Or about 25k Model S/X sales assuming no other income. Or two dozen big battery installations assuming no other income. But since Tesla is manufacturing Model S, Model X, Model 3, Powerpack and Powerwall, it’s a safe bet that $230M will be covered with expected sales even if Model 3 production stalls at this week’s peak. $920M next year means Tesla have to reach 50k Model 3 a month with no other income. If they start rolling out Solar Roof before then, and sell any Model S or X, or raise the rate of big battery installations, they will make that payment too. Tesla doesn’t only sell cars.
- dragontamer 9y agoYou're quite the optimist. There's a reason Tesla's credit was just degraded to Caa1. https://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/OG-AX813_TESLA1_FON_20171030180617.png https://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/OG-AX813_TESLA1_F... Tesla lost $1.6 Billion dollars in 2017. Tesla is going to lose money in 2018 AND it has bills due.
- transfire 9y agoIs it a purposeful tactic to undermine Tesla and slow the inevitsbile domination of electric vehicles?
- CatDevURandom 9y agoTesla: A Disruptive Force with a Debt Problem? https://youtu.be/HxkbUrNYvmY https://youtu.be/HxkbUrNYvmY
- gfo 9y agoI don't want Tesla to fail because I like what Elon Musk is doing for the world. However, the production timeline issues combined with the poor quality of Model 3 cars which have already been released is a big concern of mine, to the point where my confidence is lowered in the company. I really want to believe he'll find a way out of this but it's not hard to see why investors are worried.
- Avshalom 9y ago>because of short term production issues I agree with ironjunkie that Tesla is too hype to fail; Tesla has had production issues since the start of the Model S... 6 years is no longer 'short term'
- avalys 9y agoI've never understood what long-term value people see in Tesla. There is no major technical advantage in their motor or battery technology. Autopilot is nowhere near full self-driving and Tesla is not any further ahead on that than other players in the market (they're just more willing to hype it and ship unfinished products). Their cars are nice, but not amazing compared to other manufacturers in the same price range (in fact, build quality is notably worse in many ways). Yes, Tesla was a bit ahead of everyone else to market, but how are they going to compete when they're not the only one in the "luxury electric car" space?
- Avshalom 9y agowhen asked: "tesla is an infrastructure company" or "tesla is a battery company" (well no panasonic is...) or "tesla is an energy company" (slightly more realistic since they bailed out solarcity) or "tesla is a self driving car company" (which as you point out: they're not any further than anyone else).
- manicdee 9y agoWhere are Panasonic’s utility scale batteries? Sure, Panasonic manufactures the 2170 cells, but they aren’t in the same game as Tesla.
- Avshalom 9y ago>>Where are Panasonic’s utility scale batteries? where ever somebody wants them. >>Sure, Panasonic manufactures the 2170 cells, but they aren’t in the same game as Tesla. While true Tesla is a value-add on those cells, but like 99% a value add for themselves. The quick question is if one of them died would the other survive...
- eugmill 9y agoTesla wasn't just ahead of everyone else to market, they forced everybody else to market. If tesla gets everybody else to make great electric cars, that's a success to me, even if tesla itself implodes. I think if not for tesla, other car companies would not be scrambling to make better Evs.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoIs Tesla still being propped by US taxpayers? If so looks like you folks are up for another round of "private profits, social losses" again.
- SQL2219 9y agoJohn Thompson, Hedge Fund dude: . . . As a reality check, Tesla is worth twice as much as Ford* yet Ford made 6 million cars last year at a $7.6 billion profit while Tesla made 100,000 cars at a $2 billion loss. Further, Ford has $12 billion in cash held for “a rainy day” while Tesla will likely run out of money in the next 3 months.
- shafyy 9y agoThat dude is also shorting Tesla, of course, he's going to try to influence public opinion in this way. He'll make a shit ton of cash if Tesla goes southwards.
- panarky 9y agoIn 2004, Google was valued at $23 billion. Other advertising companies made far more profit than Google, had more cash in the bank than Google, yet had lower valuations than Google. On that evidence, many "experts" and "analysts" said Google was grossly overvalued. Today it's easy to see that their analysis was dead wrong. If you can figure out why the conventional wisdom then was wrong, you'll understand why Tesla stock has value today.
- xkjkls 9y agoGoogle was already profitable in 2004, and more than doubling revenues. Tesla is none of those things, and you're paying way more for it.
- Teeer 9y ago> Other advertising companies made far more profit than Google Your argument fails at that. Considering Google strictly an "advertising" company is a narrow view, even in 2004.
- panarky 9y agoIt's not my argument, it's an argument from analysts who said Google was overvalued in 2004. Apparently they couldn't imagine the future, so they measured Google against its contemporaries. Comparing Tesla to Ford is a similar failure of the imagination.
- Animats 9y agoProduction is up a bit this week, according to Bloomberg.[1] 1076 units of the Model 3 last week. The plant is supposed to produce 5,000 units a week. Costs are at the level for 5,000 units, while revenue is a fifth of that. That's what's killing Tesla financially. When Musk first announced the proposed Model 3 production schedule, his two top manufacturing executives quit. They knew that the shortcuts Musk wanted to take, like skipping debugging of the assembly automation at the supplier's factory, wouldn't work. They were right. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/
- abledon 9y agoHow much money does spaceX have? And ___hypothetically___, would it be possible to merge tesla into spaceX.
- jacquesm 9y agoThey already pulled that trick with Solar City for which there were at least some plausible reasons. I see no such plausibility for any SpaceX / Tesla merger. If Tesla can't make it SpaceX will not come to the rescue.
- perl4ever 9y agoI don't want them to, even though I own a tiny amount of TSLA so it would technically be in my interest. SpaceX is doing things nobody else can, and it would be a shame if they were dragged down. Batteries and electric cars will continue to be worked on by many regardless of whether Tesla were to vanish tomorrow.
- jacquesm 9y agoTotally agreed. I already think what Musk did with Solar City and Tesla was a distraction he didn't need. Let's hope that Tesla survives, it would be a damn shame to see them pave the way for everybody else. On the other hand, it's not as if they invented electric cars at Tesla, that's how the industry started out and after a 100 year detour of the ICE we're back to square one.
- sq_ 9y agoSpaceX seems to have plenty of money on hand, but I really doubt that Elon would do that, no matter how bad things looked for Tesla. It seems like SpaceX is starting to move all of their resources into BFR development/production and wouldn’t want a car company with production issues eating into said resources. I think Tesla going to Google or SoftBank or another group and asking for an infusion of money (and maybe a Waymo collaboration if it’s Google) would be much more likely.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nairboon 9y agoso it's time to buy?
- Analemma_ 9y agoIf you think Tesla is going to pull through, then sure: put your money where your mouth is and buy them cheap.