6 ms·
If Facebook goes away, MySpace is nowhere near an adequate analogy. Facebook has 2.2 billion monthly active users. In other words, there are more active monthly
by philwelch 9y ago
If Facebook goes away, MySpace is nowhere near an adequate analogy. Facebook has 2.2 billion monthly active users. In other words, there are more active monthly Facebook users in the world than:
* Roman Catholics (1.2 billion)
* People living in China (1.4 billion)
* Total speakers of English, the most widely-spoken language in the world (1.4 billion)
* Muslims (1.8 billion)
* Viewers of the 2014 FIFA World Cup final (1 billion)
* iPhones ever manufactured (1.2 billion; also, the top two most-used apps are Facebook and Facebook Messenger)
* Windows users (1.4 billion)
* Inhabitants of the European Union (508 million)
* Cats (600 million)
* Firearms (875 million)
* Africans (1 billion)
Now, obviously whether or not you use Facebook isn't as important to your identity or as hard to change as your religion or where you live, but it's also not something that's just going to suddenly disappear without some sort of replacement, or else if it does, it will be the first time in human history that two billion people all decided at once to give up on something.
- lev99 9y agoIf you assume 1 MOD account means one person 30% of the world's population uses Facebook. At one point 23% of the world's population belonged to the British empire [0]. Facebook falling would be similar to the British empire decline. [0] http://theunbrokenwindow.com/Development/MADDISON%20The%20World%20Economy--A%20Millennial.pdf http://theunbrokenwindow.com/Development/MADDISON%20The%20Wo... (page 97)
- rubidium 9y agoNo, it would be much less significant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 9y agoFacebook's metric probably counts me as a user because once or twice a month I watch a video that happens to be on Facebook. Be careful about taking that number too seriously.
- rubidium 9y agoWe all quit watching the 2014 FIFA World Cup at the same time... so it's only a factor of 2 difference from that.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoThat's because the World Cup because it ended, not because we all decided that we didn't want to watch soccer any longer. That analogy would work if we all quit Facebook because Facebook shut off its servers. It doesn't work for people voluntarily quitting Facebook.
- EngineerBetter 9y agoI think you missed the joke.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoAh, yes, I guess I did.
- dotsh 9y agoProbably half of that are fake profiles, profiles made by people for commercial purposes or bots. If you make fake account and you will start wandering in the endless facebook steppes, you will notice that many of them are one post account that advertise or play games. The best ones are those with pictures of known or lesser known models to collect friends and sell such an account for dollars later. I have reported several hundred of such profiles, of which maybe 1/20 have been blocked rest is fine because moderators can't see difference between real life person and photo from google images in 20 accounts in a row...
- philwelch 9y ago2.2 billion isn't the total number of accounts, it's the number of "monthly active users"--and Facebook would probably be in much hotter water than they are now if they cooked the books on that number.
- pkulak 9y agoBots are active though, right?
- ExcelSaga 9y agoYeah, but they’re not looking at ads or providing useful data for brokers.
- dotsh 9y agoThis don't change my comment still many of them are fakes. I know people who have 5-6 accounts active at one time playing different games with 500+ friends on it. Many of those "friends" also are fakes, some even with the same profile picture of "real person" with fake data but I have nothing against FB, every medium is abused. It's just interesting that not a single research was done on this topic that I know about. :)
- da02 9y agoWhy do your friends have 5+ accounts opened? To get around limits on games?
- Mefis 9y agoAnd myspace had 75m monthly active users at its peak. This really does look like a bad comparison. Maybe you could adjust for total internet users then and now but I doubt that would make a difference. Edit: (dubious) source: https://startupbros.com/myspace-the-rise-fall-and-rise-again-infographic/ https://startupbros.com/myspace-the-rise-fall-and-rise-again...
- icc97 9y agoThat 75m might not look so bad if you compare it to the total number of internet users at the time. But it's still probably an order of magnitude smaller than Facebook.
- Bud 9y agoWill it actually be "the first time in human history that two billion people all decided at once to give up on something"? How many users of leaded gasoline were there? I guess that wasn't "all at once", though.
- emodendroket 9y agoYou're right. If the government of the United States were to ban using Facebook, you'd probably see a lot fewer people using Facebook.
- philwelch 9y agoIt looks like ~1-1.4 billion cars are driven every day now, which is an all-time high. So add "cars" to the original list. Staggering.
- gfo 9y agoI'm curious about how many people were on the internet at Myspace's peak though. Seems a lot of the online world is on Facebook now, but technology does make it very easy to switch platforms at a moment's notice when the new thing comes out. As you've stated, it's MUCH harder to change a core part of one's identity.
- numbsafari 9y agoThe 19 Billion chickens in the world scoff at your bookface.
- ken 9y ago"Facebook" is more like a suite than a single service. For example, I use Facebook almost every day, but I never look at my newsfeed, and virtually never post to it. I basically only log in for 2 specific private groups that use it for scheduling. It would be easy to replace, if that group of friends/colleagues decided to use something else for collaboration. We don't need to replace all 100 services they offer. We need only a couple. I suspect that's how Facebook is going to end. We're not all going to stop going to "facebook.com" overnight. Someone will steal away chat (Twitter?), someone will steal away photos (Flickr?), someone will steal away events, and so on, until it's been picked clean.
- LukaAl 9y agoMmm... 2.2B MAU. When you think about how they counted them, probably they used HyperLogLog. In usual configuration, it has a 0.7 - 1% error. Basically a medium-sized country... Or the number of users that any startup founder will die for... It is impressive what Facebook managed to build, but, although the number is staggering, the relative amount of people that switched from horses to cars or to electricity for illumination from candles and burning oil is even bigger... People do not voluntarily stop using something, but the force of innovation is huge. Very few Fortune 500 companies even existed 100 years ago, and the pace of disruption is accelerating...
- nojvek 9y agowe usually overestimate short term trends and under estimate long term trends. Who would have thought Apple would be the most valuable company when the iPhone came out. Nokia was the king back then. Kids nowadays don’t even know what Nokia is.
- LukaAl 9y agoWhat is Nokia? Just joking, Totally agree with you...
- justinzollars 9y agoYou can subtract one. I'm not on it anymore.
- mseebach 9y agoMySpace didn't suddenly disappear, it fizzled out over a long time. Also, the relevant metric isn't the total number of users -- this is a massive parallellisable process -- it's the average network-effect lock-in per user. For one thing, networks are fairly segmented around geographies. And that's what makes the MySpace analogy relevant: people thought it would never go away because it had very strong network effects, everybody you care about is on it. Facebooks demise doesn't require the coordinated action of two billion people. Network effects work the other way as well: when people do leave, they make the experience a little worse for all their contacts, lowering the bar for them to leave as well. Sure, the number of users probably extends the long tail of the demise, indeed I expect Facebook to hang around as at least a low-engagement contact book/messenger platform for a long time. Their demise will look more like Yahoo than MySpace, but the MySpace story does tell us that network effects aren't magical spells that can never be broken, and network effects are Facebooks most important moat.
- Daycrawler 9y ago2.2 billion is a bullshit number, plain and simple.
- thrownaway954 9y agoyou also have to consider how many people actual connected to the internet back then... most connected with a desktop computer. nowadays, everyone with a phone has the internet in their hand.