10 ms·
Gravitational attraction of stars and cows
- amriksohata 9y agoI don't get it
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cowboysauce 9y agoThe gravitational pull of nearby, mundane objects is just as strong, if not stronger, than the pull of the stars and planets. If the gravitational pull of the stars and planets impacts human behavior, as astrology posists, then so should a cow several miles away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 9y agoDoes astrology actually posit a mechanism? I thought that part was left unspecified.
- baddox 9y agoAccording to the first sentence of the article, gravity is one suggested mechanism.
- mikeash 9y agoSure, but there’s potentially a large gulf between “some people attempt to rationalize astrology by saying” and “astrology says.”
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jpmoyn 9y agoHe is just addressing the people who rationalize it by gravity, then.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- godzilla82 9y agoExactly. Side question: If you really believe something, do you feel the need to rationalize it?
- nonbel 9y agoI think astrology only posits that human behavior is somehow correlated with the positions of the various heavenly bodies. This could be via an intermediate correlation with the weather, etc.
- abledon 9y agoIsn’t there a quantum theory of entanglement that says something like once two electrons meet then separate they are still ‘bound’ and influencing each other ? I wonder since, as carbon based life forms , we are all just made up of stardust , how and on what string theoretical levels we are quantum entangled with all the atoms known as planets moving around ?
- brianpan 9y agoJupiter is pulling on your body right now (a little bit). You would experience the same amount of pull from a cow standing half a meter away (since it is much closer, but much less massive).
- vincentchu 9y agoCalculation only holds for spherical cows. :D
- saagarjha 9y agoAnd a spherical you!
- portofcall 9y agoIn a vacuum, at infinity.
- weinzierl 9y agoWhich, as we know at least since Alan Turings 1952 paper ”The Chemical Basis of Morphogenesis”, might possibly not even exist. "a system which has spherical symmetry, and whose state is changing because of chemical reactions and diffusion ... cannot result in an organism such as a horse, which is not spherically symmetrical.” http://www.dna.caltech.edu/courses/cs191/paperscs191/turing.pdf http://www.dna.caltech.edu/courses/cs191/paperscs191/turing....
- nyrikki 9y agoIt actually is :) Under General Relativity what is commonly called gravity is a fictitious force or pseudo force and is purely an artifact of being in a non-inertial frame of reference. While a very useful in most use cases, and accurate for most needs even Newton was bothered that under his model gravity acts Instanously. This superluminal communication makes the math work but is a spherical cow :) As a direct comparison under Newtonian mechanics, the centrifugal force is a "inertial" or "fictitious" or "pseudo" force. Due to Einstein's equivalence principle, and under General Relativity gravity is also a "inertial" or "fictitious" or "pseudo" force. To quote John Wheeler. "Mass tells space-time how to curve, and space-time tells mass how to move."
- msla 9y agoI think we should dump the "fictitious force" and "pseduo force" nonsense and say what we mean: "frame-dependent force", as in this force depends on the observer being in a specific, non-inertial frame of reference. These forces are real, and observable, and their existence distinguishes inertial from non-inertial frames, which is a useful thing to do.
- coryfklein 9y agoThis is the first calculation of the gravitational forces for small objects that I can actually understand intuitively. Much better than trying to specify in newtons the actual force of gravity between me and said cow.
- amelius 9y agoWhat I find more interesting is the gravitational pull of ice sheets on the sea, e.g. [1]. [1] http://sealevelstudy.org/sea-change-science/whats-in-a-number/attractive-ice-sheets http://sealevelstudy.org/sea-change-science/whats-in-a-numbe...
- mirimir 9y agoThat is an amazing effect, which I'd never considered, before seeing it on HN some months ago. It's a nontrivial contribution to sea level rise after ice sheets melt.
- roywiggins 9y agoI wonder what the implications are for cow-based astrology.
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoI wondered whether "17 miles" is a good estimate for how far I am from a cow, and now I'm trying to do a sort of Fermi problem in my head and realizing I'm out of practice for bad job interviews.
- bluetwo 9y agoGravity is the most romantic force in all of nature. The idea that everything in the universe is connected and pulling is mind blowing.
- pugio 9y agoI'm a physics teacher, and we just did Universal Gravitation last week. I whimsically explained it as "the longing of everything for everything". (They liked it, but devolved into a giggle fest about being attracted to each other.) Other easily romantic notions in physics: * we are all born of star stuff * every breath we take has elements of the same breath as every human who ever lived (excluding some currently living ones, due to diffusion rates, but eventually...) * (The current grav force between my partner and me is 1.9159965e-15 N)
- pm 9y agoThat's a great lyric - I will have to put it into a song. Credit goes to pugio.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago> every breath we take has elements of the same breath as every human who ever lived (excluding some currently living ones, due to diffusion rates, but eventually...) Is it conceivable that some of the oxygen and nitrogen, etc, in the atmosphere today wasn’t present in the atmosphere, say, 40,000 years ago due to it being bound up in minerals or biological matter?
- mrybczyn 9y agoWell.... I'm pretty sure the field interpretation of EM also applies across the universe. So you could, on a dark night, with the electrons in the atoms of your body, feel the movement of electrons in a star, millions of light years away in space and time...
- ISL 9y agoThat interpretation is entirely valid, but the fact that objects can be electrically neutral mitigates the magnitude of that effect substantially.
- api 9y agoThe only somewhat reasonable hypothesis I've ever heard about how astrology might work (if it did) is the clock hypothesis. The idea is that the stars have nothing to do with it in a causal sense. Ancient people just noticed certain patterns and correlated them with the stars because stars were what they used to keep time. The real causal mechanism could be some kind of biological cycle or something else.
- jakeogh 9y agoCertain old but powerful gangs like to flash their signs by doing things in sidereal time, so the same stars are overhead.
- hanoz 9y agoI somehow feel you're not going to divest an astrologer of their belief in the power of Jupiter by comparing it with standing within touching distance of a massive cow.
- btilly 9y agoActually we are in free fall relative to these astronomical bodies. Meaning that the Earth and you are both pulled together and so in your local reference frame it is not detectable. The locally detectable force is tidal. Which follows a cube law. It turns out that every cow on Earth creates larger tidal forces on you than any star except the Sun. :-)
- cousin_it 9y agoWe're in free fall relative to stars, but not relative to cows. So I guess every cow affects us more than every star?
- eismcc 9y agoWonder what the effects of the great plastic islands in the oceans are.
- ben-schaaf 9y agoSince they're not really islands, more like a heap of suspended particles in the upper layer of water, they should have the same density as the water. So they should have the same gravitational effect as water.
- OrganicMSG 9y agoThey gravitationally repel cows very slightly, which is why cows tend to stay on land.
- ssijak 9y agoWe are falling in so many reference places that I can`t find where my head and where my but is.
- jacinabox 9y agoWhoa, leading with astrology in a physics article, strong choice.
- sxv 9y agoWhat this article overlooks is the indirect effect of this gravitation. Yes, the moon's effect on only my body is tiny, but the moon's cumulative effect on every particle on Earth adds up to substantial cycles which we observe as tides. If it affects the whole, then it also affects the parts.
- teraflop 9y agoAlso, being in free-fall relative to the earth isn't locally distinguishable from being in free-fall relative to both the earth and the moon. Tidal effects are caused by the gradient of the gravitational field across significant distances. And the gradient drops off in proportion to the inverse cube of the distance, not the inverse square. Which is why tidal effects are only observable from the moon and sun, not from other celestial bodies. (Jupiter's gravitational influence on the Earth is about 1% that of the moon, but it's so far away that the tidal effects are infinitesimal.)
- EvilTerran 9y agoRandall Munroe's done an edition of "What If" on a similar question: "Which has a greater gravitational pull on me: the Sun, or spiders?" https://what-if.xkcd.com/136/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/136/ The main conclusion is sadly not that exciting, but the digressions are fun as always.
- kang 9y agoThe entire universe is having measurable("infinite" but countable) gravitational effect. You need to prove that "cumulative" effect is negligible.
- pmontra 9y agoIt reminds me of this page I created a few years ago https://connettiva.eu/newton/ https://connettiva.eu/newton/ Select a planet, then touch the objects below. Eventually read the text at the end for the implementation details.
- nerfhammer 9y agoNext question, what is the smallest object whose gravitational field could reliably be measured by the accelerometer in your phone? We know that it can measure the field of the Earth at more or less sea level, how much less heavy/further away could something get for your phone to feel it? my attempt: diameter of earth = 12742 km sea level = distance from earth = 12742/2 weight of empire state building = 331000000 kg resolution of BMA280 in the iPhone 6: 1/4096 g mass of earth = 5.972e+24 kg gravity of earth = 1 g km to m = 1000x (12742/2. * sqrt(331000000 / (5.972e+24 / 4096.))) * 1000 = 3 meters So your phone should be able to register 1 bit of resolution when the empire state building is 3 meters away or less, otherwise it would be too far away to detect. Of course the empire state building would need to be compressed into a single point but that's a minor practical concern.
- dx034 9y agoBut wouldn't all of the mass need to be <3 meters away from you?
- nerfhammer 9y agoI called this out as a minor practical concern
- k3liutZu 9y ago> Of course the empire state building would need to be compressed into a single point but that's a minor practical concern. "minor" :) That's great, have an upvote.
- mirimir 9y agoIn my experience, astrologers aren't readily tempted into physical explanations.
- alberto_ol 9y agosomething related https://xorshammer.com/2016/05/18/gravity-is-stronger-than-i-thought/ https://xorshammer.com/2016/05/18/gravity-is-stronger-than-i...
- cjg 9y agoI think that if I was standing 0.57m from a cow all day, that might have some significant impact - just not in a gravitational sense.