13 ms·
Fiber Lasers are set to make laser weapons practical
- ExcelSaga 9y agoFiber lasers are part of the solution, but blooming in air, and from target ablation is still a problem. What we really need for “ray guns” are phased array lasers and/or FEL’s. Just pumping more energy through conventional optics will make the problems I mentioned worse, not better.
- jessaustin 9y agoISTM "target ablation" might be the purpose of a ray gun? It sounds painful, anyway.
- matte_black 9y agoI’m having a hard time imagining what this kind of damage would be like. What would happen for instance if it were fired at a person’s head?
- cctt23 9y agoBlindness, 2nd and then 3rd degree burns. Think of it more like a heat ray, and you get the idea. Human heads don’t have the option of countermeasures though, such as ablative costing which dramatically increase blooming, while insulating the target. You need more than 100kw to either punch through that, or take advantage of non-linear effects.
- ExcelSaga 9y agoAt these energies it’s less about ablation and more about thermal effects on propellant and warhead assemblies. The problem is that coating a missile in a thin layer of something designed to ablate is a lot cheaper than building a laser to overcome those countermeasures.
- walshemj 9y agoYes but all you need to do to the missile is perturb its flight or damage its steering fins causing it to miss - you don't need to blow it up.
- gnode 9y agoBallistic missiles often don't have steering fins, and are guided using thrust vectoring. Also, missile defence often has to take place in the terminal stage of flight (e.g. THAAD), where the missile is carried to its target by its momentum, as you can't station your defence system in your enemy's territory.
- walshemj 9y agoI was talking about PD (point defence) on the battle field where your not targeting ICBM's but RPG's, MANPADS and CPR rounds mortar's especially
- adrianratnapala 9y agoYes, to me these problem with laser weapons seem fundamental. The thing which makes light interesting and useful is that it interacts so strongly with matter. So strongly in fact that they can be hugely affected by such things are air-density variations, fine particles in the air etc. So it seems the makers of anti-laser defences will always have options. Bullets and bombs on the other hand have the "nice" property that they interact strongly with solid matter but fairly weakly with gasses. (Yes, it's more complicated than that).
- dingaling 9y agoBlooming could be partially compensated by using probing lasers and adaptive focusing optics such as in big astro telescopes. Basically one uses a standard laser to determine air interference and then use rams to reform a semi-flexible mirror to compensate.
- chris_va 9y agoMy read is that this will be great for commercial applications (e.g. welding, lighting), but a weapon that doesn't work in a smokey/foggy environment is going to be fairly easy to circumvent. Environments where something is being hit with a high power laser tend to end up being smokey/foggy. That won't make it useless, but it will definitely reduce utility and adoption. 100kW really is not that much, unless you can focus it to a fairly small diameter, which just is not possible at long distances. My personal favorite for a "ray gun", and far more difficult to make work, is the Laser-Induced Plasma Channel.
- cctt23 9y agoWhat we really need is an energetically advantageous way to produce high energy neutral particle beams. That would start to look more like the ray guns of science fiction than lasers ever will. It’s not just the weather either, when you hit a target that has a bit of appropriate ablative armor, you’ll be dealing with another source of bloom. LIPC tech is good too, and might be closer than you’d think. You can exploit the interaction of ultrashort laser pulses to create and modulate plasma, and then do neat things like send a bunch of volts down the channel.
- aaronblohowiak 9y agoLightning!
- jcims 9y agoOr just use the plasma directly - https://youtu.be/ML79u9zPZu4?t=2m47s https://youtu.be/ML79u9zPZu4?t=2m47s
- gnode 9y agoSomething like a Godiva device (pulsed nuclear reactor)? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godiva_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godiva_device They have a risk of creating a small nuclear explosion though.
- mirimir 9y agoAlso, I get from Ian Banks' SF, mirrors are a defense. And indeed, blowback offense.
- pasbesoin 9y agoOn the power end, some years ago I noticed that every time there was an announcement on supposedly significant progress in ultra-capacitors, said line of inquiry seemed to "disappear". Probably not, but I started to wonder whether military/security agencies were moving in and sitting on these developments, in lieu of having an effective defense against weapons powered by them. Not just large-scale weapons, but anti-personnel weapons.
- gregpilling 9y agoI have a 4kw IPG laser. It cuts through 1/4 steel plate with ease, unless there is a piece of tape or spray paint on the metal. It can't cut that! it has to do with how the wavelength of the light couples with the material. (I am not a laser engineer, I am the customer) The 4kw power supply only is $128,000 if you want a cost reference,(just the power supply - motion control, cutting head and chiller are extra). It is an 8 module unit of 500 watts each, that can be powered down to 50w each if wanted, with full frequency and duty cycle control of the beam. It is about 48"x48"x18" and plugs into a 460v 30A 3Ph circuit. There is a chiller the size of a refrigerator to keep it cool. 100kw like in the article would cost roughly $3.2M for the light source only. There were 20 kw lasers mounted to 7 axis ABB robot arms when I visited the IPG factory in November, being used for welding. The fiber optic cable was the size of a garden hose and terminated at the end of the robot arm in a tool changer mount. It could tool change from cutting laser head to welding head.
- archon810 9y agoWhy... do you have that?
- ggm 9y agoBecause of his second amendment rights.
- sorokod 9y agoThe right to bear robot arms with lasers?
- ggm 9y agoThat's the one. John Hancock used one to burn his big bold signature onto the sheepskin
- some_random 9y agoIt's the amendment that protects the rest. Specifically, you'll be vaporized by it if you try to grab it out of the display.
- John_KZ 9y ago>A clever configuration of industrial lasers is set to finally make laser weapons practical Finally? Really? Why is this a good thing? Because star wars manchildren want to roleplay? We're looking at terrible burns and very high chances of being blinded. These weapons should be banned from use on humans.
- fiblye 9y agoThe first use that came to mind for me was easily deployed and reusable missile defense systems. Not every country can spend billions on disposable anti-ballistic missiles, but lasers could eventually become affordable for most countries.
- John_KZ 9y agoLasers can never replace anti-missile systems completely, simply because fog or rain will stop them. Also they're completely incapable of taking on reentry vehicles. Other energy weapons might do the trick, but they're not even in protytpe phase yet (as far as we know). The only thing lasers can do is provide low cost per shot for assymetrical warfare defence/offence. They also have other niche applications (ie sensor blinding/soft kill defense) and of course they can easily make warfare an even worse hell, with the next semi-symmetrical war leaving millions blind and hundreds of thousands rotting away from skin infections.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jakeogh 9y agoIt's not for humans, that's practically pointless for this type of weapon. It's for taking out things moving fast with sensor packages. Also Geneva convention. A "little" .50BMG will from 1910 will practically aerosolize a human.
- pjc50 9y agoThey are banned for use on humans. Won't necessarily stop their use, like the Russians using a drop of nerve agent in the UK.
- wtf48272 9y agoThis thread should be the poster child for Silicon Valley's problem of only asking "can we?", and not "should we?" Humanity does not need more powerful weapons. "If I don't do it, someone else will" is too frequently used as a justification for all sorts of shit that is blatantly wrong. If we continue down that path, we'll deserve our extiction.
- api 9y agoAre they small enough to mount on sharks?
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoYou just need to breed bigger sharks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fludlight 9y agoI recall reading a thread here or on reddit about a prosumer laser pointer (the kind that people misuse against airplanes) being shined at a glass table and the reflections temporarily blinding everyone in the room. This seems like an military application worth exploring.
- Tossrock 9y agoBlinding laser weapons are banned from use by most UN members due to the 1995 Protocol on Blinding Laser Weapons. Although I guess it's only for "permanently" blinding weapons, so temporary blinding (ala a flashbang) might be permissible?
- cm2187 9y agoI think the Skripal assassination attempt in London proves that it's not because biological weapons are banned that they aren't developed. And if Russia does it, I doubt the US is sitting idle.
- agumonkey 9y agoMy cousin got a laser pen in Thailand, the thing say 5000mW which is probably false, but it's still way above the usual 5mW pointer. It's reaches buildings miles away with ease, and clouds too .. to the point that I got to learn that it's entirely dangerous and illegal because you can blind plane pilots.
- maaark 9y agoIf it was temporary, they got lucky. Reliably temporarily blinding someone with lasers is impossible.
- snerbles 9y agoLaser dazzlers [0] were deployed by the UK during the Falklands War [1], but actual combat use has not been confirmed. They've seen more common use in Iraq and Afghanistan in recent years. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dazzler_(weapon) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dazzler_(weapon) [1] http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-23518592 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-23518592
- pvaldes 9y ago80's tecno-fashion and glitterball stuff, here we go again!. Weeee!! Honest question. Would a jacket with embedded small mirrors make our children invisible to police helicopter scanners and safe against ray guns?
- sexy_seedbox 9y agoComing Soon: DJI will be mounting these on their drones.
- truculation 9y ago>By comparison, a laser shot from a fiber-laser weapon would cost only $1 in diesel fuel Ugh, what a dirty power source for a shiny ray gun! I hope diesel will be phased out soon.
- bhhaskin 9y agoIt's not going away anytime soon. Especially since jet fuel is pretty much just another form of diesel.
- truculation 9y agoSigh. I want every large marine vessel to have one of these installed: https://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/products/compact-fusion.html https://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/products/compact-fusion.ht... Well, OK, not precisely one of these because it doesn't work yet. But something similar.
- bhhaskin 9y agoIt would be fantastic if we had a reliable viable way to convert large marine vessels to clean electric, but there also a ton of other applications for diesel such as portable generators, stoves, lamps, heaters that would be hard press to switch to electric.
- markm248 9y agoFINALLY!!!
- Steel_Phoenix 9y agoI just spent two years experimenting with laser ablation of various metals with a high powered fiber laser that can concentrate its output into picosecond pulses (MOPA). I do think that something like silver plating would make a target vastly harder to destroy. That said, it's one more thing that needs to be added to a weapon that likely also needs to be hard to lock onto with conventional countermeasures, survive high speeds in atmosphere, handle high heat of engines and launch systems, etc. Rain might largely dissipate the laser over any distance. The wavelength of these lasers tends to be in the infrared. Having a second laser of a different wavelength would drastically reduce the number of materials that could be used to reflect it. Use of some kind of flak to dirty up the target could help a lot. I've found that something as simple as some pen marks on mirrored silver can make it easy to ablate. The real advantage of this tech is that it's light speed and very accurate. It could slice up a swarm of drones in a moment, or be aimed into a jet engine to avoid reflective coatings.