11 ms·
How Facebook Helps Shady Advertisers Pollute the Internet
- black_puppydog 9y agoAs much as I dislike facebook, a lot of these articles these days just seem like "piling on" (albeit deserved) and quite frankly unsurprising to most people _here on HN_.
- netsharc 9y agoEarlier I realized, the lesson to be learned is, if you have an online platform, you should care about users' privacy even if you're small, because who knows, one day it can lead to an international scandal with you as the bad guy.
- black_puppydog 9y agoSo I guess at least someone here learned something from all this. :)
- lambda_lover 9y agoWe see most of these articles because we're in tech. The average user probably will see only a fraction of them, so it's not so much "piling on" as trying to reach as many people as possible. It definitely seems like there's a media circus about Facebook right now, but that's mostly because for the first time, journalists are realizing there's a large audience for negative articles about Facebook. So this is probably months or years of articles that didn't get sign-off that are finally getting the green light by editors because there's actually a clear audience now (and maybe the media was afraid to step on Facebook's toes before?).
- black_puppydog 9y agoHmmmm... maybe I'm underestimating the number of non- and semi-technical people following HN. I do see the current debate in the general public as (at least potentially) healthy and long overdue, I just felt that here on HN this wouldn't really pass as "news" in the literal sense, and that by now everyone here would have gotten the meta-story that "the normies" are waking up to the reality of surveillance capitalist business models...
- lambda_lover 9y agoEven as somebody who works in tech, this article revealed something shockingly scummy about Facebook. The general news of "Facebook harvests your data!" is definitely well-known in tech, but I'd say that this story qualifies as a genuine scoop.
- bhouston 9y agoThe guy featured in the article is using Facebook as the bad guy instead of him. Just because Facebook allows you to post these if you are tricky enough doesn't mean Facebook is responsible for people being scammed by them. It is a weird type of projection or something like that -- a denial of responsibility. Weird guy.
- AlexandrB 9y agoIt's becoming pretty apparent that regulation is necessary in the advertising space. Left to their own devices the biggest, most well-funded ad companies are doing little to combat scams, misinformation, and outright fraud. > It is a weird type of projection or something like that -- a denial of responsibility. There's denial of responsibility at every level. What's funny is that Facebook has absolutely taken on the responsibility of censoring content - blocking nudity and certain other topics. But at the same time has denied responsibility for misleading or fraudulent ad content that gets on its site. I think the difference is that one is cheap to do (object classification via machine learning) and the other would require some real manpower.
- oblio 9y agoNot sure it would require more manpower, but it would surely decrease their revenues. People refuse to accept it, but there's a reason there used to be millions of spam messages sent out each day 10 years ago and there's probably even more sent today, we just don't see it as much. Shady business brings a lot of money. Heck, entire (smaller) countries kick-started their wealth by collecting from shady people.
- common_ 9y agoThis actually seems more damaging and disgusting than all of the Cambridge Analytica news. Facebook employees actively working to help scammers get billions of dollars out of uneducated poor users. Despicable.
- gambiting 9y agoHey but all those users agreed to have their information used this way, so what's your issue????? /s
- herbst 9y agoYou call it sarcasm however it is true. Nobody forces anyone to visit that ad invested shit hole. Even less without adblock.
- csydas 9y agoExcept for all of the non-user user tracking they do with shadow profiles and their omnipresence on the web. Like too many things nowadays with tech and finance you don't have to have done anything to be affected by what these companies do. "TOS" doesn't even apply in most cases since many people don't even use the darn service.
- lancesells 9y agoBut the info you post on Facebook.com is not the only place FB is getting your data. They purchase Credit Card data, follow you around the web with pixels and Facebook login, allegedly track cell phone calls (I don't know enough about this), encourage people to install their VPN (thereby knowing everything you're doing on your device). I do agree that the easiest thing is to delete your account there is a lot more to it than what you engage with on their products.
- herbst 9y agoYou can opt out on all of these. So I don't see the bigger issue actually. The Internet is no cuddle place. Protection always was in the hands of the user.
- fortythirteen 9y agoNow we see the propaganda machine at work. Not satisfied with sticking to the important story of FB's monstrous track record with personal data, the news media must turn each cycle into a full on character assassination. Regardless of how I feel about FB, I'm more disturbed by the media pattern.
- AlexandrB 9y agoI don't get it. You call this a character assassination, but don't elaborate on which part of the article is demonstrably false. The fact that Adtech companies such as Facebook do almost no vetting of the ad content they distribute is absolutely true and part of the problem with the ad economy. Facebook has accrued great power, but when faced with taking responsibility for any of that power has simply shrugged its shoulders. The same goes for Google.
- mistermann 9y agoIt's not that the article is false, it's the timing. Facebook has been doing this for years, as people in the tech universe are well aware, why the sudden flood of varied content in the mainstream media? Of course, a lot of these articles are going to be good old fashioned self-serving opportunism, but another possibility might be behind the scenes coordination. Impossible? Has there ever been a coordinated propaganda initiative in the history of the world?
- Angostura 9y agoTrust me, the journalists on Bloomberg aren't running this story because they think Facebook threaten's Bloomberg's business. They are running it because they think it is a juicy story.
- mistermann 9y ago> because they think Facebook threaten's Bloomberg's business A coordinated propaganda campaign rarely has anything to do with the underlying business of the various media outlets being used to run it.
- 21 9y agoWonderful example of Machine Learning being used to harm, the banality of evil: > Affiliates once had to guess what kind of person might fall for their unsophisticated cons, targeting ads by age, geography, or interests. Now Facebook does that work for them. The social network tracks who clicks on the ad and who buys the pills, then starts targeting others whom its algorithm thinks are likely to buy. Affiliates describe watching their ad campaigns lose money for a few days as Facebook gathers data through trial and error, then seeing the sales take off exponentially. “They go out and find the morons for me,”
- ThomPete 9y agoWhat in that is evil?
- WhompingWindows 9y agoYou wouldn't consider it evil to push bad products onto thousands of people with a technological tool, where before you could only push that product onto hundreds?
- ThomPete 9y agoSo it's evil because it's more successful? Not sure I understand the rationale here.
- marviel 9y agoIt's evil because it's a systematic way of hurting large groups of vulnerable people.
- thunfischbrot 9y agoTwo charts: x1: How much the product improves my life (judged based on how much I would be willing to buy it, asked after I acquired it) y1: How much the product costs x2: How much expendable income I have y2: How aware I am of how advertising influences my buying decisions Depending on where the marketed products/services and the targeted consumers land on these charts the answer to your questions may turn out very differently.
- JulianMorrison 9y agoThe whole gathering of them should have been flamethrowered.
- zombieprocesses 9y agoThis is getting annoying. Is anyone else sick and tired of the FB related propaganda? 6 out of the top 30 stories are FB related. It was like that yesterday. The day before. Usually the mods are very good about getting rid of the clutter but for some reason, FB related spam is allowed.
- guilhermetk 9y agoA bit off topic, but, is logging off from a facebook account in the browser enough to stay away from FB's radar or they can still track users through scripts running on others websites?
- jcsnv 9y agoPeople run the FB pixel scripts on their site
- manigandham 9y agoAnd yet again, this is nothing to do with Facebook but the global advertising industry that is largely unregulated and has no consequences. There is the FTC (in the US) and guidelines for TV, radio, print work well enough along with the natural time and effort barriers, but digital advertising has far greater reach, scale, and precision with almost 0 oversight. This must be fixed with actual consequences (as in prison time for offenders who run scams and malware) otherwise nothing will change.
- ungzd 9y agoI see lots of Russian scam ads ("earn money easily blah-blah") on Instagram (which uses Facebook's unified ad network). Other category of ads I see here often are ICOs.
- julienfr112 9y agoThere is one thing i don't get : If users get scammed by a facebook ad, they should lose trust in the platform, and share that mistrust. I get that you can earn some money with new users as they enter the platform, but after a while, you should not find any more suckers, because every one will be educated (at a cost of a cheese)