6 ms·
Fusion power will probably not be particularly cheap unless we really do figure out how to build very small reactors. If big Tokamaks like ITER are the way forw
by adrianN 9y ago
Fusion power will probably not be particularly cheap unless we really do figure out how to build very small reactors. If big Tokamaks like ITER are the way forward we need to build these very big, very expensive power plants whose costs need to be amortized over the electricity produced.
- wiz21c 9y agoSince energy is such an important factor to the life of humans, I'd say the dollar/euro price is a measure that is too narrow. The question is : is fusion necessary ? how many will die if we don't have it ? how many will be born if we have it ? Have we got a future without it ? what will be the quality of life without it ?
- DKnoll 9y agoIncreased birth rate is not necessarily a good thing for human development at this stage. Our planet cannot support an infinite number of people. Since we are already facing unprecedented growth that won't be stopped except by famine, world war or some other calamity, it's important we find a way to stretch our limited resources further and develop technologies that will help us expand beyond earth like nuclear fusion.
- wiz21c 9y agoYup. But I was pointing more at the fact that the notion of "price" is not very useful here. If we're talking about mankind's future, money should be brought back to the level of "minor technical detail".
- adrianN 9y agoMoney is what we currently have as a means of getting a consensus about what is important for mankind's future and how to allocate resources based on importance and expected payoff. It's not the best system, but it's hard to introduce alternatives.
- DKnoll 9y agoI agree that it should be that way. Price is important to motivate people to develop nuclear fusion technology, and to finally build commercial fusion plants when the time comes. Nuclear fission is a superior power technology already, but we've largely stopped building new plants because of the exorbitant upstart costs compared to other technologies.
- DennisP 9y agoPrice is a proxy for "how much resources would it take to roll this out at scale." That's important regardless of how your economy works. Price also tells us whether the new energy source would require government support, or require less resources than building and fueling a new fossil plant, or (if extremely cheap) would prompt people to shut down even brand-new fossil plants because the new energy source is cheaper than the cost of fuel.
- eloff 9y agoIt may well start out like that, but like most technology I expect it will just keep getting cheaper and smaller with time.
- adrianN 9y agoFundamental engineering limits aside, fusion progress competes with battery progress, and we put a lot more money into battery research.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but haven't most large infrastructure projects become more expensive over time? I mean more expensive in inflation adjusted dollars.
- eloff 9y agoOnce we get it going it will attract lot's of investment, global competition, and mass production. Every fusion reactor you build is essentially a money printing machine and capitalism excels at optimizing the production of things like that.
- giblaz 9y agoThe amount of progress over time is a bell shaped curve. For a period of time after the technology becomes practical, it will get more funding & smart people involved. During that time most of the major advanced in the tech will be made. This phase may last a long time. After much of what can be done with it is discovered and optimized, the amount of progress will slow down.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoAh, yes, thank you. I was thinking about the far side of the bell curve after most of the easy gains have been made and bureaucracy sets in.
- bsder 9y agoThe moment that anybody demonstrates a real, working fusion reactor, a gargantuan amount of money will flood the sector. At that point, fusion will go onto a Moore's Law curve and we will see exponential improvements for quite a few years.
- beagle3 9y agoBatteries have been around for a long time. A lot of money was (and is) spent, and yet we see slow improvement (incredibly slow on a given technology, advancement usually come from new chemistry, or new physics e.g. lightsail). Nothing resembling Moore’s law style advancement, despite a lot of money to be made. It is likely exaggerated but the headlines claimed the big Australian battery returned the investment within a couple of months. There’s a LOT of money to be made on energy storage. Why would fusion reactors be moorable?
- Turing_Machine 9y ago> Nothing resembling Moore’s law style advancement As you say, batteries have been around for a long time. The rapid growth/improvement part of the battery curve happened back in the late 1800s/early 1900s. The lead-acid grid lattice design, still the...errr...gold standard when it comes to the most amount of joules stored per buck, was invented in 1881. (modern technologies like the various lithium battery chemistries win when it come to storage for a given mass -- thus their use in things like portable devices and cars, but lead-acid still wins when it comes to storage for a given cost).
- parametrek 9y ago> The lead-acid grid lattice design, still the...errr...gold standard when it comes to the most amount of joules stored per buck, was invented in 1881. Li-ion has caught up. If you have $400 to spend on batteries both li-ion [1] and comparable lead acid [2] (deep discharge, long cycle life) cost around 3 Wh/$. [1] https://www.imrbatteries.com/samsung-29e-18650-2850mah-2-75a-flat-top-battery/ https://www.imrbatteries.com/samsung-29e-18650-2850mah-2-75a... [2] https://www.powerstream.com/BBep.htm https://www.powerstream.com/BBep.htm (EP100-12)
- threeseed 9y agoThe guys over at Tokamak Energy are aiming to produce a small reactor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRyUWOUk_48 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRyUWOUk_48
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI think(read: am guessing, smartly) when you factor the entire cost of fossil fuels (environmental damage to harvest, subsidies, tax breaks, etc) fusion will be cheaper. Fossil fuels have a number of intentionally "hidden" costs.
- mkempe 9y agoAre you aware of how CO2 is used by plants? that's a "hidden" benefit of the large-scale use of fossil fuels. At current CO2 levels plants are starved for CO2. At 150 ppm there would be a massive extinction of land-based plant life.
- QasimK 9y agoIs this some kind of a joke? Global warming, full stop. Plants are not starved, they were ubiquitous until we chopped “most” of them down.
- mkempe 9y agoIt's science. Land-based plants evolved when CO2 levels were much higher than today. [1] In fact levels have been steadily declining from 3000 ppm 150 million years ago; the current, holocene rise is a relatively minor bump. [2] [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1692178/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1692178/ [2] http://caos.iisc.ernet.in/faculty/pghosh/content/Publications/19.pdf http://caos.iisc.ernet.in/faculty/pghosh/content/Publication...
- mkempe 9y agoAnd by the way global temperature 150 million years ago was the same as today, +/- 2deg C.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoCould be. But the bio-make up of the planet was different then, yes?