4 ms·
The Human Genome Project was very well funded, and progressed extremely quickly.
by gowld 9y ago
The Human Genome Project was very well funded, and progressed extremely quickly.
- dekhn 9y agoThe public project actually languished for a long time until the Celera project caused a small number of HGP players to speed things up. It wasn't the funding that fixed things- it was the competitive spirit and a few smart people with duct tape.
- api 9y agoWould Celera have done what they did without HGP doing a lot of preliminary research and creating an environment of strong interest? It seems to me that these kinds of arguments have a "that which is seen vs. that which is unseen" problem. All the preliminary R&D that sets the stage and builds interest gets forgotten after the big "Eureka!" In reality "Eureka!" is a borderline myth. Look at any big invention and you can find that a lot of fertilizer was added to the soil before it sprouted.
- dekhn 9y agoYes, Celera would have done what they did. Remember, they didn't need the preliminary research of the HGP, because instead of using a scaffolding method, they went straight to shotgun sequencing which saved them 5+ years. Nobody's denying that the HGP and Celera were able to rest on a strong foundation, but the reality is that the HGP was running itself lazily because they had no competition. I worked in genomics at the time and it was really a sleepy corner of bioinformatics.
- gowld 9y agoAt the same time, Celera didn't launch until 1998, 8 years after HGP started. So Celera effectively languuished since 1990 as well. Ideas need to ripen in their time. Celera didn't jump in the game until the tech (bio tech and computer tech) was ready, and BTW Celera had the benefit of consuming all of HGP's output while keeping their own secret.