11 ms·
Number systems of the world, sorted by complexity of counting (2006)
- ColinWright 9y agoI've deliberately chosen a title for this submission that says more clearly what the content is about, and thus helps people decide whether to click through and have a look. The page's actual title is: "Number Systems of the World" I don't think that's as informative.
- gbrown_ 9y agoThe base 60 Sexagesimal system used by the Sumerians is always an interesting one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexagesimal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexagesimal
- bfrydl 9y ago> The number 60, a superior highly composite number, has twelve factors, namely 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 15, 20, 30, and 60, of which 2, 3, and 5 are prime numbers. With so many factors, many fractions involving sexagesimal numbers are simplified. It really makes a lot of sense actually.
- mjlee 9y agoThis is why I still do woodwork (as a hobby) in imperial units.
- yorwba 9y agoTFA has a section on Assyrian, but that's a decimal system, which made me wonder where the sexagesimal came from. It appears that although Assyrian and earlier Akkadian were written in cuneiform, they are Semitic languages that adopted their writing system from the otherwise unrelated Sumerian language, and apparently didn't bother to adapt the numerals to the decimal system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akkadian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akkadian
- jacobolus 9y agoAkkadians et al. kept using both decimal and sexagesimal arithmetic in parallel.
- mtreis86 9y agoWouldn't unary be considered the least complex?
- ColinWright 9y agoWhich language/society/culture uses unary?
- hinkley 9y agoSome very dead ones. Unary works like hash marks. We have archaeological records of that number system but GP is wrong. Doing multiplication in your head with unary would be a horrible experience. And any number over ten would put the listener to sleep. I suspect in a unary language system people would invent their own counting strategy in their head. Edit: ah but Wikipedia reminds me that gauge systems such as for grinding or wire use unary for negative numbers. Eg 000 guage wire or OO ground flour.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 9y agoProbably lots of neolithic tribes could be said to have unary number schemes, but such schemes would max out at e.g. 6 instead of 100.
- jazzyb 9y agoI don't understand how the author is judging complexity. The top one, Huli, is a base-15 number system but looks quite regular otherwise. French, on the other hand, switches from a base-10 to a base-20 at 80 and then switches things up at 97. According to the listing, Welsh sits somewhere between these two but it has separate numbering systems for {20s, 40s, 60s, 80s}, {30s, 70s, 90s}, and {50s}. That seems much more complicated than either Huli or French.
- nextstep 9y agoI think it’s implied that base-10 is lowest complexity (this page is for English speakers) and I think that is why base-15 is more “complex” than the weird French system which is mostly addition of base-10 primitives.
- jgh 9y agoyeah came here to say this. Huli seems to be pretty much the same as english except base-15 instead of base-10. It even has the special case of the second 10 or 15 being different in form from the rest of the numbers. edit: actually it seems like the Huli system is more uniform than English. It doesn't switch up the word order after 15. So it's "15 and 1 ..." whereas english goes "3 and 10.." and then "2x10 and 1..."
- yorwba 9y agoHuli appears regular, but a construction like "ngui ki, ngui tebone-gonaga tebira" to mean "fifteen twos and the three of the third fifteen" does seem like quite a mouthful for 33.
- jstanley 9y agoIt's not "fifteen twos" but "two fifteens". They're just counting how many fifteens they've got: "two complete fifteens, and 3 from the third fifteen"
- abhishekjha 9y agoIs the complexity based on pronunciation here?
- empath75 9y agoI think they're understanding the complexity of the Japanese number system by quite a lot: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_counter_word https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_counter_word
- yorwba 9y agoClassifiers are mostly orthogonal to the number system, and they're really no different from e.g. English using "a herd of cattle" or "a murder of crows" to redundantly encode the kind of thing being talked about. I'm actually not aware of any language that doesn't have different units of measurement for different objects, it's just that some languages effectively make it mandatory to use them. (E.g. in Chinese you could just always say 一个 to mean "one" but it sounds strange when there's a specific form that's more common.)
- mratzloff 9y agoNo way. It is absolutely different in practice because of Japanese counter words. A counter word is a counting prefix (different from the abstract number word) plus different suffixes for a variety of things. This object is long and thin, so it has one suffix. This object is a drop of liquid, so it has another suffix. This is a small animal, so it gets another suffix. The counting words for use with these suffixes are different from abstract numbers. Frankly, the system is bananas. Abstract numbers in Japanese are very simple and logical, but the overall counting system of e.g. English is objectively simpler, and I don't think you can disregard counting when examining the number system. In English, it would be equally correct to say "10 cows" or "a herd of cattle." Literally translating the first (without counting words) in Japanese would be incorrect.
- dsr_ 9y agoCan any native Hindi speakers comment on the difficulty of doing math in a language where every number 1-100 has its own name?
- nkoren 9y agoI am not a native Hindi speaker by any means, and I certainly haven't done math in it. But my experience (in places like Delhi) is that people routinely use Hindi up to 20, then give up and switch to English.
- abhishek0318 9y agoThis is only true for young urban middle class people.
- nkoren 9y agoYeah, my sample is fairly biased in that direction. That and rickshaw wallahs who'll speak the language of their market I guess.
- abhishek0318 9y agoEvery number doesn't have its own name. If you observe closely there is a pattern. From 21 to 99, you can observe that every digit at tens place decides the suffix and the digit at ones place decides the prefix.
- rlpb 9y agoFurther, the author says "because of a lot of irregular pronunciation, you have to memorize 100 different words as if it were a centesimal system". But I could say the same for English. We won't say "three-ty-three", we say "thirty-three". Hindi's irregularities are pretty much at the same level.
- Manishearth 9y agoNo, for English the thirty series is always "thirty-foo", and numbers ending in three are always "foo-three". It is true that you don't use the same word for the number when it's in the tens place (like Chinese), but that's as complex as it gets (and the teens, of course). In Hindi 40 and 41 use a different word for 40. 51 and 53 use a different word for 50. 55 and 45 use a different word for 5. Plus there are smaller but still significant differences between pretty much every number -- e.g. it's chauBees, but puchees and chauNtees.
- abhishekjha 9y agoDoesn't hindi have its own script for numbers as well? The 'Number' column doesn't reflect the same fact very well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_numerals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_numerals
- hmd_imputer 9y agoAnother article that was published a while ago had an interesting take on it. There is a quite high correlation between numbering system of a language and how quickly/well kids speaking that language learn counting and math skills. Apparently, the article itself is taken down, but I found an archived version. https://web.archive.org/web/20141215072819/http://playthink.wordpress.com:80/2008/11/17/gladwell-why-asianchildren-are-better-at-maths/ https://web.archive.org/web/20141215072819/http://playthink....
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIt seems that a child will perhaps learn to count quicker in Japanese than in French, say, but the complexity and inclusion of factors/compounds also seem like they would push a more complex understanding of number to be adopted. I wonder if a French people make change with 20 Euro-cent coins more often than others do.
- Moru 9y agoI bet they use card instead... In Germany you stand in line waiting for everyone to find exactly the right change, be them young or old. Most people pay with cash even though it seems to get more common to use card. Euro has at least eight different coins. Sweden has 1, 2, 5, 10 as coins but most people still pay with card because it's easier and people are not burned by the big brother syndrome of the WW1/2 :-) Would be interesting to see relative difficulty of each language, some of them are pretty close and have very similar difficulty while others are close but widely different difficulty.
- hmd_imputer 9y agoAnother Germany related comment today. Made my day :) It really becomes annoying when you have to wait a minute because an old lady needs to count all her coins in Lidl. Back to the original topic, as someone who can speak a few languages, I find the arguments stated in the article quite interesting. Obviously, just because one speaks Chinese doesn't mean they will definitely be a wunder-kind in math. Yet, it plays an important role in speeding up the learning process.
- julian_t 9y agoI'd put traditional Danish numbering a bit further up the list... it's pretty strange (http://www.olestig.dk/dansk/numbers.html http://www.olestig.dk/dansk/numbers.html)
- hvidgaard 9y agoI was surprised to see Danish so high on the list, but after a short while it's not too surprising. It's base-20 for the first 20, like English. Then it's backwards base-10 up to 99 with special names for the whole 10s, 42 is pronounced as "2 and 40". Above 99 it's base-10, 420 is "400 20". But if it's 428 it's "400 8 and 20", but 512 would be "500 12". It's not difficult, it's just a special rule for 1-20, backwards for 21-99, and then straight as you'd expect (including the irregular first 20). Okay, it is quite confusing for none native speakers. To our defense, we use a system more like the Norwegian and Swedish for formal documents including contracts and cheques, though the latter has been phased out in Denmark. The "perfect" would obviously be a purely base-10 with suffix if it's 10's, 100's, ect.
- gkya 9y agoThat's nearly exactly how german works, 428 is "4-vier 100-hundert 8-acht and-und 20-zwanzig", 512 is "5-fünf 100-hundert 12-zwölf" (excuse my rusty german). The und thing is a germanic thing I think.
- hvidgaard 9y ago"Und" is "and" in English, and "og" in Danish, and is used in Danish as well. I think Danish and German is quite similar as you say. It's been 20 odd years since I learned to speak German and it's long since forgotten.
- amelius 9y agoNice to see that Mandarin and Japanese have simple number systems compared to English. It might be worthwhile to learn them and impress your friends while you're reading numbers from restaurant menu-cards :)
- panglott 9y agoApparently the person who compiled this has never tried to actually count items in Japanese, to figure out which of the two number systems to use and which counter words to use.
- magissima 9y agoThe person who compiled it is Japanese
- Taniwha 9y agothe one thing missing is the two mandarin words for 2 (essentially 2 and couple, used in different contents)
- kristianov 9y agoEvery numeral in Mandarin does have 2 words. It's like NATO phonetic alphabet "Alpha, Bravo, Charlie, ...". "零一二三四五六七八九" maps to "洞幺两参肆伍六拐八勾". What's more, there are multiple characters for the same numeral, mostly used to counter tempering in bookkeeping.
- craptocurrency 9y agoHuli ki ma behan kar diya logo me
- tekkk 9y agoWow, Tongan number system is simply beautiful. Pure elegance that I'm sure could be defined mathematically very simply. I myself can only scribble a naive implementation for natural numbers in Javascript: const base = ["noa", "taha", "ua", "tolu", "fa", "nima", "ono", "fitu", "valu", "hiva"] const tongan = n => Array.from(n.toString()).map(Number).map(i => base[i]).join(" ") Not as pretty as I thought. Probably would look better in functional language.
- FullyFunctional 9y agoI theorize that humans do poorly with too much regularity and we actually benefit from irregularity, unlike computers. In Haskell, first line would be the same without the const and the other could be tongan = intercalate " ".reverse.map ((base !!).(`mod` 10)).takeWhile (> 0).iterate (`div` 10) (ISTM that there must be a better alternative to takeWhile + iterate).
- kjaer 9y agoI wrote it in Scala below; it's a bit shorter, and I really like the map(base). Getting the digits from a number turns out to be most of the work, and the int->string->int conversion also seems to be the best approach. val base = List("noa", "taha", "ua", "tolu", "fa", "nima", "ono", "fitu", "valu", "hiva") def tongan(n: Int) = n.toString.map(_.asDigit).map(base).mkString(" ")
- kccqzy 9y agoEnglish numbers aren't much harder. englishNumbers n = ten9 !! (n - 1) where infixr 7 <<>> (<<>>) = liftA2 (<>) ten1 = ["one", "two", "three", "four", "five", "six", "seven", "eight", "nine"] ten2 = ten1 <> ["ten", "eleven", "twelve"] <> (["thir", "four"] <> prefixes) <<>> ["teen"] <> (["twen", "thir", "for"] <> prefixes) <<>> ["ty"] <<>> ([[]] <> ten1) where prefixes = ["fif", "six", "seven", "eigh", "nine"] ten3 = ten2 <> ten1 <<>> ["hundred"] <<>> ([[]] <> ten2) ten6 = ten3 <> ten3 <<>> ["thousand"] <<>> ([[]] <> ten3) ten9 = ten6 <> ten3 <<>> ["million"] <<>> ([[]] <> ten6)
- no_identd 9y agoA LOT of these have massive errors. I strongly recommend comparing all that to this paper: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5ca1/fa0ffca55e9003053de2f5ef36a25819109b.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5ca1/fa0ffca55e9003053de2f5... - Harald Hammarström - Rarities in Numeral Systems (2009) And this page: https://mpi-lingweb.shh.mpg.de/numeral/ https://mpi-lingweb.shh.mpg.de/numeral/ "Numeral Systems of the World's Languages" By the way: If anyone can find a digital copy of this paper from 1840 by Augustin-Louis Cauchy (yes, THAT Cauchy!): https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=6877129426190119313&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=6877129426190119313... I'd very much appreciate it. Donald E. Knuth cites it in TAOCP while discussing Balanced Ternary: "Cauchy pointed out that negative digits make it unneccesary for a person to memorize the multiplication table past 5x5." [Comptes Rendus Acad. Sci. 11 (Paris, 1840), 789-798] But he doesn't elaborate on it further, and neither does anyone else from what I can tell, and I have yet to figure out the trick. (I currently try to teach myself to EFFICIENTLY do all my mental arithmetic in balanced ternary - not an easy task!)
- joshuamorton 9y ago>But he doesn't elaborate on it further, and neither does anyone else from what I can tell, and I have yet to figure out the trick 5 * 9 = 5 * (10 - 1) = 50 - 5 = 45 Specifically, you need to know everything in the 5x5 area, and how to multiply by 10. More generally, any digit 6-9 can be rewritten as (10 - (10 - digit)) and then you can apply distribution rules to clean things up. Here's a three by two digit example: 247 * 68 = (10 - 3) * (10 - 2) + // 7 * 8 10 * (10 - 3) * (10 - 4) + // 7 * 60 10 * 4 * (10 - 2) + // 40 * 8 10 * 10 * 4 * (10 - 4) + // 40 * 60 10 * 10 * 2 * (10 - 2) + // 200 * 8 10 * 10 * 10 * 2 * (10 - 4) // 200 * 60 evaluating we get 100 - 50 + 6 + 10 * (100 - 70 + 12) + 10 * (40 - 8) + 100 * (40 - 16) + 100 * (20 - 4) + 1000 * (20 - 8) And then to finish up: 00056 + 00420 + 00320 + 02400 + 01600 + 12000 = 16796, which is the correct answer. Edit: The fun thing to think about is conceptually why this works. If you consider numbers as just bits, all you're doing is converting the highest bit from base to sign, without actually changing it, doing the multiplications on the lower bits, and then tracking the sign to know whether or not to add or subtract later. Or to put it another way, you're shifting your set of numbers from being +0 - +10 to being -5 - +5. This makes the lookup table smaller, but requires you to do some additional intermediate lookups (up to four, one in each "quadrant" of the 10x10 table) to be as powerful. Fun to conceptualize that way.
- wodenokoto 9y agoDanish typically ranks high on these lists because the names for some of the tens have etymological roots in base 20. But this doesn't add any complexity, compared to having just named tens. Nobody is doing any kind of everyday counting in base 20 in Denmark. Everything is base 10, with 9 irregular named numbers for the multiples of 10.
- madmoose 9y agoAs a parent of English/Danish bilingual children I have to tell you that you are very wrong on this. My children still occasionally make mistakes when saying numbers in the range 50-99 in Danish, they haven't said the English numbers wrong for years. That the word for 50 contains the word "tre" (three) and the word for 90 contains the word "fem" (five) is very confusing to our children, especially when the English equivalents are so simple in comparison.
- wodenokoto 9y agoFair enough. As a child I could never remember if it was 50 or 60 that had "halv" (50 is halvtreds, 60 is treds, neither word have any resemblance to 5, 6 or 10, but 50 sounds a bit like it ought to be half of 60), but my point is that the number system has nothing to do with base 20 except a few etymological roots of some names, that for all intents and purposes might as well be random. But you are right: they are worse than random, since they are named close enough to other entities to be confuseaable.
- elvirs 9y agoim surprised not to see lezgi language here. we have 1 to 10 10+1 to 9 20+ 1 to 19 (ie 37 is 20 and 19) 40+ 1 to 19 3x20+ 1 to 19 (ie 63 is 3 twenties and 13) 4x20+ 1 to 19 hundred
- Mimino123 9y agoA small correction to the Georgian language: it belongs to the south Caucasian/Kartvelian(not Georgian) language family. What's interesting here is that Kartvelian does literally mean Georgian in translation, but since it is a term it should not be translated.
- drewmate 9y agoI didn't see Russian listed anywhere on there, but I suspect it would be in the top 20 on this list. It is a pretty straightforward base 10 complicated by archaic phonetic rules that change the pronunciation and stress of words with logical roots in unintuitive ways. In addition, countable nouns (like cars, people, cities, but also including multiples of 100, 1000, etc...) change form depending on how many of them there are (1, 2-4, 5-20, 21-24, 25-30 etc...) Usually these separate forms are phonetically related, but sometimes there is no connection at all. These rules don't come in to play when strictly counting numbers until 200, but is an integral part of what makes it hard to count things in Russian. There are also wrinkles like the word for 40 (сорок) and 90 (девяносто) that don't fit in the usual tens pattern like 20 (двадцать - two * ten) or 30 (тридцать - three * ten). Any Russian speakers care to explain what's going on with those two?
- ezolotko 9y agoConcerning 40 - “sorok” was a name for a unit of measure for fur. One sorok was a bundle consisting of 40 animal furs. As for 90 - devyanosto - I think it comes from “9 to 100”. Its strange though its 9 and not 10.
- Fins 9y agoInitially, Russian used the same convention for 40 as it does for other multiples of 10. Other Slavic languages still do. However, 4 (четыре) is the longest word by syllable count in the 1..10 range, so over time a shorter word that used to mean "a bag with 40 skins" (apparently a standard count to make some article of garment) came to replace it. The original meaning is all but forgotten now, and сорок means only 40 now. 90 also used to use the more common form of "nine tens", but for some reason came to be replaced by something that looks like it means "nine out of hundred" but the etymological explanations for it seem to be rather inconsistent. One explanation is that Russians used to count by 9 -- remnants of that can be seen in fairy tale expressions for "very far" -- "beyond three times nine lands".
- drewmate 9y agoThanks for sharing. Studying Russian has helped me notice interesting patterns in languages. Where there is much friction (due to heavy usage, difficult pronunciation, or both) languages tend to break rules to make things easier to say. For example, it's trivial to conjugate a verb like "контролировать" that you might only use occasionally, but verbs that you say dozens or hundreds of times a day, like "идти" become increasingly irregular.
- jessaustin 9y agoTypo on traditional Welsh: The traditional system is basically vigesimal (base 20), but it calls 50 "half-hundred" and 19 "two-nine", and it also uses 15 as a reference point.
- DonaldFisk 9y agoKhmer is quite complex, and isn't on the list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_numerals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_numerals Up to 30, it's got a base-5 component so, for example, 16 = dap pram muoy (10 5 1). From 30 onwards, like Thai it follows the more straightforward Chinese number system. The numbers in Scottish Gaelic have recently been changed and are now base 10: https://gaelicgrammar.org/~gaelic/mediawiki/index.php/Numerals#Decimal_20-99 https://gaelicgrammar.org/~gaelic/mediawiki/index.php/Numera...
- jankovicsandras 9y agoWhy is hungarian considered more complex than english or norwegian? Hungarian has regular "on ten one" for 11 and "on ten two" for 12, when english and norwegian have different words; and teens are arguably also more complex.
- Taniwha 9y agoprobably because it has special words for 20 and 30, and switches between "9 on 20" to "30 plus 1"
- PaulHoule 9y agoHow do they quantify complexity?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhcom2 9y ago> Polari is an in-group language of gay and lesbian people, theatrical people, and circus people in Britain. It's interesting 8 and 9 are called "6 + 2" and "6 + 3" in Polari. Crazy interesting https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8yEH8TZUsk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8yEH8TZUsk
- dalbuschat 9y agoGerman is much more complex in counting than Japanese in that table, which I would wager is not true. In Japanese, you have to decide which counting words you use depending on what you are counting, and most of those words are highly irregular. There's no such complexity in German, it's only irregular for 10, 11 and 12.