9 ms·
Diaphragmatic Breathing Exercises and the Vagus Nerve (2017)
- HillaryBriss 9y agoFWIW, Andrew Weil took what he calls the "4-7-8" breathing exercise from ancient India. Video demonstration: https://www.drweil.com/videos-features/videos/the-4-7-8-breath-health-benefits-demonstration/ https://www.drweil.com/videos-features/videos/the-4-7-8-brea... It bears some resemblance to the breathing exercise described by the author of the Psych Today article.
- amelius 9y agoDoes anybody here have experience with the VNS devices mentioned in the article?
- codeulike 9y agoUsually they are implants, a control unit with battery embedded under the skin in your shoulder and then a wire up to the vagus nerve in the neck. They are used to control epilepsy among other things. I think there may be external versions too but they are newer and I'm not sure how effective they are.
- mark_l_watson 9y agoAs someone who has practiced yoga for 40 years and started qigong a few years ago, the advice in the article seems fairly obvious. Still, great to see the article in the front page of HN! I had not thought of deep belly breathing helping calm and relax me during meetings - will try that.
- leg100 9y agoYup, I do this as part of tai chi and qi gong (referred to as 'dan tian' breathing). Seems to be a thing of the west to take elements of yoga, tai chi, daoism et al, and distill them - mindfulness comes to mind - and as devices they're good, but together they amount to so much more than the sum of their parts, hence the eastern penchant for a 'holistic' approach.
- crpatino 9y ago> Seems to be a thing of the west to take elements of yoga, tai chi, daoism et al, and distill them Well, traditional systems take actual effort. You cannot market to the masses if 90% of your customers are going to stop coming after a handful of sessions. ... Unless you do a January promotion, pay the full year and get 50+% off. In that case, the wannabes subsidize the actual students.
- ggm 9y agocould this work to calm breathing in freestyle swimming? I try using 'box' breathing exercises and they seem to work a little (in-count-4, hold-count-4, out-count-4, hold-count-4 cycle)
- chillax 9y agoNot a direct answer, but I've found this helpful: http://www.swimsmooth.com/exhalation.html http://www.swimsmooth.com/exhalation.html
- nsouth 9y agoYoga (proper yoga, not the gymnastics they do in most gyms) is all about stimulating the vagus nerve and several others. The "locks" (bandhas) and various breathing exercises (pranayama) all work on it in different ways and stimulate different parts of the nerve. If you really want to juice it up add in some breath retention. Eventually you reach a sort of homeostatic state where your breath just naturally suspends, and that's when the doorway to the inner world opens. There's more about the nerves in The Accidental Yogi's ebook (free online), and more about breath retention in Kundalini Exposed (on Kindle). The "Supreme Kriya Fire" technique in that book is the absolute real deal, but definitely not for beginners. Beginners may want to start with Yogani's free lessons at aypsite.org. Remember - Kundalini is not a game. Work up slowly to avoid negative side effects.
- moate 9y agoYea, but like, acid and mushrooms don't require any effort.
- domparise 9y agoTheir effects are not well controlled either.
- mr_overalls 9y agoAnd they tend to be transitory as well. Meditation, while slower, tends to do a better job of integrating insights into one's personality and daily life.
- Stanish 9y agoWhat are you talking about, they require money and effort to acquire, and can produce horrendously difficult trips. Breathing is quite a bit easier than all that...not that they should even be compared. Not sure why you are taking cheap shots at people who find value in these things. Value which is becoming more and more scientifically understood each year, by the way.
- nsouth 9y ago
- tomcooks 9y agoA technique I used to learn to breathe with my diaphragm: - stand tall like you're the batman (open up chest, don't slouch shoulders) - place your hand on your belly, pinky on navel and thumb touching the tip of your sternum - inhale from nose - let jaw loose and make the deepest "oooohm" note you can produce, look at the hand on your belly getting closer to your spine as you exhale - inhale and look at the hand on your belly rise - repeat, always inhaling from your nose only, keep lips closed and jaw loose (no need to make any sound once you get it) This technique immediately drops high stress bpm's from 120/140 to ~68.
- tandav 9y agoOne note: fresh and clean airflow is important, don't do this indoor with high co2 ppm (high co2 is basically poison)
- jackhack 9y agoUnless you're locked in an airtight space (or small closet, etc) high CO2 should not be a concern whatsoever. Any normal living space is going to be fine. Even a relatively "tight" super-efficient modern home changes air over several times per hour (and have fresh-air injectors on the heating/cooling systems to introduce fresh air and prevent staleness). Even there, a house full of people wall-to-wall could not significantly alter the CO2 levels to a degree there is a health risk. If you need something to worry about in the air, be concerned about diesel particulates in filthy city air. source: former HVAC tech.
- csours 9y agoWhat about a dancehall/disco packed with people dancing?
- jackhack 9y agoOxygen consumption increases with activity, obviously. Air handling is rated on square footage, structure design and intended purpose. A home is going to carry a very different set of requirements than a factory floor or a restaurant (which often has high CFM exhaust hoods and requires a large amount of fresh-air infiltration to make up for exhausted air). Max occupancy permits as based on these factors, and often limited by egress (exits) plus a safety-factor is added to that. But that's about the limits of my expertise. Beyond this lies architects & permitting inspectors. The calculation of human heat load and perception of temperature (sensible/latent heat, and psychrometrics in general) is a big part of system design. I'd have to break out the software and start asking specifics to get you an actual number but my gut feel is that a dance hall is going to easily pass the air quality tests. Of course, somebody could pack 100 people into a low-ceiling windowless 200 ft^2 room without forced ventilation and have a problem with not just air quality but also heat (each person is approx 20W at rest, 200W w/vigorous activity), but I'm speaking in generalities about properly used residential & commercial space.
- rootbear 9y agoI am a lifetime choral singer and during a recent medical exam I was asked to take a series of deep breaths. So I took my usual singer's diaphragmatic breath and was complemented on my "yoga breathing"!
- portofcall 9y agoTrumpet player here, and I’ve had similar experiences. A longtime friend of mine is an operatic soprano, and she can practically break a spirometer!
- milesward 9y agoTuba player here: suffice to say, I'm a calm guy.
- portofcall 9y agoTuba! I’ve always been impressed by the dual demands of breath control and lugging around a tuba. You can probably snuff a candle at a quarter mile.
- shitgoose 9y agosame with swimming. lungs expand dramatically.
- rishirishi 9y agoBreathing through your diaphragm is desirable all the time and not only during a conscious exercise. Many years ago, I would breathe through my chest which made for shallow breathing. Look at how babies breathe; through their diaphragm/stomach. It took several months to shift my breath to the diaphragm. The exercises certainly help with lengthening the inhale and exhale, maximizing both oxygen intake and carbon dioxide excretion.
- preparat 9y agoAbout 3 years ago I started martial arts training. One of the first things I had to unlearn was shallow chest breathing. Imagine that, 40yrs old and having to relearn how to breathe properly. It took me probably close to 6 months to adjust.
- rishirishi 9y agoYeah, I was surprised how long it took me to realize the error in my breathing. In hindsight, my athletic life before 21 could have benefited greatly from breathing "right".
- dgreensp 9y agoHealthy, full breathing involves significant expansion of the rib cage in all directions. I wish people would remember this before spreading the advice, “breathe into your belly, not into your chest.” Your lungs are in your chest. (And contrary to the article, by the way, the “lower part of your lungs” is not “just above your belly button.”) Most importantly, do not lock your chest or inhibit its movement. If you have poor posture and core support and a tight chest, I would say experiment with filling your lungs completely, and with engaging your abs very slightly on the _inhale_, to feel some of the sensations of full, supported breathing. Your core muscles create pressure that helps fully inflate your lungs. Don’t listen to any admonishments about “breathing wrong” as your body will use them to create additional tension and restriction rather than relaxation and freedom.
- JshWright 9y ago> maximizing both oxygen intake and carbon dioxide excretion. Assuming you're a reasonably healthy person (i.e. you don't have a chronic breathing condition like COPD), then your tidal volume isn't the limiting factor in either of those things. Your respiratory rate is driven by the level of carbon dioxide in your blood. Your body will adjust the rate up and down to keep it at an appropriate level (this is an important tool in your body's toolbox for maintaining the correct pH of your blood). Getting rid of too much CO2 is also bad (it's why someone who is hyperventilating ends up with spasms in the hands and feet). Getting rid of CO2 requires much more air movement than is necessary to keep your blood oxygen levels up. tl;dr; "Maximizing" those things shouldn't be a goal. Your body is already managing CO2 and O2 levels appropriately.
- ada1981 9y agoI'm curious if the converse is also useful. In holotropic Breathwork breath is made faster and deeper in order to access and release old trauma (including PTSD). I imagine this uses a mechanism of conciously activating fight or flight to confront whatever psychological material is available and recontextualize the self as safe.
- zentiggr 9y agoWould that be a strong effect on an uncontrolled basis? (I.e., fast irregular shallow and/or interrupted breaths tending to reinforce anxiety etc.?)
- ada1981 9y agoI'm not entire sure I understand your question. Maybe I can clarify what I said and that will help. Holotropic Breathwork was created by Dr. Stan Groff as an alternative to LSD Therapy after prohibition. His thesis was that symptoms were just a half expressed cure. Meaning, if you have anxiety, the trick is to actually "make it bigger" - in this case using breath work, to release whatever trauma was at the core of it. Holotropic Breathwork is usually "faster and deeper" breath. After 20 minutes or so (combined with Rythmic music) you end up in a space very similar to classic psychedelics. However this space is much more controllable in that if it gets too intense you can always slow your breath down. Much in the same way people find relief from PTSD, anxiety, depression, etc. with the classic psychedelics, they have similar results with Holotropic Breathwork. Once these sessions are over, often whatever it was that was the issue is resolved for good or at least dramatically diminished. I've found HB to be very useful in conjunction with more classic Psychedelic therapies. Does that help? If not, please rephrase for me and I'll try to answer.
- 09bjb 9y agoWhere did you learn? There seems to be a large divide between the training, time, and money required to become certified, and the one-off Saturday event. I'd like to use it but I'd also like to understand how it works. Grof's book doesn't contain a how-to and the knowledge seems a bit cloistered...too much so given that it's hard to hurt yourself in this method. I'm already "sold" on the healing potential of these modalities: psychedelics, float tanks, Lucid Lights, etc...HB would be good to add to the list, mostly because it's probably a great gateway for others to direct spiritual practice and more healing. Thank you!
- DiabloD3 9y agoSo, when do we start discussing the scientific research of Wim Hof? The "Wim Hof Method" combines breathing exercises that stimulate the vagus nerve with cold exposure to release cold shock proteins.
- jmkd 9y agoNever heard of Wim Hof but have for years promoted cold water swimming as a way to stimulate the vagus nerve to improve health and well-being.
- discussedbefore 9y agoLast week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16573571 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16573571 Study Reveals Brain Mechanisms That Allow “Iceman” Unusual Resistance to Cold https://hn.algolia.com/?query=Wim%20Hof&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=Wim%20Hof&sort=byDate&type=com...
- montrose 9y agoMy yoga teacher always says this is the most important part of yoga. She says it's why she rarely gets sick. She was delighted to hear it was one of the top stories on HN.
- maxerickson 9y agoMake sure to tell her that I also rarely get sick, without the bother of doing yoga.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- koonsolo 9y agoI used to be like that, until I got kids that went to school. It's possible that you're just not coming into contact with a lot of viruses (maybe the same for the yoga teacher). Funny story of a friend of mine: had no kids, and started dating a pre-school teacher. First year they dated, he was sick 50% of the time.
- truculation 9y agoIs there any benefit to taking a deep breath and holding it for a while before commencing the diaphragmatic breathing?
- agumonkey 9y agoBefore I read this, I also read that improved oxygen saturation has long distance effect on arteries (vasodilatation maybe ?) and probably other parts in your system. So deep breathing might improve oxygen intake thus relax you too. One thing I realized over time is that my lungs don't open linearly, there's a resistance period after the first second on intake, if I keep sucking air in after 3 seconds my whole chest opens. After that I can feel my lungs full. I also try to keep air in for ~2 seconds, thinking that it might help keeping pressure in deep into all alveolis and cleaning / exchange more oxygen. All this is Sample of One guess fest. If anybody knows it's useless or could be improved, feel free to reply.
- Nokinside 9y agoPolar (heart hate monitors) did pioneering work with HRV in the late 90's and their heart rate monitors have have a mode that HRV to to determine best heart rate limits for each exercise period for almost two decades. Heart rate itself is a good indicator of stress. Aerobic training using HR limits helps to avoid overtraining (and undertraining). If you are stressed out in one day your HR is up and you exercise slower. HRV gives even more detailed information. HRV is high during a rest and starts to decrease when the heart works closer to maximum. Measuring HRV change during a rest and gradually increasing the level of exercise gives more info than HR alone. Validity of the Polar V800 heart rate monitor to measure RR intervals at rest https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4751190/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4751190/
- duolol 9y agoI used a heart hate monitor once and that thing was always beeping
- meganibla 9y agoAlso, vagus nerve can be stimulated by anal penetration. Some people might also recognize the feeling of having a very relaxing poo.
- propman 9y agoDon't do it while sitting when first getting started, stand up or lie on your back. Hand on belly and chest, only let belly move and feel your back and ribs expand too, not just belly. Go slow and you'll find truly how large your lungs are.
- jehlakj 9y agoI’d like to add that a lot of people do diaphragmatic breathing incorrectly. The ultimate goal for utilizing the diaphragm is slow and steady breathing in a controlled manner. I see too many people taking in big gulps of air and exhaling out with no sign of control. Even when think they got it, it’s still too fast. You must keep the rib cage expanded on the exhale in order to expel the air. There is no pushing, just allowing the air to escape slowly. This may vary from activity to activity, but there needs to be a reasonable amount of control during exhalation.
- mistrial9 9y agoPeople! please be careful with these casual references to breathing exercises and other mind-body techniques. Breathing changes can hurt you. Please seek an experienced teacher.. for example, another post mentioned a cessation of breathing rhythm as a gateway.. BS, and dangerous too. Blood pressure, cardiac rhythm, mental balance, are all deeply effected. thanks and take care
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nsouth 9y agoThe key word is spontaneous breath retention. Google "kevala kumbhaka". Not BS at all, in fact it is a primary aim of the breathing exercises known as pranayama and is very widely documented within yogic texts, both old and current.
- djtriptych 9y agoWhile breath retention is part of pranayama techniques, they are NOT beginner techniques, and misuse certainly does have the capacity to do damage. Consider the inner breath as a pneumatic tool. Can you imagine holding in a powerful sneeze or cough and hurting yourself? That’s the power of the diaphragm. Getting it under control cannot be done overnight, and retention techniques increase the risk of accidental injury.
- fsloth 9y ago" Breathing changes can hurt you. Please seek an experienced teacher." Could you provide some reference of the dangers? That sounds like a generic marketing speech for yoga instructors. I don't mind finding guidance, but empty scare tactics are the cheapest trick in the salesmans arsenal. If there are explicit dangers, give external reference. Otherwise you just sound like a snake oil salesman.