18 ms·
Startup founders throughout the Midwest are doing something new: staying
- carrja99 9y agoNo.
- munk-a 9y agoSeconded.
- jonathankoren 9y agosure Silicon Valley sucks from a housing stand point, and you’d think that you can fire up an AWS instance from anywhere, and you can. However SV has one thing no place else has, a density of talent and capital unrivaled in the world. That’s why it continues to exist. Compare it to Hollywood. Sure you can make movies anywhere, but you don’t. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-silicon-valleys-success-is-so-hard-to-replicate/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-silicon-valle...
- majormajor 9y agoYou do "make" movies anywhere (well, a few places: Atlanta, Vancouver, etc). But so far the companies, business, and performers are still based in Hollywood. Question is: after a distributed generation or two, does that still hold as a natural law?
- ghaff 9y agoNot so much a natural law but definitely a natural tendency for a lots of types of businesses to cluster. It's probably particularly pronounced in industries where there is a lot of in-person deal making, "power lunches," etc. (Which is one of the reasons why traditional publishing tends to be pretty centralized as well.) As you say, actual filming has become somewhat more distributed though that is somewhat constrained by the whole ecosystem of associated trades that are needed to setup and do filming.
- acchow 9y agoYou usually need to get a ton of people physically together to shoot a scene. Programming isn't like this.
- sedachv 9y agoNot only that, but smaller, non-union productions also do everything at the last minute. This is possible in Los Angeles, where there is enough work to go around to support a lot of people in all the specialties - you can call your contacts and someone will be available. Getting custom props or set design on an 8 hours' notice is possible. Only larger projects can afford to have all of the production requirements planned in advance, something that you need if you are planning to film somewhere without a well-established film industry.
- wpietri 9y agoHollywood's not a great example. Their centrality to the movie industry has been declining for decades. E.g.: https://www.thewrap.com/louisiana-california-movie-making-capital-world-2013/ https://www.thewrap.com/louisiana-california-movie-making-ca... Or an article from this year listing LA as the 3rd-best place, after Atlanta and Vancouver, for moviemakers to live: https://www.moviemaker.com/archives/best_of/best-places-to-live-and-work-as-a-moviemaker-2018-big-cities/ https://www.moviemaker.com/archives/best_of/best-places-to-l... One important factor at work here is the Internet. Effects companies, for example, are all over the place, including London, New Zealand, Vancouver, LA, and even here in San Francisco. Big movies will often use multiple companies, something that would have been very challenging 30 years ago. Silicon Valley does have capital and talent. But it's not like that capital is in doubloons in a vault. It's purely digital. A big reason it's not more mobile is that VCs wouldn't deign to stop in a flyover state. Talent isn't quite as mobile, but a) advances in technology mean talent is less necessary, and b) the rise in remote work means the location of talent is less and less meaningful.
- jrs95 9y agoThe talent is also considerably more expensive and not substantially better unless you need people in a specific niche. And if you really need talent from SF, you could always hire them on remotely.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoMuch of this is due to unfair tax credits in various areas. And instead of competing, the geniuses in Cal/LA have been raising taxes.
- majormajor 9y agoActually tax credits for staying local have been increasing, e.g. http://www.latimes.com/business/hollywood/la-fi-ct-amazon-sneaky-pete-tax-credit-20180319-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/hollywood/la-fi-ct-amazon-sn... today
- mixmastamyk 9y ago
- ashwinaj 9y agoWell put! Instead of downvoting the authors comment, take a moment and think about it... The same analogy can be made for NYC with the finance industry.
- sdca 9y ago>a density of talent and capital unrivaled in the world The Four Asian Tigers have already surpassed SV on that. There's obviously a government-related cultural gap that won't win them any popularity contests.
- delecti 9y agoI would posit that the overwhelming majority of startups don't require "unrivaled density of talent". Most computing problems just need a decent availability of moderately competent engineers. Additionally, locating elsewhere reduces the need for such an abundance of capital.
- jonathankoren 9y agoThe density isn't just about how much talent and capital you can get, it's about how easy it is to get talent and capital.
- Erlangolem 9y agoSilicon Valley needs tech, not the other way around. Tech needs investment though, and often flocks to where the money is. Right a lot of people are throwing a lot of money around Silicon Valley, so a lot of tech (or bullshit masquerading as tech) lives there.
- wpietri 9y agoTo me this is heartening in a variety of ways. One is that we're finally making good on the promise of the Internet. The hype was that it made location irrelevant. And it did for a lot of things. But somehow VC-backed web and companies were immune to that, even though money and software are both digital. Two is that this is great news for founders everywhere. Before they often had to choose between family and success. Now they can have both. (That didn't matter to me much when I was 25, but now it's easier to see costs of that.) Three, I think this is great for customers and users. A frequent and frequently valid critique of Silicon Valley startups is that many only make sense in our hothouse atmosphere. E.g., Juicero. There are real-world needs out there that we're missing because we don't see and spend time with the people who have those needs. Four, I believe that this is good news for both our cities and our startup community. The flood of money has driven up prices just like it did during the gold rush era. That's certainly a problem for people outside of tech. But I think it's also bad for entrepreneurs: it keeps getting more expensive to build a team and a company here. Turning down the heat a little will make it easier for us all to succeed without having to take gobs of money.
- jt2190 9y ago> The hype was that [the internet] made location irrelevant. And it did for a lot of things. But somehow VC-backed web and companies were immune to that, even though money and software are both digital. montrose did a good job of summarizing a recent Wall Street Journal article ("Why Cities Boom While Towns Struggle", March 13, 2018) about this very phenomenon: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16611042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16611042 To summarize his summary: > [R]emote exchanges of ideas are no substitute for the elemental human process of face-to-face communication. Innovators don’t do their work in isolation; they stimulate one another. -- Enrico Moretti edit: Here's a link to a non-paywalled interview with Mr. Moretti about his book, "The New Geography of Jobs" (2012): https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/enrico-moretti-geography-jobs https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/enrico-moretti-geograp...
- aaron-lebo 9y ago[R]emote exchanges of ideas are no substitute for the elemental human process of face-to-face communication. Innovators don’t do their work in isolation; they stimulate one another. Historically, many have. And today, when you can ping almost anyone in the world, it's not an obstacle. Not to mention, most big cities have a research university (if not multiple). Nobody is lacking for input. The claim about "elemental" processes isn't based on anything concrete. I work in multiple remote teams and it's never been an issue. We get more work done than if we had to see each other every day. That's hardly an endorsement for SV alone unless SV has all the talent in the world (it doesn't). I think your post and some of the other posts advocating for SV have knowingly or not accepted a belief about how things work, but they are essentially mythologies. Some work as loners, some work in groups. The biggest mythology of all is that it takes hundreds of millions in funding and unethical behavior to build cool stuff - it doesn't. That seems to be the SV way, many of us don't want that.
- aidenn0 9y agoI graduated from Purdue in '04 and the job market in-state was terrible. The best offer I received in Indiana was a one year contract @ $35k in Fort Wayne. Several talented people I knew took software jobs at $40k or under to stay close to family. I didn't even have to go to a tech hub to get more than double that $35k job offer. As an aside: I will never work for Caterpillar after seeing the way the recruiters treated students at the job fair. An actually overheard sentence (and whatever tone you are hearing in your head is likely less harsh than what was used): "Our requirements list a minimum 3.5 GPA, why are you wasting my time with a 3.2?" this was not a particularly egregious example either, but rather the typical way they talked to candidates once they found a reason to throw away their resumé.
- Trundle 9y agoWith your opinion on Caterpillar, I feel like I need to share that I once spilt the contents of about 10 beers on top of some of their bigwigs. You're welcome.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoDid you graduate from the Engineering College? I am on the Engineering Accreditation Board now and this is the feedback that we need from alums.
- aidenn0 9y agoI graduated from the College of Science. Since that time there has been a huge increase in software openings in the Midwest. I was looking at software jobs, with a preference for embedded. At the time there were very low paying jobs in the Fort Wayne area and some startups in Indy. Now Cincinnati is booming, with Indianapolis falling not too far behind. Big 10 wise, Madison and Ann Arbor both seem to have more of a tech hub than Lafayette. The company I currently work for recruits fairly heavily from Illinois and Rose Hulman. I can track down some recent grads if you want recent midwest job-hunt info.
- imroot 9y ago
- yesimahuman 9y agoThe headline is clickbaity. The point isn't that Silicon Valley isn't a major force in tech or that other parts of the US will "beat" it. Rather, it's that you can build valuable tech companies outside of it, and that the Midwest in particular is ripe for more tech companies. I know first hand, I'm building my VC-backed (including coastal $) startup in Madison, and we've stayed put. I realized the pressures we felt to move early on were our own insecurities and the bias of tech/investor media (which I've noticed has changed recently, we're not seen as so crazy!) I'm glad we stayed put, especially as we've started to focus on real revenue and scaling, and less on trying to be hot for the purposes of raising a big early round. I feel like the market for engineers around here is becoming an advantage for us, and we're not having to fight the same talent wars as those on the coasts. That matters.
- dang 9y agoWe changed the baity title to the less baity subtitle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sidlls 9y agoMadison has a lower cost of living, but my experience there (working and looking for work), admittedly dated by half a decade, is that the variety and quality of engineering work pales in comparison to that available in bigger hubs. It's mostly very mundane work for one of the many insurers there, maybe Epic, etc. It's also generally very poorly compensated relatively.
- yesimahuman 9y agoThat’s a slightly ancillary point to mine. Regardless, a lot has changed in the last two years even (and we’ve had to raise salaries to compensate). It has a ways to go but I’d like to think we’re proof of the potential that is there today. (We didn’t even exist 5 years ago anyways!) Also I’d like to think what we’re working on isn’t mundane!
- cirgue 9y agoSilicon Valley has a radically different viewpoint and set of priorities than the rest of the world. This discrepancy still has not been exploited to anywhere near its full potential. Edit: To clarify, I think SV is increasingly insular, and there is untapped innovative potential outside the bubble.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThe singular success of SV might point to some of its values being linked to its success. “Correlation is not causation” doesn’t even apply, because regardless of causality (a->b, b->a, or even x->a && b) it would seem that it’s difficult to have one without the other. It’s also important to note that the high reaches of other creative industries espouse values very similar to those of The Valley.
- jerf 9y agoTimes change. The "SV values" of 40 years ago are noticeably different than the ones of today. Heck there's been a pretty noticeable shift even in the past 5 years. If SV did have the right values for success 20 years ago, I'd at least put out the suggestion that that opens the possibility that it doesn't have the success values today.
- asabjorn 9y agoIt might also mean that the hard work of the people creating interesting things has not yet been outweighed by other negative factors in its environment. The old school hacker culture is very contrarian to the current dominant SV viewpoint due it’s nerdiness and focus on what you can create above all other values.
- arthurcolle 9y agoApologies for the tangent - I have never been to the bay area, but I am frequently reminded many times when I meet a “pure tech company” ala google, msft, amzn, fb software engineer (I’m only 3 years out of school, studied CS) of this self-righteous and condescending narcissism that I haven’t seen repeated across other workers in other industries and a kind of deep sense of self-congratulatory entitlement. It is a little bit akin to what you see with Ivy League students -> Banks/Mgmt Consulting, but infinitely more detestable given how flippant toward the rest of the world the tech attitudes can be. Silicon valley is obviously the new wall street in terms of attracting the big brains and bringing a focused collection of hard working or brilliant individuals - yeah, we need the infrastructure to make the world spin faster but it can really bring out the worst and most myopic visions even from the “best and brightest”. I like automation and disruption, purely for its own sake, because we can. But the hyperaccumulation of wealth driven entirely by advertising is absurd and is effectively non-productive and I hope more people refuse to take classical VC funding and instead opt for organic growth and/or pure public raises. The only reason a web app development company (basically all these startups) that is 6 months old needs 5 million bucks is to create a legal fiction that from its inception is designed to create liquidation events that make VCs extremely wealthy, done in a way that gives the impression of “risk taking” without any real risk being taken because of the ability to create unicorns from deliberate successive raises - all of these entities exist within the same monoculture, with huge overlap in board of directors and investor groups. I think that ICO related innovations can help in potentially mitigating the development and solidication of this monoculture as we have seen in Wall Street, but unfortunately the criminality of some of the newer players in this field is staggering and equally disappointing Tech almost certainly doesn’t need Silicon Valley and a decoupling of peoples thinking in those terms will be very useful step in the right direction
- aaron-lebo 9y agoThere's a lot of truth to what you say, but you are preaching to the wrong audience.
- sneak 9y agoIt is very difficult to get a person to understand something when their salary depends on them not understanding it, or so the quote goes.
- influx 9y agoWhat would Microsoft and Amazon have been without Silicon Valley?
- irrational 9y agoDo you mean because they are located in Seattle instead of Cali?
- twblalock 9y agoI suspect that when Silicon Valley loses its dominance it will be to China, not to other parts of the United States.
- gowld 9y agoDoes China export consumer webtech? The unique "Chinese characteristics" as they call it would seem to make it hard to export consumer services.
- zachguo 9y agoMany Chinese tech companies are expanding overseas, just not much in North America, mostly in high growth areas in Asia. They also own and control many well-known mobile game studios. TBH, apps like Facebook and even Snapchat copied features from Chinese apps like Wechat and Alipay.
- gaius 9y agoNo one knows if Chinese consumer sites/apps like Weibo, Tencent etc can compete in an open market. Maybe they can but if so, why hide behind the Great Firewall?
- varjag 9y agoAnd the few Web companies from China that took off globally all seem to specialize in selling physical goods originating from China.
- dangerbird2 9y agoWhile China is well on its way to becoming a key player in fields like AI, by far the greatest thing preventing it from becoming the "next Silicon Valley" is censorship and protectionism of the Chinese government. The fact that online social platforms in China have to play by the CPC's rules makes it extremely difficult for a service to have both a mainland Chinese and international market. Places like the E.U. and large democracies like India have a huge competative advantage due to the fact that there are very few bureaucratic and political hurdles to get a business started.
- rdiddly 9y agoBetting now that Peter Thiel's recent "move" is mentioned. Now off to read the article. EDIT: Well I lost that one. It's about the Midwest. They did mention Thiel though, just not in that way. EDIT 2: And now the title has been changed (an improvement), making me look like (more of) an EEEDIOT!
- aaavl2821 9y agoThe abundance of startup jobs and VCs in Silicon Valley is not matched anywhere else, and this makes quitting a stable job and working for a startup / starting a company a far less risky proposition than if you lived in an area where there were maybe 1-2 startups big enough to hire reliably. In those places people just don't make careers of working in startups because there aren't enough jobs / funding That said, there are a lot of complicated industries where domain expertise trumps tech ability (healthcare is a prime example). Most successful health tech companies are not in CA (epic in Madison and cerner in Kansas City as two big examples). As more people learn to code I think there will be a growth in startups with relatively simple tech that is just well suited for the problem it addresses. Solutions that don't scale to millions of users / are not optimally performant but are designed by users can win in a lot of sectors
- arca_vorago 9y agoI think this conversation is missing a big piece of what made SV in the first place. Namely, the military industrial congressional complex. I can't remember the author but he gave a good Google talk on the origins of SV from war engineering. I think since the type of warfare of the future is largely informational, and governments are increasingly neo-fuedal and authoritarian, in the future SV will be seen as a base of operations of the enemy of tech. Not only does tech not need SV, but they are going to largely be at odds. SV will probably still have the highest concentration of VC to IPO cycles but the problem is so many of them aren't solving problems with products or services and are generally focused on how to turn customer data into an advertiser money pit while they angle for the IPO boom and exit (betraying users more and more the closer the exit is) I'll tell you what tech does need though... non SV big money representation on the hill. That said, there some good things in SV like the EFF, and I don't have much knowledge of the area other than riding my Harley up 1 to visit a friend a few times. I do know Pelosi is a a horrible authoritarian in democratic clothing and it surprises me SF hasn't gotten rid of her yet.
- pfarrell 9y agoWas it Steve Blank's "The Secret History of Silicon Valley"? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo
- arca_vorago 9y agoIndeed it is. Thank you. One thing I forgot to mention is how bad, constitutionally speaking, NSL's and other pressures from the government are. We just don't know how prevalent it has become, perhaps the government is NSL strong-arming companies left and right at the moment... Which is why the legislation that enabled NSLs is unconstitutional imho.
- EADGBE 9y agoBut she was hesitant to move. She’d grown up in Northern Indiana and studied communications at DePauw University. She and her husband, a commercial real estate developer, had built a life for themselves and their two kids near the capital city. This is an important aspect that I can't assume is only important to the Midwest, but something that I come across myself here, also in the Midwest. Occasionally an over-enthusiastic recruiter will reach out about a relocation opportunity. I sometimes can't help but reply "No. I love it here." Much to what I assume is confusion. We can still move fast and break things out here in Fly Over Country. And our salaries can afford us better opportunities in comparison. I think a lot of 'Coasters have a hard time even rationalizing that. No technology I've encountered is locked down to a location.
- Spooky23 9y agoIt’s weird to me that the myth is that you need to be in the Valley... until you open your development center in Hyderabad.
- tjr225 9y agoI dunno...I make a lot more out here on the coast...I graduated from school at the end of 2014 and I make 2.75x more than my first job offer out of school back in my home state of MI. The weather is a lot more mild and pleasant. There are also things on the coast that you simply can't get in flyover country- mountains, ocean, vast empty national parks, for instance...I swear it feels like I'm on vacation every other weekend. OTOH I don't really want to buy a house out here just because it's a daunting prospect but there are pros and cons to living and working in each area.
- tannhauser23 9y agoYeah, when you are young SV makes a lot of sense. But once you start a family? It gets very tough to stay here, very tough.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 9y ago
- danschumann 9y agoI live in Oshkosh, Wisconsin. We used to make kids clothes, now we make trucks(military trucks). I've been writing animation software for the past 2 years. I work 3 hours a day freelancing to pay the bills ( my rent is 540 / month for a 2 bedroom ). When the software is done, it could be a multi million dollar thing, but for now I'm living on beans and rice. It's quite a hard thing, quite giant project for one person to do. Hopefully I think it was all worth it, if and when I get through it.
- dang 9y agoGood luck! I hope it works.
- antoineMoPa 9y agoI just hope for you that this software has something different from other existing software.
- drb91 9y agoWow that rent though, a great place to live frugally. How is your health insurance (if you don’t mind my asking)?
- danschumann 9y agoIt's $500 a month but I pay $.16 after tax credit. (my income is pretty low due to only freelancing as little as possible)
- pnutjam 9y agoIn my experience, health insurance is no cheaper in the midwest, but you have lower quality care in many areas. Care can be especially difficult in rural areas. For comparison, I pay about $600 / month for a High deductible plan that pays nothing until I pay $6k. This is through a company with about 300 employees. I'm in an urban area (Indy).
- chaostheory 9y ago> She was running into the same issue that Case had observed in other cities. It had been easy enough to scrounge up seed money and desk space in Indianapolis, but the venture capital she’d need to bring her company to scale was much harder to find locally. > Case acknowledged that the investment culture of Silicon Valley is unique. It “encourages fearlessness,” he said, “and that’s something to be admired.” It can also be difficult to replicate elsewhere. This is one of the many things that keeps SV dominant. Unless this changes in the MidWest, things will stay the same. It will still be more beneficial for your company to move to California than stay if you need money. Investors in other parts of the country (and the world) are just less risk tolerant than California.
- PhilipA 9y agoAs a Danish company who a year ago moved to Minneapolis, I can tell you that there is hidden gold in the mid west. Especially in Minneapolis there are tons of universities and cost of of living is much lower than the west coast. It makes it a lot easier to keep your employees once they want to start a family, something far too many companies neglect.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoUnless you want a bunch of people from CA to show up and ruin it you should stop bragging about how great it is. Sincerely, Denver
- twblalock 9y agoYeah, that's the irony of other cities trying to compete with Silicon Valley. If a city succeeds at this and a lot of well-paid engineers move there, that city will end up a lot like Silicon Valley, including the high housing prices and the traffic.
- bproven 9y agowell, mainly the problem is the city doesn't prepare for it. For example, not keeping up with housing demand, public transit demand etc. THEN you get the bay area ;)
- Tempest1981 9y agoAnd if you try to tax businesses to pay for infrastructure, they threaten to leave the state. And businesses barely pay employees enough to afford a mortgage, or even rent, so you can't tax the residents. How do we get our infrastructure?
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoThe private market will make the housing available and keep rent low, which you can then serve with infrastructure via. property tax. San Fransisco and other coastal cities are the only ones that haven't figured out to just build homes.
- jdhn 9y agoAs someone who went to school in the Midwest, moved away, and then moved back, I think it's good that this is happening. That being said, I plan on moving away from the Midwest for good later this year, as there are better opportunities (and weather) elsewhere.
- swanson 9y agoIf you happen to be an Indianapolis-based (or surrounding area) developer reading these comments, please tweet me @_swanson and I'd be happy to get you invited to our local Slack instance.
- tschellenbach 9y agoBoulder is actually getting quite close to SF in terms of engineering salaries. This is article is a bit late with spotting the trend.
- whalesalad 9y agoDoes Boulder count as the Midwest? Plus... Colorado/Denver/Boulder has a lot more sex appeal than Des Moines IA or Columbus OH so I’m not surprised it isn’t facing the same salary challenges as the actual Midwest.
- shagie 9y agoColorado is in the West - Mountain region in the Census ( https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Census_Regions_and_Division_of_the_United_States.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Census_Regions_and_D... ). It isn't part of the breadbasket / midlands culture ( https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2013/11/08/which-of-the-11-american-nations-do-you-live-in/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2013/11/08/w... ) It doesn't have the midwest linkages in Facebook ( https://petewarden.com/2010/02/06/how-to-split-up-the-us/ https://petewarden.com/2010/02/06/how-to-split-up-the-us/ ). It isn't part of the hopelessly midwestern culture ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3B9iu3QAwM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3B9iu3QAwM ). So nope... Colorado isn't midwestern.
- matthewwiese 9y agoLove that last link. As a kid who grew up in the Midwest with a soybean field outside the kitchen window, the song put a wide smile on my face.
- omot 9y agoKind of an irrelevant tangent, but I think the reason why Snapchat is suffering is that HQ is in LA. I noticed that you have to pay great developers/designers more to relocate away from the Bay Area. You also get slower iteration on new hires since they have to fly to/from SF/LA for interviews. It's great that these founders could stay in the Midwest, but if they're ever to compete against the giant companies, they'd probably have to relocate to the Bay Area or Seattle.
- hokumguru 9y agoI live in Lincoln, Nebraska and this has been clear to us for years. We've a few startups and agencies of decent size and reputation that have made their home here. Quite interestingly, it's not been that terribly difficult to find tech jobs paying 80-110k here where one might find a good rental for 600-700/m (I should add home ownership in Nebraska is quite large). I quite like the idea of the west-coast salary in a midwest cost of living. Hoping it stays that way :) If interested you could check out http://siliconprairienews.com/ http://siliconprairienews.com/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Tempest1981 9y agoI see 2 companies with looking for software developers on your Jobs page: D3 Banking, and Proxibid. Is that typical?
- tortasaur 9y agoIf you're asking if it's typical of the area, no. It appears that job board only has two companies posting to it. Indeed or LinkedIn are better indicators of the market.
- uptownfunk 9y agoThe internet I would contend didn’t make location completely irrelevant. I think the existing gap lies in access to capital. And while we do not have crypto done anywhere near correctly, the true democratization of capital will do a lot more for the redistribution of wealth displacing the SF VC CF that currently exists today.
- _bxg1 9y agoHopefully this will reduce some of the techno-elitism that's been on such a sharp rise for the past decade. It's heartening to see an intersection of the progressiveness of tech with the groundedness of people outside The Valley.
- lettergram 9y agoAs a startup founder who moved to the Bay area and moved back. I can see why, literally I own a house, with better internet, 5 minutes from a store, with no traffic, no distractions, and can communicate with anyone online... Honestly, location matters to an extent, but it's really what you make of it. I know people across the country, they intro me to others. Many I never meet in person, yet we all help one another. I think it's more than possible to grow connections in the absence of presents, just harder.
- lowpro 9y agoI grew up in Fishers, and currently go to Purdue (an hour north). I can say from what I've seen that tech really is coming here, it isn't trying anymore. I know there is a lot of 'Silicon Valley of X', but I don't think Indy is trying to be the next Silicon Valley. It feels like the people here are content at solving problems big and small, and not as focused on capital and business. Personally I think this a good thing, and prefer it. And of course as the article states, a little Midwest politeness pervades the area. Salaries are also way higher in the area then they used to be (expect maybe $50,000-60,000 in the area, at least for new grads in the area for larger name companies). It's not SV wages, but it's not city living either, and the area is great. To follow some of the people in the area, I'd look at @DonWettrick [0] on twitter, he's an educator in the area and a lot of his students are a part of Launch Fishers and are coming into the local start up scene. If you care about the next generation, definitely a class to keep up with! [0] https://twitter.com/DonWettrick https://twitter.com/DonWettrick
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIn my experience, if you like working and you're top 10%, you will do well in a big city. By the time you're 26 to 28, and you have an MBA/JD/MD, I see my friends making $200k+ easy. If you're in this group, then you're household income is $400k+ easy, but the big difference is the connections you're making which can enable you to go up to 7 and 8 figures or more. Really depends what you want to gamble on, but if you're top of the class and want to make money I would definitely try out a major city.
- TulliusCicero 9y ago> Poring over the available data, Case discovered that plenty of Midwestern and Southwestern cities were leveraging tax incentives to stanch local brain drain, and a few, such as Pittsburgh and Indianapolis, were cultivating their own robust startup scenes. Tax incentives means competing on price, which is a loser in the long run. Lower taxes sounds good until you consider the implications: less money invested in the society itself. > “We have a lot of quality-of-life advantages: not a lot of congestion, good restaurants, low home prices,” he said. “It’s a place where a young family won’t bankrupt themselves buying a house with a yard.” * Not a lot of congestion just means they have car-dominant sprawl that hasn't hit a huge economic boom yet. That's a downside to me. * Somehow I really doubt their restaurants are significantly better than the bay area, NYC, or Boston. * Home prices aren't so much a quality of life advantage as a cost of living advantage.
- briandear 9y ago> Lower taxes sounds good until you consider the implications: less money invested in the society itself Or, perhaps the Laffer Curve? Maybe revenue actually increases? Look at Texas: huge budget surpluses and lower taxes and public schools ranked higher than California. I am not trying to debate which state is better, but I am trying to make the point that lower taxes does not correlate to a lower quality state. A poorer state does correlate: such as Mississippi for example, but low tax “rich” states do just fine.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoYes, but look at what usually happens. For example, most of the top 10 GDP per capita states are blue (and the ones that aren't are tiny petro states), while most of the bottom 10 GDP per capita states are red. This directly contradicts the conservative mantra of "low taxes spurs economic growth", if anything it looks like the opposite is true. > I am not trying to debate which state is better, but I am trying to make the point that lower taxes does not correlate to a lower quality state. Well, "quality" is a pretty subjective word, but it does seem to generally lead to certain things being worse, like social safety nets, education, etc. For example, in the case of Texas, it also has an insanely high maternal mortality rate, and while public schools there may outrank California's, California has an extremely strong public university system.