5 ms·
The Paragon closure has come with a surprising number of upsides compared to the usual collapse of a game. I really wish more companies opened up their assets (
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
The Paragon closure has come with a surprising number of upsides compared to the usual collapse of a game. I really wish more companies opened up their assets (or even the game code) upon the closure of a game they've written off.
The other highlight note is that when Epic decided to shutdown Paragon, they opened up the refund offer for all purchases, not just really recent ones. They've taken essentially a complete loss on this entire project, that I believe had upwards of 100 developers working on it at one point.
But given Fortnite's success, plus the general solid padding of cash Epic always gets from having one of the most popular game engines that everyone else uses, means they can afford it.
- ramy_d 9y agoWow I hadn't heard about the refunds. That's really uplifting.
- mbesto 9y ago> They've taken essentially a complete loss on this entire project It's a genius financial and strategical move, predicated by having a lucky monster success elsewhere in the company that required a quick influx of resources (Fortnite). They can effectively write off a failed game over the next 5 years, and reduce their tax burden as a result. They then act as a "benevolent" actor to the gaming development community by giving away assets that have no financial incentive to them. So they get a nice influx of resources and get to advertise to a new pool in the same breadth. That's a win-win. EDIT: I should also note - I was a benefactor of shifting my payment from Paragon to Fortnite. Given that it had no variable cost to give me $20 worth of skins in Fortnite, that's a pretty solid user acquisition strategy.
- Erlangolem 9y agoDeleted
- gmueckl 9y agoParagon was/is already a F2P "monster".
- sbarre 9y agoI don't see why benevolent needs to be in quotes in your comment. Regardless of whatever financial or tax upside they get from doing this, the upside the game development community gets is the same. They are doing something they really didn't need to do, and as GP pointed out, most companies don't do.
- mbesto 9y ago> I don't see why benevolent needs to be in quotes in your comment > most companies don't do. Because most companies are for-profit entities. Most companies don't do this because they aren't in this specific situation. Most gaming companies have really delicate economics (high up front capital costs, with less than guaranteed returns). Call me cynical all you want, but the idea that video gaming companies (of all industries) are somehow out to provide benevolently for it's software developing community is laughable at best (see EA, Ubisoft, Zynga etc). The video gaming market is rife with abusing long hours out of it's employees.
- rootlocus 9y ago> see EA, Ubisoft, Zynga etc You're cherry picking a handful of awful companies for the sake of making a point about the entire industry.
- mbesto 9y agoI take it you haven't worked in the industry? There's literally an industry term for it ("crunch") because it's so bad. https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/257143/Working_time_among_video_game_developers_Trends_over_200414.php https://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/257143/Working_time_amon... http://www.gameinformer.com/themes/blogs/generic/post.aspx?WeblogApp=features&y=2018&m=01&d=16&WeblogPostName=crunch-the-video-game-industrys-notorious-labor-problem&GroupKeys=&PostPageIndex=2 http://www.gameinformer.com/themes/blogs/generic/post.aspx?W... https://kotaku.com/crunch-time-why-game-developers-work-such-insane-hours-1704744577 https://kotaku.com/crunch-time-why-game-developers-work-such... https://venturebeat.com/2016/03/20/why-crunch-time-is-still-a-problem-in-the-video-game-industry/ https://venturebeat.com/2016/03/20/why-crunch-time-is-still-... https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/25/opinion/work-culture-video-games-crunch.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/25/opinion/work-culture-vide... https://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/PaulTozour/20150120/234443/The_Game_Outcomes_Project_Part_4_Crunch_Makes_Games_Worse.php https://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/PaulTozour/20150120/234443/T...
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoAnd hopefully get more devs to use their platform (Unreal Engine) using these assets as their entry point, giving them dank licensing money if there is a good game amongst the many mediocre ones.
- tyrust 9y ago>reduce their tax burden Why do people always make this argument? Loss is loss. You're financially better off if you make money, even if you have to pay taxes on it.
- Kiro 9y agoYeah, I don't understand how this reduces anything. Can someone explain?
- simaracode 9y agoYou basically can take a Tax deduction on capital losses, meaning paying less tax (Super simplifying the complex US Tax Code) https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/062713/capital-losses-and-tax.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/062713/capit...
- tyrust 9y agoYou pay taxes on capital gains. Suppose that Epic made P income from Paragon and I income from everything else. They are taxed at T. So if they return P to customers, that's a loss. So they will pay (I - P) * T in taxes and end up with (I - P) * (1 - T). Suppose they kept P, that's gain. So they will pay (I + P) * T in taxes and end up with (I + P) * (1 - T). So even though they pay less in taxes ((I - P) * T < (I + P) * T), they will end up with less money ((I - P) * (1 - T) < (I + P) * (1 - T)).
- mbesto 9y agoWhoa, even I couldn't follow this :) Basically, what it means is the following: Year 1 - I spent $10M on Paragon (let's pretend I've made a single dollar from it). I therefore have negative -$10M in profit, so I pay zero taxes. Year 2 - I shut Paragon down. I still have $10M in losses from Paragon. Fortnite does $30M in Revenue and it cost me $20M to build Fortnite in Year 2. Theoretically I profited $10M in year 2 and I'd have to pay ~30% (thats not the real number, so don't correct me) of that in taxes, so I really only get to keep $7M of that to reinvest. But I get to carry my loss forward from Year 1 onwards. So in theory I get to keep more of my profit due to a smaller tax burden. Generally speaking this is usually done over 5 years. So I'd take $10M and amortize it $2M ever year. Meaning Year 2, instead of paying 30% of $10M, I would pay 30% of 8M, so $2.4M versus $3M. It's obviously way more complicated than this, but this is the gist.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoIt still takes time and energy to package and release something to the public, even if it is assets.
- barking 9y agoI come in peace. You're not a benefactor given that you are the one who benefited
- maaaats 9y ago> I really wish more companies opened up their assets (or even the game code) upon the closure of a game they've written off. Or just old games in general. Many rewrites of old games are hampered by the lack of assets.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoSure, but there's a big difference in how a company sees the value. If you're talking about a property the company found success with, they surely want to hang onto the copyright and exclusive control of those assets with which to make sequels and the like, or even remasters and re-releases as Nintendo often does. I particularly feel we need to clear up the copyright drama for abandoned works in particular, but there's a reasonable point that plenty of companies do continue to use and sell their game content for a very long time. A failed project has very little value for the purposes of monetizing again later, you don't make a sequel to a game that you didn't make a profit on (usually). So it's a particularly good category to give away to the community.
- snuxoll 9y agoI'm interested to see if Epic releases the entirety of the remaining assets, while they are no longer interested in developing the game there was a small but dedicated community that was sad to see the game shutdown. It would be interesting to see the community take over the game and continue to give it life, and it wouldn't be the first time this has happened (see Allegiance/FreeAllegiance as an example, Microsoft just re-licensed the game under the MIT license last year at that - it was already available under the MSR-SSLA for quite a while).
- banned1 9y agoWell, in this case Epic and whoever benefits from these assets are taking the Taxpayer for a ride. So this is a “convenient” incentive to Epic and others who use these assets (as opposed to inconvenient, as when it happens with [company not relevant to the SV echo chamber]). A) Epic closes Paragon down B) Epic opens Paragon assets C) Epic deducts Paragon losses from their earnings, saving on federal taxes D) Companies that build assets based on these assets do so while getting a nice taxpayer-enabled corporate welfare check.
- pjc50 9y agoC) would happen regardless of the other items.
- banned1 9y agoMy understanding is that this happens when an asset is written off. I understand it would be either now [with the action], or over time [without this action]. Maybe a person with an accounting background can correct me so I can edit my comment. Thanks for bringing this potential issue up.
- throwaway2048 9y agopretty much all corporate expendature is tax deductable.
- banned1 9y agoSoftware is an asset that depreciates over time. It's not an expenditure in the sense of when one spends money on, say, a trip, which would become an instant expense.
- cdkee 9y agoWell to Epic, their games are usually a showcase of their engine. It makes sense to open source their assets. It also helps that Fortnite is a massive success.
- Thaxll 9y ago"They've taken essentially a complete loss on this entire project, that I believe had upwards of 100 developers working on it at one point." Not really, they're doing that on purpose to put everyone on Fortnite, it's a very different story.