4 ms·
Why Is Kitty Hawk's Flying Taxi Taking Off in New Zealand Instead of California?
- carbonatedmilk 9y agoGosh darn it Orville, I told you we needed a section 333 exemption with a part 61 pilot rating, not a Part 107 waiver! Maybe the drone guys should just start strapping cannons to the wings, then they'd be classed as assault rifles and there'd be no regulation at all.
- fwgwgwgch 9y agoOr we could bring a constitutional amendment?
- bmelton 9y ago> then they'd be classed as assault rifles and there'd be no regulation at all Well, they'd need to become a Type 7 and Type 10 FFL, subject to numerous regulations by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, meaning every design would need to be subject to approval by the government only after they've ensured that it isn't easily modifiable by consumers. If you actually do manufacture an assault cannon, it's a destructive device of greater than half inch bore, meaning it wouldn't be eligible for civilian purchase at all, so your clientele would be limited to government. You'd be subject to paying applications fees, renewal fees, design submission fees, approval fees, etc. You'd be subject to routine inspections by the government, who can choose to disallow any product you'd like to make. Your clientele would be limited to government only, and you'd be subject to literally thousands of pages of regulations. Smugness aside, your strategy is very flawed, as adding firearms to your device would add immense heaps of regulation, and doesn't help avoid any, whatsoever. And of course, you'd still be responsible for all the regulatory hurdles of building a drone too.
- icelancer 9y ago>> then they'd be classed as assault rifles and there'd be no regulation at all. I really don't understand people that say this. Have you ever tried to buy an actual "assault" rifle, meaning a select-fire battle-ready rifle? Even for semiautomatic rifles, the regulations are quite long. Maybe no one should own an AR-15 (though I doubt banning specifically the AR-15 would do anything since its not even the most effective gun for what people illegally and terribly use it for, people just happen to do it because its popular and in Call of Duty), but to call it "no regulation" is just silly.
- alistairSH 9y agoYeah, the OP conflated assault rifle with assault weapon (the first being select fire, the second being semi-auto). That said, the regulations for purchasing a plain-old semi-auto rifle are not a particularly high hurdle. In my state (VA), you walk into store, point at gun, hand over 2 ID and a credit card, fill out a background check, and wait a few minutes for the NICS check to complete, then walk out with the gun. If you buy the gun from a private party, you get to skip the ID and NICS portion - just hand over cash and walk away with gun.
- jlebrech 9y agoto use an AR-15 you need quite a bit of training, for an actual battle scenario. an "assault" anything, just means it looks badass (or scary). the problem is when AR15s are used to shoot fish in a barrel, aka people in school corridors. machine guns are very well regulated on the contrary.
- jessaustin 9y agoAn AR-15 is a rifle. That's all. If you can shoot rifles safely, you can shoot an AR-15 safely.
- kahnpro 9y agoMaybe he's trying to refer to automatic weapons?
- keithnz 9y agowell, makes sense, we were the first to fly.... http://www.ctie.monash.edu.au/hargrave/pearse1.html http://www.ctie.monash.edu.au/hargrave/pearse1.html
- adventured 9y agoThere's essentially zero strong evidence for the timeline actually being correct. That has always been the problem with Pearse. Nothing was recorded, and there were no observers. Further, Pearse admits he was not the first to achieve flight. "In two letters, published in 1915 and 1928, the inventor writes of February or March 1904 as the time when he ‘set out to solve the problem of aerial navigation’. He also states that he did not achieve proper flight and did not beat the American brothers Wilbur and Orville Wright, who flew on 17 December 1903." https://nzhistory.govt.nz/culture/richard-pearse https://nzhistory.govt.nz/culture/richard-pearse
- adventured 9y agoAs much as I'd like to see this being tested in California, this is also perhaps more of benefit to both the US and New Zealand. New Zealand is a small nation of less than five million people. It's a competitive advantage to be able to offer greater and more nuanced accomodation. Anything New Zealand can test at a smaller scale and prove out, that larger countries can then learn from and adopt, is a win all around. The government system of New Zealand is radically smaller and you can interface far more directly and easily with it accordingly. Their government is ~1/90th the size of the US Federal Government + States. For something like Kitty Hawk, it makes a lot of sense to prove the concept first before engaging a bureacracy the size of the US Govt + States (California in this case). If a country like New Zealand does things right, that will always be the case no matter how hard the US tries.
- WhompingWindows 9y agoWhile the regulatory, political, and economic factors are useful for a budding company, I also think about the geography of New Zealand. It has two main islands and an estimated 600 islands total. It's also long/narrow with mountains and impassable terrain in many central locales. I can't help but feel a passenger drone with 60 miles of range could save a significant amount of time for passengers, whether that's avoiding a ferry or avoiding impassable (for a car or boat) terrain. One could also see these services being used in lieu of helicopters for transferring sick hospitalized patients, transferring high-priority payloads, and so forth. Really interesting to see what use-cases this tech will cater to, I'm hoping not just recreational uses for the wealthy.
- lazerpants 9y agoAdd to that the low population density that makes potential crashes far less dangerous to people on the ground.
- jessaustin 9y agoTheir government is ~1/90th the size of the US Federal Government + States. It's true our government is simply too big. Most of the serious problems we have, stem mostly from the inherent scale. We would be happier and better-governed if the Union were broken up in about ten pieces.
- lancewiggs 9y agoTesting advanced UAVs and services? Some locals are setting up an area in the far north for wide open drone testing, including flying well out of line of site, challenging terrain and weather/wind.
- djsumdog 9y agoI think it's interesting this flying taxi would never be deployable in the nation's capitol. Wellington is literally the windiest city in the world. On nights when the windows rumble, residents tend to ask "Was that the wind, or an earthquake?" (they get quite a lot of both). I'm sure these would do fine in Auckland or Christchurch, but they'd be grounded most of the year in Wellington. For people who are interested, look up videos of pilots landing in Wellington on high wind days. My airlines require separate training programs for that airport.
- aunty_helen 9y agoChristchurch also gets very bad trade winds from the North West, the difference being the ample flat land they have allows for a runway to accomodate this. Spring/Summer seasons see a fair amount of use of the N/W runway at Christchurch international. Wellington is just a badly placed airport. Just as an FYI, going off the pictures from their website I'd place the test flights ~20km from Methven from the scenery in the background.
- rplnt 9y agoSlightly offtopic, but once again, the "American/English" style of title makes it almost incomprehensible. How is it in any way better than this? > Why is Kitty Hawk's flying taxi taking off in New Zealand instead of California?
- samb1729 9y agoI currently see this title: > Why Is Kitty Hawk's Flying Taxi Taking Off in New Zealand Instead of California? What was it before?
- rplnt 9y agoThat's what I saw. The unnecessary capitalization is what I'm talking about. To be fair, this is far from the worst case. There are titles where it doesn't make a difference, some are so-so, and some are really bad. But I'm fairly certain there is no case where it makes it better (easier to read).
- dingo_bat 9y agoI think they are complaining about the capitalization.
- rplnt 9y agoYes, there's a name (Kitty Hawk) comprised of common words (Kitty, Hawk). If you don't know the name, you can't pick it out because every word is capitalized. It's stupid design.
- pc86 9y agoIn what possible way does capitalization make something "incomprehensible?" You know what actually makes your original point incomprehensible? Needless hyperbole.
- rplnt 9y agoI explained that down in this thread somewhere. Most importantly, the capitalization has absolutely no benefit and way too many drawbacks. Not a single reply in this thread addressed the issue at point. People are just defensive, because that's what they are used to, and don't like it being called stupid (even though no one can say it isn't). PS: It's not the hyperbole that is being downvoted either. People are touchy every time I bring this up.
- nickpp 9y agoIt makes sense: every time you tax or regulate something - you get less of that. Every time you sponsor/deregulate something - you get more of it. Applies to innovation too, and to California.
- CPLX 9y agoIndeed. This is easily proven by comparing Colorado, which has extensive regulation of ski resorts, with Bermuda, which doesn't have any.
- jaclaz 9y agoIf I may this strikes me as "odd": >Nobody wants to wake up to an autonomous vehicle crashing through their roof, but it's possible to prevent that without driving companies overseas. Requiring passenger services to secure a hefty amount of insurance is one approach—strict regulations would exist, but would be drafted by insurers. Unless I am missing something, that would not avoid the drone/whatever to crash through one's roof, maybe the insurance will add a further layer of safety precautions, and the damages would be covered but initially doing flying tests and testing service where there are less roofs/people seems to me like a very good idea.
- alistairSH 9y agoThe implication is required insurance forces drone operators to be careful where/when they deploy their drones, for fear of increased premiums/dropped coverage. Similar to automotive safety features. Extra air-bags or ABS systems reduce accident, lowering premiums, driving demand for those features.
- jaclaz 9y ago>The implication is required insurance forces drone operators to be careful where/when they deploy their drones, for fear of increased premiums/dropped coverage. >Similar to automotive safety features. Extra air-bags or ABS systems reduce accident, lowering premiums, driving demand for those features. Sure, I understand that, but it's not the same thing. An extra air bag still doesn't prevent at all the crash (it may minimize fatalities and reduce injuries of the people inside the car). An ABS system may - in some cases - i.e. as an example on slippery roads, prevent incidents. If a car swerves and hits a cyclist the airbags and ABS won't do anything (for the cyclist), and having a separate, protected cycle lanes (not allowing cars were cyclists are) or not allowing cyclists on trafficked high speed roads seems to me anyway a good idea. An insurance - as said - may increase safety requirements, and each added safety requirement may (or may not) contribute to less crashes, but it's not like it will directly prevent incidents, that is what sounded "odd" to me.
- mbrameld 9y ago
- bayesian_horse 9y agoThat's my main issue with "drones will solve everything". Basically the things still can crash on your head. The flying taxi is even worse, being able to wipe out a small building when falling from very high. The type of aircraft - essentially an electrical multicopter - is so new, that you would have to fear some failures in testing.
- OliverJones 9y agoElectricity costs probably are no factor in test location choice. It looks like each kWh of electricity costs about NZ$0.29, which is US$0.21. But, I wonder what the energy cost / carbon footprint is for such flying devices? Risk management has to be part of the choice of test location. The US is lawsuit-happy compared to other jurisdictions. And, the sponsor of this project has what lawyers like to call "deep pockets."
- jlebrech 9y agowouldn't the country's scenery (elevation etc) help with the demand, it's also slightly horseshoe shaped and narrow, so could accommodate flying transport to the sides, and it being narrow means you can't have much road traffic. there's a bit of a bottleneck getting from the south island to the north island. but maybe i've underestimated the size of the country.
- 7952 9y agoDoes anyone know how they are going to maintain seperation from other aircraft?
- ekianjo 9y agoNot flying at the same altitude?