14 ms·
Gaijin Engineer in Tokyo
- tecleandor 9y agoFunny thing, although the PDCA process is always popularly related to the Toyota Production System, apparently it was created by Deming, "father of modern quality control", who divulgated it through Japan. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDCA https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDCA
- erikb 9y agoReminds me of the more military OODA loop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OODA_loop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OODA_loop
- gramie 9y agoAnd before Deming, there was Sarasohn (http://honoringhomer.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/cringely.pdf http://honoringhomer.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/cringely...). In fact, Sarasohn recommended Deming for the job.
- fiblye 9y agoIt's really hard to overstate just how bloated emails are in Japanese. They seem to follow a very strict script. Once you learn the key words, it's easy to write and understand, but it's so much fluff for so little meaning. I've gotten dozens of lines from single emails just asking me about confirming a skype interview date, while any normal English message would literally be no more than, "Sure, let's talk at X:XX PM. Contact us beforehand if you have any troubles."
- avar 9y agoCompanies do this via E-Mail? Where I work you send someone a Google Calendar invite and they click "yes" or "no", and they can see if you have a free spot in your schedule beforehand, so it rarely goes wrong.
- striking 9y agoGoogle Calendar invites are still transferred over email, generally.
- avar 9y agoSure, but the transport part isn't relevant to what the GP is mentioning, which is that apparently Japanese etiquette requires you to write some amazingly long E-Mail. With a calendar invite all that's abstracted away and you just get "can you make it at such-and-such date at such-and-such time? yes/no/maybe".
- oliverlundquist 9y agoI've been living and working in Japan for 10+ years and totally know that feeling .. I even wrote an article about it: https://getworkjapan.com/2018/02/26/why-are-japanese-business-mails-so-long/ https://getworkjapan.com/2018/02/26/why-are-japanese-busines...
- Erlangolem 9y agoIt doesn’t necessarily make anything easier that the natural default of courtesy in Japan is, when in doubt, “maximum formality is employed.” To be honest though, I prefer the sometimes confusing formality of Japan to the curtness (or downright rudeness) of the US. Especially when it comes to customer service, the people pumping your gas in Japan are more friendly and polite than most waiters in Michelin starred restaurants in the US.
- chrischen 9y agoYea there’s a weird disjointness where customer service or service industry workers can be relatively rude or arrogant in person, but online you get the super courteous maximally formal (although usually templated) emails.
- humanrebar 9y agoFor what it's worth, people tend to be more courteous in smaller and more rural areas of the U.S.
- markbnj 9y agoTend? Perhaps. I've lived, worked and traveled all over the U.S. The smallest town I lived in was Sherwood, Maryland (population 44 at the time), and I now live an hour outside NYC. It really totally depends on the person you're interacting with, their personality, the kind of day they're having, the days they had before that. Culture certainly determines a lot of it, but that is harder to reduce to small town/big town dynamics. In America some of our most densely populated places (i.e. New Jersey) have some of the lowest rates of depression and suicide. People may appear to be ruder to each other in those places, or not, but something about the proximity of so many other humans creates some sort of social behavioral order that allows them to get along. People are strange, is really the tl;dr.
- chrischen 9y agoI read his sample bloated email and found it interesting that they are writing it in the exact same way a (US) business would write a customer service email.
- farnsworthy 9y agoAgreed, it's a simple, polite request to a business partner. George says: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usN3rpfFoGA&t=30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usN3rpfFoGA&t=30s
- sirn 9y agoThere are also small details that you will learn the first time doing it wrong. For example, when contacting with someone outside of the company, you would NEVER refer to anyone in the same company as you with -san honorific (Mr./Ms.) via email even in maximum formality mode, e.g. "I'll forward this to Tanaka-san, head of sales" may be considered rude. Instead, you will have to skip -san, as in "I'll forward this to Tanaka, head of sales." These small details are so subtle and there's a lot of them. Many people don't really mind if you use it wrong, but some do, so you have to always be cautious with.
- CydeWeys 9y agoInteresting rule. Do you know why that is? Is there some implied level of familiarity with coworkers?
- sirn 9y agoIIRC from what my senior explained to me few years ago, this has to do with the inward and outward aspect of the Japanese business society and the Japanese language itself. The Japanese honorific is usually used from inward to the outward (e.g. to stranger, customer, partner, etc.) I think the easiest way to think might be that you won't refer to your sister/brother with honorifics when talking about them with someone. When you (an outsider) email a company, everyone in the company who replied to the email are considered belonging to the same group, so they should not use honorifics to refer to themselves regardless whether they are CEO or just random employee (even if you call them with honorifics in internal email.) There's also another small rule regarding this, such as you can say something like "Uchida, the CEO" (CEOの内田) but NOT "CEO Uchida" (内田CEO) because the title in the latter is being used as a suffix, and considered a honorific (equivalent to -san). It's a weird rule.
- rangibaby 9y agoTalking about your own “team” honorably (-san) is not humble. To be fair Japanese people have trouble with it all the time too; There are tons of results for on Google for phrase + polite or phrase + business
- 9y ago
- ilamont 9y agoI consulted for a Vietnamese tech company some years ago and was surprised to see that most internal emails among top management (most of whom had attended university overseas) were in English, rather than Vietnamese. The reason? Written Vietnamese is too formal, and they prefer English for getting to the point quickly.
- freddie_mercury 9y agoI find this explanation for their choice hard to believe. I live in Vietnam, speak Vietnamese, and see millions of people post not-formal, to-the-point things on Facebook and Instagram every day.
- dfcowell 9y agoOh, don't be daft. You're comparing the way people act and speak on Facebook with how they are expected to act in a formal setting such as work? Totally different ball game.
- wink 9y agoMaybe I should rethink how informal I speak at work. Or how formal I speak to my friends. I absolutely think there are people where there's a huge gap and others where it's hardly noticeable ;)
- coconut_crab 9y agoI'm Vietnamese, some of us prefer English as it lack the formality for pronouns, those who have studied oversea are even more likely to use English in their daily conversation. (interestingly, my friends point out that I seem to have different personality when using English instead of my mother language)
- samastur 9y agoI am a native Slovenian speaker who speaks a bunch of different languages to varying degrees of "speak". I definitely feel each of them changes my personality somewhat in its own way. I assume part of it is due the language used and part due to cultural traits you pick up when you learned it. Would be surprised if there was no feedback loop between language and cultures that use it.
- chiph 9y agoI've noticed their thing about paper before. Oddly, it was in videos of Japanese offices during earthquakes, where my concern was that people were going to get hurt by all the falling binders and documents that were coming off the bookcases.
- erikb 9y agoI don't know why this is always made a topic, but I never felt offended by "gaijin" or the Chinese counterpart "laowai". No big deal. However I also don't think that "they don't think it's offensive" has any relevance. Some people think the N-word is not offensive. It still is. Some men don't think calling a female colleague "babe" is offensive. It still is.
- laurieg 9y agoI spent a year abroad studying in Japan with a group of 10 westerners. At the beginning of the year some people were apprehensive when they learned about the word 'gaijin'. By the end of the year every member of the group used 'gaijin' in their regular conversation. This was far outside of Tokyo and seeing a 'gaijin' was a genuinely rare occurrence. More than anything the word seems to fit a real communicative need. "I had an interaction with someone that was different from the norm because they did not look Japanese" is quite a mouthful and invoking the word 'gaijin' starts to happen quite naturally. My biggest problem with the word is that it is used sloppily. It conflates race, culture, language and nationality and assumes a kind of all or nothing approach to them. My black student who was born and raised in Japan fulfilled 3 out of those 4 categories but would be considered gaijin everywhere he went.
- sangnoir 9y ago> My biggest problem with the word is that it is used sloppily. It conflates race, culture, language and nationality and assumes a kind of all or nothing approach to them Westerners are no better - the US does the same for everyone who is not "default" (i.e. white) where they are differentiated by a prefix, usually their heritage, which conflates "culture, language and nationality". Your black Japanese student would be considered "African American", which is beyond absurd.
- lmm 9y ago> Westerners are no better - the US does the same for everyone who is not "default" (i.e. white) where they are differentiated by a prefix, usually their heritage, which conflates "culture, language and nationality". Your black Japanese student would be considered "African American", which is beyond absurd. Isn't that the grandparent's whole point - that we at least have distinct categories for "whatever-american" and "foreigner", where "gaijin" conflates both and others.
- dreit1 9y agoYou’ve reminded me of the horrors of “keep, problem, try” Let’s discuss this every week, and then not take any actual action
- skizm 9y agoAre mechanical keyboards frowned upon in the silent open offices of Japan?
- williamdclt 9y agoI would frown upon it in our not-silent-at-all open space, so I suppose yes. No idea what the reaction would be though!
- twic 9y agoThey're frowned on in my full-of-banter-and-music office in London. When i arrived, i asked for a specific new keyboard, and the IT guy, thinking it was a loud mechanical one, said i would have to get permission from my manager before he'd order it!
- raverbashing 9y agoDon't, unless you want to drive your colleagues crazy
- wst_ 9y agoI've never saw cherry blue switches in the office but browns, blacks and reds are common. While switches themselves don't give loud feedback, keys hitting the keyboard frame are loud enough. No one makes a fuss about it. Not to mention that not all open space offices are that silent. Mine isn't. Not that everyone is listening to a music but chatter can be heard all around.
- arctice 9y agoBit off-topic but I don't think the "Cultural Differences" dismissals are unique to Japan; One of my friends from the US will often try to explain disagreements away with "must be different over there" and other similar statements. It's endlessly infuriating.
- subway 9y agoIn the US, that roughly translates to "I'm tired of this conversation; go away".
- humanrebar 9y agoDepends. It could be, "let's agree to disagree and still be congenial."
- singlow 9y agoApart from the specific Japanese language specifics, I didn't read anything that I wouldn't expect in more than half of the American companies that I encounter outside of SV. There may be differences in how prevalent these things are, but I can't really use this account to draw conclusions about that.
- obblekk 9y agoThis is excellent. I would love to read one written from the same outsider (gaijin?) perspective about Silicon Valley.
- jimmaswell 9y agoYou wouldn't be seen as a "perpetual foreigner" (gaijin) like that, and American culture is much more lenient on foreigners carrying along their old customs compared to in Japan. Overall I'd expect an easier time, particularly in that it's always achievable to be seen as American (more in some areas than others, especially SV, not to say the US doesn't have any problems with discrimination), but in Japan a foreigner or even foreign-looking native is never truly accepted as Japanese, as pointed out here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16612178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16612178
- dahdum 9y agoSV is segregated based on class far more than race or ethnicity. Not all of America is lenient, but more so than any other country I’m aware of (though Canada seems close), anyone can become accepted as a citizen.
- twic 9y agoThe closest thing that springs to mind is https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2017/11/western-elite-chinese-perspective/ https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2017/11/western-elite-chi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coconut_crab 9y agoI noticed something similar in my company: - Meeting, a lot of meeting, on average 2 hours a day. - Scrum is also meeting heavy, for a 5 days Sprint, the first 3 days is to write the document, splitting tasks into smaller subtasks (so that anyone can code for it), the rest 2 days are for actual coding. - It's very hard to track responsibility due to 'group think' - HoRenSo. - Disputes aren't resolved completely but just shoved under the rug. The one who tries to pursue it will be alienated. They have a proverb: "The nails that stick out shall be hammered". - A lot of engineers don't have formal computer education. But they make up for that by putting a lot of effort in learning how to code, so they can catch up with their peer in one or two years. For example, one programmer was working as a system admin for 2 years, and before that she studied marketing in university. - Community events are mostly for middle aged people, not students or young one. Overall I think it's interesting to work in a Japanese company, there are a lot to learn from them. EDIT: Format
- bamboozled 9y agoHad the same experiences in western corporations. I think people like the idea that this is all a Japanese phenomenon. The majority of “engineers” I’ve worked with (including the best) don’t have computer science degrees.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoYou’re Not From Here You are a foreigner. You were a foreigner before you arrived, you are a foreigner while you are in Japan, and when Japanese go abroad they will still refer to you as a foreigner, ironies be damned. This cannot be understated and will be a recurring theme in the stories to come. Never forget, you’re a foreigner. They won’t ever forget. Well, I experience exactly the same situation and I'm a Greek living and working in the UK, so it's not something that's particular to the Japanese. It seems a sizeable chunk of most people you'll meet when you live abroad will be constitutionally unable to let go of the fact that you didn't grow up within the same national borders as each other.
- pryelluw 9y agoI am an American born and raised in Puerto Rico living in Georgia. I am treated as an immigrant every day. You will be treated differently everywhere if you are even a bit different. Such is humanity.
- m_fayer 9y agoI'm an American with mediocre German living in Berlin, I've been here for a decade. I don't feel like a foreigner whatsoever. My social circle is 70% German and the rest is a mix of nationalities. I would absolutely feel like a foreigner in any other city in Germany, but not here. If being a "foreigner" disturbs you significantly, like it did me when I lived in Vienna, I would say moving is worth it. There aren't many cities where there is no such thing as a "foreigner", but they do exist and are not exactly mysteries.
- baursak 9y agoI'm confused, why is Berlin unlike any other city in Germany in this regard? E.g. what would be different in Frankfurt?
- aaronblohowiak 9y agoBerlin is more like Brooklyn than the hamptons... different notions of what is considered “belongs here” mediated by history and local culture.
- maxxxxx 9y agoDoes Japan still have the crazy working hours they were famous for?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- candybar 9y agoAlmost everything under "real cultural differences" seems to describe culture as it exists in corporate America as well. Edit: even some of the other stuff seems to be more about tech vs non-tech, as opposed to Japan vs US.
- iamaziz 9y agoAlthough this blog post is about work in Japan and its "foreigner" consequences. In my opinion, this writing explains exactly why the USA is the best place for work, and perhaps the most welcoming environment for foreigners.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- meganibla 9y agoAren’t some of these things actually good? Preserving social harmony. Lean into it more. It’s a job it doesn’t matter so much. Adapt yourself to these values and enjoy your time more. Being in another culture you get the chance to do things their way so try it. Give you a chance to maybe see that the things you think are so important don’t actually matter. Maybe you can have a better time and enjoy your life more if you just go along with the way that everyone does them there. Power harassment. Stop being such a savior and assuming that your morals are better. Open your eyes and see what’s good and see how things got together.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoYou managed to be vastly more condescending than the author. Every culture has its strengths and weaknesses, noticing and commenting on them is fine.
- erric 9y ago>The thinking goes, if everyone is involved in the decision-making process, then when something inevitably goes wrong, there’s no individual person to blame! Problem solved. This is _exactly_ how life in the US Govt. IT sectors go.
- mitchell_h 9y agoA co-worker gave me a great phrase for this: Fix the blame. I've run into a bunch of companies that spend far more time fixing the blame, then actually fixing the problem. Good luck with that business model.
- erric 9y agoMost of the 13 year experiences I have there can be summed up as: if it isn’t broke, fix it until it is.
- MacroChip 9y agoMister Wainzinger, Sorry to ask for your time, but if it is possible for you to let me know, I would love to read about a Japanese engineer living in the US. Are you aware of any related articles or response articles on this topic? I understand that it may be an inconvenience to tell me about these articles, but your cooperation is greatly appreciated in this matter. Apologies and thanks, Thien, Chip
- schoen 9y agoI don't think you'll get a reply to this because this article wasn't posted to Hacker News by its original author, and I don't think the original author is participating in this comment thread at all. You might want to find a different way of contacting the author.
- Zircom 9y agoI don't blame him for trying, the number of times I've seen someone pop into the comments of a submission saying "Hi I'm ________ and I wrote/made/did/worked on this" is pretty high on this website.
- viraptor 9y agoI'm 99% sure it was a joke, written in the style described in the article.
- schoen 9y agoCould be! Poe's Law has come up pretty often on Hacker News recently; maybe I'm the latest "victim". :-)
- twosheep 9y agoIt appears to be a reference to the part of the column discussing trouble crafting emails.
- vogt 9y agoNice article. In my experience, the "Real Cultural Differences" section sounded like every enterprise company I've interacted with in the US.
- grose 9y agoI think you should try working at a smaller company. I've also been an engineer in Japan for a while and found startups a lot easier to deal with than mid-sized or larger companies. For example, you almost never have to send e-mails because everything is over Slack and surprisingly casual. Working with other teams is easy because there are only a small amount of engineers and everyone knows each other. Google Docs instead of Excel so you don't have to worry about SHIFT-JIS. Go somewhere without middle management where you work directly under the CTO or at most one other guy and you'll see less meetings. Of course, you'll still see some of the classic Japanese bureaucracy, but nothing compared to the bigger places. My main gripe with Japanese companies is that they simply don't pay as well as American ones do.
- GuiA 9y ago> My main gripe with Japanese companies is that they simply don't pay as well as American ones do. Fair, but Tokyo can be much, much cheaper than SF or NYC (in my personal experience, rent alone is up to a 2-3x difference. Same with dining out - a 1500¥ dinner easily runs you $30-40 with tip in SF).
- desu_ 9y agoI think the implication is that Japanese companies in Japan pay generally less than American companies in Japan, which seems true at least when comparing Japanese and American big names. It's also the case outside engineering/tech. It's fairly common knowledge among Japanese workers and foreign residents living in Japan. One hypothesis (which I like) is that Japanese companies offer a higher non-monetary compensation (I am not talking about flex-time).
- GuiA 9y agoOh I see. I didn’t get the “American companies in japan” subtext. Yes, that makes sense.
- toephu2 9y ago>> Do they have X in gaikoku? (you’ll be amazed what people will ask about, I was once asked if gargles exist in gaikoku) What are 'gargles'?
- checkroth 9y agoI think he's referring to gargling. I've gotten the same question. I've also gotten "How many colors does a rainbow have in your country?" which is just beyond me
- 205guy 9y agoPerception, or rather expression of color is cultural, so that question is quite astute. https://www.sapiens.org/language/color-perception/ https://www.sapiens.org/language/color-perception/ Similarly, when my cousin from Ohio asked if the French people I was visiting in the winter celebrated Chrsitmas, it was ignorance, but a well-intentioned question none-the-less.
- gldev 9y agoThis holds true for Japanese companies outside Japan, my wife was working as a developer for TOTO Mexico and they had a lot of personnel rotation because of these differences, mainly the meeting culture, it would often get in the way of the work and people ended up quitting or getting fired. It was however a good experience because of the high quality and standards it kept up with the product.
- bamboozled 9y agoTL;DR “I moved overseas it was sometimes frustrating, challenging and different” Having lived and worked overseas myself in European country none of this persons experience comes as a surprise honestly.
- bitL 9y agoOnce you reach certain good level of Japanese mastery, suddenly those phrases and behaviors you considered very polite and which deeply impressed you, turn out to be jokes, fun Japanese had with you. Or talk to Japanese escapees to Europe that work for non-Japanese companies and hence can have some life for an explanation.
- GuiA 9y agoGot a design meeting? Print high-quality printouts of the mockup for every person in the room. Then mark them up with pens, make the changes digitally, and reprint everything and repeat. I work in a design studio in Silicon Valley. We do this, and it is extremely common in any design studio. Essentially, there is simply no digital device that matches the ease of annotation, the resolution, and the size compared to printing on a 11x17 piece of paper. You can put them up on the wall for everybody to see, and have a 10 meter wall covered in comps if that's what you need... impossible to do with any digital tool.
- jrockway 9y agoI think people put too much meaning in Japanese set phrases, imagining them to have their literal meaning when that is not what they actually mean. The author provides this transcript: Me: This is clearly broken! Tanaka: Yes, you’re right. M: Shouldn’t we do something about this? T: Nothing can be done. M: This is easily patchable! T: I’m sorry. M: Who’s responsible for this code? T: Team X. M: Somebody on our team should talk to them. T: Yes, you’re right. M: Well, can I talk to them? T: Ah, it’s not impossible. M: Does that mean I can? T: Who knows. M: … I've had this conversation in English with American coworkers more times than I can remember: A: This is clearly broken! B: Yeah.... A: Shouldn't we do something about this? B: It's not a priority. A: This is easily patchable! B: I have to work on Project X now, they've been bugging me about it for months and their manager is getting mad at _me_ now. A: Who's responsible for this code? B: Team X. A: Somebody on our team should talk to them. B: I already have 8 meetings this week, I don't have time. A: Can I talk to them? B: They never answer my email. A: I'll email them. B: Good luck! It all boils down to the same issue: the person you're conversing with doesn't consider the matter as urgent as you. The words used are different but the message is the same: "meh". This isn't a Japanese thing or an American thing... it's a people thing. And honestly, a lot of times, they're right.
- eyrarric 9y agoGreat novel (and movie) about cultural misunderstandings in Japan from prolific author Amélie Nothomb. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_and_Trembling_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear_and_Trembling_(novel)
- hardwaresofton 9y agoA little late, but I think one of the most important distinctions between "otherness" in a place like Tokyo versus a place like the US is the fact that you can "become" an American in at least one sense if not completely, but you can basically never be Japanese in almost any sense. It's always felt that America is the kind of place that once you've put in your 6 years (I think it's 6 now) on the way to citizenship (or however you get your citizenship), and are sworn in/become a citizen, the next person that implies you're un-american you're free to punch in the face (most of the time not not literally). People may imply it, but the way the country is built/the culture is structured is at least supposed to imply that once you choose to join "Team America" so-to-speak, you're a team-member and that's that. America struggles with the divisions and history between the cultures/races within it, but I think that's natural, sometimes healthy, and to some degree inevitable -- there's no way you're going to have lots of cultures mix without conflict/racism. So if you start with the preconception that friction is a 100% certainty, the question is whether you can see it, and whether the culture is one where you can freely discuss it or not. Japan on the other hand, is like 95%+ Japanese last I checked -- there just isn't enough mixing at any sort of scale to widen the idea of what a Japanese person is, and much of the segregation is intentional (which is fine by me). Even Japanese people who go abroad for a long time as children and return are treated differently, and have to be careful when re-entering society, there just isn't any hope of melting into the society in any reasonable sense for someone who is in actuality 100% gaijin (and looks nothing like a japanese person). While I haven't lived in the UK, I imagine it's the same, they seem to have a melting pot culture very similar to the US in this sense, in some ways they seem even better mixed than the US -- I feel like I see less overt racism there. I don't think this phenomenon is limited to Japan of course, just happens to be on topic right now -- I imagine being a white person in Nigeria or some other prosperous African country would be a somewhat similar situation as far as otherness goes.
- Jerry64545 9y ago> You are a foreigner This is a big pro than a con. You can really think and act on your own with out bothering too much thinking about society pressure. One can act independently in a manner which is not possible within the society he was brought up.