16 ms·
US utilities have finally realized electric cars may save them
- chapill 9y agoNot if those cars are going to be largely powered by home solar.
- pixl97 9y agoYa, I wouldnt worry about that for a long time.
- maliker 9y agoA lot of the charging will happen at homes at night, so until energy storage doesn’t add 200% to the cost to take a solar install to solar + storage, the utilities are still going to be the power providers. There are also going to be (hopefully) some low cost utility scale storage options that, along with the 50% cost advantage of utility solar over rooftop, could be combined with the existing distribution infrastructure to provide low-cost and low-carbon energy for transportation.
- meric 9y agoIt's a reasonable idea if car batteries become easily swappable.
- xyzzyz 9y agoNot likely any time soon. There's absolutely no way humans are going to pull >1000 lbs worth of batteries out of the car every day, and put the same >1000 lbs worth of batteries into it. With a unit of work of 50 lbs (reasonable for fit people), and a minute to pull out each pack, stow it away, take fresh pack and put it back in, it would take half an hour of hard physical work every day. No way regular people are going to do that.
- adrianN 9y agoYou don't put gas in your tank with a laddle, why wouldn't you use a machine to swap batteries?
- ddnb 9y agoOfcourse this would be automated, you don't see a person hauling jerrycans to fill up his car in gasstations do you?
- xyzzyz 9y agoI definitely carry jerry cans when I want to fill up my vehicles at home, which is the context we are in — we were talking about home rooftop solar installation, and how it can or cannot be used to charge cars overnight.
- maliker 9y agoSwapping does solve the charging time problem. There was a pretty big effort to build out a swapping network, but it ran in to business issues: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company)
- 6d6b73 9y agoMost electric cars won't need to be charged from empty to full everyday.. If someone drives just few miles a day, they will be able to either do trickle charging with solar panels, or do full charge on weekends where the car is mostly sitting idle. And if you're traveling on weekends, you will use superchargers, which might be powered by solar.
- maliker 9y agoCan’t forget the potential load from those kitty hawk autonomous electric helicopter/planes. https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/03/12/business/dealbook/flying-taxis-larry-page.html?referer=https://www.google.com/ https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/03/12/business/dealbook/flyi...
- spchampion2 9y agoA few years ago I was working with a custom builder on a house plan (that we didn't end up pursuing), but one of the things I suggested was future proofing the garage for electric cars. Given that a Tesla can charge on 80 amps, it seemed reasonable that a two car garage in a custom home should have 160 amp service. It may not useful right away, but it would very probably be useful over the life of a home. He thought I was crazy, and maybe I was. But articles like this make me wonder.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI would suggest 200A service as a bare minimum, with 400A being ideal (this will be heavily dependent on your electric utility service entrance). Consider two EVs, HVAC loads, and possibly electric water heaters, clothes dryers, and a stove. Also, NEC 80% derating (100A circuit required for an 80A 100% duty cycle load). The electrician's time is the most expensive part; oversize for decisions such as these (load center, EV run to outlet, subpanels, etc).
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoAfter putting up panels at my relatively modest house, I’m honestly surprised at the kind of juice I can produce. I’m ready to convert everything I have to electricity
- toomuchtodo 9y agoIf you didn't put a battery in at install time, there's a recent IRS determination suggesting [1] you can still receive the 30% tax credit if the battery is installed at a later date. I would highly recommend pulling the trigger right before the tax credit begins its phase out at the end of 2019, assuming costs come down further between now and then. The caveat is that your system must charge the battery from your panels, and cannot charge from the utility (trivial inverter setting). With that said, based on net metering laws in most locales, it behooves you to consume as much of your own production as possible. Exceptions abound. https://www.reddit.com/r/energy/comments/82fchy/irs_letter_on_home_batteries_could_open/ https://www.reddit.com/r/energy/comments/82fchy/irs_letter_o...
- noobermin 9y agoAm I the only one who finds this whole logic upsetting? We're on the verge of a mass species extinction event and with the news that efficient electronics are in fact using less energy is somehow bad news. The profit motive doesn't work for utilities...well it does most of the time, but this is a clear example of when it doesn't.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoNot upsetting. It interesting, really. Finding ways to economically rationalize good climate behavior. You no longer need to ask people to install renewables to save the planet; it just makes plain economic sense [1] [2]. Utilities need electrical usage growth to offset consumption stagnation (and occasionally, structural and energy efficiency declines). That growth will occur moving ground transportation off of oil. If that creates an unexpected coalition, why not roll with it? It'll increase the EV uptake rate, it'll ensure transmission infrastructure still sees necessary upgrades and investment, and because vehicle charging can be structured around time of day metering, they're a perfect mix for more renewables being added to the grid. EDIT: OP I replied to should not be downvoted. The situation really is dire [3]. At our current renewables deployment rate, it will take 400 years to swap out all fossil fuel generation; we can and must do better, but we're going to have to properly incentivize action and rapidly increase the replacement rate of fossil fuel generation. [1] https://i.imgur.com/FCYT1xa.jpg https://i.imgur.com/FCYT1xa.jpg [2] https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-2017/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-... [3] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/610457/at-this-rate-its-going-to-take-nearly-400-years-to-transform-the-energy-system/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/610457/at-this-rate-its-g...
- noobermin 9y agoThe thing that drives climate change is the burning of fossil fuels needed produce electricity in the first place. Keeping the rate of electric production constant will not help us. The fact that electric energy usage is dropping is a good thing and we should keep a negative derivative, not increase it! There needs to be a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, keeping it constant (or even worse, increasing it) will not help this. I really think everyone needs to take a step back from the HN ideology and think this through. Here climate change has a chance to essentially kill our grand children or at the very least leave them with a much more barren of a planet and a life. But somehow, the issue of a single institution's profit is somehow more important than actual people, children. The free market is a tool, it shouldn't be more important than human lives.
- justonepost 9y agoI laughed long and hard when I read this. You never really know who your friends and enemies are.
- inteleng 9y agoThanks for telling us.
- justonepost 9y agoOk, fair point. Sometimes though you have to take a step back and appreciate the wonderful complexity of the universe. So long have we railed against utilities for their environmental destruction - when it looks like they might be the actual solution for what we face. It really makes you question all of your assumptions about what you know and the people who you think might be working against you. Maybe there is some way they can work with you.
- loeg 9y ago@dang: Article title is now "may save them," not "will save them."
- John_KZ 9y agoUS utilities don't need saving. It seems like a bizzare statement to make. The reason behind the slow growth in electricity demand is the high price dictated by environmental politics. Also having such a high burst in demand will be a major problem, not a benefit. Maybe we need to account for grid expansion, peak demand management and production capacity increase costs in a new bill of EV taxes. Arguing that it's good for the economy because of jobs is the same like arguing war is good for the economy because you get to rebuild infrastructure. It's not, we can use this potential for more useful things.
- sauwan 9y ago>The reason behind the slow growth in electricity demand is the high price dictated by environmental politics. That seems like a pretty dubious claim. For one thing, how often do you (or any home or business owner) not turn stuff on because of how much it might cost them? For another, the largest driver in my understanding is growing energy efficiency (e.g. LED's use fractions of the old incandescent bulbs)
- John_KZ 9y agoEnergy efficiency has been a big factor, but an even bigger one is the energy-intensive heavy industry fleeing from the developed world to china and other places where power is cheap and plenty. Countries like Germany that kept their industry at home face extraorbitant prices. I think they pay close to 30+cents/kWh.
- blattimwind 9y agoResidential power is more expensive (per kWh) than industrial power, which might also be subsidised depending on industry — likely the same for most western countries. Half of the residential price is a good approximation for Germany.
- beiller 9y agoThis is maybe off topic, but it also may pave the way for us to use nuclear energy to produce electricity without greenhouse emissions. I think the problem we have yet to solve with nuclear, is safety diligence. Maybe some automation can help with modern tech? Or maybe with efficient manufacturing like 3d printing, we could tear them down and rebuild them each year?
- wongarsu 9y agoIn the case of the Three Miles Island Accident, modern sensors and more automation would have helped. With Fukushima, automation wouldn't have helped, what they were lacking was better tsunami protection, more resistant construction, bigger battery backups. At Tschernobyl they had an inherently unsafe reactor type, operated the reactor outside the safety parameters and had safety systems deactivated. Not much you can do about that. Automation would help, but more modern reactor designs that are less prone to causing problems likely have a much bigger impact. >Or maybe with efficient manufacturing like 3d printing, we could tear them down and rebuild them each year? Tearing nuclear reactors down on regular basis sounds like a much worse nuclear waste problem than the power production already is. All the stuff that would be interesting to tear down and rebuild is contaminated from radiation exposure.
- blattimwind 9y ago> With Fukushima, The main issue with Fukushima and other Japanese nuclear plants is Japanese regulation enforcing 1960s nuclear safety.
- olivermarks 9y agoFrom repoweramerica.org in 2009 "The Problem: The US electricity transmission and distribution system – or ‘grid’ -- is in critical need of an upgrade. It is old, balkanized and too limited in its reach. The current grid is a series of independently operating regional grids – it can’t meet the needs of a nation whose economy would benefit substantially from the system optimization that comes with national interconnection. Its limitations and vulnerability to failure are also reported to cost the nation $80 billion to $188 billion per year in losses due to grid-related power outages and power quality issues.1 And most critical to clean energy development, areas rich in renewable resources like solar, wind and geothermal are currently not well-served and thus have no ‘highway’ available to move power outputs to the markets where that power is needed" I wrote a post on ZDnet http://www.zdnet.com/article/al-gores-unified-smart-grid-vision-for-repowering-the-usa-will-it-happen/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/al-gores-unified-smart-grid-vis... discussing efforts for a unified grid, but haven't seen much progress since then to support the demands of electric vehicles.
- themihai 9y agoIsn't the energy getting cheaper due the advances in regenerable sources? This can't be good for utilities.
- IpV8 9y agoWhy not? Utilities make money by power transmission. Even if every single house in the US has solar panels there still is a massive market around transferring power between houses to balance loads and time of use issues. In my direct and relevant experience talking with r&d folks and strategic planners at big utilities, they treat cheaper utilities as another market to get in to. They don't think of it as a threat to their business.
- miketery 9y agoI'm not following. Let's say current transmission and generation is the baseline. In the future when there is distributed generation, transmission is definitely going to go down as generation will be tightly coupled with supplying private, commercial, or industrial entities (eg panels on the roof). So generation goes down (since more renewable), and distribution as well on average (due to coupling mechanisms).