19 ms·
It's sort of sad to read a story about a story, and not be able to figure out which problems were created in the source vs. the retelling. Mashable: "Right now
by CharlesW 9y ago
It's sort of sad to read a story about a story, and not be able to figure out which problems were created in the source vs. the retelling.
Mashable: "Right now, it looks like Siri won't be blown up and a [sp] rebuilt". Yeah, well, that'd most likely be a huge mistake[1] depending on your definition of "blown up" and "rebuilt", and also Siri's already been rebuilt twice.[2]
The Information: "One of Apple’s original plans was to launch its speaker without Siri included, according to a source." Of course — there are always contingency plans. To me, this is a much more damning comment about the Siri team than Apple's "vision".
[1] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-never-do-part-i/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-...
[2] Mesosphere blog post, definitely reviewed and approved by Apple: http://archive.is/YNMLh http://archive.is/YNMLh
- flounder3 9y agoRegarding [1], the move to Mesos was not a rewrite. Some core components had to be improved, but [2] was primarily an infrastructure upgrade that happened to make Siri considerably faster by ditching hypervisors. It was a massive feat that was accomplished by relatively few engineers. There were always many components under review for reengineering; keep in mind that Siri was released before WebSockets was a thing, let alone RFC. The snowball effect of Siri's failures originated from iOS Program Management pushing us to expand into as many other languages as soon as possible from the beginning, thus diverting resources from implementing or polishing original "Siri, Inc." features and various "nice to have" improvements to en-US usage. Source: I worked on Siri from the moment it was acquired, and no longer work at Apple. Richard Williamson's recent comments are pathetic.
- MBCook 9y agoI always wondered how much of a toll Apple’s multilingual support was compared to the small number that Google and Amazon have.
- refulgentis 9y agoGoogle supports all of the same languages as Siri, and also supports Brazilian Portuguese. Amazon supports 2 languages
- jacksmith21006 9y agoPlus is actually far more functional in the languages compare to Siri.
- jd20 9y agoYeah, claiming that moving to Mesos was rebuilding Siri is stretching it a bit. The beauty of the Mesos transition was that most services needed only minor modifications to be moved to the new scheduler, and still get the benefits of better resource utilization. Regarding building a speaker without Siri, the origin story I read from Bloomberg was that the idea of a great-sounding speaker that would adapt to room acoustics was dreamed up by Mac audio engineers, before Echo was even announced, so a speaker with a smart assistant built-in probably wasn't even on their radar at that point. I didn't necessarily interpret it as a lack of faith in the Siri team to deliver.