23 ms·
Ok, this is the money line in that press release for me: “The charges against Theranos, Holmes, and Balwani make clear that there is no exemption from the anti
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Ok, this is the money line in that press release for me:
“The charges against Theranos, Holmes, and Balwani make clear that there is no exemption from the anti-fraud provisions of the federal securities laws simply because a company is non-public, development-stage, or the subject of exuberant media attention.”
For all those entrepreneurs are trying to "fake it until you make it" be aware that the SEC considers your strategy both fraudulent and they feel they have the jurisdiction to prosecute you. And while I doubt the SEC is going to go after every CEO that raised a Series A on a pitch deck that was pure fantasy, the people who participated in the round might bring them in if it served their purposes.
- minimaxir 9y agoIt's worth nothing that one of Theranos's VC funders, Tim Draper, did defend Holmes despite the fraud allegations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973102 https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/theranos-investor-claims-theres-a-conspiracy-to-take-down-elizabeth-holmes https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/theranos-investor-cl...
- devy 9y agoSomeone called Tim Draper the Trump of Venture Capital[1] :) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973420
- Coding_Cat 9y agoTim Draper also stands to gain from Theranos being reviewed positively, valid product or not, being an investor.
- minimaxir 9y agoThat's true, which just compounds the problem of newbie investors thinking "fake it until you make it" is OK because they get positive reinforcement from their investors.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pinewurst 9y agoAlso Dan Warmenhoven, speaking for the board. Re a previous Holmes forfeiture: "Warmenhoven added Ms. Holmes showed “a level of selflessness and grace reflecting her commitment to the company’s success.”
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoThat's extremely interesting, thanks for sharing. Think about the decision that he had to make in 2016. He had to choose between admiting his mistake and doubling down. The downside of admitting his mistake is that he's guaranteed to get negative points; the upside is that it will minimise futures downsides. By dubling down, he's guaranteed to reduce his negative points in 2016 but exposes himself to magnified upsides (if he's proven right) and downsides (if he's proven wrong) in the future. Now think rationally how you'd choose. The second strategy is a lot riskier so it better have better return as well! But the second strategy can only have higher reward if you either believe high probability of future upsides (i.e. Theranos might be faking till you make it, but they'll make it) or low probability of future downsides (i.e. I'm not sure what's going on, but definitely not fraud). I submit that the only way that you could come to believe either is if you're hugely misinformed about the company. I.e. that guy is just a bit incompetent.
- taurath 9y agoMy understanding is that competence only matters when other people are giving you money, and doesn't matter at all when you're giving people money. I think you're really overestimating the downsides.
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoReputation is everything in this business. I think you're underestimating the downsides.
- taurath 9y agoEvery VC has 100s of failures. He just proved that he will go to bat for his startups even if they're doing fishy stuff :P
- nradov 9y agoThose kind of decisions are made on a purely emotional, reactive basis without going through the rational game theory analysis you laid out. Most wealthy investors are no more rational than the rest of us.
- mathattack 9y agoCould this be due to the litigation?
- jonmc12 9y agohttps://www.axios.com/tim-draper-keeps-defending-theranos-1513299953-eadf43f6-1803-422c-8869-f55d86844d6b.html https://www.axios.com/tim-draper-keeps-defending-theranos-15... "Venture capitalist Tim Draper, an old family friend of Theranos founder and CEO Elizabeth Holmes, who led an early $1 million investment into the company (split between two investment firms).."
- Noughmad 9y agoSV/tech/USA is so great, anyone can make it big. You just have to be smart and work hard. Oh, and be family friends with billionaires. Yeah, that's all.
- ericd 9y agoThat's one way to get funding, but it's certainly not the only way, there are lots of counterexamples. As one obvious counterexample, one of the founding principles of YC is providing an open application process to provide people who don't have any personal connections access to the SV network. Larry and Sergey weren't well connected when they started, either, afaik, as most PhD students aren't. If you're doing something interesting that seems likely to succeed, and you're motivated, it's not all that hard to become connected to wealthy people who are very interested in turning their money into more money. This is an incredibly defeatist/self pitying line of thinking that I'm seeing more of (the world is stacked against me, you have to be born into it, etc) and is related to a lot of other self-defeating thought patterns. It's not going to help you or anyone else who subscribes to it. Maybe it's just that bad news is much easier to see, thanks to the web, so people think bad behavior is more common now, and it's turning people cynical.
- joering2 9y ago> Larry and Sergey weren't well connected when they started, either, afaik, as most PhD students aren't. Doubt it. I don't think In-Q-Tel/CIA will write you a check because you just happen to have this shiny new search engine that may or may not change the world.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AlexCoventry 9y agoHe's also stuck by Tezos through its organizational catastrophe, and it's looking as though that might pay off for him. Generally, "they're family" sounds like a sensible default attitude for a VC towards their investments.
- burner5692 9y agoThe more SEC oversteps their boundaries, the less anyone will take them seriously.
- sctb 9y agoCould you please start commenting substantively? Many of your recent posts have the effect of trolling, whether that was your intention or not. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- asperous 9y agoI think there is a significant difference between lying about what you can do (fraud) and simply saying you hope to accomplish something.
- rabidonrails 9y agoAgreed. Here's the support to you: The complaints further charge that Theranos, Holmes, and Balwani claimed that Theranos’ products were deployed by the U.S. Department of Defense on the battlefield in Afghanistan and on medevac helicopters...[i]n truth, Theranos’ technology was never deployed by the U.S. Department of Defense...
- leroy_masochist 9y agoRight, but that doesn't mean that fraud can't happen with very early stage companies....there are plenty of b2b SaaS startups out there who are raising on non-GAAP metrics like "bookings" and who are grossly inflating both the certainty and pro forma value of these projected numbers.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI don't disagree, but recognize that an investor can feel defrauded even when one can show precisely what was said and what was not actually said. Most CEOs I've heard pitch are creating a narrative and they leave out facts that would disagree with that narrative. And sometimes they state the 'facts' in a way that imply more than they actually say. For example, you can say "We are building a tester that can run tests using only a drop of blood." and "We have test results from blood showing markers" and never mention that the "test results" came from an industry tester and not the "tester you are building". The implication is that your tester did that but you didn't actually say that. What I read from the press release was that this sort of messaging was going to be actionable. If you look at various full disclosure rules the SEC has for public companies, this felt like a shot across the bow to startups that they would do well to think about that instead of glossing over bad news.
- prostoalex 9y agoI interpreted it somewhat differently. The money paragraph seems to be > claimed that Theranos’ products were deployed by the U.S. Department of Defense on the battlefield in Afghanistan and on medevac helicopters and that the company would generate more than $100 million in revenue in 2014. In truth, Theranos’ technology was never deployed by the U.S. Department of Defense and generated a little more than $100,000 in revenue from operations in 2014. This was not even a forward-looking statement, it was an outright lie in the legal document. One can do pretty much whatever they wish with accredited investors' money, but it has to be disclosed in the PPM. Even if you have a line item where all the money will be spend on CEO's dog's private jet travel, accredited investors who have reviewed and signed the PPM have no legal recourse. In Theranos case it looks like a straightforward misrepresentation of facts, which is a red flag for SEC.
- fragsworth 9y agoWhat does "PPM" stand for?
- calbear81 9y agoPrivate Placement Memorandum - http://www.capitalfundlaw.com/blog/2015/04/05/whats-in-a-private-placement-memorandum http://www.capitalfundlaw.com/blog/2015/04/05/whats-in-a-pri...
- BillTheBiker 9y ago"Private Placement Memorandum" - first result on googling 'investor PPM'
- x0x0 9y agoprobably private placement memorandum
- neurotech1 9y agoPrivate Placement Memorandum https://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/offeringmemorandum.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/offeringmemorandum.asp
- deleted 9y ago
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoLets not pretend that everyone isn't just following the leaders here with grandiose messaging. Major tech corporations have done this as much as small startups. IBM's Watson comes immediately to mind. The difference is whether or not you can come through with some percentage of your promises. The ones who can eek out some kind of repeatable traction long enough to exit are successes, the ones who never get to scale are frauds.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> IBM's Watson comes immediately to mind. All of the industry AI labs follow the same pattern, even (perhaps especially) the en vogue ones (well, I guess depending on wtf "solve intelligence" is supposed to mean...). Watson is just old enough that it's now obvious the advertising agency was given too much leash. Ditto for self-driving. Ditto, in fact, for basically any basic or applied research happening in the research arm of any for-profit organization. And at a lot of universities besides! In fact, as far as I can tell, positive PR is some non-trivial aspect of the ROI for industry research labs. BUT... there's a HUGE GAAP ( ;-) ) between marketing hype and lying in financial disclosures. One is eye-rolly and should be called out on internet message boards and during sales pitches. The other is criminal.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNo, Theranos outright committed fraud. They did things like used test results from some other kind of blood test to "prove" their test worked. That isn't "We are on shaky ground with new, unproven tech." That's "We know it doesn't work. We are comfortable lying about it because money."
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAgreed, but that's not what Chuck was talking about which is the "fake it till you make it" attitude/messaging.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SilasX 9y ago>For all those entrepreneurs are trying to "fake it until you make it" be aware that the SEC considers your strategy both fraudulent and they feel they have the jurisdiction to prosecute you. Holmes was, in many ways, embodying that HN mentality, acting on the basis: - that an entire industry has been doing it wrong - that it can be fixed by a low-bureaucracy, Angel-funded startup - that once you have enough success you can just rewrite the laws that were slowing you down - that no one knows what they're doing anyway, major projects are 100% guesswork, and you should just "fake it till you make it" - that any skill is just a matter of 10,000 hours of practice - that you can outsmart an industry before even passing or placing out of sophomore level classes - that any self-doubt must be Impostor Syndrome, and so it's not worth your time to even check if that doubt has a factual basis Yes, I've posted this twice before but I'm citing it and admitting to it, and it got heavily upvoted both times (thanks to Algolia for making comments so easily searchable btw): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12071172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12071172
- aerovistae 9y agogood thing you told us it was heavily upvoted before, now i know to upvote it this time too
- fwdpropaganda 9y ago- dropping out is a positive thing (the implication being that education is either a scam or for dumb people, not smart people like us)
- padobson 9y agoThis feels more like an over-correction to the prevailing cultural wisdom that everyone needs a post-secondary education. Contrary thesis to the prevailing wisdom is where a lot of startup fortunes have been made. Hopefully we're about to land in a cultural place where getting an education is seen as getting an education, rather than either a panacea for individual success or a complete waste of time/money for the docile masses.
- 9y ago
- walrus01 9y ago"fake it till you make it" is one thing if your product is a new dating app to compete with grindr, or a clone of flappy bird... entirely another thing if you're making tangible claims about the ability of a medical device.
- matte_black 9y agoI’m glad, and frankly I’m tired of all these “fake it till you make it”, “lean” startup, wizard of oz type companies polluting people’s attention with fake or half baked product offerings for shit that doesn’t exist just so they can get a signal to see if something is really worth doing or not. Consumer hostile.
- abalone 9y ago"Fake it til you make it" generally refers to acting like you believe in yourself even if you're filled with self-doubt. Not actual fraud.
- matte_black 9y agoYou can believe in yourself without faking anything, and it’s healthy to do so. Faking it implies you want to give others the impression you’re already a big shot, and it dilutes out the accomplishments of people who actually made it. The downside should be that if you’re faking it and you don’t make it, your shame should be relentless and brutal, and no one should ever take you seriously again. Also, even if you make it you will feel alone and empty in your success, because everyone will have long thought you already “made it” and you have to continue hiding your true story. There is no one to celebrate with except those who are also in on it. Where as if you would have just been humble and true to where you currently are, people have headroom to express sympathy and support should you encounter a setback.
- gowld 9y agoaphorisms have established common meanings: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fake_it_till_you_make_it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fake_it_till_you_make_it
- matte_black 9y agomeanings are not immutable
- heavenlyblue 9y agoNo, you just don’t want to admit that you don’t really know the generally-agreed meaning of that phrase.
- mnemonicsloth 9y ago> You can believe in yourself without faking anything... I don't think so. Self-doubt is natural. Mandatory, really. Someone who never has moments of self-doubt is a bad investment risk; it means they probably aren't thinking hard enough about what could go wrong. But concealing those doubts is also mandatory: if you can't, it may be a sign that you have more problems than you know how to deal with.
- mbell 9y ago"fake it until you make it" generally refers to the product implementation vs pitch on the consumer side. e.g. You pitch "The best automated way to do X!", but in actuality you have a horde of people doing the work initially to figure out the problem before building the actual automation. There is nothing wrong with this and remains a completely viable approach. What you don't do is tell your investors you've already built the automation tech and hide the labor cost of doing it manually in your financials.
- wpietri 9y agoI think the Concierge and Wizard of Oz approaches [1] are just one thing people mean by "fake it 'til you make it", but I definitely don't think they're the most common meaning. Startups engage in all sorts of puffery, trying to project the appearance of success long before they have actual success. Fancy websites, fancy offices, sales and investment pitches that cherry pick stories, numbers, and milestones that give an enormously positive impression of what's generally a very bumpy reality. I personally don't like that, but the game is the game. But it's very easy for that puffery to slide over into outright fraud when things get desperate. Which is why I'm so glad that the SEC is going after Theranos with great vigor. Hopefully these clowns will end up sharing a cell with Shkreli, giving every would-be startup CEO a clear example of what happens when they push it too far. [1] https://www.allencheng.com/concierge-mvp/ https://www.allencheng.com/concierge-mvp/
- sgt101 9y agoThis is fine when the elements of automation aren't beyond the state of the art. However when you have startups like Spinvox et-al hoping that automated transcription will show up and save them (I mean transcription of variety of voice in variety of environments, using uncharacterized microphones and transcoded from mobile to core ect) or the current rash of chatbot liars and charlatans then real real damage gets done to real companies where execs believe the trendy w*nkers vs real people who understand technology. I've seen good engineers hounded out and scores of millions of pounds wasted because of "warp drive over powerpoint" and I've had enough. Not that I'm bitter or anything.
- tzhenghao 9y agoDon't get me started on the whole ICO, crypto hype. Responsible optimism and execution is key to a company's success. Disregard this, and you'll face consequences like these.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- x0x0 9y agoThe last para is even crazier. > Ms. Holmes and Balwani falsely claimed to investors [...] and that Theranos would generate more than $100 million in revenues in 2014, the SEC said in its complaints. In fact, the company’s revenues were a little more than $100,000 that year. I couldn't figure out why investors were putting all that money in. Telling them you were making $100m makes the investments make a hell of a lot more sense. What's 3 orders of magnitude between friends? She deserves prison time for this.
- arbuge 9y agoIt really depends on whether the intent to defraud was there or not. The SEC is probably not out to outlaw founders being true believers in their vision, even if their beliefs are often misguided. On the other hand, if there is solid proof that founders knew their vision had no hope of succeeding but presented it as though it did, that could and should be a problem.
- otakucode 9y agoWell, 'prosecute'... no one is going to jail. White collar crime is normalized and expected in upper class circles. A single case like this is a drop in the bucket. While certainly not a majority, there are absolutely people in this world that believe if someone will not come to you and put a gun to your head, back you into a cage, and lock you in it, then whatever they are doing is fair game. If people really wanted to stop them, they'd take it that far. So they see any other standard as frivolous and silly to pay attention to. Ethics? What ethics?
- warmcat 9y agoAlso, "fake it until you make it" might work for photo sharing apps and such but it should never be the case when human health is involved. Holmes and people around her were no other than quacks who promised the world to whoever they met.
- ransom1538 9y ago"For all those entrepreneurs are trying to "fake it until you make it" be aware that the SEC considers your strategy both fraudulent " Sigh. The SEC is concerned with lying about actual numbers. Not about future projections. What a terrible comment on a startup forum. "Fake it until you make it" it as about having confidence -- not about lying to investors. Please downvote this parent comment.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe SEC is concerned with lying about actual numbers. Not about future projections. Our experiences are different I suspect, Check this out https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-regfdhtm.html https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-regfdhtm.html. I sat in the courtroom once as one of the officers of a company was being prosecuted for violating this disclosure rule. There are a number of regulations that the SEC enforces that have nothing to do with "actual numbers" and everything to do with information asymmetry where the company knows something and the investors don't. They have historically been all about that when non-accredited investors are involved (aka public companies). And reading their action with respect to Theranos suggested to me that they are going to bring that hammer into the startup space.
- LukaAl 9y ago> Our experiences are different I suspect, Check this out https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-regfdhtm.html https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-regfdhtm.html. What this has to do with the parent comment? I'm asking these because I'm not sure I follow the reasoning. Your concern is that the SEC has very strict reporting standards and regulations. These are intended to provide a fair field between all investors (accredited and non-accredited) in order for the market to function in a more efficient way. In exchange for this increased cost of regulation upfront, the transaction between investors on the company's shares have a much lower friction (and transaction costs). Private companies have lower regulation because the assumption is that the investors willing to buy shares are open to assume higher transaction costs in terms of due diligence. Obviously, reporting the false could open the company to lawsuits, but that's also part of the potential cost for the investors. The choice between being a public company and a private one, in the end, is a function also of this trade-off. If I understand your reasoning, you fear that the SEC forcing himself into the private market could increase the regulatory cost of all startup. Am I right? If that is correct, my answer would be that the SEC is not imposing the full regulation but just a minimum level of accurate reporting on behalf of the investors. This is because there's an assumption that a well behaved private market is essential to make the economy more active (imagine if this level of lying was accepted, how many investors would be willing to invest?). On the other side, I see the risk of a slippery slope and having the SEC power to grow to large and kill the startup ecosystems. I don't have a clear answer for that.
- happertiger 9y agoThese are desperately embattled claims at scale. If you lie to the SEC and you are an ass to the government they will crush you. Oldest story in the valley, and certainly beyond... another tale of hubris that ends in classic tragedy.