9 ms·
So we've gone from IRC which worked perfectly fine to a billion dollar business just to port that software back to the terminal, where we started out to begin w
by Barrin92 9y ago
So we've gone from IRC which worked perfectly fine to a billion dollar business just to port that software back to the terminal, where we started out to begin with
I don't understand this world any more
- brandonmenc 9y agoWell then everyone should feel stupid for not realizing you could make a billion dollars creating a sane sign-up and account management system for IRC.
- Siecje 9y agoI wouldn't call it sane. Why do I have to sign up for different Slack organizations and have a different password for each one? Why can't I private message someone on Slack with just a username? I think Discord does this much better.
- aviv 9y agoI'm guessing because of deep technical debt from some very early decisions made.
- DividableMiddle 9y agoI would assume so as well. Maybe a Slack engineer can chime in?
- aviv 9y agoI got downvoted, I think one of them chimed in.
- kainosnoema 9y agoYes. As of a couple years ago at least, Slack was a monolithic PHP app that could support a few thousand users in a single team. Each “workspace” was assigned to a server and scaled vertically. LinkedIn notoriously had two Slack workspaces in order to support all of their users, and I’m guessing other large companies have had to do the same. I’m sure Slack is using their vast resources and large team to solve these problems at this point, but it probably hasn’t been easy to create a horizontally scalable system from the early codebase, especially when the data model was designed for a single team of users.
- mudetroit 9y agoSo, I preface this by saying that I do feel like Slack could have better authentication mechanisms, decoupling the account from the networks. But I do think that some of this is by design as well. I think it is worthwhile to think of each Slack organization as a completely independent and isolated network. This is one way that they can reasonably give some security to their corporate customers. I don't believe that there is any intention to ever lat you send a blind message to someone on another Slack organization, but maybe I am wrong there. It would absolutely be nice however for me, as a user who is in multiple organizations, to be able to log in one time and have all of them be connected.
- ergothus 9y agoI'm in multiple organizations, but some are against different email accounts, some use an external SSO and some don't. Were Slack to give a single login I would probably NOT be able to connect to the multiple workspaces I do now, which is a major benefit to me.
- ivm 9y agoDiscord also has amazing performance. I guess it's because gamers would be mad for something like Slack eating up all the computer's resources.
- Karunamon 9y ago...and push notifications, and offline message history, and a mobile client, and services that aren't hacky god-clients, and content storage, and previews/inlining, and.... About the only thing IRC has going for it is decentralization, and that's not very valuable in the market it seems. Seriously. IRC has had 30 years to get with the times. It's stagnated and been lapped by its competitors, and the efforts to improve it didn't properly start until Slack and friends simultaneously re-cooked and ate everyone's lunch and dinner.
- ranza 9y agosooo convor/grove? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grove.io https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grove.io
- pimeys 9y ago> push notifications, and offline message history, and a mobile client https://irccloud.com https://irccloud.com has all these, done really well. Offline message history you get also by running a server somewhere and just having an irssi in a screen/tmux. Still my favorite protocol and I have some channels that I consider to be my favorite social network for about 10-15 years already.
- always_good 9y agoI pay for irccloud, but most people don't. It's annoying trying to talk to someone who disconnects when they shut their laptop and will never receive your message. Not very good tooling to build a community or relationships, that's for sure. Having to pay for basic features that competitors like slack/discord have is exactly why the slack community for something is often much bigger these days. Even the larger communities like #node.js are really just 10 regulars. For example, Elm's slack is vibrant. Elm's IRC channel is dead. This is the reality for most communities I've been joining these days.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoGreat point. You can add these features for yourself with IRC, but Slack guarantees that the other party also has those features.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoAlso , infinite scroll back , a standard set of easy to use clients, hosted services and API integrations.
- kqr 9y agoI fail to see how those things should be part of the protocol. That's like complaining HTTP doesn't support tags for your bookmarks. It's so out of scope. Unless, of course, you are talking about a user-friendly service offering IRC access to those who do not want to set up their own clients. So, something like IRCCloud, which does exist, fyi.
- aidenn0 9y agoInfinite scrollback is only possible with support from the protocol: if you assume that partitions happen between two servers or between the client and the server, then the client will not be able to see every message that happens so cannot provide the scrollback.
- rspeer 9y agoOkay. So why isn't IRCCloud better than Slack?
- zitterbewegung 9y agoI can’t convince my colleagues to use IRCCloud at least people will put up with using slack. Rocketchat has much more feature parity to slack tbh. Comparing slack to IRC isn’t really fair even though they do the same thing. I have used irc and slack and slack’s ease of use is its asset. I used freenode in high school and college to teach myself scheme. The barrier to entry is not something that can be explained as just use IRC.
- bphogan 9y agoDisagree about barrier to entry. I run an office hours chat for my online classes powered by IRC. I use KiwiIRC as the front-end. Students need only the web address of the web page I want them to go to. When they get there, they need only a username. No signup, no verification, none of that. They're online, getting help in seconds. Individual public channels requiring nickserv registration and all that? that's another story. But seriously - the barrier to entry to get started is this: https://kiwiirc.com/client/irc.freenode.net/?##irc_can_be_easy https://kiwiirc.com/client/irc.freenode.net/?##irc_can_be_ea...
- Viper007Bond 9y agoYou can actually connect to Slack via IRC: https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/201727913-Connect-to-Slack-over-IRC-and-XMPP https://get.slack.help/hc/en-us/articles/201727913-Connect-t...
- guessmyname 9y agoUnless your employer decided to disable that option because an upper manager didn't like the idea for reasons that I don't even understand. It's even more difficult when you are part of a corporation with thousands of employees that are in favor of using Slack over IRC.
- diaz 9y agoA colleague of mine uses through irc gateway but tells me a lot of stuff is not supported well like threads (which some people unfortunately started using more) and that you can't see edits, which many people also do. I think attachments and files are also a problem. And slack is complete garbage that is pushed and we as employees most of the time have no other options. Besides the whole problems mostly talked about related to memory and cpu usage, the one nobody seems to check or understand is that it is completely frustrating and unusable from accessibility point of view. I've seen this first hand as that person above is blind and the slack application is of one the worst offenders there is regarding this point. I've seen and felt his frustration and how slack team manages to avoid his point all the time. So I hope it dies out eventually :D
- typon 9y agoOh c'mon. Slack absolutely destroys IRC in terms of usability. And that's what ends up counting in the end.
- tachyoff 9y agoWhich usability features are they? The 3 GB of RAM usage, the battery-draining, or the culture of “always-on” availability and interruptions?
- Karunamon 9y agoYour failure to set your coworker's expectations for your availability or the failures of organizational culture being projected onto the messaging tool are not the fault of the messaging tool.
- drb91 9y agoThis ignores the fact that if you don’t respond to people contacting you you’ll get fired. As a salary you have no voice. The market simply optimizes for whatever is easiest for a ceo to install and maintain.
- Karunamon 9y agoHow is this Slack's fault, again? Or is the argument that messaging systems should be hard to install so they aren't misused? Seriously, what even is this comment chain getting at? If you work somewhere where always-on is a hard requirement, it doesn't matter what messaging system is used. Any place that would fire you for muting notifications would just as easily fire you for turning off email notifications. In short: Let's stop blaming the damn tool for something that is the fault of the humans using it.
- gsich 9y agoProbably because Slack makes it easier to establish an "always-on" culture.
- chubot 9y agoI love using Unix and the terminal, but I hate using IRC. I don't think it works "perfectly fine". I have been lurking on a few IRC channels due to my work on http://www.oilshell.org/ http://www.oilshell.org/ . Problems I noticed: - The lack of conversations/threading is really annoying. Most worthwhile IRC channels have more than one conversation going on at once. Not only do you have to untangle who's talking to who, there's no way to know where the beginning of a conversation is. I have to read messages backward to find the beginning . - By default there seems to be a lot of leave/join spam. I used IRC for a year before turning this off and it vastly improved my experience. - I think most clients don't save anything by default. When I reboot my computer and don't log in again, I miss messages. - Having to use pastebins for code is annoying. I'm sure that someone will respond with how you can solve all these problems with a certain IRC client. But I don't want to do that. I'm not technically unsophisticated -- I write software in 5+ languages and I know all about Unix and networking. I just don't want to spend my mental energy on my chat client -- I have tons of other projects to spend it on. So I only use IRC when necessary; I use e-mail otherwise (through GMail.) Of course, I also don't use Slack. But from what I hear it solves some of these problems.
- jaytaylor 9y agoUnsolicited feedback for you @chubot, in case you're open to it: Clicking through to oilshell - I wanted to know what is different and exciting about it, but all I found was text saying it's "new". Making the value proposition clearer would go a long way and be a big help to people who are curious and geniunely want to understand what's amazing about your creation.. !
- chubot 9y agoThanks for the feedback. I thought I had solved that with the "Why a New Unix Shell?" link at the very top, but I understand you still have to read a bunch of text to answer your questions. My main goal right is to have sophisticated users try it and give bug reports. It's not ready for people to use as their daily shell (and that isn't even the primary purpose of the project. As explained in the FAQ, I'm focused on shell as a programming language first.) Some people have tried it and reported bugs, but I could use more reports. So I suppose I could try to sell it a little more and maybe get more feedback. But overall I feel like it's gotten a lot of feedback and attention. I'll think about whether it makes sense to "sell it" more. The other thing I would like is to attract experienced developers who have implemented VMs and programming languages. Most of those people are working on their own projects. But I think many of them understand my project and half of the blog posts are aimed at that audience.
- guessmyname 9y agoI created my own Terminal client to communicate with Slack [1]. I did it because I like IRC, but my employer (and many of my co-workers) love Slack. I dislike Slack, having the option to connect to an IRC gateway (unless your employer disabled this option) or to communicate with their API service with a program like this one (linked above) or mine (linked below) is good for people who still need to communicate with their peers but want to do so through the program that they are more comfortable with, in this case, the Terminal. [1] https://github.com/cixtor/slackapi https://github.com/cixtor/slackapi
- vlunkr 9y agoThis is for the people who want to use IRC but work somewhere that requires Slack. Obligatory relevant XKCD https://xkcd.com/1782/ https://xkcd.com/1782/
- tachyoff 9y agoEverything old is new again. ;) Okay, that’s a bit flippant. Obviously Slack isn’t IRC (with several major differences), but I think as far as communicating with your coworkers goes, they both accomplish the task. It’s just a matter of how much you want to spend.
- wmeredith 9y agoTeach my CEO, Design Director, and EVP of Sales to use this terminal slack client and you’ll understand.
- tomc1985 9y agoI have arrived at the mindset that if you are in a technology company than all these people need to be technically-oriented as well. Failure to perform these fundamental tasks should be grounds for coaching or discipline.
- lasereyes136 9y agoSlack is a billion dollar company because they made IRC accessible to the non-technical people. Technical people write a terminal client for it because they like being in a CLI for reasons. Making a popular service look and feel like the older service that inspired it is completely reasonable. Different people, different needs, different drivers. Just don't expect the actions and motivations of different groups of people to align with each other. Sure as a while it doesn't seem to make sense but each individual part is reasonable on it's own. There must be a powerful German word for things systems that look crazy at the macro level but are reasonable at the micro level.
- astronautjones 9y agoVenture capital