11 ms·
A Simulated Stable Planetary System with 416 Planets in the Habitable Zone
- COil 9y agoThat's a lot of eclipses no?
- loxs 9y agoAnd a lot of collisions, resulting in formation of bigger planets.
- HorizonXP 9y agoOr maybe a white sky and hard rain scenario.
- hetman 9y agoNone of the other orbits will be close enough to noticeably obscure the central star. The only eclipses worth considering would be from the binary planet's twin.
- unit91 9y ago> This system is completely stable—I double-checked with computer simulations. I would think that's a hilarious joke if the author didn't seem so serious.
- d33 9y agoI assume you're alluding to N-body problem? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_problem
- jdc0589 9y agothat....and the assumption that general idea that we know everything we know to engineer a stable solar system with 416 plants is kind of hilarious.
- unit91 9y agoExactly
- Parcissons 9y agoMy assumption is that this simulation did for example not contian liquid planetary cores- who if repeatetly beeing subject to gravity fluctuations - would start to resonate- basically resulting in a sort of lava tide to shake the planets apart over time.
- marcosdumay 9y agoI assume he is alluding to how a simulation of finite precision can not prove anything about a chaotic system. And yes, that the N-body problem is chaotic.
- tgb 9y agoI believe you're underestimating the state-of-the-art. See [1], for example, which claims a method for saying that a sufficiently good numerical solution implies an exact periodic solution close by. (I doubt that the author of the original article did anything like this.) [1] http://ww2.ii.uj.edu.pl/~kapela/papers/nosym.pdf http://ww2.ii.uj.edu.pl/~kapela/papers/nosym.pdf
- saalweachter 9y agoWell, that's the question - is his 416-planet system chaotic? Do perturbtions get amplified or do they get pushed back to the stable configuration? Of course, when you're talking about a civilization building 416 equal-mass planets equally spaced in 8 counter-rotating orbits, worrying about how stable they are is kind of silly; as long as they're "mostly" stable the maintenance of monitoring and tweaking their orbits for a billion years would presumably both be feasible and cheap compared to the initial construction.
- marcosdumay 9y agoOrbits on a N-body system are chaotic if N > 2. Always. That said, the longer you simulate those orbits, the more certainty you have that they are stable. But you will never get a mathematical proof, because only symbolic math can ever prove things in a chaotic system, finite precision math can only deal with statistic degrees of certainty.
- keymone 9y agothere's nothing that prevents nbody to be solvable with certain starting conditions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_problem#n-body_choreography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N-body_problem#n-body_choreogr...
- d33 9y ago...as long as nothing hits the system, right? I don't know much about astrophysics, but this sounds logical: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14767295 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14767295
- keymone 9y ago2+2 is also not 4 when you change the base assumptions drastically. obviously if another star smashes into planetary system - it won't survive, at least not in original form.
- ithinkso 9y agoThe point is, if you perturb it by a small enough epsilon will it go back to the initial configuration or fall apart? Pencil standing on its tip kind of a deal.
- keymone 9y agoin nbody terms - that is an additional condition so the problem would have to be solved separately. ask the author, i'm just a lurker here.
- mabbo 9y agoI think the problem gets into some chaos theory, the kind you see in weather prediction. When the forecast says "60% chance of showers tomorrow", what he really means is that they ran a few billion simulations of the environment with very tiny perturbations of the initial conditions and in 60% of those simulations, it rained. In 40%, it didn't. Tiny little changes in any variable in a chaotic system will, in the long run, lead to huge variations in outcomes. This system with it's 416 planets has one outcome- perfect orbits constantly. But if you add a single 1 kg asteroid to the system, that would perturb everything ever so slightly. That slight change could result in the entire system chaotically coming apart from stability.
- archgoon 9y agoTo the point, it's unknown if our current solar system is stable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stability_of_the_Solar_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stability_of_the_Solar_System https://www.ias.edu/ideas/2011/tremaine-solar-system https://www.ias.edu/ideas/2011/tremaine-solar-system
- dsr_ 9y agoStability is an unobtainable goal if you don't put a particular timespan on it. 5-6 billion years is probably just fine.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoSounds fair. Outside perturbations are probably likely in that timeframe.
- yummybear 9y agoUntil an extra solar asteroid entered the system and wiped out 200 civilizations, and sent the rest hurdling into intergalactic space.
- odabaxok 9y agoPrevious submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14764125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14764125 (91 points, 32 comments)
- mihai_maruseac 9y agoIt's the same article, same content, same title, but different publication date.
- linuxguy2 9y agoI thought I had seen this before.... Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14764125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14764125 It even links to the same site and the blog was posted by the same guy. I wonder why he's recycling content.
- NietTim 9y agoHe posts a lot of content, possibly he just forgot he posted again
- hobofan 9y agoThe financial situation of Nautilus is not the best[0] which might explain why they recycle content. [0]: https://nautil.us/blog/a-letter-from-the-publisher-of-nautilus https://nautil.us/blog/a-letter-from-the-publisher-of-nautil...
- spennant 9y agoWake the Magratheans.
- jmts 9y agoI for one was expecting the author to be Slartibartfast.
- tartuffe78 9y agoWould make for an interesting sky
- exelius 9y agoYeah but now connect them all with space elevators.
- blunte 9y agospace catapults, good aim, good timing. (and lots of pillows)
- bmcusick 9y agoAlthough obviously ridiculous in many ways, the ability to design large stable systems is relevant for when thinking about the question "How many O'Neil cylinders can we build in the habitable zone?". If we mine the asteroids, Mars, and Mercury for materials we can build habitable surface areas that are in aggregate many times greater than Earth in size. Each carbon fiber Bishop Ring could have an internal surface area the size of India. This simulation reminds us that space is really, really big, and really, really empty. If you can fit 416 planets, just think how many space stations you can fit.
- adrianN 9y agoSpace stations can probably also adjust their orbits a bit, so it doesn't have to be stable forever.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoWith simple electromagnetic tethers! Drop a cable toward the sun, run a current through it and gain impulse from the ambient magnetic field. Or does this only work near a planet?
- clavalle 9y agoIt would work (maybe) but the generated current would be about 50,000 times weaker than it would be using the Earth's magnetic field...at least at the distance of Earth from the Sun.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoMaybe its still workable - the impulse to keep station at that distance would be smaller too?
- clavalle 9y agoYeah. The main problem with keeping a space station at a stable orbit above Earth is friction with the atmosphere. There might be small adjustments that need to be made where Earth's atmosphere is almost completely negligible but there are fewer forces degrading the orbit and there's no immediate threat of crashing into a planet if the adjustments aren't made in time.
- tardo99 9y agoCouldn't you fit in more if you didn't assume all planets orbit in the same plane?
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoA planet cannonballing through the plane is generally very disruptive, giving anything they pass near an impulse normal to their orbit and eventually making the whole thing wobble like a plate on a circus clowns finger
- 0xfeba 9y agoI want to see that simulation.
- sys13 9y agoMakes me think about Firefly with "dozens of planets and hundreds of moons".
- Casseres 9y agoReading the article, I imagined what the people (?) on those planets must think when they discover they're not alone. Let's say we discover we are not alone. We know those aliens must not be from our galaxy, so do we push for development of faster-than-light travel? If so, why? Intelectual curiousity, defense, offense, trade, habitation? As for the hypothetical galaxy with two planets of life: Are they developing the same? If not, do they, and if so why, expand to the other? If they are, are they afraid of each other? Do they have a "cold war"? The possibilities are endless. Like Firefly, there are many posibilities for great sci-fi.
- philliphaydon 9y agoI got to the bit about 2 earths circling each other and instantly thought of the Fire/water planets that exist on the opposite side of the sun to earth which is why we didn't know they exist, from the TV show Lexx (season 4, worst season ever)
- maxxar92 9y agoCall up Isaac Arthur, I'm sure we'll have an episode on how to build this system soon.
- spacepinball 9y agoThis would be like a gigantic space pinball as soon Oumuamua showed up. Then it would just be a huge asteroid belt which would eventually form a normalized amount of planets.
- hendersoon 9y agoI imagine this sort of thing is how HN will actually look in a hundred years, if humanity survives that long.
- dmytrish 9y agoIt's hard to imagine natural formation of such a complex structure in real universe. It needs a lot of precision (interplanetary engineering?) or luck to put 416 bodies in the exact positions and velocity for the model to be stable. Another unnatural thing about this model is that adjacent orbits rotate in opposite directions: according to existing theories of formation of planetary systems, it seems impossible for the gas disk to go into different directions in layers. Anyway, this model is definitely cool (416 bodies in stable orbits!) and might be a useful blueprint for interplanetary engineering of the future.
- geuis 9y agoFrom the article: > This system is completely stable—I double-checked with computer simulations. But nature would have a tough time forming this system. If it exists, it could only have been built by a super-advanced civilization. That’s why I call it the Ultimate Engineered Solar System.
- jpfed 9y agoThe fact that it would never occur naturally makes it even more interesting. Imagine interplanetary civilizations rearranging star systems to send the unambiguous signal "1. intelligent life lives here, and 2. they are powerful enough to arrange planets, so a peaceful posture is probably advisable.".
- animal531 9y agoProbably if you're capable of capturing and moving 400+ planets into a new sun's orbit in a decent enough amount of time, then no one is going to be bothering you. But it'll send a pretty impressive message.
- tempodox 9y agoIf only one inhabitant of any of these planets so much as sneezes too hard, it will destabilize the whole system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butterfly_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butterfly_effect
- utopkara 9y agoThis points to a fundamental problem in the understanding of planetary systems. Planets do not come to being out of nothing; enourmous amounts of matter have to come together to make up a planet. Great example of experts ignoring "details" outside their expertise.
- lalaithion 9y ago"But nature would have a tough time forming this system. If it exists, it could only have been built by a super-advanced civilization."
- 120bits 9y agoThis is really nice read! I remember I visited a local Planetarium few weeks ago. They had a game where you will need to pick like 5 planets and design the solar system. It had the asteroid belt. Big planets and small ones. The game will end if the EARTH collides with any other planet and if the other planet collides you lose points. The simulation was just amazing.
- hateful 9y agoCould probably apply for a job on Magrathea.
- matte_black 9y agoWould like to see an artist rendition of this sky. Someone should make a VR app that lets you simulate the surface of any kind of planet and any kind of sky based on a solar system configuration.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoThat's ambitious! But I could definitely see being able to produce a few preset configurations. That would be easy enough (relatively speaking) to put together in Unity—maybe even with a bit of interactivity (eg. day/night cycle). Even without VR the game is a lot of fun: http://store.steampowered.com/app/230290/Universe_Sandbox/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/230290/Universe_Sandbox/ On steam there is Universe Sandbox^2 that has a VR version included. I don't think you can simulate the surface of planets, though. (I have it, but I haven't tried the VR version yet due to some persistent glitches with Oculus on many Steam apps).
- bmcusick 9y agoIt's real question how dark these planets would ever get. With 416 planets reflecting light, the closest ones would be pretty bright all the time. Maybe even visible discs from the surface, although I'm not sure. Brighter than Venus is on Earth though, and lots of them. You'd have to take that into account when doing your global warming models too.
- Retric 9y agoVenius is a long way from impacting earths climate. The scale is 2.512^(x-y). Sun −26.74, Moon −12.74 (average full moon), Venus -4.89 to −3.82. So sun is around 400,000 times as bright as the moon, and the moon is ~1500 times as bright as the Venus which is bright largely because it's so close to the sun. Mars is −2.91 at it's brightest. So 1/2 as much light as Venus because it's further from the sun even if it's closer. These might be closer than Mars, but not closer than the moon.
- bmcusick 9y agoVenus all by itself is minimal. These planets would be closer and there'd be a lot more of them. If they're supposed to be Earth-like they'd also have clouds, making them reflect more like than airless worlds like the Moon does. I bet there would be a measurable effect.
- amelius 9y agoCan't we see a simulation of this running? Also, I'm wondering about tidal forces ...
- berbec 9y agoImpressive. Pierson's Puppeteers only managed six. [1] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierson's_Puppeteers#Homeworld%E2%80%94The_Fleet_of_Worlds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierson's_Puppeteers#Homeworld...
- clort 9y agoits worth noting, that they were not orbiting a star (I don't know if that would be a positive or negative issue, for stability .. they moved away from the star to cool off)
- logfromblammo 9y agoIf I recall correctly, they were attempting to move away from the galactic core, so that they could escape some ultimate cataclysm faster than the destruction could catch up to them. Their major technological problem was rejection of waste heat.
- mfoy_ 9y agoWell, these are beasts of a different feather. These 416 aren't orbiting around each-other like in a Klemperer Rosette, they're just equally spaced out alone the same orbit around the sun. So it's a lot easier to get higher numbers. I mean, our own solar system has more planets than "Pierson's Puppeteers".
- jlebrech 9y agoGod? is this you?
- wcoenen 9y agoMakes you wonder whether the remarkable density of terrestrial planets in the TRAPPIST-1 system is the result of engineering. Maybe somebody is planning far ahead and counting on the tiny star's long lifetime (which is in the trillions of years) to keep their civilization going? On the other hand, the intense star flares and tidal locking seem very inconvenient.
- avmich 9y ago> which is in the trillions of years Is it always such a big lifetime for small stars? White dwarfs have a long lifetime, but they have interesting stories behind them; what about other types of small stars?
- wolfram74 9y agoIf I'm not mistaken, the smaller stars don't have as high a gravitational gradient and are fully convective so the helium ash and hydrogen fuel mix closer to uniformly, allowing them to burn through all of it. Stars on the scale of sol slowly build up helium until it chokes out, compresses and starts burning helium at higher temperatures, causing the rest of it to expand.
- detuur 9y agoDoes this remind anyone of the "Golden Hour" from House of Suns?
- aklemm 9y agoWho can summarize why this is interesting?
- _rpd 9y agoBecoming a Type II civilization on the Kardashev scale might involve construction of a Dyson swarm. This is a thought experiment in which each of the swarm elements is Earth sized, presumably providing near-ideal additional habitat for a larger human population.
- blackrock 9y agoIs a complete Dyson sphere even possible? Given the mineral resources available in a solar system. Say you are an advanced alien civilization. And you reach the point where you haven't nuked yourself to death, so now you can expand into space. The first thing you do is to mine all the asteroids, that hadn't coalesced into a planet. So you spend all this energy to capture them, to smelt them, and then you build out your Dyson sphere. You can achieve some coverage of the star, but is it even possible to cover the entire star with solar collecting panels, to capture all the energy output of the star? At best, I think you might be able to get a ring around the star. But even this, is dubious.
- _rpd 9y agoYou would likely need to obtain the material via ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_lifting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_lifting and possibly large scale transmutation. Disassembling the gas giants might be enough for some designs. My understanding is that it isn't physically possible to construct rigid spheres or rings in that orbit, so it would be an orbital swarm of some kind, with the elements able to actively correct for the inevitable perturbations.
- animal531 9y agoTo be fair, where did the 400+ planets come from? One must surely be able to import some material as well. Most of the mass in a generic system should be in the planets, if I remember correctly from an old article here in Sol if we scrapped all the planets we could create a 3m thick Dyson shell. But a ring should be a lot easier to construct.
- AndrewStephens 9y ago> This system is completely stable—I double-checked with computer simulations. Until some idiot on planet 297 moves his couch from one side his living room to the other. Then the whole system is going to slowly fall apart,
- catpolice 9y agoWhen I read this article initially, I got the impression that here "stable" actually means that it's not sensitive to small perturbations - the orbital pattern is a local attactor and is thus sort of "self-correcting", at least over some non-trivial timespan. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong about that (in which case this whole exercise is somewhat silly).
- ygaf 9y agoYeah I think HN forgot to be charitable today.
- personjerry 9y agoWhat's the point of this if it's impossible to arrive at?
- cmurf 9y agoEasier and cheaper than a Dyson sphere?
- hossbeast 9y agoThey're all still orbiting in a single plane. What about the z axis?
- Thoreandan 9y ago"Our moon is almost half the size of Earth" What? No, it's not.