6 ms·
Old but good HN discussion on homelessness http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=116079 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=116079 > 2) The existence of the min
by wallflower 16y ago
Old but good HN discussion on homelessness
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=116079 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=116079
> 2) The existence of the minimum wage hurts the homeless. The people I worked with were incapable of producing $6 an hour of value for an employer. If there was no minimum wage, they could work $2 an hour of value and then gradually work their way up.
- jacquesm 16y agoIt wouldn't work though. Employers would take advantage of the situation, market rates would drop to the point where the homeless person would no longer be able to create $2 of value per hour either...
- jerf 16y agoI don't think the supply of human time is that large that the market would adjust that significantly to a lower minimum wage. Lowering the minimum wage would generally raise supply of human time, yes, which drops the price, but the additional human time is by the terms of this discussion already relatively low-grade stuff. $2/hr of value is a low bar. Anyone who can't do that can't be saved by any job. Based on previous discussions, that statement covers a lot of homeless people anyhow. ISTM that the ones who would be helped by lower minimum wage are high schoolers and younger workers trying to get their first part time jobs, not the homeless.
- jacquesm 16y agoMinimum wage was created specifically to stop abuse of large numbers of people. I don't think it is realistic to expect that dropping the minimum wage will have just a beneficial effect on the few homeless people that we're talking about, it will have a huge impact on everybody that now earns minimum wage (and you'd be surprised how many people earn 'just' the minimum wage). Employers as a rule extract a multiple of value from their employees time, not just a little bit over. You could make the opposite argument: raise the minimum wage to $30 per hour. Suddenly all the homeless people are worth $7 per hour at a minimum. Free markets are rarely really free, there usually is someone that benefits from the market being free, and in the case of employer employee relationships there always is someone to be found that will do the job for less. That's why we have minimum wage.
- jerf 16y ago"Minimum wage was created specifically to stop abuse of large numbers of people." Yes, but A: goals and effects are two very different things and B: it was created in an increasingly foreign world and every year it is less obvious that the original logic holds. (I mean that in a very general sense, not in an immediate "discard minimum wage and return to a libertarian paradise" sense; as robots become more and more capable and really start eating into the low wage jobs we may have to consider things like guaranteed minimum incomes or other radical proposals.) "Employers as a rule extract a multiple of value from their employees time, not just a little bit over." In my opinion, not if you do a full accounting. Profit margins for established, successful companies in the vast majority of industries tend to run in the single digits percentages, bursting up to 10% or the low teens for some rare cases. And then there's the tech industry, which is another story altogether. It may be true in some abstract sense that companies extract multiples of value over what they pay but it isn't true in a useful sense. Generally speaking, I deny that there's a huge amount of room for people to cut minimum wages, because employers do not make radical profits on their employees. The job market isn't perfectly efficient, but it's more efficient than that. A person/task that can't justify minimum wage in the modern economy is a person not hired and a position not created, not a person generating 2$/hr of value but forcibly paid minimum wage. Now, if the economy was grotesquely inefficient and the average company made 200% profit and the only way to pry money out of their hands was with a minimum wage, I'd agree, but that's not the world we live in. It's certainly a world we hear about a lot in propaganda but it doesn't correspond to reality.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoI have to agree with jacquesm here. You're right that many homeless individuals can't produce a minimum wage's worth of value for an employer, and you're right that the requirement of a minimum wage then makes it nearly impossible for them to get work that has any chance of improving their situation. However, jacquesm is right that the minimum wage exists as a lower threshold that prevents the exploitation of workers, and that's as true today as it was in the 1920s. Reducing or abolishing the minimum wage would certainly lead to powerful economic deflation, and while that looks great on paper, in reality it leads to lots more homeless and poor people. In practice, game theory does not apply to economics as often as theorists think it does. For example, you'd think that if some employer wasn't offering a decent wage, then they'd be unable to get workers, so they're forced to maintain the same wages as everyone else. However, eventually there will be an economic depression like the one we have now, and that will result in huge numbers of able employees, and a ripe opportunity for would-be employers to exploit that situation in a way that wouldn't fix itself for decades. I am an employer. And, yes, although my margins are ridiculously thin after you count up all the money that goes in to everything, the truth still is that I do make sure I get multiples of value from my employees (or contractors); otherwise, I simply wouldn't bother having them. Homelessness and the problems of the poor are something that I think about a lot, and as I said, I have no idea what the solutions are. I do know that merely reducing or eliminating minimum wage requirements -- even only for their specific case -- is not a viable solution.
- grandalf 16y agoMinimum wage just outlaws all jobs that are worth less than $6 per hour. Suppose the unemployment rate is 5%, if minimum wage were raised, unemployment would increase. If it were lowered, unemployment would decrease. There is a widespread misperception that businesses naively overpay employees for work that is actually worth less than minimum wage. This is not the case, which is why there is litter on sidewalks and beaches (for example) and why there has been a rise in the use of robotics (mechanical car washes, street sweepers, assembly line robots, grain harvesters, etc.) Maybe in the short term some workers were overpaid, but it is generally very brief and does nothing to equip those overpaid workers for the future since industry is striving to correct the inefficiency and develop a robot, etc. I think the point you are missing is that it's not just about the wage someone is paid, it's also about the training the job provides. Minimum wage prevents people unable to add $6/hour of value from having a job at all, which makes them helpless wards of the state. Great accomplishment.
- jacquesm 16y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1644264 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1644264
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoYou're assuming that those working for $2 an hour were being paid fairly and that what they were doing wasn't worth $6. Also I've read at least 2 studies showing that min wage in the US didn't decrease employment but did increase earnings (ie people weren't sacked nor even underemployed because min wage increased).
- thaumaturgy 16y ago> ...if minimum wage were raised, unemployment would increase. If it were lowered, unemployment would decrease. And yet, there are so many stories from wait staff about how important tips are to their ability to survive. Lowering unemployment at the expense of a much larger group's ability to survive is not a good idea IMO.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ataggart 16y agoBut employers don't set the wage. If they did, then all wages would fall to the minimum wage, when in fact only 2% of the US labor force does. Why is that? Russ Roberts covers the answer better than I could: http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2005/Robertsmarkets.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2005/Robertsmarkets....
- jacquesm 16y agoBut minimum wage affects many more wages than just the minimum wage itself. It shifts the whole range to the right, with some compression at the top end.
- ataggart 16y agoYour insight is correct, but I don't think you're following it through to its conclusion. As a thought-experiment, step through the economic process that would occur in the face of increasing the minimum wage to $100. Think about how the prices would flow through the economy. Nominal wages across the spectrum would increase at various rates, leading to a general price inflation. Actual wage increases, if any, would last only until the market adjusted to the new price levels. In the meantime, the structure of the market would shift to become more capital-intensive and less labor-intensive, and would increase imports from labor-rich but capital-poor nations. Prices are information, and the market obeys. When you tell the market that labor is more expensive, it will adapt to need less labor or look for it elsewhere. It's not clear to me how such a scheme helps low-skilled workers. Now, of course no one is arguing for a $100 minimum wage, but the economic effects of a smaller minimum wage are different only in magnitude. The core flaw is not understanding that prices emerge from the market. When you try to treat them as inputs rather than outputs, you create systemic misinformation. That distortion tends to lead to misallocated resources which in turn leads to a poorer world.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoThere's been research either side of a county line in catering and related service jobs (short order, waiter, barmaid, etc.) USA indicating that min wage lead to more employment ... I couldn't find it but there's this one from 2007: "For cross-state metro counties and cross-state contiguous counties, we find strong earnings effects and no employment effects of minimum wage increases. The large negative elasticities in fixed-effects panel regressions are generated primarily by regional and local differences in employment trends that are unrelated to minimum wage policies. This point is supported by our finding that division-level placebo minimum wages are negatively associated with employment in counties with identical minimum wage profiles." Dube, Arindrajit, Lester, T. William and Reich, Michael, Minimum Wage Effects Across State Borders: Estimates Using Contiguous Counties (August 1, 2007). Institute for Research on Labor and Employment Working Paper Series No. iirwps-157-07. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1005523 http://ssrn.com/abstract=1005523
- loewenskind 16y agoAll first world countries (and probably most developing countries) have a minimum wage, yet all the "homeless person found dead from ..." are from the US. In Western Europe most of the the "homeless" I see are actually bussed in from eastern Europe to pan handle.
- WilliamLP 16y ago> If there was no minimum wage, they could work $2 an hour of value and then gradually work their way up. Wouldn't panhandling itself be far more lucrative than this? Based on walking by many beggars every day in a downtown area and seeing people giving them money, I'd estimate most of them make more than minimum wage anyway.
- cletus 16y agoThis was my question. I used to live in London and there were a lot of panhandlers there. It was clear that for some this was their job. Moreso, you just need one little old lady to give em a fiver to beat busting your hump at MacDonalds for an hour (for less, even before taxes). A lot of panhandlers were (clearly) illegal immigrants. Some had mental health problems. Whatever the reason there seemed to be a code for the homeless, like not crowding certain areas (basically "territory"). I don't know the details but from an anthropological point of view it's interesting that even the desperate, destitute, mentally ill, drug addicts and illegal immigrants seem to have an innate capacity to self-organize.