4 ms·
I have a question for Bitcoin fans. This is the opening sentence of the abstract from the original Bitcoin paper: "A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic
by wpietri 9y ago
I have a question for Bitcoin fans. This is the opening sentence of the abstract from the original Bitcoin paper:
"A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution." [1]
In the Bitcoin community is that vision basically dead? As here, all of the action seems to be through financial institutions.
[1] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- aphextron 9y ago>In the Bitcoin community is that vision basically dead? As here, all of the action seems to be through financial institutions. It's never been about the "vision" for anyone but Satoshi. It's just money. That's why this whole thing is just incredibly uninteresting IMO.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 9y agoYeah. I was originally pretty open-minded; blockchains are a cool technology, and I like to see people try out-there experiments. But for me this stuff increasingly falls into the same bucket as 3D movies/TV: lots of excitement, cool tech, and a plausible story as to why it could amazing valuable. But in practice, I've seen little value actually demonstrated, so my eyes generally glaze over at this point. That's part of why I'm curious to hear from people who were excited about the initial vision. Maybe there's a pony in there somewhere?
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoYou probably aren't the intended audience. Ask someone in Zimbabwe or Venezuela how they feel about crypto. Ask a woman in Afghanistan where all her money is considered property of men. Ask a millennial that has no other way out of the class system they were born into. Ask someone tired of governments printing money to finance wars. You'll get more positive answers.
- romanr 9y agoI don’t understand how it’s useful to poor farmer in Zimbabwe when crypto transaction takes hour and cost is equivalent to $20 which is their monthly income.
- whataretensors 9y agoThat's basically just bitcoin at this point. Lots of alternatives.
- djhartman 9y ago> Ask a woman in Afghanistan where all her money is considered property of men. Yes, clearly the solution to this problem is BTC, NOT some kind of other reform or liberalization. </s>
- kelnos 9y agoI'm not usually one to defend the parent in this kind of argument, but I think there's room for both. Social reform can take years or even decades. If Bitcoin acts as a band-aid while those reforms take their time to progress, it could be a net positive there. But I do remain skeptical that it's actually making much of a difference.
- djhartman 9y agoI agree in principle, it's just that I'm pretty sure BTC is pretty useless for the things someone needs to buy on a day to day basis in Afghanistan.
- marnett 9y agoThe financialization of commodities is exactly why everyone you listed is in the situation they are in. How does Bitcoin's financialization actually help anyone you listed?
- spookthesunset 9y agoGive me a break. Those are political and socioeconomic problems. None of them are solved by tech. You can't sprinkle Satoshi's fairy dust on Afghanistan women and expect them to have equal footing with their male counterparts. You can't just inject Satoshi's Revolutionary Blockchain into zimbabwe or venezuela and solve their political problems. Life just doesn't work that way.
- FloresHernandez 9y agoI own a small business in Venezuela. Nothing tech related, but in the food industry. Bitcoin has been a godsend. We are able to save money again having it as hard currency. I do exchange some of my btc for dollars, using btc to help to make the transaction (Why change it? Because I respect that you shouldn't have on crypto more than you can't afford to lose). I'm buying small amounts every day (As our currency depreciate every day as well), but it give us the chance to save and is easier and safer than buying usd in cash. I do understand the benefits have yet to "trickle down" to the regular people (I'm after all, a business owner), but it will trickle down. Our business is safer, I can afford to raise wages and able to plan ahead (As much as you can plan ahead in a country like Venezuela).
- aphextron 9y agoHow do you do transactions in bitcoin though? Don't you have to convert it back to local currency at some point?
- FloresHernandez 9y agoUsing localbitcoin to buy them. I either send them to a wallet for long term storage or use uphold to change to usd. I'm only buying in btc "saving money". Local currency (which my business generates) is spent either in supplies, wages, or just living here. I have yet to change some btc back to local currency (Which I might do to make a large purcharse or some emergency), but will probably just change USD cash (it will be easier). BTC is not being used for small purchases (So no bitcoin to pay for coffee). Is really just used as "store of wealth". Most business could take USD if you want to use it for payment and some even demand USD (car repairs, construction work, that kind of stuff). Most people DO know about bitcoin, but I wouldn't say is mainstream to own it. There's still fear about volatility.
- otoburb 9y agoDid you purchase any Venezuelan petro[1]? [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/02/venezuela-says-its-cryptocurrency-raised-735-million-but-its-a-farce/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/02/venezuela-says-i...
- baddox 9y agoThat was some humorous unintentional irony, considering that the vision was for Bitcoin to be just money.
- kirillseva 9y agothat vision is not dead. google "lightning network" for an answer to how this vision will be realized at scale this app is just USD <> crypto onboarding + price speculations for those who enjoy gambling on their mobile phones
- colordrops 9y agoYou mean blockstream's revenue model?
- statoshi 9y agoNo; keep your FUD on /r/btc.
- colordrops 9y agoExcept it's not FUD. That is their revenue model.
- statoshi 9y agoNonsense. Multiple teams are developing Lightning Network implementations and anyone who desires to commit capital to operate a Lightning node can do so without asking permission from anyone.
- colordrops 9y agoHow is that contradictory with blockstream's lightning network business model? Redhat's business model is around Linux even though anyone can commit capital to build their own Linux business.
- colordrops 9y agoIndividuals can still transact without interference if they wish, and no one can arbitrarily issue new bitcoin at a whim, so the important properties of bitcoin are still intact. The vision never included anything about preventing middlemen from using the blockchain. Bitcoin is about adding degrees of freedom, not removing them.
- stefano 9y ago> and no one can arbitrarily issue new bitcoin at a whim Anyone can fork it though. And the interesting part, as seen for bitcoin cash, is that the total market cap of the fork + original chain right after the fork was greater than the value pre-fork. You can technically argue that this doesn't amount to creating new bitcoins, but for all practical purposes the total amount of digital tokens did increase.
- bdamm 9y agoAn often overlooked detail of crypto currencies is that the miners are in fact acting as the "central banks" in terms of controlling currency policy.
- bdamm 9y agoThis is exactly it. Just like with the Internet... you may choose to transact directly, but if you choose not to the fundamental capability of direct transaction (or direct IP) still remains. Choosing an institution to hold your coins leaves open the option to withdraw your coins and put them somewhere else, perhaps even your own personal wallet on your own personal node if you so wish. The dream of a micro-payment platform remains to be realized, however. The gains in Bitcoin have been towards freedom, but not efficiency.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- malux85 9y agoYou can send directly from one party to another. The financial institution part is still optional.
- zanny 9y agoIt costs $2.50 to have your transaction go through in the next 10 minutes. It costs 50c to have it go through in the next HOUR. Bitcoins fee structure is wholly antithetical to its use as currency but TPTB in the mining ecosystem are making fantastic profits milking the fee rates. Nobody is really using it as a currency when having any amount change hands costs on average a fancy coffee drink from a fast food joint.
- malux85 9y agoAnd in 1999 it took me 15 minutes to download 1MB over my dialup connection. Bitcoin is the v1 of crypto. Give it a chance.
- tmat 9y agoi just sent a transaction for 6 cents and it was included in the next block.. that problem is resolved. so you can see i'm not making shit up https://live.blockcypher.com/btc/tx/8b420f5e6548865535381fdbbe4c0fc4c4ca2afdc0e1f094de6f54d104df8af3/ https://live.blockcypher.com/btc/tx/8b420f5e6548865535381fdb... That's a 2sat/byte transaction... come on man! this is amazing for shop owners. wait until lightning network and its INSTANT.
- 9y ago
- clarkmoody 9y ago> In the Bitcoin community is that vision basically dead? Not at all. The primary innovators of the protocol are pushing forward with privacy and scalability enhancements every day. The cypherpunk ethos is strong if you know where to look (hint: not CNBC). Sure, there are lots of corporate-types pushing corporate-type stuff. But any industry will have that before too long, especially if there is profit to be made.
- berberous 9y agoIt's still early days. It's like asking if the goals of the Internet are dead because most people log-in via AOL and browse only AOL curated content. Crypto adoption is still at a very low percentage in the United States. Imagine one day when _most_ people own crypto, and are willing to transact in it, and there is more advanced tooling and software and understanding. What will the world look like then? As a specific example, take a look at the 0x protocol, and the many relayers that are building on top of it like Radar Relay or Dy/Dx. 0x and these companies are tying to build exchanges that let you trade alts with zero counter-party risk. The trade occurs via on-chain smart contracts. The above could all fail; I'm not saying it _will_ happen. Just that it's too early to declare the original vision dead. And as sibling commentators have noted, even today one can easily send BTC peer-to-peer once you have some without any intermediaries.
- spookthesunset 9y ago> It's still early days. Bitcoin is 10 years old... hardly the "early days" in tech.
- Klathmon 9y agoAnd depending on when you define the "launch" of the internet, it's 10 year anniversary was in 1999, square in the AOL timeperiod that the parent comment was talking about.
- edanm 9y agoI know you put launch in quotes, but just to emphasize - the internet was launched much earlier than 1989 in terms of the technology. The base technology was worked on in the 60s and 70s, and things like email were already in use in the 70s and early 80s. Of course, digital cash has been worked on for many years too, but if you compare the bitcoin whitepaper to, say, the TCP/IP RFC, then you'd expect AOL-comparable bitcoin usage in 2030, more or less.
- spookthesunset 9y ago
- village-idiot 9y agoYes. Bitcoin itself has a laughably low transaction speed, somewhere in the neighborhood of 4/s. The main way around this appears to "trade" crypto in exchanges without most clients ever taking physical possession of their coins via the blockchain itself. This is why exchanges getting their hot wallets hacked is a big deal, a shocking percentage of crypto "traders" leave their holdings with the exchange.
- berberous 9y agoThe Internet used to have laughably low speed as well. Are you old enough to have used a dial-up modem? You are right that 4 tx/s is too low in the long-run. But people are innovating: DAG networks like Nano, BTC's Lightning Network, Ethereum's Plasma and sharding, etc. Maybe those ideas will work, maybe they won't, but very smart people like Vitalik believe they will work, and they are putting serious time and effort into them. Happily, Lightning Network, sharding and other proposals are making serious pushes forward this year as a top priority, so we don't need to argue -- we'll soon see how well these upgrades work in practice.
- Blackthorn 9y agoI had a series of dial-up modems for many, many years. It was always good enough because it's not like we were watching Netflix on them. Bitcoin is not good enough. Compare to alternatives that aren't cryptocurrency and it's just straight garbage. Saying that people are innovating is a pointless tautology, that's always true and doesn't change the fact that right now it is absolute garbage. (I trade bitcoin futures. I don't in any way believe in or care for the tech, I'm just here to make money.)
- fooker 9y agoCompared to the TV, video on the internet was not good enough for a long time.
- Blackthorn 9y ago
- nfin 9y agoyou are right in the sense that the percentage of such posts (focusing on financial instutions) are too high here. A small percentage should be ok if you believe in the vision, because bitcoin is not just blockchain, it needs a coin with financial value to work, and for that matter it needs users that either trade or at least can enter the system with what they already have (fiat). Such institutions do the onboarding of users. Afterwrds, those users can then stay in the crypto(currency) world without using financial institutions if they wish...
- rajacombinator 9y ago>In the Bitcoin community is that vision basically dead? No, and based on the question it seems like you don’t understand what’s going on very well. Robinhood is a fiat<>btc channel, has nothing to do with btc’s vision.
- book_mentioned 9y agoBitcoin: Update network descriptions to be more accurate | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16039587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16039587 (Dec 2017) Bitcoin.org removes “fast” and “low fees” from Bitcoin description page | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16204387 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16204387 (Jan 2018)
- wmf 9y agoSome people are using cryptocurrency (not necessarily BTC) for remittance and buying drugs.