10 ms·
From imitation to innovation: How China became a tech superpower
- tristanj 9y agoThis article is missing the key part where China blocked and limited products by major foreign tech giants such as Google, Facebook, Microsoft et al so homegrown Chinese variants could flourish.
- aikinai 9y agoWhen I first saw the headline, that’s specifically what I assumed it would be about!
- yadongwen 9y agoGoogle, M$ and Amazon were not successful when they were not blocked in China.. Amazon China is still not blocked but far behind JD, Alibaba, etc. In some areas like fintech, drones, consumer apps and games China is clearly the leader. If FB is unblocked I doubt it can compete with Tencent at all. Tencent has a higher market cap than FB and understands the Chinese so much more..
- Zafira 9y agoI don't think this concedes how much a factor Chinese regionalism plays into the dominance of Chinese companies in China. The government has had a much stronger hand in shaping what technologies and companies flourish than in the rest of the developed world. How the market would have looked if the government was less heavy-handed is an open question, but I think it is misleading to omit this factor. Also, there are things that foreign companies simply will not concede to Beijing. Tencent allows full access to their networks to the government. Ephemeral criticisms of the government can get you a warning from the state. This is unconscionable behavior in a lot of other countries, but it's a concession Chinese companies have made time and again.
- kochthesecond 9y agoWell, I did not know that. Are there any sources where I can read more? I know Google fought a lot over similar issues and eventually withdrew their hardware from China. Also, the Chinese are building a citizen scoring card system, that will rate your standing with the government from birth to death.
- ghostcluster 9y ago> In some areas like fintech, drones, consumer apps and games China is clearly the leader Maybe vaping/e-cigarette technology too. > BIS Research estimates that the global electronic cigarette industry will exhibit a growth of over 22.36% (CAGR) from 2015 to 2025, to reach a total market value of $50 Billion by 2025 https://bisresearch.com/industry-report/electronic-cigarette-market-size-forecast.html https://bisresearch.com/industry-report/electronic-cigarette...
- Arn_Thor 9y agoThe classic 'East Asian growth model' tactic. It's classic because it works, almost every time
- intended 9y agoAlso its not like the west managed its growth solely out of the strength of their intellect and labor. It seems that all major ladders to the top have some dark rungs the victors are happy to hide when they reach the top.
- tinyrick2 9y agoDon't you think that by limiting foreign companies' products the local companies would operate less efficiently since there is no competition? I think I was taught about this in my econ 101 class. Why does it work differently this time?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoNo, it’s still true. Chinese companies in protected industries are as inefficient as expected.
- coldtea 9y agoReally, Weibo, TaiBao, Alibaba and co are "inefficient"?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoTaibao and Alibaba aren’t really protected. As for Tencent, look at its success in other countries when competing against google and Facebook....
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y ago> Don't you think that by limiting foreign companies' products the local companies would operate less efficiently since there is no competition? There is no foreign competition but Chinese companies still have competition from other Chinese companies. Even if the Chinese market is less efficient because competition is limited to China: The goal is to foster a healthy national economy, create knowledge, and most importantly keep total control over technologies and communication channels.
- dogma1138 9y agoNot necessarily the same things happened also in Russia. Competition can still happen just locally and while competition is good when the scale is unbalanced it can be just as bad or worse than no competition at all. Almost no one is developing a Google search competitor because it’s near impossible to do so while people have access to Google the need isn’t there and you can’t compete unless you are actually better there isn’t as much niche to search as people think. You also have the problem of resource imbalance where Google can just go and buy out the local competition at ease due to their wealth this what has happened with dating and P2P commerce sites all over the world.
- coldtea 9y agoIf brands like Google, Facebook, Microsoft et al were Chinese owned and controlled, the US would have done much of the same. Only third and fourth tier players (like what the European countries have become now) let others control such key infrastructure.
- Bucephalus355 9y agoThere was an article in the WSJ yesterday that called the last 20 years of GE under CEO under Jeff Immelt “success theater” due to the underlying rot. China is a country of “business theater”. They sure look like they’re doing business, lots of factories, tons of people in suits, cargo container ships, etc. But it’s all just a lie. It’s nothing but the 21st century planned economy version of the Soviet Union. It’s not even communism as much as simple totalitarianism. The only thing I haven’t figured out yet is if more than 50,000,000 million people are going to die, which was the same amount in 1958-1963 that died in totalitarian China, a number greater than the USSR and the Holocaust combined I would like to add. Capitalism in the US sucks, but it’s very fixable. Capitalism in the 1910’s was far more horrible, but it was fixed beyond even today with the reforms of the 30’s-50’s, so I don’t want anyone to think my criticism of China is some apologia for capitalism right now. This I do not believe in / don’t want to, but just so everyone is aware, the theory that really propelled Trump into office was that of the “fourth turning”, which Steve Bannon was a huge believer in. Essentially it’s the belief that every 80-90 years a massive war and change in Western government happens, stretching back to the British defeat of the Armada in 1588. As Christopher Coker wrote in “The Improbable War”, the next World War is most likely with China, a county with the manpower and resources to fight a grinding global battle against the US. We will see. https://www.amazon.com/Improbable-War-United-States-Conflict/dp/0199396272 https://www.amazon.com/Improbable-War-United-States-Conflict...
- ghostcluster 9y agoEveryone points to automation as the savior, but where is the Chinese Caterpillar? The Chinese Bosch? As far as I can tell, they still rely primarily on companies from the US, Japan, and Germany for their automated heavy industry. https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Companies/Japanese-robot-maker-taps-China-s-demand-for-automation https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Companies/Japanese-robot-ma...
- maxerickson 9y agoThere's multiple Chinese heavy equipment manufacturers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Heavy_machinery_manufacturers_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:Heavy_machinery_manuf... Have you compared sales numbers? The LiuGong article shows equipment used in other Asian countries and Africa.
- Mononokay 9y agoIt's not too hard! The steps on how it did anyone can follow, given they have the resources! Step One: Have 1/8 of the world's population in a densely populated region. Step Two: Don't actively harm people trying to innovate. Step Three: Wait.
- IntronExon 9y agoReal Step Two: Just copy everything.
- 2muchcoffeeman 9y agoI guess we really taught them how to copy everything by moving all manufacturing there. Once they could do everything without external help, they would innovate.
- mirimir 9y agoLiterally. We packed up steel mills, and shipped them there. We can blame it all on Nixon and Kissinger.
- lafar6502 9y agoAnd the article mentions envy as one of possible reactions. Don’t forget about all the western startups when looking for copycats and impostors
- bewo001 9y agoEvery industrial nation started by copying the British. The European countries and the US did it in the 19th century. In the 1960s/70, everybody joked about the Japanese copying everything. In the 80s, South Korea was known for cheap copies of electronic devices. It is/was only a matter of time for China to move from copying to innovating.
- speedplane 9y agoOne thing the U.S. (and Europe) still deal very well is branding and messaging. Most of our electronics are designed and made in China, but they are still branded and sold by western countries. The U.S. is still adept at manufacturing brands, lifestyles, identity, and "cool". While China developing it's own technology was practically inevitable, it will be far more interesting when they begin influencing what people want.
- Chiba-City 9y agoThere is nothing obviously wrong with copying things and nothing obvious right with "inventing" them first. DOS was not first but beat CPM. Microsoft even went on to PROMOTE its "fast follower" modus operandi. VC's seeking exits have very sound reasons for wanting something "first" and preferably "license protected." But those wins do not obviously confer to either nation states or even all industries or companies. Making things over and over for expanding markets is the best source of innovation. Any delusions of "labs" as "heads" and "making things" as "mere hands" are in fact pure delusions. [Edit: sp]
- gt_ 9y agoMaybe not pure delusions! But I think you’re otherwise right. It’s slow to penetrate post-modern perspectives, so much that pointing it out seems to only confuse and slow us down. I think it’s sad. At this point, an American with the lab:factory perspective is met with a set of industries and personnel perfectly trained to that model, and scarce resources to undermine it if they choose to go against the grain (See Tesla’s uphill battles in manufacturing, not an isolated or perfect example but fits). We’re also likely to be surrounded with success stories of that model. But, like you say, there is another way. It’s pretty tough to see the benefit of not looking for it, especially when comparing the pace of the outsourcing model. But, we ironically installed the artisan model in our nation’s individualist “doer” image of itself and spend a lot of effort talking around it. It’s proven time and time again in stories of history, art and innovation but it’s just a matter of a pendulum swing.
- petra 9y agoIt probably depends on industry. It doesn't work so well in today's software, like Microsoft has proved. Also in industries with strong patents or with effective process secrets. And i'm not sure that way of thinking is effective in industries with network effects. So what's left ? usually industries with low-margins. And afaik, that generally describes China.
- Chiba-City 9y agoFirst, it would certainly depend on as many sample variations we can find. Second, you are approaching tautological nonsense where patents and copyrights are nothing more than excuses for undeserved "outsized returns." Maybe that is true now or in countries with "first-to-file" patent regimes. There are no guarantees of ANY future outsized returns, no matter how much people might desire them. Low-margin might just equal "useful and fair."
- Animats 9y agoIt's mostly making real stuff, too. The US suffers from ad-based companies, especially Google and Facebook, dominating "tech". YC recognizes this; most newer YC startups are not ad-funded. But it's going to take a while to turn this around. It's like that strange period in the 1990s when 40% of US corporate profits came from financial activities, and every big company had to have a finance subsidiary with a trading desk. That's so over.
- elefanten 9y agoThe examples you chose in particular are strange. Yes, they're ad-supported but they're both still "making real stuff" and both still "tech". Isn't the turn away from ad funded user-count business models more about attention saturation and the fact that those markets have stabilized around a set of incumbent platforms by now?
- ddeck 9y agoIt's like that strange period in the 1990s when 40% of US corporate profits came from financial activities, and every big company had to have a finance subsidiary with a trading desk. That's so over. I realize that you're refering finance activities contribution to the profits of perhaps non-financial firms, but the contribution to GDP from financial services firms has been growing steadily since the 50s and shows no sign of slowing [0]. [0] https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/BL-REB-15342?responsive=y https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/BL-REB-15342?responsive=y
- nl 9y agoIt's mostly making real stuff, too. The US suffers from ad-based companies, especially Google and Facebook, dominating "tech". This is an odd criticism. Newspaper, Cable and TV companies have always been financial giants. It would be more surprising if ad-based companies hadn't remained big players.
- yuhong 9y agoYea, that ad bubble is one of my favorite topics right now. Part of it is that the US economy has been mostly based on debt (to generate growth) since the 1970s though, with the Japanese being first (after US manufacturing lost dominance). As a side note: https://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303/imageroot/2017/01/23/20170127_debt1.jpg https://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user330... Notice the period where debt was not increasing but stocks were going up. I suspect this was not a coincidence.
- yusuke10 9y agoIt's funny, if an author with a book to peddle repeats the mantra enough times..."China is innovative", it might become true. And yet, what evidence does she raise? "the electronics were assembled in China; almost never were they invented in China" "paying with your smartphone has become the norm" "bikeshare firms" "China has the largest number of unicorns outside the US" Nothing that would define as innovations. Let's ask ourselves. What consumer innovations has China come up with in the last 40 years that is known worldwide. Think hard. Maybe none? one? Now compare that against Japan in its 40 years rise.
- ghostcluster 9y agoBest example I can think of is DJI. Best in class consumer electronics drone manufacturer and a worldwide brand with high cache. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DJI_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DJI_(company) Founded by a Chinese engineering student with a personal aeronautics hobby, based in Shenzhen — he's now a billionaire.
- TTPrograms 9y agoI would argue drones are mostly commodities at this point.
- vadimberman 9y agoActually, yes. DJI and Yi-Hang. These ones are truly impressive. But apart from this, KPIs aside, the Chinese landscape is amazingly scarce innovation-wise. If one has to tout bikesharing as innovation, it sounds like there's not much to brag about. I am puzzled at Kai-Fu Lee's claims, he's not just another VC.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI’ve heard from someone who actually met with him at Innovation Works that Kai Fu actually encourages the startups he funds to be derivative. It is much less risky that way, and VCs in china don’t like much risk, Preferring to transplant proven businesses from elsewhere.
- speedplane 9y agoI was recently reviewing front-end frameworks (i.e., React vs. Angular), and part of the review was looking at Google Trends to get an idea of their relative popularity. I was pretty surprised to see that while React has been gaining on Angular for some time worldwide, it's had remarkable growth in China, where it now surpasses Angular by a wide margin. Certainly seems that China is faster to adopt this technology than others. Unclear if this is an isolated incidence, but was just surprised to see China pick up a new technology faster than most established tech centers.
- dep_b 9y agoReminds me of a story I read a while ago about Russian programmers that didn't speak English at all so all things we recognized as words in the programming language didn't have any meaning to them. Perhaps React has a syntax / mental model that's easier to grasp for non-English speakers. OO programming is definitely more wordy than functional(ly oriented) programming.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y agoI think expansion of software / tools into non-English markets is mostly driven by the availability of native language documentation, tutorials, blog posts, etc. The more translated documentation exists, the more the software is used, the more is written about it, the more it is used, etc.
- fny 9y agoThis is probably because Vue.js is as dominant in China as React.
- bajablast 9y agohonestly, who in their right mind would use the new Angular it's objectively worse in every area. In my experience only Angular development is maintaining Legacy code. Picking the new Angular would be insane it's slow, buggier, less flexible and more expensive to develop and find talent to build it's truly a lose-lose (unless you are a Angular team consultant that is)
- hownottowrite 9y agoThe article is missing the real step one: Education. From "China’s rise as a major contributor to science and technology"[0]: "China is now the world’s distant leader in bachelor’s degrees in Science and Engineering, with 1.1 million in 2010, more than four times the US figure. This large disparity reflects not only China’s dramatic expansion in higher education since 1999 but also a much higher percentage of students majoring in S/E in China, around 44% in 2010, compared with 16% in the United States." [0] http://www.pnas.org/content/111/26/9437 http://www.pnas.org/content/111/26/9437
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoMany of those CS degrees outside of first and second tier universities are not very good, however. When every foreign language unverisity and teacher’s college (there called normal universities) has a CS department, there is definitely something going on.
- hownottowrite 9y ago> Many of those CS degrees outside of first and second tier universities are not very good, however. Sure, but even if half the total degrees are substandard that's still twice the output of the United States. It's a wave that will only pay more dividends over time. > When every foreign language unverisity and teacher’s college (there called normal universities) has a CS department, there is definitely something going on. The same could be said for every liberal arts college in the United States which suddenly has a brand new science/math/CS center plopped onto campus. Anyway, I'd recommend giving the study a read. The authors discuss these issues as well as a few others. Problems aside, there's a clear trend developing.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoEven the Chinese government admits quality is a problem, I’ll see if I can pull up a CD or GT article I read a few years ago. The CS programs in lower tiered schools are not given many resources, they are often taught programming by teachers who have never programmed before (similar to being taught English by the book by an instructor who can’t speak english, my mother in law did this). It’s not the same as Hoboken liberal arts college teaching CS, it’s more like Scottsdale cooking academy teaching CS (or at least Zhangjiajie Tourism College). When I was working in china, everyone was complaining about finding programmers that were good enough to hire. You would filter your resume stacks by 1st then 2nd tier universities (throw everything else out), and still had to be very rigorous in interviewing. This was way after the CS education boom happened in the early part of this decade.
- dep_b 9y agoThe next step in China will be that an important part of their citizens will earn a living above a certain threshold where they will think about non-material problems in their lives, which is the moment the Chinese government has to start dealing with unruly citizens. This happened in the 1960's in Western Europe and the US.
- remir 9y agoI am not American, but I think it's fair to say that America brought the world into "modernity". Telephone, computers, software, the internet, smart devices, these had a huge impact on the world. To me, the real test of China's innovation will be to see if they can have a true and significant impact on the world. We often talk about innovation in terms of technological advancements, but we need to also talk about innovation as new methods, new way of thinking. What does the world need today in 2018? The environment is in peril, the resources are diminishing rapidly, the climate is changing, etc... Going forward, I believe the most impactful innovations will be the ones who will deal with these huge problems. I sure hope both the US and China can unite their efforts here because in the end, we are all sharing this planet.
- dalbasal 9y agoIn that context, I think you need to consider the US' impact on political norms. It was the first modern democratic republic. Its basic political norms and rights form the most important example of what we know as liberal democracy.
- harperlee 9y agoWouldn't that be France, between the French Revolution and Napoleon's regime?
- dalbasal 9y agocontemporaries, really. But, the US' political ideologies were more easy to understand. France's was always more layered and abstract. Also, fewer peopele were looking at revolutionary France with envy, because of all the violence. .. that's my take anyway.
- thefounder 9y agoI believe US should be credited with being the biggest supporter of modern democracy rather than being the first modern democracy. This seems to be changing though, pure financial interests seem to the new policy. If there is one reason I don't want China to succeed is because of its communist regime.
- sarcasm_heals 9y agoWhat is stopping a sovereign state like China from stealing source code from companies and giving it to its own entrepreneurs? China follows state-run capitalism. It decides who gets what. I'm not just talking trade secrets but rather code bases with millions of lines of code that took hundreds of thousands of person-hours to create and evolve. Also, it would only need to focus all of its resources on cloud infrastructure where companies put all of their eggs in one basket. China won't start from 0 when it can steal and copy.
- agumonkey 9y agoWell students imitate masters before taking their place.