4 ms·
Why Can’t Riding Bikes in America Just Be Normal?
- jseliger 9y agoI also just read and submitted "We’re witnessing the fastest decline in Arctic sea ice in at least 1,500 years" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16414695"and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16414695"and cannot help wondering about the connection between the two.
- kevmo 9y agoThe title of this blog - "Bike Snob" - answers its own question.
- chapium 9y agoI found it to be self deprecating, in a humorous way.
- alvern 9y ago+1 for the Yuba Supermarche. That cargo bike is super fun to ride. The steering takes a minute to get used to, it has a 4:3 ratio. For every degree you turn the handlebars, the front wheel turns 1.33 times more. It handles speeds up to 30mph suprisingly well. I made a quick video when we got one in the shop last summer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_l_M6UrHY5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_l_M6UrHY5k
- toomuchtodo 9y agoYou can also add electric assist to cargo bikes such as these, making them even easier to use.
- tstrimple 9y agoThe average commute is 15 miles and the average cycling speed is 9mph which gives you an average of 3 hours per day commuting via bicycle. Can't imagine why riding bikes isn't normal!
- jacobolus 9y agoThe average commute in cities with more cycling isn’t 3 hours. People just live closer to work. The big problem the USA has is that its zoning laws and urban planning are completely screwed up, making it impossible in most places to build bike- and pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods. (Minimum lot sizes, low units per lot, low height limits, large setbacks, wide streets, massive numbers of car parking spaces required everywhere, few mixed-use areas, neighborhoods cut off by highways, lots of disconnected dead-end streets, very high urban speed limits, ...)
- Cw67NTN8F 9y agoThe road + trees, plus walking path is x. So carving out a 10-12 feet bike lane (two ways) is a challenge.
- OscarCunningham 9y agoThe question should be why a 15 mile commute is normal!
- falcolas 9y agoTypically because families in the latter half of the 1900's wanted to move out of the crowded cities to raise their children, forming suburbs. We're left with that infrastructure with no real money to change it.
- jacobolus 9y agoA lot of the regulatory changes were explicitly racist. By “crowded” what many really meant was “full of those people” (and especially after Brown v. Board “my kids might have to go to school with those kids”). And regulations were intended to prevent poor racial minorities from following. (Starting with explicit rejection of minorities, but when that was found illegal switching to regulations that deliberately made suburban life more exclusive or expensive.) Edit: For the downvoters, this is not a controversial summary. Start with e.g. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-government-intentionally-racially-segregated-american-cities-180963494/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-governmen... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residential_segregation_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residential_segregation_in_the... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusionary_zoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusionary_zoning There are ways we can start changing it though: change the zoning laws, change the tax laws, etc. Changes to the built infrastructure will slowly respond over the coming decades.
- burnte 9y agoGuy with very unusual bike riding through NYC wonders why he can't just be seen as "normal" and not get comments. No one would have looked twice if we riding a normal bike, but he is riding a VERY unusual (really neat, though) bike, so yeah, you're going to get comments. Most of them were positive, too, by the sounds of the article.
- huebomont 9y agoYou need to pay more attention to biking in NYC. Drivers HATE bikers to an incredibly unreasonable extent.
- orangecat 9y agoAs a pedestrian in NYC I wasn't fond of them either. At least once a month I'd have a near miss due to a cyclist barrelling through a red light at full speed. I know it's a only a minority that does things like that, but it unavoidably creates a bad impression.
- Joe-Z 9y agoI guess traffic will always elicit emotional reactions in people. I bike through a tourist-laden, relatively narrow, street on my way to and from work and, my god, the amount of people just wandering around aimlessly seemingly having no sense of their surroundings is astonishing.
- burnte 9y agoI get that, but he's ESPECIALLY noticeable here. It's basically the Dave Chapelle "Wearing the uniform" joke.
- fnord123 9y agoThey're super common in NL and BE. So I guess the inferred question is why can't they be common in NYC? From the Article: > As it happens, as a male cyclist I have indeed experienced that same line of questioning, but only while carrying children on my bike, and only from women who were concerned for their safety. I would not want to ride a bakfiets in traffic in the US with children riding along. I would be concerned for their safety as well.
- Piskvorrr 9y ago"having things thrown at me from car windows (this has happened to every cyclist)"...I am genuinely shocked. I would not expect that from a third world banana republic, not a fact-of-life in the USA.
- mc32 9y agoI rode a bike back when riding a bike wasn't very popular. People who owned "10speeds" only had them so they could take them out on the weekend and show their friends they had a "10-speed". I rode shoulders and shared dangerous roads --no shoulder a bike could ride on alongside a 40/45mph road. I never had things thrown at me. Now, I never intentionally tried pissing drivers off, that's for sure. Or maybe I was lucky, or those drivers were especially nice. Possibly as well, since I was only the odd bike, it wasn't irritating drivers. On the other hand, I do recall a few other odd cyclists "advising me" to keep some D-cells with me in case I had to hurl one at a car. I never carried one. That said, people thought it was peculiar that I would ride a bike and not own a car. Basically, I just could not afford one at that time.
- GuiA 9y agoI moved to the US for grad school (in the south). Biking to school, I remember people yelling at me, and people driving pickup trucks feigning to run into me and honking very loudly. Very confused as to the thought process going on in the mind of those people.
- anfilt 9y agoSome people think cyclists don't belong on the road.
- loudmax 9y agoI've been riding a bike to work on and off for several years, and I pretty much also think cyclists don't belong on the road. The road is dangerous, far better to ride on sidewalks. In the Northern Virginia suburbs where I live, there aren't a lot of people on the sidewalks. When I do pass a pedestrian, I slow down and give them a wide berth so they aren't startled. Sometimes I'll even ride into the street to give them more room, especially if they're walking a dog. And then, I get back on the sidewalk where my life isn't in the hands of aggressive or distracted drivers.
- axau 9y ago> For that matter I’ve also never had anyone of any gender implore me to be careful when loading my children into a car, which statistically speaking is far more warranted. This would be extremely surprising to me. Citation needed.
- blhack 9y agoBecause Brooklyn and Manhattan are nothing like most of the other cities in the US? Also, what the hell is this author talking about? People are looking at your bike because they think its interesting. It IS interesting, because it looks very different than most bikes people have seen, even people who are "in" to bikes (like bike messengers, that he mentions). Also this: >“How do you steer that thing?” >“With the handlebars” Oh man you sure showed him, author! The guy outside of the supermarket is clearly showing interest in your unique, interesting bicycle. You don't have to be a jerk about it. -- People in the US largely don't have the time to ride bikes. We work from 8:00am to 5:00pm, and it's too expensive for many people to live near where their office is. If you pad an hour on each side of that work schedule for commuting, that leaves 13 hours of non-work-related time per day, 8 of which has to be dedicated to sleeping, leaving 5 hours to "live" each day. If you take 30 minutes to get ready in the morning, and 30 minutes to wind down before bed, that brings you down to 4 hours. People want to reclaim as much time as they can for living. Cars give them the ability to do that. It would be great if we all lived a mile from where we work, and could all ride funky unique bikes to our jobs, then post self-righteous blogs on a website called "bike snob" about how annoyed we are that people notice our weird bike. But we don't, and blogs like this only serve to further the distance between cyclists and non-cyclists. On a semi-related note: my city recently got a BUNCH of dockless bike share bikes. They're EVERYWHERE now. Pretty much any bar, any grocery store, any restaurant, shopping center, etc. all have a few bike shares parked outside of them now. It's AWESOME. And yet every bike-group I'm a part of is complaining about them. So I don't know cyclists, maybe you should turn that "bike snob" lens towards yourself and ask why more people aren't ditching their cars for bikes.
- ricardobeat 9y agoHave you used the shared bikes? They are usually expensive, heavy, not ergonomic and take up valuable parking space. Amsterdam recently went on a collecting spree, outlawed many of them and reclaimed a few thousand parking spaces. “People don’t have time to ride bikes” - this is exactly what the article is about: using bikes for normal tasks, like taking kids to school, going to the grocery store, commuting to work. Not for recreation in your off time, or as a sport. Journeys up to 6-7km are absolutely normal, you don’t have to live next door to the office to cycle. What else is stopping you?
- NegativeLatency 9y agoThat bike would fit right in in Portland. Would still probably get some comments, but cargo bikes are not uncommon.
- bluedino 9y agoHere in the rust belt, if you're on a bicycle and over the age of 25 or so, the stigma is "I don't have a drivers license because of multiple DUI's" That said, the guys that ride bikes are tough. They do it in in the rain, through the cold and snow, in the dark with no lights. Pedaling miles going along picking up cans, riding back home with plastic grocery bags full of 40oz beer bottles to enjoy the rest of their day.
- watchdogtimer 9y agoI made a bike[1] very similar to the authors about 10 years ago and have used it as my main vehicle ever since. It's been extremely useful for getting groceries and hauling packages. My experience has been similar to the author's, with people curious about it and often taking pictures of it as they drive past. [1]-https://photos.app.goo.gl/Bc7bvq1ipqznTImR2 https://photos.app.goo.gl/Bc7bvq1ipqznTImR2
- oceanghost 9y agoInclimate weather is why. Bikes are well and fine when it's not too hot, not too cold, and not raining, and if you're in shape and not suffering from any serious medical problems. Otherwise, its the car.
- rexgallorum2 9y agoIn the case of the US, it's really an infrastructure issue. Attitudes follow from that. I grew up in the US and live in Europe now, and I bike or walk everywhere. The difference is of course staggering. Here, biking is just something ordinary people do to get around, and it doesn't require any special equipment or make any kind of statement. In the US, biking is primarily associated with recreation and a specific subculture. In the US case, changing infrastructure priorities and urban planning practices will go a long way toward alleviating the problem.