9 ms·
Type 2 diabetes can be reversed with a low-calorie diet
- loeg 9y ago(2017) (At least the study itself: "Published on 10 December 2017.") Previous article: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/dec/05/radical-diet-can-reverse-type-2-diabetes-new-study-shows https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/dec/05/radical-diet... And discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15873389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15873389
- vonmoltke 9y ago> (2017) (At least the study itself: "Published on 10 December 2017.") So, two months ago? Who cares if it's on the other side of an arbitrary point in time?
- DanBC 9y agoloeg is politely pointing out a large, recent, discussion. That's a useful thing to do.
- vonmoltke 9y agoI quoted the specific portion because if the propensity of people here to immediately jump in and "tag" articles with the year they were published. If loeg had left the quoted line out if its post I would not have mentioned anything.
- Someone1234 9y agoThat's fantastic news. I do have a question, how safe is 830 calories/day for a diabetic? For an otherwise healthy person I can see it being safe with medical supervision but for an individual already seeing blood sugar spikes due to diabetes, I wonder about the dangers? I guess what I am getting at is that this intervention for diabetes might only be safe enough to try in early stage even if it would work for more progressed diagnosis.
- a3n 9y agoThe subjects were under medical supervision ...
- stephenhess 9y agoAlso, non-insulin dependent which lowers the risk considerably
- Someone1234 9y agoI never claimed they weren't. I asked about the safety of diabetics on low calorie diets. I have no idea how stringent the entry criteria was for this study, they could have picked the [otherwise] healthiest diabetics they could find. Which brings us back to the question I asked, which was how this could scale to older or in worse health individuals suffering from type 2 diabetes? Even with medical supervision.
- maloney 9y agoIt would only be a problem if you took insulin and then did not eat. Given that type two diabetics cell’s are stuffed full of sugar from insulin resitance, not eating or eating less can only help.
- loeg 9y ago> I do have a question, how safe is 830 calories/day for a diabetic? They're largely not at risk of anorexia, if that's what you're asking. "Somewhere in the neighborhood of 85% of people who develop type 2 diabetes are overweight or obese."[0] > For an otherwise healthy person I can see it being safe with medical supervision but for an individual already seeing blood sugar spikes due to diabetes, I wonder about the dangers? That's why it's done under medical supervision. A very low calorie diet (VLCD) should result in fewer blood sugar spikes, not more, simply due to the body having less sugar available. [0]: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/diabetes-can-strike-hard-even-when-weight-is-normal-201208085121 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/diabetes-can-strike-hard...
- 9y ago
- turc1656 9y ago...or you could not starve yourself on <900 calories a day and instead be a sane person and just eat low carb: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13300-018-0373-9 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13300-018-0373-... "Insulin therapy was reduced or eliminated in 94% of users; sulfonylureas were entirely eliminated in the CCI. No adverse events were attributed to the CCI." Wow, that's pretty extraordinary, isn't it? Every single person in the non-control group eliminated the need for sulfonylureatic compounds and a massive 94% reduced their insulin level or completely got off insulin altogether. All with no adverse affects being recorded. You don't need to starve yourself or go on some ridiculous diet. You just need to eat low carb and eat clean (a.k.a. "real" food) and your body will begin to heal in nearly every case. I suspect the few test cases that didn't improve were so far gone they were too metabolically impaired to achieve any positive results. The damage was likely too extensive and age possibly played a factor. For everyone else, it appears they can get rid of diabetes...if they actually care enough to do so.
- arkades 9y agoRepeated studies have shown that weight loss plays a bigger role than carb restriction. The article you linked showed a 12% weight loss in the experimental group, which also had continued support by a health coach throughout its duration, which was the actual intervention. You make it sound like the intervention was carb elimination, rather than weight loss with a health coach. It was not.
- originalsimba 9y agoRepeated studies have shown that carb restriction leads to weight loss.
- arkades 9y agoNo, repeated studies have shown that -any diet- leads to weight loss. Drawing anyone’s attention to what they’re eating in a detail-oriented way helps lose weight. When someone says “carb restriction is the ticket,” they’re attributing the effectiveness -to the carb restriction-, explicitly, as having an effect on weight loss notably above and beyond that of calorie restriction. Pretty much no decently structured studies have supported that. A couple animal studies suggest shit like HFCS has a much more severe short term effect on insulin than other foods, but they’re small, animal based, and “don’t eat junk food” is world away from “carb restrict.”
- spodek 9y ago> Weight loss of 15kg or more was achieved by 24% of the intervention group compared to none of the usual care group. > Diabetes remission occurred in 46% of the intervention group compared to 4% of the usual care group. It only occurred in people who had lost weight. Unless the people with type 2 diabetes were fit and going underweight for the experiment, instead of implying overweightness is normal, could we say that a high calorie diet can maintain or accelerate diabetes? This rephrasing suggests prevention.
- hawkice 9y agoFair, but I think there's something to the opposite tone. A lot of people know that if you're healthy, you can generally avoid type 2 diabetes. Saying it basically 1:1's with weight issues is... important. Prevention is important, but there's this idea weight loss is impossible, or keeping weight off is impossible, and boy howdy that isn't true.
- vevoo 9y ago>could we say that a high calorie diet can maintain or accelerate diabetes. Yes we can say that. But we can say the same about an isocaloric diet and a negative balance diet of 5 or 10% deficit. It is better said as the paper did.
- stephenhess 9y agoWe've known that low-calorie dieting has this effect for some time; unless I'm missing something, this looks like solid confirmation of this point but isn't adding much knew to our understanding of diabetes prevention. The big challenges in this space are adherence, scaling access to treatment and creating long-term lifestyle change that will help the patient maintain the weight that is lost. There's good evidence that ketogenic diets have an additive metabolic effect beyond pure calorie restriction which is exciting. Virta Health is doing some interesting work here and just published some results that speak to this: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13300-018-0373-9 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13300-018-0373-...
- arkades 9y agoThe only novelty in this study was doing it in people with longer term diabetes than most such studies.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoWell, the more the merrier is as true for scientific studies as for sex parties. The point is that no two studies are going to be set up in the exact same way, so it's interesting to examine the results of slightly different experiments. But probably more importantly, because there is no study that can claim 100% certainty for anything, having many studies confirm the same effect is always a good thing.
- arkades 9y agoThe headline is a bit misleading. We have previously known diabetes is reversible with low calorie diets. This study was notable for two things: (1) finding that this holds true even six years into mild diabetes (previous studies were on much more recent diagnoses). This is useful information because of the widely held misconception that type 2 diabetes is just a disease of insulin insensitivity. Actually, over time, islet amyloid peptide is deposited in the pancreas where it slowly kills off beta cells and removes your ability to actually produce insulin. In effect (though not literally nor in every particular), type 2 dm slowly transitions into type 1. So it’s useful to know that six years out the pancreas is functioning well enough to allow dietary reversal. (2) being funded by a private company pushing a meal replacement-and-weight loss coaching program, which used this private program as the intervention arm. Turns out that, yes, if you live on slimfast for 3 months you’ll lose weight and your diabetes will calm down. That Lancet didn’t exactly lead with that latter point, oddly enough. The co is pushing for the NHS to fund their program in more locations, under the argument that bariatric surgery isn’t available to everyone. This is part of their PR push.
- throwaway5752 9y agoBariatric surgery (not personal experience, but secondhand) is not a picnic and requires a large/equal amount maintenance/discipline post-op to not harm yourself or regress. Again, admittedly 2nd hand and would love to be corrected.
- arkades 9y agoThe more recent generation of bari surgery approaches are more gentle than the first generation. That said, I agree, it’s not a free pass. Thing is, we have about half a century of consistent clinical findings saying, without exception, no diet-based approach shows long term weight reduction. The most successful have zero effects by 5-10 years out. Bari surgery is the first and only intervention we’ve had that has shown sustained weight loss over 10 years. I don’t mean to in any way understate its dangers or its difficulty. But from a medical standpoint, I have to raise a red flag when someone says “hey, instead of using the only treatment that’s ever been shown to have a sustained effect, you should use a variant of a treatment we’ve spent half a century proving doesn’t generally work.” The linked article phrased it as being for people for whom bari isn’t an option, but even the Lancet article proper - iirc, as I read it at the beginning of the week - phrased it as, “there aren’t enough bari surgeons to go around, so in the meantime...”
- Greenisus 9y agoIt seems that a keto diet/lifestyle does this in a far more enjoyable way than restricting calories to such a low level. Mixing in restricting to zero calories (aka fasting) also helps. Either way I'm so happy to see people start to attack this problem with smarter food choices.
- originalsimba 9y agoI think the conclusion is false and the real culprit is low-sugar, not low-calorie. Insulin production is directly influenced by sugar levels. It is not influenced by caloric intake. I didn't read the whole article but I bet their method is flawed and further study is required.
- vevoo 9y agoI did read it. They might have other method issues, but not that one you mention. In this analysis the did not focus on insulin secretion or sensibility. You are right in a sense. The authors used to say that it does not matter what you eat, as far as is a lot of caloric restriction. That was back in 2016, when I interviewed them. I hope now they will disagree if someone comes with a 800 calorie diet made of sugar only.
- grater 9y agoIt's fat, not sugar https://nutritionfacts.org/2016/11/17/fat-is-the-cause-of-type-2-diabetes/ https://nutritionfacts.org/2016/11/17/fat-is-the-cause-of-ty...
- aviv 9y agoWater fasting. But people don't want to listen.
- sethrin 9y agoFlat assertions of efficacy unadorned by empirical support may not be well received. However, I am sure that the idea is taken seriously by most, and that supporting evidence would be of great interest.
- aviv 9y agoI used to back it up by quite a bit of data but I get downvoted to oblivion regardless of all the effort. Why bother anymore. I put it here, whoever is interested can research on their own.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoMeaning restricting water intake? Or general fasting with only water consumed?
- jessejmc 9y agoUsually general fasting with only water consumed. Many practitioners will allow unadulterated coffee or tea. I haven't seen much evidence to indicate that dry fasting provides additional health benefits over water fasting.
- fernly 9y agoDoes anyone know what the UK NHS means by a 'formula diet'? The overview says, > The program involved... going on a formula replacement diet. This consisted of 825 to 853 calories per day... and the published abstract also refers to > ...825-853 kcal/day formula diet... So what's the formula? Was it a commercial feeding formula such as Ensure? Or a dietician's list of approved foods? What was the macronutrient ratio?
- homero 9y agoMight be slimfast
- dempseye 9y agohttp://www.dictionary.com/browse/formula?s=t http://www.dictionary.com/browse/formula?s=t Definition 6. They are using the word "formula" as in "baby formula."
- fernly 9y agoI found this announcement of a follow-up study [1], which > will see 140 people with Type 2 diabetes spend between eight and 20 weeks consuming just 800 calories per day, mainly in the form of nutritionally-complete formula shakes. The phrase "nutritionally-complete" indicates a meal replacement; probably not Slimfast or Ensure, neither of which is suitable for 100% meal replacement, but something like Huel or Soylent, which are. However, being a medical operation, I would bet it will be some hospital-approved TPN [2] such as Jevity [3]. [1] https://www.diabetes.org.uk/About_us/News_Landing_Page/Low-calorie-liquid-diet-study-launched https://www.diabetes.org.uk/About_us/News_Landing_Page/Low-c... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parenteral_nutrition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parenteral_nutrition [3] https://nutrition.abbott/uk/product/jevity https://nutrition.abbott/uk/product/jevity
- nradov 9y agoNutritional ketosis was also recently shown to reverse type 2 diabetes. That approach might be more sustainable for some patients. https://blog.virtahealth.com/one-year-clinical-trial-outcomes-provide-evidence-for-changing-the-way-we-care-for-patients-with-type-2-diabetes/ https://blog.virtahealth.com/one-year-clinical-trial-outcome...
- will_brown 9y agoAnd Type 2 diabetes can be entirely prevented thru low sugar diets.
- fahayekwasright 9y agoDuh
- mirimir 9y agoI gained ~50 kg after quitting tobacco. But I'm not sure that it'd work the other way around. I do recall that "feeling hungry" and "needing a cigarette" were quite fungible. But then, smoking is obviously a huge cancer risk factor. Maybe vaping isn't so bad. And for what it's worth, testosterone supplementation disappeared my prediabetes. Also less white hair, and better muscle health.
- pascalxus 9y agoSticking to a very low calorie diet is super hard. You'r body starts producing all kinds of hormones to get you to eat more. I fight against this every day. So, I've created a tool that shows me all the lowest caloric density foods and ranks. It also ranks foods by nutrients too: highest nutrients per calorie: https://kale.world/c https://kale.world/c
- known 9y agoTL;DR If pancreases produces less insulin, eat less calories.
- gorsh 9y agoI lost 60kg in the last year after being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, following a moderated carb and low calories diet, with 1h of gym almost every day of the week. The latest HbA1c was 5.5%, which is inside the range for 'normal' people (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycated_hemoglobin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycated_hemoglobin)
- rexstjohn 9y agoHello, I see many people on here deriding low calorie diets as “starving.” As someone who was 100+lbs overweight I can attest that low-carb, diet, exercise, weight training were not sufficient to help. For whatever reason, genetics combined with work and lifestyle, I was unsuccessful with any commonly recommended diet for reducing body mass, I tried for years. Recently, I lost 40lbs using intermittent fasting and then continuos fasting. The experience was night and day, I have written about my experience here: http://rexstjohn.com/thoughts-fasting-part-iv-lost-40-lbs-two-months-now-want-answers/ http://rexstjohn.com/thoughts-fasting-part-iv-lost-40-lbs-tw.... Starving is the wrong way to frame this diet approach. I want people to change their minds about how they frame the problem of obesity. If you have 10 lbs of excess body fat, that represents 35,000 stored calories. Your body is used to doing much more work and exerting much more energy to locate food than what we do in modern society. If you wanted an Apple 100 years ago, chances are you had to walk for 30 minutes. Furthermore, our bodies are adapted to numerous days of fasting. If you are hunting a wounded deer over rough terrain, you don’t have room to carry a refrigerator with you - you burn stored reserves. If your crop fails and you have to wait three months to eat again subsisting off of grass and worms for vitamins, your body can do that too (I don’t recommend it). In my research I have found numerous examples, personal blog accounts and scientific studies backing them of people fasting for a week or greater and suffering no ill effects. The real issues with fasting occur only after many weeks, with low vitamin / potassium / electrolyte consumption or when you fast while having low body fat resulting in true starvation. In the example of the man who fasted 360 days and lost 350+lbs, doctors had him eating supplements and brewers yeast (protein, low calories) and they documented very few noticeable negative side effects which were addressed by adjustments to supplementation. Starvation is when your body consumes itself. This happens when you completely exhaust your stored fats. Fasting becomes riskier after the first 21 days, the really dangerous effects such as referring syndrome only occur in extreme situations where you had indeed been starving for a period of time before eating. I have lost 40lbs in the last year using these approaches and recommend them to everyone I meet. Fasting is a skill anyone can learn. I believe fasting is the best way to lose weight, don’t call it starving.